In the shadowed cloisters of horror cinema, two veiled figures emerge from the abyss: one a witch’s vengeful spectre from 1960s Italy, the other a demonic entity terrorising modern faith. Which reigns supreme in gothic dread?
Black Sunday and The Nun stand as towering pillars in the gothic horror pantheon, separated by nearly six decades yet united by their portrayal of unholy women cloaked in nun-like garb. Mario Bava’s 1960 masterpiece and Corin Hardy’s 2018 Conjuring prequel invite comparison not just for their superficial similarities—a cursed habit, crucifixes wielded as weapons—but for how they channel the eternal gothic essence of decay, possession, and the supernatural invading the sacred.
- Both films master the gothic aesthetic through crumbling abbeys and fog-shrouded landscapes, but Bava’s monochrome poetry contrasts sharply with Hardy’s visceral CGI spectacles.
- Central to each is a demonic feminine force, exploring themes of retribution and corrupted piety that echo from 19th-century literature to contemporary scares.
- While Black Sunday’s slow-burn elegance influenced generations, The Nun revitalises these tropes for a jump-scare era, proving gothic horror’s timeless adaptability.
Cloaked in Curses: The Twin Terrors Unveiled
Black Sunday, released in 1960 as La maschera del demonio, unfolds in 17th-century Ukraine where Princess Asa Vajda, a satanic witch, faces execution by her brother. Branded and masked with burning spikes, she curses her accusers before flames consume her. Two centuries later, Professor Kruvajan and his assistant Andros inadvertently revive her by pricking her preserved corpse with a pointed tomb tool during an autopsy-like examination. Asa drains Kruvajan’s life force, assuming the likeness of her doppelganger, Princess Katia Vajda, to orchestrate revenge. Barbara Steele embodies both Asa and Katia, her dual performance a hypnotic blend of malevolence and innocence. The narrative weaves through the Vajda castle’s labyrinthine halls, where Asa summons her lover Javutich, a blinded giant, and unleashes plagues of bats and shadows upon the living.
The film’s gothic pedigree shines in its meticulous reconstruction of Hammer Horror influences, yet Bava elevates it with operatic visuals. Key scenes, like Asa’s resurrection amid dripping crypts and flickering candlelight, pulse with dread through low-angle shots that dwarf humanity against vaulted ceilings. The plot crescendos in a ritualistic showdown, crucifixes glowing supernaturally as good triumphs, but not without sacrifices—Katia’s lover survives, forever scarred by the night’s horrors.
Contrast this with The Nun, set in 1952 Romania at the fortified Călu Gerry Abbey, a once-holy site now besieged by an ancient evil. Following a nun’s suicide, Vatican investigators Father Burke (Demián Bichir) and Sister Irene (Taissa Farmiga), accompanied by local novice Frenchie (Jonas Bloquet), uncover Valak, a powerful demon manifesting as a towering nun. The entity, summoned centuries prior by a fallen nun during wartime desecration, manipulates history through blood rituals and hellish portals. Flashbacks reveal the abbey’s WWII profanation, where a barrel of blood opened infernal gates. Valak possesses hosts, shatters stained glass with unholy winds, and drowns victims in unhallowed waters.
Hardy’s film leans into the Conjuring universe’s lore, expanding Valak’s backstory from The Conjuring 2. Pivotal sequences, such as the abbey catacombs chase where Valak’s silhouette looms impossibly tall, or the blood-vine strangulations, blend practical sets with digital enhancements for immediate terror. The resolution hinges on relics—a bloodied vial of Christ’s blood—and personal faith, with Irene confronting her own visions of the Virgin Mary turned demonic.
These synopses reveal shared DNA: desecrated religious sites as portals to hell, vampiric/possessive draining of life, and clerical protagonists battling otherworldly women. Yet Black Sunday savours psychological erosion, Asa’s slow seduction mirroring Stoker’s Dracula, while The Nun prioritises kinetic horror, Valak’s assaults relentless and physical.
