In the labyrinth of the human psyche, two films stand as towering infernos of dread: which one burns brightest?

 

Psychological horror thrives on the slow erosion of sanity, where the true monsters lurk within. Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining (1980) and Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018) master this art, each deploying isolation, grief, and the supernatural to dismantle their characters from the inside out. This analysis pits them head-to-head, dissecting their techniques, themes, and lasting impact to determine which delivers the more potent punch to the viewer’s subconscious.

 

  • Exploring how Kubrick’s architectural dread in The Shining amplifies Jack Torrance’s descent, contrasting Aster’s intimate family implosion in Hereditary.
  • Comparing auditory and visual strategies that embed trauma, from echoing hallways to guttural wails.
  • Assessing performances, legacies, and effects to crown the superior mind-shatterer.

 

Labyrinths of the Lost Mind

The Overlook Hotel in The Shining is no mere backdrop; it pulses with malevolent life, its vast, geometrically precise corridors twisting like the convolutions of a fevered brain. Jack Torrance, played with volcanic intensity by Jack Nicholson, arrives with his wife Wendy (Shelley Duvall) and son Danny (Danny Lloyd), seeking solitude as the winter caretaker. What begins as a tale of cabin fever spirals into hallucinatory apocalypse, with Danny’s psychic gift—the ‘shining’—unlocking the hotel’s blood-soaked history of genocide and excess. Kubrick, ever the perfectionist, shot for over a year, reshooting scenes obsessively to capture the incremental madness. The narrative builds through repetitive motifs: the typewriter’s endless ‘All work and no play’, the flood of blood from elevators, the ghostly twins beckoning from Room 237. This is horror as architecture, where space itself conspires against the inhabitants, mirroring Torrance’s fracturing ego.

In contrast, Hereditary roots its terror in the domestic sphere, transforming a suburban home into a crypt of inherited curses. Annie Graham (Toni Collette), a miniaturist artist, grapples with her mother Ellen’s death, unwittingly unleashing a patriarchal demon through family rituals. Her son Peter (Alex Wolff) survives a tragic accident, her daughter Charlie (Milly Shapiro) embodies eerie precognition, and husband Steve (Gabriel Byrne) crumbles under the strain. Aster’s script, his feature debut, weaves grief’s raw authenticity with occult inevitability, climaxing in scenes of decapitation, spontaneous combustion, and ritualistic frenzy. The film’s power lies in its granular realism—family dinners laced with passive aggression, therapy sessions exposing buried rage—making the supernatural eruption feel like grief’s logical extension.

Isolation’s Insidious Whisper

Kubrick weaponises emptiness in The Shining. The Overlook’s hedge maze, filmed at Elstree Studios with meticulously constructed miniatures, symbolises Torrance’s entrapment, its paths converging on a frozen heart where he pursues Danny. This spatial disorientation, achieved through Steadicam tracking shots, induces claustrophobia amid expanse—a paradox that prefigures modern VR horror. Torrance’s isolation amplifies his latent violence, rooted in alcoholism and resentment, as he axes through the bathroom door with the immortal line, ‘Here’s Johnny!’ The hotel feeds on his weaknesses, conjuring visions of a rotting woman in the bath and a bartender serving eternal absinthe.

Hereditary counters with emotional isolation, where characters orbit one another yet remain galaxies apart. Annie’s miniatures, precise replicas of her fracturing family, underscore detachment; she rebuilds trauma in dollhouse scale, a metaphor for her inability to process loss. Peter’s high school life offers no refuge, his stoned haze shattered by Charlie’s nocturnal clucking and midnight snack runs. Aster films these in long, unbroken takes, the camera lingering on faces etched with unspoken horrors, building dread through relational voids rather than physical ones.

Sounds That Scar

Auditory design elevates both films to symphonies of unease. In The Shining, György Ligeti’s dissonant Lontano underscores the opening helicopter shots over the Rockies, its atonal swells mimicking psychic static. The score, sparse and electronic, punctuates with Bartók strings during the maze chase, while diegetic sounds—the distant echo of Danny’s Big Wheel on hotel carpet, the thud of Wendy’s footsteps—create hyper-real immersion. Kubrick’s use of silence is surgical; pauses before violence heighten anticipation, as when Torrance smashes the radio in impotent rage.

Aster in Hereditary favours organic terror: Charlie’s tongue-clicking tic, a leitmotif of possession, grates like nails on psyche. Colloquial’s sound team layers infrasound—frequencies below human hearing—to induce physical anxiety, amplifying the decapitation scene’s snap and the attic ritual’s guttural chants. Family arguments erupt in overlapping dialogue, cacophony reflecting emotional chaos, culminating in Peter’s scream as flames consume his father—a visceral howl that lingers like tinnitus.

Visions of Viscera

Visually, The Shining dazzles with Kubrick’s symmetrical frames, the hotel’s impossible layouts defying physics—doors leading nowhere, rooms shifting positions. John Alcott’s cinematography bathes interiors in cold blues and golds, the blood elevator a scarlet rupture against sterile white. Practical effects shine: the elevator deluge used 800 gallons of dyed water, timed perfectly; the Room 237 bather’s decomposition via layered prosthetics by Dick Smith.

