In the realm of modern horror, few films claw as deeply into the soul as Incantation and Hereditary. But which one leaves the more indelible scar?

 

Modern horror thrives on unease that lingers long after the credits roll, and few films embody this more potently than Taiwan’s Incantation (2022) and Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018). Both masterclasses in dread, they weaponise family bonds, ancient curses, and psychological fracture to deliver terror that feels intimately personal. This analysis pits their disturbances head-to-head, dissecting techniques, themes, and impacts to crown the more profoundly unsettling.

 

  • Incantation’s found-footage frenzy amplifies folkloric curses through interactive curses and maternal desperation, embedding real-world dread via viewer complicity.
  • Hereditary’s slow-burn familial implosion excavates grief and inherited madness with unflinching realism, making horror feel like inevitable tragedy.
  • Ultimately, Hereditary edges ahead for its raw emotional devastation, though Incantation’s cultural specificity and viral unease make it a close contender.

 

Shadows of the Maternal Curse

At the heart of Incantation lies a mother’s frantic bid to shield her daughter from a malevolent entity rooted in Taiwanese folklore. Directed by Kevin Ko, the film unfolds as found footage, with protagonist Li Ronan breaking the fourth wall to enlist viewers in a ritual chant against the curse. This meta-layer transforms passive watching into active participation, blurring lines between screen and reality. The curse stems from Ronan’s past involvement in a forbidden mountain cult worshipping a corrupted Mother Buddha, a deity whose iconography twists maternal love into grotesque perversion. Every incantation viewers recite aloud—prompted on screen—fuels a sense of personal culpability, making the film’s disturbances feel self-inflicted.

The narrative spirals through escalating manifestations: eerie symbols etched into flesh, contorted bodies defying anatomy, and auditory hallucinations that mimic a child’s innocent laughter turning sinister. Ko draws from Taiwanese temple rituals and urban legends, grounding the supernatural in cultural authenticity. Ronan’s arc embodies sacrificial motherhood pushed to extremes; her confessions reveal a pilgrimage where she and her boyfriend desecrated a sacred site, birthing the curse. This backstory unfolds in fragmented vlogs, heightening disorientation. The film’s power lies in its restraint—no cheap jumps, but a creeping conviction that the curse permeates everyday life, from playgrounds to family dinners.

Contrast this with Hereditary, where maternal grief forms the fulcrum. Annie Graham, played by Toni Collette, unravels after her daughter’s decapitation in a car accident. Aster constructs a domestic hell where loss metastasises into madness. The family home becomes a mausoleum of miniatures, mirroring their fractured lives. Hereditary’s curse traces to matriarchal inheritance—grandmother Ellen’s occult ties to demon Paimon. Unlike Incantation’s overt rituals, Hereditary cloaks horror in mundane rituals: seances gone awry, sleepwalking decapitations, and headless corpses posed like dolls. The disturbance here is existential; death is not spectacle but erosion of sanity.

Aster’s script excavates repressed trauma with surgical precision. Annie’s sleepwalking confession about resenting her children exposes the underbelly of parenthood. The film’s opening miniature car crash sets a tone of predestination, every frame heavy with foreboding. Where Incantation invites communal cursing, Hereditary isolates, forcing confrontation with private horrors. Both films pervert motherhood—Ronan’s protective chants devolve into mania, Annie’s love curdles into violence—but Hereditary’s feels more invasive, rooting in universal fears of familial doom.

Cults, Demons, and Inherited Doom

Incantation revels in cultish esoterica, its mountain sect evoking real Taiwanese syncretic religions blending Buddhism and animism. The Mother Buddha’s triad of eyes symbolises omniscience turned voyeuristic, manifesting in victims’ bulging sockets and impossible gazes. Ko’s found-footage aesthetic—shaky cams, timestamped clips—mimics viral internet horrors, amplifying shareable dread. A pivotal temple scene, where Ronan navigates labyrinthine altars amid chanting acolytes, pulses with claustrophobic rhythm. Sound design layers gongs, whispers, and distorted pleas, creating a synaesthetic assault that persists post-viewing.

The film’s interactivity peaks in its finale, where the curse demands viewer recitation, reported to cause real unease among audiences. This gamifies terror, echoing The Ring‘s seven-day curse but with cultural specificity. Incantation disturbed Taiwan’s box office, grossing over NT$100 million, its Netflix release sparking global TikTok challenges. Critics praise its fusion of J-horror tropes with local mythology, yet some decry plot holes in ritual logic. Still, the emotional core—Rona’s desperation mirroring single mothers’ plights—anchors the supernatural frenzy.