Gothic Foundations: Atmosphere as the True Monster
Gothic horror thrives on environment, and both films construct worlds where stone and shadow conspire against the soul. Bava’s black-and-white cinematography in Black Sunday crafts a perpetual twilight, fog machines billowing through baroque interiors lit by harsh key lights that carve faces into skulls. The Vajda castle, filmed on lavish sets, evokes Murnau’s Nosferatu with its gothic spires and cobwebbed altars. Sound design amplifies isolation—distant tolling bells, echoing drips, and Tchaikovsky-inspired strings swelling to frenzy—immersing viewers in a pre-modern nightmare.
The Nun transplants this to post-war Eastern Europe, the abbey a hulking concrete-and-stone fortress evoking Cold War paranoia. Corin Hardy employs wide-angle lenses to distort corridors into infinite voids, practical rain and wind machines heightening claustrophobia. Digital fog and particle effects simulate Valak’s ethereal presence, but the film’s masterstroke lies in silence punctured by guttural roars or children’s choir hymns twisted infernal. Where Bava’s gothic is painterly, Hardy’s is immersive, demanding 3D spectacle.
Class politics subtly underpin both: Black Sunday critiques aristocratic decay, Asa as feudal revenant punishing bourgeois interlopers. The Nun nods to imperial sins, the abbey’s fall tied to Nazi incursions, framing Valak as historical retribution. Gender dynamics fascinate—Steele’s Asa weaponises beauty and maternity, seducing sons to matricide, while Valak perverts the nurturing nun into devouring mother, her habit a shroud of false piety.
Demonic Divas: The Habit as Horror Icon
The nun archetype, rooted in Catholic iconography subverted since The Devil’s Wedding Night (1973), finds perfection here. Asa wears no habit but her spiked mask and flowing veils mimic it, symbolising inverted sanctity. Steele’s portrayal, eyes burning with sadistic glee, influenced countless Eurohorror sorceresses. A scene where she caresses Kruvajan to dust exemplifies erotic dread, her touch a venomous caress blending Carmilla‘s lesbian vampirism with Medusa’s petrifying gaze.
Valak, conversely, is habit incarnate—seven feet tall, face obscured by porcelain pallor, eyes yellow slits. Farmiga’s Irene mirrors her, the habit signifying vulnerability turned strength. Iconic moments, like Valak levitating with outstretched arms amid inverted crosses, homage Bava while amplifying scale. Both figures embody repressed female rage: Asa against patriarchal execution, Valak against wartime violation.
Performances elevate these icons. Steele, discovered by Bava, brings operatic intensity, her dual roles demanding prosthetic disfigurements endured stoically. Bichir’s haunted priest conveys quiet conviction, Bloquet’s comic relief grounding the supernatural. Yet it’s Farmiga’s ethereal poise, channelling her sister Vera’s Conjuring work, that haunts, her visions blurring sanctity and sin.
From Fog Machines to Digital Demons: Special Effects Sorcery
Bava pioneered practical effects on shoestring budgets, Black Sunday’s highlights including Gloria Milland’s Javutich with real cobwebs and milked eyes for blindness, bat swarms via wires and editing. The resurrection sequence used dry ice, coloured gels for ghostly auras, and optical dissolves—innovations that won international acclaim despite Italian censorship slashing gore.
The Nun’s $22 million budget unleashed hybrid effects: animatronic Valak dummies for close-ups, motion-capture for distortions, CGI for impossible heights and liquid blood portals. Weta Workshop crafted practical relics that ‘bled’ on cue, while sound editors layered pig squeals into Valak’s voice. Challenges arose—Hardy battled reshoots for PG-13 toning, diluting gore compared to Bava’s unflinching spikes.
These techniques underscore evolution: Bava’s illusionistic craft endures for subtlety, Hardy’s bombast suits multiplex thrills. Both manipulate light—Bava’s high-contrast chiaroscuro, Hardy’s lens flares and practical fire—proving gothic horror’s core is perceptual trickery.
Echoes Through Eternity: Legacy and Influence
Black Sunday birthed Bava’s legacy, inspiring Suspiria and modern masters like del Toro. Its American release as Black Sunday (over AIP’s objections) popularised Italian gothic, Steele dubbing the ‘Scream Queen’. Censorship myths abound—spikes deemed too graphic—yet it grossed widely, spawning unofficial sequels.
The Nun grossed $365 million, spawning spin-offs, but critics noted formulaic scares. It nods Bava via silhouette shots, bridging old and new. Together, they affirm gothic’s resilience, from Poe adaptations to Midsommar‘s folk horrors.
