In the shadowed realms of psychological horror, where dread seeps into every frame, The Wailing and The Witch vie for atmospheric supremacy – but only one truly suffocates the soul.
Two films, released mere months apart in 2015 and 2016, redefined the boundaries of psychological terror through their meticulously crafted atmospheres. Na Hong-jin’s The Wailing plunges viewers into a fog-shrouded Korean village gripped by plague and possession, while Robert Eggers’s The Witch transports us to the bleak isolation of 1630s New England Puritan life unraveling under witchcraft’s insidious gaze. Both masterfully blend folklore, faith, and fear, yet their approaches to building unease diverge sharply. This analysis dissects their sonic tapestries, visual textures, and narrative rhythms to crown the true king of creeping horror.
- The Wailing’s chaotic, cacophonous dread born from cultural shamanism eclipses The Witch’s restrained Puritan gloom through relentless sensory overload.
- Superior cinematography and sound design in The Wailing create an immersive, inescapable panic unmatched by The Witch’s deliberate sparsity.
- Ultimately, The Wailing claims victory in atmospheric depth, its fusion of mystery and monstrosity lingering longer in the psyche.
Fogbound Frenzy: The Wailing’s Village of Madness
The Wailing opens in the mist-cloaked mountains of rural South Korea, where a mysterious Japanese stranger arrives amid a rash of gruesome murders. Police officer Jong-goo, portrayed with raw desperation by Kwak Do-won, investigates as his own daughter falls victim to a grotesque illness. What unfolds is a labyrinthine tale blending serial killings, shamanistic rituals, and possible demonic incursions, directed with operatic intensity by Na Hong-jin. The atmosphere here is not subtle; it assaults from the outset, with thick fog rolling through narrow village paths like a living entity, obscuring threats just beyond visibility.
This fog serves as more than mere backdrop – it embodies the film’s core tension between the known and the unknowable. Cinematographer Hong Kyung-pyo employs wide-angle lenses to capture the vast, indifferent landscape dwarfing human figures, amplifying isolation amid community. Sounds of distant shamans’ drums and guttural chants pierce the silence, building a rhythmic pulse that mimics a heartbeat accelerating toward breakdown. Unlike traditional ghost stories, The Wailing roots its horror in Korean folklore, where ghosts demand justice and spirits possess through water and mountains, turning the environment itself into antagonist.
Jong-goo’s arc exemplifies this atmospheric stranglehold. As rational cop devolves into frantic father, scenes of him chasing spectral figures through rain-lashed forests pulse with kinetic energy. The rain, torrential and unending, slicks surfaces and blurs vision, heightening disorientation. Possession sequences erupt in visceral fury – convulsing bodies, foaming mouths, eyes rolling back – all underscored by a score that swells from eerie flutes to thunderous percussion, courtesy of composer Jang Young-gyu. This sensory barrage ensures viewers feel the chaos viscerally, as if infected by the village’s plague.
Puritan Penance: The Witch’s Bleak Wilderness
Contrast this with The Witch, where Robert Eggers conjures 17th-century New England through meticulous historical accuracy. A banished Puritan family – father William (Ralph Ineson), mother Katherine (Kate Dickie), and their children – ekes out existence on a forested farmstead. When their infant vanishes, snatched by a cackling witch in the woods, paranoia festers. Eggers, drawing from trial transcripts and diaries, builds atmosphere through austerity: grey skies, barren fields, and a goat named Black Phillip whose knowing stares hint at Satan.
The film’s visual palette, shot by Jarin Blaschke on 35mm, revels in natural light’s harshness. Candle flames flicker across wooden interiors, casting elongated shadows that twist like accusing fingers. Exteriors frame the family against impenetrable woods, symbolising wilderness as moral wilderness. Sound design by Leslie Shatz emphasises sparsity – wind howling through cracks, goats bleating ominously, Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy) whispering to Black Phillip in the finale. This restraint fosters creeping dread, where silence amplifies every creak or distant howl.
Yet, for all its authenticity, The Witch’s atmosphere leans scholarly. Period dialogue, thick with archaic phrasing, immerses but distances modern audiences. Key scenes, like the midnight meeting or the blood-soaked birth hallucination, stun with slow-burn intensity, but lack the propulsive terror of The Wailing’s climaxes. The witch herself appears sparingly, her naked form streaking through trees a jolt amid buildup, yet the film’s power resides in psychological erosion – faith crumbling under grief and accusation.
Sonic Assaults: Sound Design as Spectral Weapon
Atmosphere thrives on sound, and here The Wailing dominates. Jang Young-gyu’s score weaves traditional Korean instruments – gayageum strings twanging like snapping tendons, jing drums booming like ritual heartbeats – with modern dissonance. Voices warp during exorcisms, layering human screams with animalistic growls, creating a polyphonic nightmare. Ambient recordings of village life – barking dogs, clanging pots, shaman bells – ground the supernatural in everyday menace, blurring reality’s edges.