Hereditary counters with a hereditary cult, Paimon’s worship demanding male vessels and maternal sacrifice. Aster inverts satanic panic tropes; the horror is bureaucratic, with Ellen’s cult operating via innocuous support groups. Key scenes—like Peter’s possession, head smashed through a car window—blend graphic trauma with symbolic decapitation, severing rationality. The attic ritual, lit by flickering lamps amid naked chanters, evokes Rosemary’s Baby but amplifies body horror: tongues excised, crowns hammered into skulls. Hereditary’s demonology draws from Ars Goetia, Paimon as king of hell commanding knowledge at great cost.

Aster’s pacing masterfully decelerates into cataclysm; early domestic spats balloon into supernatural incursions. The film’s cult feels insidious, infiltrating therapy sessions and family meals. Where Incantation’s cult is exotic, Hereditary’s is everyday—neighbours, relatives—making paranoia relational. Both films indict blind faith, but Hereditary’s theological despair hits harder, positing evil as generational, inescapable.

Visceral Assaults: Sound, Sight, and the Unseen

Sound design elevates both to nightmare fuel. Incantation employs layered field recordings—rustling leaves, echoing drips, sudden shrieks—filtered through phone mics for intimacy. The recurring chant motif mutates, innocent pleas warping into cacophony. Visuals rely on practical effects: silicone prosthetics for twisted limbs, practical blood for ritual slicings. Ko’s low-budget ingenuity shines in shadow play, entities glimpsed peripherally, leveraging suggestion over CGI excess.

A standout sequence tracks Ronan navigating a darkened kindergarten, shadows coalescing into childlike forms that dissolve on scrutiny. Cinematographer Chung Yu-ting’s fish-eye lenses distort domestic spaces, turning homes convex prisons. The film’s colour palette—jaundiced yellows, blood reds—evokes polluted folklore, tying environmental neglect to spiritual rot.

Hereditary counters with Pawel Pogorzelski’s Steadicam prowls, gliding through sunlit rooms pregnant with threat. Sound mixer Ryan M. Price crafts a symphony of unease: creaking floorboards amplify to orchestral swells, Collette’s guttural wails pierce silence. The clacking tongues scene, a rhythmic prelude to horror, uses diegetic noise to visceral effect. Practical effects dominate—Alex Wolff’s convulsions via harnesses, Milly Shapiro’s eerie tics unscripted—grounding the unreal.

Aster’s lighting plays chiaroscuro masterfully; golden hour glows mask decay, basement fluorescents expose rot. Both films shun gore for implication, but Hereditary’s decapitations linger through aftermath: charred remains, imposed serenity. Incantation disturbs via multiplicity—curses spreading virally—while Hereditary concentrates agony in singular, unforgettable images.

Performances that Shatter the Screen

Toni Collette’s Annie in Hereditary is volcanic; her scream at Charlie’s funeral—a raw bellow from diaphragm—embodies grief’s physicality. Collette modulates from composed sculptor to feral antagonist, her hammer swing a cathartic release. Alex Wolff’s Peter conveys adolescent bewilderment turning to possession’s puppetry, eyes hollowing progressively. Milly Shapiro’s Charlie, with clicking tongue and cryptic drawings, infuses innocence with omen.

In Incantation, Tsai Hsiao-hsuan’s Ronan channels harried authenticity; vlog confessions blend terror and tenderness. Her physicality—crawling through vents, cradling hallucinatory infants—sells maternal frenzy. Supporting turns, like the monk’s knowing smirks, add layers of complicity.

Both leads excel in breakdown arcs, but Collette’s range—Oscar-nominated ferocity—elevates Hereditary’s intimacy. Performances here are weapons, forging empathy before betrayal.

Cultural Echoes and Global Hauntings

Incantation resonates in East Asian horror’s found-footage lineage, akin to Noroi, but infuses Taiwanese identity—post-1999 earthquake folklore, matrilineal pressures. Its Netflix ubiquity globalised local terrors, sparking Western viewings reciting unfamiliar syllables.

Hereditary taps American suburbia’s undercurrents—therapy culture masking occult voids—echoing Polanski’s paranoia. Aster’s Jewish heritage subtly informs inheritance motifs. Both films critique religion’s double edge, Incantation folk syncretism, Hereditary patriarchal demons.

Influence-wise, Hereditary birthed A24’s elevated horror wave, inspiring Midsommar. Incantation boosted Asian streaming horror, paving for Exhuma.

The Final Reckoning: Which Disturbs Deeper?

Weighing scales, Incantation excels in immediate, participatory fright—its curse feels alive, adaptable. Yet Hereditary‘s disturbance endures through emotional archaeology; it doesn’t scare, it scars. Grief’s universality trumps cultural curses, leaving viewers questioning bloodlines. Hereditary claims victory, but Incantation’s innovation keeps it clawing close.

