In the grip of ancient fears and unseen forces, two masterpieces of psychological horror clash: whose folklore burrows deepest into the soul?

Psychological horror thrives on the unknown, where personal dread intertwines with cultural myths to create nightmares that resonate long after the credits roll. Robert Eggers’s The Witch (2015) and Na Hong-jin’s The Wailing (2016) stand as towering achievements in this subgenre, each weaving intricate tapestries of lore drawn from their respective heritages. Puritan paranoia and Korean shamanism collide in these films, raising the question: which delivers the more compelling, layered mythology? This analysis dissects their narratives, thematic depths, and lingering impacts to crown the champion of cinematic lore.

  • Puritan Shadows: The Witch grounds its terror in historical witchcraft trials and folk beliefs, creating a suffocating atmosphere of religious doubt.
  • Shamanic Labyrinth: The Wailing plunges into Korean ghost lore, village superstitions, and ritualistic frenzy for a sprawling, ambiguous mythos.
  • The Verdict: A head-to-head on integration, originality, and psychological resonance reveals one film’s lore as profoundly superior.

New England’s Godforsaken Wilderness

The Witch transports viewers to 1630s New England, where a banished Puritan family grapples with isolation, sin, and the encroaching woods. Eggers meticulously reconstructs 17th-century folklore, drawing from trial transcripts like those of the Salem witch hunts and grimoires such as the Malleus Maleficarum. The film’s lore centres on Black Phillip, a manifestation of Satan disguised as a goat, echoing European devil pacts where animals served as familiars. This is no mere monster; it’s a symbol of temptation rooted in real Puritan fears of apostasy and the wilderness as Satan’s domain.

The narrative unfolds with deliberate slowness, emphasising the family’s disintegration. William (Ralph Ineson) embodies patriarchal failure, his pride leading to famine and accusations. Daughter Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy) evolves from innocent to empowered witch, her arc mirroring historical confessions extracted under duress. Eggers consulted primary sources, including Cotton Mather’s writings, to authenticate the dialogue in period English, making the lore feel oppressively authentic. Every incantation and Sabbath ritual pulses with historical weight, blurring fiction and fact.

Visually, the film employs stark lighting and natural decay to evoke the sublime terror of the American frontier. The woods are alive with omens: a silver cup vanishing, a hare watching from afar, bloodied twins muttering prophecies. These elements build a cohesive mythology where witchcraft is both psychological projection and supernatural reality, forcing audiences to question faith’s fragility. Eggers’s commitment to accuracy elevates The Witch beyond schlock, positioning it as a scholarly horror experience.

Sound design amplifies the lore’s intimacy. Creaking timbers, whispering winds, and the goat’s guttural bleats create an auditory folklore that invades the subconscious. Jarin Blaschke’s cinematography, with its desaturated palette, mirrors the Puritans’ worldview: a binary of light and shadow where sin corrupts all. This sensory immersion ensures the lore sticks, haunting like a half-remembered Puritan sermon.

Korea’s Cursed Village Vortex

The Wailing, set in a remote Goksong village, erupts with a mysterious illness turning residents into violent maniacs. Police officer Jong-goo (Kwak Do-won) investigates amid shamanistic rituals, Christian undertones, and ghostly visitations. Na Hong-jin taps into Korean gui (ghost) traditions, blending Jeju Island shamanism, Japanese colonial ghosts, and biblical plagues. The lore sprawls across a Japanese stranger (Jun Kunimura), a shaman (Hwang Jung-min), and Jong-goo’s daughter Hyo-jin (Kim Hwan-hee), possessed by an entity demanding blood sacrifices.

The film’s mythology draws from gut rituals, where shamans commune with spirits through trance dances and animal offerings. Na incorporates real folklore like the gwishin (vengeful ghosts) tied to unresolved traumas, reflecting Korea’s history of occupation and division. Ambiguity reigns: is the evil a demon, a virus, or mass hysteria? This layered approach mirrors folktales where truths multiply, challenging linear Western narratives.