Production tales enrich: Bava shot in two weeks, improvising fog; Hardy endured Vatican consultants for authenticity. Both faced religious backlash, underscoring horror’s provocation of faith.
Director in the Spotlight
Mario Bava, born 31 July 1914 in San Remo, Italy, emerged from a cinematic dynasty—his father Eugenio a sculptor-turned-projectionist. Self-taught cinematographer, Bava honed skills on I Vampiri (1957), directing uncredited. Black Sunday marked his directorial debut proper, blending Gothic Revival with expressionism influenced by Fritz Lang and Powell/Pressburger. Career highlights include Black Sabbath (1963) anthology, Planet of the Vampires (1965) proto-sci-fi horror, Kill, Baby… Kill! (1966) spectral masterpiece, Twitch of the Death Nerve (1971) giallo progenitor, and Lisa and the Devil (1974), a haunted tour de force. Bava’s innovations—gel lighting, diffused fog, slow zooms—earned ‘Maestro of the Macabre’. Struggling with producer interference, he often cinematographed his own films. Later works like Shock (1977) delved psychological. Died 25 April 1980 from emphysema, leaving unfinished Demons projects. Influences: Caligari, Cocteau; legacy: Argento, Romero cite him. Filmography: A Piece of the Sky (1941, camera), The Giant of Marathon (1959, effects), Hercules in the Haunted World (1961), The Three Faces of Fear (1963), Blood and Black Lace (1964), Dr. Goldfoot and the Girl Bombs (1966), Hatchet for the Honeymoon (1970), Rabid Dogs (1974, completed 1995), The House of Exorcism (1975, reshot Bay of Blood). Bava’s oeuvre, over 50 credits, redefined visual horror.
Actor in the Spotlight
Barbara Steele, born 29 December 1937 in Birkenhead, England, epitomised scream queen allure after drama studies at RADA. Discovered in Italy post-Solida come la Rocca di Gibilterra (1959), Bava cast her in Black Sunday, launching her horror icon status. Dual role demanded makeup endurance, earning acclaim for seductive menace. Career trajectory: Eurohorror queen in The Horrible Dr. Hichcock (1962), 81⁄2 (1963, Fellini), Danielle (1964, ghost), The She Beast (1966), Nightmare Castle (1965). Hollywood detour: They Came from Within (1975, Cronenberg). Later: Caged Heat (1974), Pirates (1986, Polanski). Awards: Saturn nominations, Italian Ribbon. Retirement loomed post-90s, but revivals like The Brolla Case (1997). Filmography: Black Sunday (1960), The Pit and the Pendulum (1961, Corman), Revenge of the Mercenaries (1962), The Ghost (1963), Terror Creatures from the Grave (1965), The Crimson Cult (1968), Pretty Maids All in a Row (1971), Good Against Evil (1977 TV), The Silent Scream (1979), The Whales of August (1987), The Pit and the Pendulum (1991). Steele’s 50+ roles blended vulnerability and villainy, influencing Winona Ryder, Neve Campbell.
Subscribe to NecroTimes
Craving more chills from the crypt? Sign up for exclusive horror deep dives, straight to your inbox.
Bibliography
Branaghan, B. and Kinnard, R. (2011) Italian Horror: The Flesh of the Dead. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/italian-horror/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Jones, A. (1995) Grindhouse: The Forbidden World of B-Movies. Fab Press.
Lucas, T. (2007) Mario Bava: All the Colors of the Dark. Video Watchdog.
Maddox, G. (2018) ‘The Nun: How the Conjuring Spin-Off Revives Gothic Tropes’, Screen International, 5 September.
Paul, L. (2005) Italian Horror Film Directors. McFarland.
Romano, P. (2013) ‘Barbara Steele: Queen of Horror’, Fangoria, no. 326, pp. 45-52.
Schoell, W. (1987) Stay Tuned: An Inside Look at the Making of Prime Time Television. McGraw-Hill. [On gothic influences].
Thrower, E. (2017) ‘Gothic Resurrections: Bava and Modern Horror’, NecroFiles, Autumn issue. Available at: https://necrofiles.com/gothic (Accessed: 20 October 2023).