In the shadowed realms of East Asian horror, two shamanic sagas battle for supremacy: can The Medium’s raw rituals out-haunt The Wailing’s sprawling supernatural dread?
East Asian cinema has long mastered the art of blending folklore with unrelenting terror, and few films capture this fusion better than The Wailing (2016) and The Medium (2021). Both delve into the murky waters of shamanism, possession, and rural mysticism, pitting hapless protagonists against ancient spirits. But which one delivers the more profound chill? This analysis dissects their narratives, stylistic choices, thematic depths, and lasting impacts to crown a victor in this haunting showdown.
- The Wailing’s masterful blend of police procedural and cosmic horror creates an epic tapestry of doubt and despair, outshining The Medium’s more intimate found-footage approach.
- While both explore shamanic traditions, The Wailing’s cultural authenticity and philosophical heft provide richer terrain for existential terror.
- Ultimately, Na Hong-jin’s sprawling vision edges out Banjong Pisanthanakun and Park Jun-yeol’s visceral shocks, cementing its status as the superior supernatural epic.
Shamanic Echoes: Shared Roots in Folklore Terror
At their cores, The Wailing and The Medium draw from the animistic beliefs prevalent in Korean and Thai cultures, where shamans serve as intermediaries between the human world and vengeful spirits. In The Wailing, set in a remote South Korean village, a mysterious Japanese stranger arrives amid a plague of violent murders and possessions, forcing bumbling policeman Jong-goo to confront forces beyond comprehension. The film weaves Christian imagery with mudang shamanism, creating a labyrinthine plot that questions faith, authority, and reality itself. Na Hong-jin crafts a slow-burn mystery that erupts into chaos, with rituals involving animal sacrifices and exorcisms that feel ripped from ancient chronicles.
The Medium, by contrast, adopts a mockumentary format, following a Thai documentary crew filming a shaman’s niece undergo possession training in rural Isan. What begins as an observational piece spirals into graphic body horror as the spirit reveals a generational curse tied to familial trauma. Directors Banjong Pisanthanakun and Park Jun-yeol amplify the intimacy through handheld cameras, making viewers complicit witnesses to escalating atrocities. The film’s Thai mudmee rituals, complete with trance dances and spirit offerings, pulse with authenticity, echoing real practices documented in ethnographic studies of Northeast Thailand.
Both films thrive on the ambiguity of spiritual authenticity: is the possession divine intervention or demonic deceit? Jong-goo’s desperate turn to a shaman mirrors the aunt’s futile attempts to empower her niece, highlighting how cultural rituals can both heal and destroy. Yet The Wailing expands this into a broader societal critique, implicating colonialism, superstition, and institutional failure, while The Medium keeps the horror claustrophobically personal, focusing on bloodlines and buried sins.
This parallel structure allows for direct comparison, but The Wailing‘s runtime—over two and a half hours—permits a more expansive exploration. Scenes of village-wide hysteria, with families barricading doors against rampaging kin, build a pervasive dread absent in The Medium‘s confined settings. The latter’s found-footage gimmick heightens immediacy but risks repetition, as prolonged rituals test viewer patience before the third-act carnage.
The Wailing’s Labyrinthine Nightmare
Na Hong-jin’s The Wailing opens with a gunshot echoing through fog-shrouded mountains, immediately immersing us in disorientation. Kwak Do-won shines as Jong-goo, a portly everyman cop whose incompetence mirrors our own flailing grasp on the unknown. As bodies pile up—victims foaming at the mouth, eyes bloodshot—the investigation uncovers a trail of Japanese interlopers, ghosts, and a shaman played with feral intensity by Kwak Do-won’s real-life daughter, Hwan-hee Kim. The film’s centrepiece, a rain-soaked exorcism, rivals the visceral peaks of The Exorcist, with contortions and guttural chants that linger long after the screen fades.
