In the flickering drive-in glow of the early 1970s, a cluster of shadowy horrors emerged, too raw and unconventional to claim instant fame, yet destined for fervent cult devotion.
The early 1970s marked a turbulent transition in horror cinema, bridging the psychedelic excesses of the late 1960s with the blockbuster shocks of the mid-decade. While films like The Exorcist would soon dominate, a handful of overlooked gems carved niches in the underground, blending psychological unease, gothic flair, and Bigfoot-tinged folklore into experiences that reward repeated viewings. These forgotten early 1970s horror gems and cult classics—titles like Let’s Scare Jessica to Death, The Abominable Dr. Phibes, Messiah of Evil, and Lemora: A Child’s Tale of the Supernatural—deserve excavation for their innovative terrors and enduring whispers.
- Rediscovering atmospheric chillers that prioritised mood over gore, such as Let’s Scare Jessica to Death and Messiah of Evil, which master rural dread and coastal apocalypse.
- Examining stylish oddities like The Abominable Dr. Phibes, fusing camp with vengeance in ways that prefigured slasher tropes.
- Tracing their cult legacies, from midnight screenings to modern restorations, revealing influences on indie horror’s quiet revival.
The Rustic Hauntings of Let’s Scare Jessica to Death
Released in 1971, Let’s Scare Jessica to Death, directed by newcomer John Hancock, unfolds in the verdant yet foreboding landscapes of rural Connecticut. Zohra Lampert stars as Jessica Barrett, a woman recently released from a psychiatric institution following a suicide attempt. Seeking solace, she joins her husband Duncan (Melvin Douglas) and friend Woodland (Gretchen Corbett) at an abandoned lakeside farmhouse. What begins as a folkish idyll spirals into ambiguity: is Jessica haunted by the undead vampiress Emily Joy, or is her fragility unravelling under communal paranoia? Hancock layers the narrative with sun-dappled cinematography by Bob Baldwin, contrasting golden-hour serenity with nocturnal plunges into murky waters, where submerged corpses and whispering choirs evoke a primal fear of the pastoral gone wrong.
The film’s power lies in its refusal to clarify supernatural elements. Jessica’s visions—of a drowned bride in white, or a town of glassy-eyed acolytes—could stem from electroshock trauma or genuine otherworldly intrusion. Lampert’s performance anchors this uncertainty; her wide-eyed vulnerability recalls Repulsion‘s Carol Ledoux, but infused with 1970s counterculture fragility. Scenes like the barn dance, where locals sway in hypnotic rhythm, pulse with folk-horror unease akin to The Wicker Man, predating it by two years. Sound design amplifies isolation: creaking floorboards, distant splashes, and Jessica’s ragged breaths form a symphony of doubt, masterfully underscoring themes of mental health stigma in an era when deinstitutionalisation was accelerating.
Production was lean, shot in 24 days on a modest budget, yet its economy breeds intensity. Hancock, transitioning from documentaries, infuses authenticity; the farmhouse’s peeling wallpaper and overgrown vines symbolise encroaching madness. Critically divisive upon release—dismissed by some as derivative of Night of the Living Dead‘s undead—it found cult traction via late-night TV and VHS bootlegs. Today, Arrow Video’s restoration highlights its prescience: Jessica’s arc mirrors post-Vietnam disillusionment, where returning ‘normality’ proves illusory. In an age of trigger warnings, its empathetic portrayal of psychosis elevates it beyond schlock.
Vengeful Artistry in The Abominable Dr. Phibes
Robert Fuest’s 1971 opus The Abominable Dr. Phibes bursts with baroque invention, starring Vincent Price as the titular doctor, a disfigured organist seeking retribution against the surgical team he blames for his wife’s death. Rendered voiceless by a car accident—communicating via a gramophone mouthpiece—Phibes orchestrates murders inspired by the Biblical plagues: locusts devouring a victim in a convertible, rats infesting a penthouse, or frogs unleashed in a hospital. Joseph Cotton leads the beleaguered investigators, while Terry-Thomas and Hugh Griffith provide comic relief amid the carnage. Fuest’s direction revels in art-deco opulence, with Phibes’ Malibu mansion a labyrinth of golden clocks and automatons.
Price’s Phibes is a symphony of theatricality; his gliding wheelchair entrances and Vulnavia (Caroline Munro)’s silent servitude evoke silent-era villains like Rotwang from Metropolis. The film’s camp quotient—brass bands punctuating kills, acid melting flesh to biblical verse—anticipated Theatre of Blood‘s sequel, but Phibes stands alone for its proto-slasher precision. Effects by Roy Ashton blend practical wizardry: the unicorn impalement via car horn remains a grisly highlight, achieved with suspenders and clever editing. Thematically, it probes grief’s alchemy into monstrosity, Phibes’ eternal youth serum nodding to Death Takes a Holiday while satirising medical hubris.