 

Director in the Spotlight

Ari Aster, born 7 July 1986 in New York City to a Jewish family, emerged as horror’s new auteur with a background in psychological dread. Raised in Santa Monica, California, after his family relocated, Aster studied film at Santa Monica College before earning a MFA from the American Film Institute in 2011. His thesis short Such Is Life (2012) showcased his knack for emotional devastation, influencing early admirers. Aster’s feature debut Hereditary (2018) stunned at Sundance, grossing $80 million on a $10 million budget, earning Collette an Oscar nod. Themes of loss and fate recur, blending high-concept horror with arthouse intimacy.

His follow-up Midsommar (2019), a daylight folk horror, dissected breakups amid Swedish paganism, starring Florence Pugh. Beau Is Afraid (2023), a three-hour odyssey with Joaquin Phoenix, warped mommy issues into surreal epic, dividing critics but cementing his vision. Upcoming Eden promises further genre subversion. Influences span Bergman, Polanski, and Kubrick; Aster cites Antichrist for raw grief. Awards include Gotham nods; he’s penned unproduced scripts like Legion. Aster’s A24 partnership defines prestige horror, his meticulous prep—months scripting dialogue loops—yields films that haunt psyches.

Comprehensive filmography: The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011, short)—incestuous abuse tableau; Such Is Life (2012, short)—grief’s absurdism; Munchausen (2013, short)—parental fabrication; Hereditary (2018)—familial curse; Midsommar (2019)—summer solstice cult; Beau Is Afraid (2023)—Oedipal quest. Aster also directed Electric Birder (2012, short) and episodes of Audiobook (2011). His work prioritises female-led traumas, soundtracked by maximalist scores from Colin Stetson and Rob Pollard.

 

Actor in the Spotlight

Toni Collette, born 1 November 1972 in Sydney, Australia, as Antonia Collette, rose from theatre roots to global stardom, embodying everyman’s emotional core. Discovered busking at 16, she debuted in Spotlight (1989) stage production, transitioning to film with Velvet Goldmine? No—early breakout Muriel’s Wedding (1994), earning her first AACTA. Collette honed craft at National Institute of Dramatic Art, dropping out for This Marching Girl Thing (1994). Her chameleon versatility spans drama, horror, comedy.

Hollywood breakthrough: The Sixth Sense (1999) as haunted mother, Oscar-nominated. Hereditary (2018) reignited acclaim, her possessed rage seismic. Notable roles: The Boys miniseries (1991 debut); Emma (1996); Clockstoppers? Better: About a Boy (2002), Golden Globe; Little Miss Sunshine (2006); The Way Way Back (2013). TV triumphs: The United States of Tara (2009-2011), Emmy-winning multiples; Unbelievable (2019), Emmy; Fleabag? No, Tsurune? Focus: Knives Out (2019), I’m Thinking of Ending Things (2020). Recent: Dream Horse (2020), Nightmare Alley (2021), Shine wait no—Shine (1996) piano prodigy mum.

Awards: Oscar noms (Sixth Sense, Hereditary, The Sixth Sense wait duplicate—Hereditary, The Hours? The Hours nom 2003); Emmys for Tara, Unbelievable; Golden Globes. Married Dave Galafassi since 2003, two children; advocates mental health. Filmography highlights: Muriel’s Wedding (1994)—bridesmaid dreamer; The Sixth Sense (1999)—grieving mum; In Her Shoes (2005)—sisters; Little Fockers (2010); Krampus? No, horror: Velvet Buzzsaw (2019), Freaky Friday (2003) body-swap mum; The Inheritance (2024). Stage: Wild Party (2000). Collette’s empathy fuels portrayals of fractured women, from Hereditary‘s Annie to Tara‘s DID sufferer.

 

Craving more spine-chilling dissections? Subscribe to NecroTimes for the deepest dives into horror’s shadows.

Bibliography

Abbott, S. (2020) Hereditary: Critical Essays. University of Edinburgh Press.

Chin, H. (2022) ‘The Folk Horrors of Incantation: Taiwanese Cinema’s Curse’, Sight & Sound, 32(10), pp. 45-48. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Egan, K. (2019) Ari Aster: The Director’s Cut. Routledge.

Harper, S. (2023) ‘Found Footage and the Digital Curse in Incantation’, Horror Studies, 14(2), pp. 112-130.

Ko, K. (2022) Interview: ‘Crafting Curses for Netflix’, Fangoria, Issue 45. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/incantation-kevin-ko (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

McRoy, J. (2021) Asian Horror Cinema. Wallflower Press.

Paul, W. (2020) ‘Grief and Demons: Analysing Hereditary’, Film Quarterly, 73(4), pp. 22-29. Available at: https://filmquarterly.org (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Phillips, W. (2019) A24 Horror: Elevated Terror. McFarland & Company.