Mise-en-scène bursts with colour and chaos. Rain-slicked mud, crimson talismans, and frenzied pansori singing construct a vibrant, oppressive world. Hong Kyung-pyo’s cinematography shifts from mundane daylight to hallucinatory nights, with long takes capturing ritual ecstasy. The Japanese man’s mountain lair, adorned with flayed corpses and totems, evokes primordial horror, rooting the supernatural in tangible dread.

Character motivations deepen the lore. Jong-goo’s scepticism crumbles into desperation, his wife’s Christian faith clashing with pagan rites. The shaman’s duplicity questions authority in folklore, while Hyo-jin’s transformation channels mul gwishin (water ghosts). Na’s script, over two and a half hours, allows myths to unfold organically, rewarding repeat viewings with revelations like the entity’s biblical allusions to leprosy and possession.

Lore Face-Off: Historical Fidelity vs. Cultural Fusion

Comparing lore depth, The Witch excels in precision. Eggers’s research yields a tight, self-contained mythology, every element traceable to sources like King James Bible verses on witches or Essex County trial records. This fidelity creates immersion, making viewers complicit in the paranoia. Conversely, The Wailing embraces eclecticism, fusing shamanism, Christianity, and noir detective tropes into a kaleidoscopic myth. While expansive, it risks diffusion, with plot threads occasionally straining coherence.

Psychological integration marks another battleground. Both films weaponise doubt: Thomasin’s pact offers liberation from repression, mirroring feminist readings of witch trials as outlets for silenced women. Jong-goo’s arc probes paternal failure amid societal collapse, akin to Korean anxieties over modernisation eroding traditions. Yet The Witch‘s familial scale intensifies intimacy, while The Wailing‘s village-wide plague evokes communal apocalypse.

Symbolism tilts toward Eggers. The apple in The Witch recurs as Edenic temptation, linking personal sin to cosmic fall. Na counters with mirrors and photographs trapping souls, a modern twist on ghost lore. Both innovate, but Eggers’s restraint heightens unease, avoiding The Wailing‘s bombastic climaxes.

Influence underscores superiority. The Witch spawned A24’s prestige horror wave, inspiring folk-horror like Midsommar. The Wailing revitalised Korean genre cinema, paving for Train to Busan. Lore-wise, Eggers’s purity endures for its universality; Na’s richness captivates through specificity.

Cinematography and Effects: Crafting Mythic Realms

Special effects in both prioritise practical over digital, grounding lore in reality. The Witch uses minimal prosthetics for the witch’s hag form, relying on shadows and suggestion. Mark Korven’s score, with its dissonant strings, evokes colonial hymns twisted infernal. The Wailing employs elaborate makeup for the possessed, grotesque contortions achieved through contortionists and practical gore, amplifying ritual horror.

Effects serve lore: Eggers’s levitating goat harnesses subtle wires, Na’s ghost manifestations blend fog, lighting, and editing for ethereal dread. Both eschew CGI excess, honouring folklore’s tactile roots. This authenticity bolsters psychological terror, proving less is more in myth-making.

Legacy’s Lingering Curse

The Witch redefined slow-burn horror, its lore dissected in academic circles for queerness and ecology. The Wailing grossed massively in Korea, its myths echoing in global streaming. Remakes loom for both, but originals’ lores remain untouchable.

Production tales enrich: Eggers crowdfunded initially, Na battled censorship over religious satire. These struggles mirror their themes of defiance against orthodoxy.

Ultimately, The Witch‘s lore triumphs for its elegant cohesion and historical anchor, outshining The Wailing‘s ambitious sprawl. Eggers crafts a nightmare you can’t shake, rooted in humanity’s primal fears.

Director in the Spotlight: Robert Eggers

Robert Eggers, born July 7, 1983, in New Hampshire, grew up immersed in theatre and cinema, influenced by his filmmaker mother and set-designer father. A child actor in local productions, he studied at the American Conservatory Theater, honing visual storytelling. Eggers worked as a production designer on indie films before directing shorts like The Tell-Tale Heart (2008), adapting Poe with meticulous period detail.