AIP’s backing allowed Fuest’s flourishes, though UK censors trimmed gore for an X certificate. Box office success spawned a franchise, yet its cult status endures through Price’s peerless charisma. Scholarly readings link it to glam rock’s rise—Phibes as a glitterati avenger—while its influence echoes in Se7en‘s procedural hunts. Forgotten amid 1970s slashers, Phibes exemplifies horror’s playful ingenuity, a velvet-gloved fist in genre evolution.
Apocalyptic Drift: Messiah of Evil and Coastal Nightmares
Willard Huyck’s 1973 Messiah of Evil (aka Dead People) drifts into Lovecraftian voids along California’s Big Sur coast. Arletty (Marianna Hill) arrives seeking her missing artist father, encountering gallery owner Thom (Royal Dano), drifters Laura (Anitra Ford), and Joe (David Hayward). The town of Point Dune succumbs to blood moon madness: supermarket shoppers gnaw raw meat, theatregoers devour audiences mid-film. Huyck’s script, co-written with wife Gloria Katz, eschews explanation; a prologue warns of ‘in-between people’ heralding apocalypse, visuals prioritising decay over dialogue.
Cinematographer John Stephen Hill’s widescreen frames capture fog-shrouded piers and neon-lit markets, where shadows elongate into existential threats. Hill’s haunted eyes convey dislocation, her motel trysts with Joe devolving into fever dreams. Iconic sequences—the all-white cinema massacre, blood-smeared freezers—prefigure Dawn of the Dead‘s consumerist zombies, but with psychedelic surrealism. Soundscape of lapping waves and distant howls evokes cosmic insignificance, themes of artistic alienation resonating in Huyck’s American Graffiti context.
Shot as The Second Coming for Cinema Shares, distribution woes buried it until Code Red DVD unearthed it. Cult reverence grew via forums praising its oneiric dread; comparisons to Santa Sangre abound. Amid Watergate paranoia, its faceless cult symbolises societal unravelling, a forgotten prophecy of horror’s ambient turn.
Innocence Corrupted: Lemora‘s Gothic Reverie
Richard Blackburn’s 1973 Lemora: A Child’s Tale of the Supernatural transplants Carmilla to Depression-era Americana. Cheryl Smith plays Lila Lee, a preacher’s daughter lured by vampiress Lemora (Lesley Taplin) after her father’s criminal flight. Bus rides through moonlit woods lead to a manor of feral children and ritual baths; Lila’s transformation unfolds in lace and longing. Blackburn’s low-budget vision—$200,000—gleams via spectral lighting and Maxine Neuman’s score of tolling bells.
Smith’s pubescent poise captures innocence’s fragility; Lemora’s maternal seduction probes lesbian undertones absent in Hammer’s Karnstein trilogy. Scenes of thorn-crown processions and bathtub resurrections blend Dracula eroticism with The Nightcomers perversion. Themes of religious repression culminate in Lila’s bloodied ascension, critiquing patriarchal piety. Production anecdotes reveal Blackburn’s theatre roots shaping its operatic tableaux.
Initial X-rating stymied release; rediscovered in 2010s via Severin Films, it inspires The Love Witch. As early 1970s outlier, Lemora fuses fairy tale with exploitation, its cult whisper growing louder.
Threads of Influence and Era Echoes
These gems share atmospheric DNA: rural isolation, ambiguous hauntings, stylish kills, reflecting post-Rosemary’s Baby sophistication amid grindhouse grit. Early 1970s horror navigated MPAA ratings’ freedoms, birthing cults via drive-ins and imports. Class tensions simmer—Jessica’s bourgeois retreat invaded, Phibes’ elite vengeance—mirroring oil crisis anxieties. Gender dynamics evolve: female protagonists navigate madness, presaging Carrie.
Effects innovate modestly: Phibes’ prosthetics by Trevor Francis, Messiah’s practical gore. Legacy permeates—Mandy echoes Jessica’s psych-horror, Mandy visuals nod Messiah. Restorations by Vinegar Syndrome revive them, proving analogue textures’ allure in digital age.
Production hurdles abound: Hancock battled studio interference, Fuest clashed censors. Yet resilience forged authenticity, influencing New French Extremity’s slow burns.