The Witch counters with minimalist mastery. No swelling orchestra; instead, diegetic sounds rule: rustling leaves foreshadowing evil, the axe thudding into wood echoing familial strife. Black Phillip’s deep, velvety voice in the climax – "Wouldst thou like to live deliciously?" – resonates with seductive menace, a sonic seduction pulling Thomasin toward damnation. Yet this subtlety, while effective, cedes ground to The Wailing’s immersive cacophony, which engulfs like the fog itself.
Critics note how The Wailing’s audio mimics psychosis onset, with overlapping dialogues and sudden silences heightening Jong-goo’s unraveling. In one pivotal sequence, a mountain chase builds through accelerating breaths and snapping twigs, culminating in a reveal that shatters composure. The Witch’s sounds, precise and historical, evoke dread through omission – what isn’t heard looms largest – but rarely achieves such raw, physiological impact.
Visual Viscera: Cinematography’s Grip on the Soul
Hong Kyung-pyo’s work in The Wailing is a tour de force of movement and mood. Steadicam tracks through crowded funerals and frantic pursuits, lenses distorting faces in rage or rapture. Colour grading favours sickly greens and muddied browns, with crimson blood erupting vividly against desaturated backdrops. Night scenes, lit by practical lanterns and car headlights, pierce fog like futile beacons, underscoring impotence against ancient evils.
Blaschke’s The Witch employs static compositions evoking Dutch masters, with frontal framing emphasising confrontation. Shallow depth of field isolates characters, their faces etched with fanaticism or fear. The woods, shot in Canadian forests standing in for New England, loom cyclopean, branches clawing at skies. Slow zooms during rituals build tension geometrically, yet the film’s aspect ratio – tall and narrow – constrains, mirroring familial entrapment.
Where The Witch paints with Vermeer’s precision, The Wailing splatters like Munch’s scream. Dynamic crane shots over plague-ridden villages convey scale and spread, while close-ups on pustule-covered flesh repulse intimately. Practical effects – melting faces, impaled bodies – ground horror physically, their grotesque realism amplifying atmospheric weight.
Cultural Cauldrons: Folklore’s Fertile Ground
The Wailing draws from Jeju shamanism and Japanese yokai lore, post-war tensions simmering beneath. The stranger embodies colonial ghosts, his mountain shrine a portal to vengeance. This cultural specificity infuses atmosphere with authenticity; rituals feel lived-in, possessions rooted in historical exorcisms. Na Hong-jin consulted shamans, incorporating authentic chants that resonate with Korean audiences’ collective memory.
The Witch excavates Salem hysteria from primary sources – Cotton Mather texts, family journals – portraying Puritanism’s repressiveness as witchcraft’s true vector. Gender tensions peak in Thomasin’s trial, her budding sexuality demonised. Eggers’s research yields palpable period terror, but universality tempers specificity; the family’s plight echoes any isolated zealotry.
Both films weaponise culture against psyche, yet The Wailing’s blend of Christianity, shamanism, and mystery – is it ghost, demon, or madness? – sustains ambiguity longer, fogging resolution till final frames. The Witch resolves more neatly, damnation a logical Puritan endpoint.
Pacing’s Poison: Slow Burn or Sudden Inferno?
The Witch excels in slow erosion, its 92 minutes unfolding deliberately. Early domestic scenes establish fragility, escalating to hysteria without rush. This mirrors psychological descent, unease compounding incrementally.
The Wailing sprawls over 156 minutes, procedural investigation ballooning into apocalypse. False leads and red herrings mimic Jong-goo’s confusion, pacing mirroring mania. Climactic ritual, a 30-minute tour de force of violence and revelation, cathartically explodes built pressure.
This expansiveness allows deeper atmospheric immersion; viewers marinate in dread, village life pulsing around periphery. The Witch, tauter, risks predictability despite brilliance.
Legacy’s Lingering Chill
The Wailing influenced Korean horror’s global rise, paving for Train to Busan and Peninsula with its spectacle-folk fusion. Fan theories dissect endings, fuelling discourse.
The Witch launched Eggers, Taylor-Joy, and A24’s prestige horror, spawning Midsommar echoes. Its feminism-through-folklore resonates culturally.
Yet atmospherically, The Wailing’s unyielding intensity haunts deeper, its village a perpetual nightmare.
Verdict from the Void: The Wailing Prevails
In psychological horror’s pantheon, atmosphere crowns The Wailing superior. Its sensory onslaught – fog, frenzy, folklore – immerses utterly, outpacing The Witch’s elegant chill. Both masterpieces, but one smothers breath completely.
Na Hong-jin: Architect of Korean Cosmic Horror
Na Hong-jin, born in 1974 in Jeonju, South Korea, emerged from a background blending film studies at Korea National University of Arts with early jobs in theatre. His debut, The Yellow Sea (2010), a brutal crime thriller starring Ha Jung-woo, showcased raw energy and moral ambiguity, earning best director at Blue Dragon Awards. This led to The Wailing (2016), his magnum opus blending police procedural with supernatural epic, grossing over $32 million domestically and cementing his status.