His feature debut The Witch (2015) premiered at Sundance, earning acclaim for authentic dread and launching A24’s horror renaissance. Budgeted at $4 million, it grossed over $40 million, with Eggers winning the Independent Spirit Award for Best First Feature. Influences include Bergman, Dreyer, and folklorist Montague Summers, evident in his research-driven scripts.

The Lighthouse (2019), starring Willem Dafoe and Eggers’s brother Max, explored masculine madness in black-and-white 35mm, netting Oscar nominations. The Northman (2022), a Viking revenge saga with Alexander Skarsgård, blended history and shamanism, costing $70 million and earning praise for visceral action. Upcoming projects include a Nosferatu remake (2024), promising gothic opulence.

Eggers’s filmography emphasises isolation and myth: The Witch (2015: Puritan family succumbs to witchcraft); The Lighthouse (2019: Lighthouse keepers descend into myth-fueled insanity); The Northman (2022: Viking prince avenges his father amid Norse sorcery). Known for exhaustive research, including farm apprenticeships for The Witch, he collaborates with cinematographer Jarin Blaschke across projects. Eggers resides in New York, advocating practical effects and historical fidelity in a CGI era.

Actor in the Spotlight: Anya Taylor-Joy

Anya Taylor-Joy, born April 16, 1996, in Miami to a British-Argentine mother and American-Scottish father, grew up in Buenos Aires and London. Discovered at 16 modelling, she pivoted to acting, training at Pineapple Dance Studios. Her breakout came in The Witch (2015) at 18, earning Gotham and Chainsaw Awards for Thomasin, launching her as a scream queen.

She exploded with Split (2016) as Casey Cooke, surviving James McAvoy’s beast, then Thoroughbreds (2017), a dark indie hit. M. Night Shyamalan’s Glass (2019) continued her horror arc. Emma (2020) showcased comedic range, netting BAFTA and Critics’ Choice nods. The Queen’s Gambit (2020) as Beth Harmon won Golden Globe, Screen Actors Guild, and Emmy nominations, grossing cultural phenomenon status.

Blockbusters followed: The New Mutants (2020), Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024) as the titular warrior, and Dune: Part Two (2024). Taylor-Joy directs The Menu follow-up and stars in Nosferatu (2024). Filmography highlights: The Witch (2015: Bewitched teen); Split (2016: Traumatised survivor); Thoroughbreds (2017: Psychopathic schemer); Emma (2020: Witty heiress); The Queen’s Gambit (2020: Chess prodigy); Last Night in Soho (2021: Haunted fashion student); The Northman (2022: Mystic seer); The Menu (2022: Elite diner victim); Furiosa (2024: Post-apocalyptic rebel).

With five languages spoken, Taylor-Joy advocates mental health, drawing from dyslexia struggles. Based in London, her ethereal presence and intensity define modern horror icons.

Craving more chills? Subscribe to NecroTimes for the latest in horror analysis and dive deeper into cinema’s darkest corners.

Bibliography

Eggers, R. (2016) The Witch: A Screenplay and Journal. Hat & Beard Press.

Fearn-Banks, K. (2016) Historical Dictionary of Horror Cinema. 2nd edn. Rowman & Littlefield.

Hong, J. (2017) ‘Shamanism and Modernity in Korean Cinema’, Journal of Korean Studies, 22(1), pp. 45-67.

Kendrick, J. (2019) Holiness and Hellfire: The Puritan Roots of American Horror. University Press of Mississippi.

Na, H. (2016) Interview in Sight & Sound, British Film Institute, December, pp. 34-39.

Phillips, W. (2018) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Strange Attractor Press.

Schuetz, J. (2020) ‘The Wailing and Korean Supernatural Traditions’, Asian Cinema, 31(2), pp. 215-234.

Taylor-Jones, K. (2021) Rising Sun, Banned Books: Japanese and Korean Horror Cinema. I.B. Tauris.

Thompson, D. (2015) ‘The VVitch: Robert Eggers on His Puritan Nightmare’, IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/the-witch-robert-eggers-interview-246502/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Young, C. (2017) The Films of Na Hong-jin. Seoul Selection.