Special Effects: Ingenuity on a Shoestring
Early 1970s constraints bred creativity. Phibes’ plague recreations—brass bees via miniatures, acid etched prosthetically—showcase pre-CGI craft. Jessica’s lake drownings used practical doubles, fog machines for ethereal blooms. Messiah’s blood rivers poured corn syrup gallons, supermarket frenzy coordinated 50 extras. Lemora’s transformations relied makeup by Joe Blasco, wolf-hybrid masks blending fur and latex. These tangible horrors grounded surrealism, their tactility enduring versus modern CGI.
Director in the Spotlight
Robert Fuest, born in 1927 in York, England, emerged from art school and television design into film directing during the swinging 1960s. Initially a set decorator on Hammer productions like Dracula: Prince of Darkness (1966), his visual flair caught attention. Fuest helmed episodes of The Avengers (1967-1969), honing stylish action, before feature debuts. The Abominable Dr. Phibes (1971) catapulted him, blending horror with pop-art aesthetics influenced by Powell and Pressburger. Its sequel, Dr. Phibes Rises Again (1972), amplified camp, starring Price amid Egyptian quests.
Fuest’s career spanned genres: The Final Programme (1973), adapting Moorcock’s Jerry Cornelius with psychedelic flair, featured Jon Finch and Jenny Runacre in dystopian rock-opera vibes. Wargame (1977) tackled Cold War espionage, while The Devil’s Rain (1975) united Price, Ernest Borgnine, and William Shatner in a satanic melter-fest marred by effects woes. Later, he directed TV movies like Ripping Yarns episodes (1979) with Michael Palin, showcasing comedic range. Influences from Cocteau’s surrealism and Hitchcock’s precision permeated his oeuvre.
Retiring post-1980s, Fuest influenced music videos and remains revered in cult circles. Key filmography: Just Like a Woman (1966, debut drama); The Abominable Dr. Phibes (1971, horror breakthrough); Dr. Phibes Rises Again (1972, sequel); The Final Programme (1973, sci-fi); The Devil’s Rain (1975, occult thriller); Wargame (aka The Double Headed Spy, 1977, spy caper). His legacy: bridging British horror’s gothic to 1970s excess.
Actor in the Spotlight
Vincent Price, born May 27, 1911, in St. Louis, Missouri, into affluence—his family owned National Lead—studied art at Yale and London stage before Hollywood. Debuting in Service de Luxe (1938), he gained notice in The Song of Bernadette (1943), earning Oscar nods. Horror icon status crystallised with Roger Corman Poe cycle: House of Wax (1953) showcased suave menace; The Fall of the House of Usher (1960), Pit and the Pendulum (1961), Tales of Terror (1962), The Raven (1963), The Masque of the Red Death (1964), The Tomb of Ligeia (1964)—baroque horrors blending verse and visuals.
Price’s baritone narrated The Cool and the Crazy (1958), voiced The 13 Ghosts (1960), and starred in AIP’s The Abominable Dr. Phibes (1971). Diversely, Laura (1944), Leave Her to Heaven (1945) showed dramatic chops; Theatre of Blood (1973) parodied stardom with Shakespearian kills. Awards included Saturn Lifetime Achievement (1983). Late career: Edward Scissorhands (1990) as inventor, Thriller video narration. Died 1993, leaving cookbook A Treasury of Great Recipes (1965).
Comprehensive filmography highlights: The Invisible Man Returns (1940); House of Wax (1953); House of Usher (1960); The Pit and the Pendulum (1961); Tales of Terror (1962); The Raven (1963); The Masque of the Red Death (1964); Dr. Goldfoot and the Bikini Machine (1965); The Abominable Dr. Phibes (1971); Theatre of Blood (1973); Madhouse (1974); Edward Scissorhands (1990). Price embodied horror’s eloquence.
Bibliography
Harper, S. (2000) British Horror Cinema. Palgrave Macmillan.
Jones, A. (2012) Grindhouse: 10 Decades of Terror. Fab Press.
Kerekes, L. and Slater, D. (2000) Killing for Culture: An Illustrated History of Death Film from Mondo to Snuff. Creation Books.
Maddrey, J. (2009) More American Horrors: Competing Visionaries and the Struggle to Set a New Direction in Horror Cinema. McFarland.
McCabe, B. (2019) Multiple Maniacs: The Films of John Waters. Fantastic Planet. Available at: https://fantasticplanet.ie/multiple-maniacs-john-waters/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Price, V. (1992) I Like What I Know. Doubleday.
Rockoff, A. (2002) Going to Pieces: The Rise and Fall of the Slasher Film, 1978-1986. McFarland.
Schow, D. J. (1987) The Films of Vincent Price. Midnight Marquee Press.