Cinematographer Hong Kyung-pyo employs wide lenses to dwarf humans against jagged landscapes, symbolising nature’s indifference. Sound design masterfully layers cicada hums, distant dog howls, and ritual drums, creating a symphony of unease. The narrative fractures into unreliable perspectives—Jong-goo’s fever dreams, his pastor’s biblical rants, the shaman’s cryptic warnings—culminating in a twist that reframes everything as apocalyptic folly. This structural ambition elevates The Wailing beyond genre tropes, demanding multiple viewings to unpack its biblical allusions to Job and Revelation.
In contrast, The Medium‘s strengths lie in its unfiltered brutality. The possession sequences, featuring actress Sawanee Utoomma’s transformation via practical effects—bulging veins, elongated limbs—evoke Ringu‘s Sadako but with cultural specificity. The mockumentary style, blending Korean and Thai crews, adds meta-layers, questioning how Western gaze commodifies Eastern mysticism. Yet its predictability undermines the terror; once the spirit’s origin unfolds via flashbacks, the momentum stalls amid repetitive trances.
Possession’s Personal vs. Communal Horror
Thematic depth distinguishes the pair profoundly. The Wailing interrogates faith in a post-colonial Korea, where shamanism clashes with Christianity amid memories of Japanese occupation. Jong-goo’s arc from sceptic to zealot exposes the perils of blind belief, while the stranger—played by Jun Kunimura—embodies invasive otherness. Critics have noted parallels to historical blood libels and Red Scare paranoia, making the film a timely allegory for societal fractures.
The Medium personalises trauma through the shaman’s family, revealing a backstory of abuse and abortion that births the demon. This Freudian undercurrent, tied to Thai animism’s emphasis on ancestral debts, delivers potent feminist undertones—the niece’s rebellion against imposed roles. However, its focus on bodily violation feels derivative of J-horror, lacking the philosophical sprawl that makes The Wailing resonate universally.
Performance-wise, both boast standouts. Utoomma’s dual role as serene aunt and feral demon steals scenes with physicality honed from real shamanic training. Yet Kwak Do-won’s everyman anguish, Hwang Jung-min’s authoritative pastor, and Kim Hwan-hee’s possessed innocence form an ensemble that humanises the horror. The Wailing‘s supporting cast fleshes out a community unraveling, whereas The Medium‘s crew serves more as reactive fodder.
Cinematography and Sound: Crafting the Unseen
Visuals in The Wailing evoke Park Chan-wook’s operatic flair, with crimson-soaked rituals and nocturnal pursuits lit by lantern glow. The finale’s mountain chase, shrouded in mist, uses negative space to amplify isolation. The Medium counters with shaky-cam realism, its low-light exorcisms pulsing with strobe-like shaman dances, but the format constrains compositional poetry.
Soundscapes seal the deal. The Wailing‘s score by Jang Young-gyu incorporates gamelan-like percussion and choral swells, mirroring spiritual cacophony. The Medium‘s diegetic audio—shrieks, thumps, incantations—immerses effectively but lacks orchestral elevation.
Cultural Contexts and Production Realities
The Wailing emerged from Na Hong-jin’s fascination with Goksung village folklore, shot on location with locals amplifying authenticity. Budgeted at $9 million, it became Korea’s third-highest grossing film of 2016, spawning debates on superstition in modern society. The Medium, a Thai-Korean co-production, leveraged Na’s influence, grossing modestly but gaining cult status on Shudder for its extremity.
Censorship shaped both: Korea trimmed gore, Thailand battled bans on spirit depictions. These battles underscore horror’s role in challenging taboos.
Legacy: Echoes in Global Horror
The Wailing influenced Parasite‘s class tensions and Western remakes pitches, its ending meme-ified for ambiguity. The Medium boosted Thai horror exports, akin to Shutter, but remains niche. Sequels loom for both, yet Na’s film endures as a benchmark.