Influenced by Bong Joon-ho and Park Chan-wook, Na infuses social commentary into genre – class divides in The Yellow Sea, rural superstitions in The Wailing. Post-Wailing, he helmed Illang: The Wolf Brigade (2018), a dystopian actioner adapting Ghost in the Shell, praised for visuals despite mixed reviews. His latest, Pavilion of Spirits (upcoming), promises further shamanistic depths.
Filmography highlights: The Yellow Sea (2010): Ruthless hitman tale; The Wailing (2016): Plague-possessed village; Illang: The Wolf Brigade (2018): Armoured police vs terrorists. Na’s meticulous prep – living in villages for Wailing – yields authentic terror, positioning him as Korea’s horror visionary.
Robert Eggers: Forging Folklore into Nightmares
Born 1983 in New Hampshire, Robert Eggers grew up steeped in theatre, apprenticing at Arlington’s factory. A production designer first – The Lighthouse sets drew acclaim – he scripted The Witch (2015) from family documents, self-taught in historical research. Its Sundance premiere launched A24 careers, earning $40 million on $4 million budget, Independent Spirit Awards.
Influences span Germanic fairy tales, Lovecraft, and Powell/Pressburger. The Lighthouse (2019), starring Willem Dafoe and Eggers’s brother, channelled Melville into black-white mania, Venice awards. The Northman (2022) epic Viking revenge, grossing $70 million, blended history with shamanism.
Filmography: The Witch (2015): Puritan family vs woodland witch; The Lighthouse (2019): Keepers’ descent; The Northman (2022): Prince Amleth’s saga. Upcoming Nosferatu remake promises gothic revival. Eggers’s obsession with authenticity crafts immersive dread.
Kwak Do-won: Embodiment of Fractured Resolve
Kwak Do-won, born 1973 in South Korea, trained at Seoul Institute of Arts, debuting in theatre before film. Breakthrough in The Attorney (2013) as principled lawyer opposite Song Kang-ho, mirroring real activist. The Wailing (2016) showcased range, his Jong-goo shifting from bumbling cop to berserk parent, earning Blue Dragon nomination.
Notable roles span genres: Inside Men (2015) corrupt politico; Steel Rain (2017) North Korean defector; Deliver Us from Evil (2020) haunted priest. Awards include Grand Bell for The Attorney. Filmography: The Standard (2007); The Attorney (2013); Inside Men (2015); The Wailing (2016); Confidential Assignment (2017); Dark Figure of Crime (2018); Deliver Us from Evil (2020); Special Delivery (2022). Kwak’s everyman intensity anchors horrors.
Anya Taylor-Joy: Witch’s Enigmatic Heir
Anya Taylor-Joy, born 1996 in Miami to Argentine-British family, raised in London, scouted at 16 post-ballet. Debut The Witch (2015) as Thomasin propelled stardom, her wide-eyed innocence curdling to defiance earning Gotham Award. Split (2016) prey-to-predator arc, then Thoroughbreds (2017) psychopathic teen.
Global acclaim via The Queen’s Gambit (2020 miniseries), Emmy-nominated chess prodigy; Emma. (2020) Jane Austen lead. The Menu (2022) satirical horror. Filmography: The Witch (2015); Split (2016); Thoroughbreds (2017); The New Mutants (2020); Emma. (2020); The Queen’s Gambit (2020); Last Night in Soho (2021); The Menu (2022); The Northman (2022); Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024). Taylor-Joy’s piercing gaze defines modern scream queens.
Craving more atmospheric horrors? Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive deep dives into cinema’s darkest corners!
Bibliography
Bainbridge, C. (2015) Performing Dark Arts: A Cultural History of the Witch. Palgrave Macmillan.
Choi, J. (2018) ‘Shamanism and Spectacle in Na Hong-jin’s The Walling’, Journal of Korean Studies, 23(2), pp. 145-170. Available at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/26584321 (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Eggers, R. (2016) ‘Historical Horrors: An Interview with Robert Eggers’, Sight & Sound, British Film Institute. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-sound/interviews/robert-eggers (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Hong, K. (2017) ‘Cinematography of Dread: The Wailing’, American Cinematographer, 98(4), pp. 56-63.
Kim, Y. (2019) Korean Horror Cinema. Edinburgh University Press.
Na, H. (2016) ‘Behind The Wailing: Director’s Notes’, Korean Film Archive. Available at: http://www.koreafilm.or.kr (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Sharrett, C. (2017) ‘The Witch and American Puritanism’, Film International, 15(1), pp. 22-35. Available at: https://filmint.nu (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
VanDerWerff, T. (2020) ‘Revisiting The Witch Five Years Later’, Vox. Available at: https://www.vox.com/culture/2020/2/19/21142579/the-witch-robert-eggers-anniversary (Accessed: 15 October 2024).