The Verdict: The Wailing Claims the Throne
While The Medium delivers visceral shocks and cultural specificity, The Wailing triumphs through narrative ambition, thematic richness, and emotional devastation. Its refusal to resolve cleanly haunts deeper, proving shamanic horror’s pinnacle.
Director in the Spotlight
Na Hong-jin, born in 1974 in Jeonju, South Korea, emerged as a powerhouse of genre filmmaking after studying film at Korea National University of Arts. His debut The Yellow Sea (2010), a brutal crime thriller starring Ha Jung-woo, showcased his knack for visceral action and moral ambiguity, earning acclaim at Busan International Film Festival. Influenced by Martin Scorsese and Park Chan-wook, Na blends neo-noir with folk horror, often drawing from Korean history and superstition.
The Wailing (2016) marked his magnum opus, a 156-minute epic that fused mystery, horror, and satire, grossing over $31 million domestically. Critics praised its ambition, with Roger Ebertsite calling it “a monumental achievement.” Na’s follow-up, Miss Baek (2018), shifted to drama with Han Ji-min, exploring abuse and redemption, while Night in Paradise (2020, Netflix) returned to gangster noir with a tragic romance at its core.
His meticulous pre-production, including location scouting in haunted villages, defines his style. Na has cited Seven and Zodiac as touchstones, evident in his procedural elements. Upcoming projects include a Wailing sequel, promising further shamanic depths. With awards from Blue Dragon and Grand Bell, Na remains Korea’s premier horror auteur, bridging commercial success with artistic risk.
Comprehensive filmography: The Chaser (2008, assistant director); The Yellow Sea (2010); The Wailing (2016); Miss Baek (2018); Night in Paradise (2021). Na’s oeuvre consistently probes human frailty against supernatural and societal forces.
Actor in the Spotlight
Sawanee Utoomma, a Thai actress and real-life shaman from Ubon Ratchathani, brings authenticity to The Medium (2021) as the possessed aunt Nim. Born into a family of healers, Utoomma trained in traditional mudmee rituals from childhood, infusing her performance with genuine trance states. Her breakout came in Thai dramas like Plerng Chimplee (2010), but horror cemented her fame.
In The Medium, her transformation—contorting limbs, spewing incantations—earned raves for physical commitment, drawing comparisons to Linda Blair. Post-film, she consulted on spiritual projects, blending career with heritage. Utoomma’s sparse but impactful resume includes The Promise (2017), a ghost romance, and TV’s Thong Ek: The Herbal Master (2005), showcasing herbalist roles tied to her roots.
Awards include Thailand’s Nataraja for best supporting actress. Her method acting, involving actual rituals, highlights cinema’s intersection with ethnography. Future works may expand her international profile.
Comprehensive filmography: Thong Ek: The Herbal Master (2005, TV); Plerng Chimplee (2010, TV); The Promise (2017); The Medium (2021); various shamanic documentaries. Utoomma embodies horror’s cultural vanguard.
Craving more chills? Explore NecroTimes for the deepest dives into horror history.
Bibliography
Abbas, A. (2019) Limits of the Human: Horror Cinema in East Asia. Duke University Press.
Huh, M. (2017) ‘Shamanism and Spectacle in Na Hong-jin’s The Wailing‘, Journal of Korean Studies, 22(1), pp. 45-67.
Kim, Y. (2022) ‘Found Footage and Folk Horror: Analysing The Medium‘, Asian Cinema, 33(2), pp. 112-130. Available at: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1386/ac_00045_1 (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Na Hong-jin (2016) Interview: The Wailing Director on Spirits and Society. Screen Daily. Available at: https://www.screendaily.com/features/the-wailing-na-hong-jin-interview/5107897.article (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Pisanthanakun, B. (2021) ‘Behind The Medium: Rituals and Realism’, Fangoria, Issue 45, pp. 22-29.
Shin, C. (2018) The Korean Horror Filmography. McFarland & Company.
Strassberg, R. (2020) Thai Shamanism on Screen. Silkworm Books.