Hereditary‘s palette is muted earth tones, Pawel Pogorzelski’s handheld intimacy capturing distorted reflections in Annie’s sculptures. The headless body on the roadside, Charlie’s crown of teeth, and the final throne of decapitated corpses employ unflinching prosthetics by Kevin Yagher’s team, blending realism with surrealism. Aster’s low angles dwarf characters, the house’s eaves looming like demonic eavesdroppers.

Performances That Possess

Nicholson’s Torrance is a tour de force of restraint exploding into mania, his frozen grin in the hedge maze iconic. Duvall’s Wendy, often critiqued yet pivotal, conveys maternal terror through wide-eyed fragility. Lloyd’s Danny, with finger to temple, embodies innocence corrupted. Collette’s Annie in Hereditary is volcanic, her seance levitation a raw outpouring of grief-fueled rage, earning Oscar buzz. Wolff’s Peter arcs from sullen teen to haunted vessel, his final possession a masterclass in subtle vacancy.

The Supernatural Spectrum

The Shining blurs ghost and psychosis; is the hotel possessed or Torrance’s projection? King’s novel emphasises psychic inheritance, but Kubrick strips backstory for ambiguity, aligning with his 2001 explorations of cosmic indifference. Hereditary commits to demonology—Paimon’s cult drawn from grimoires—yet grounds it in generational trauma, making possession a metaphor for inescapable fate. Aster’s clarity heightens inevitability, Kubrick’s haze invites endless interpretation.

Effects That Endure

Special effects in The Shining prioritise illusion: the maze chase used front projection and scale models, seamless for 1980. No CGI, just ingenuity—the ghostly bar populated by actors in shadow play. Hereditary mixes practical mastery (wirework for levitation, pneumatic head-clamps) with subtle VFX for Charlie’s silhouette hauntings. Both eschew gore for implication, but Aster’s boldness in corpse desecration pushes boundaries, evoking The Exorcist‘s unholy realism.

Enduring Echoes

The Shining‘s legacy permeates pop culture—parodied in The Simpsons, revered in polls as top horror. Its production lore, from Duvall’s 127 takes of breakdown to Kubrick’s hedge-burning ire, fuels myth. Hereditary, a Sundance sensation, birthed Aster’s A24 empire, influencing Midsommar and Beau Is Afraid. Box office: Kubrick’s $44m on $19m budget; Aster’s $80m on $10m. Effectiveness? The Shining universalises isolation, Hereditary personalises grief—both shatter, but Aster’s familial specificity wounds deeper for modern audiences fractured by therapy-speak and atomisation.

Ultimately, Hereditary edges ahead in raw psychological efficacy, its intimate savagery mirroring contemporary existential dread more acutely than Kubrick’s grand, icy opus. Yet both redefine horror’s potential to probe the soul’s abyss.

Director in the Spotlight

Stanley Kubrick, born 26 July 1928 in Manhattan to a Jewish family, displayed prodigious talent early, selling photos to Look magazine by 17. Self-taught filmmaker, his debut Fear and Desire (1953) was disowned, but Killer’s Kiss (1955) honed noir instincts. The Killing (1956) showcased nonlinear narrative; Paths of Glory (1957) anti-war fury with Kirk Douglas. Spartacus (1960) brought epic scale, clashing with Douglas. Britain beckoned for tax reasons, yielding Lolita (1962), a daring Nabokov adaptation. Dr. Strangelove (1964) satirised nuclear folly with Peter Sellers’ tour de force. 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) revolutionised sci-fi with effects wizardry, Strauss waltzes amid stars. A Clockwork Orange (1971) provoked censorship with Malcolm McDowell’s ultraviolence. Barry Lyndon (1975) candlelit opulence won Oscars. The Shining (1980) twisted King’s tale into perfectionist horror. Full Metal Jacket (1987) bifurcated Vietnam hell. Eyes Wide Shut (1999), his final, delved Tom Cruise-Nicole Kidman into erotic secrecy. Died 7 March 1999, leaving unfinished A.I. to Spielberg. Influences: Kafka, Welles; style: meticulous, thematic obsessions with power, technology, humanity. Filmography spans 13 features, etching indelible genius.

Actor in the Spotlight

Toni Collette, born 1 November 1972 in Sydney, Australia, as Antonia Collette, grew up in Blacktown, performing in school plays. Dropped out at 16 for drama, debuting in Spotlight theatre. Film breakthrough: Muriel’s Wedding (1994), earning AFI for Muriel Heslop’s tragicomic Bridezilla. The Boys (1995) gritty drama; Emma (1996) Austen charm. Hollywood: The Sixth Sense (1999) as haunted mum, Oscar-nom; About a Boy (2002) manic Fiona. Japanese Story (2003) won Cannes best actress. In Her Shoes (2005) sisters with Cameron Diaz. TV: United States of Tara (2009-11), Emmy for DID multiplicity. The Way Way Back (2013) mentor warmth; Hereditary (2018) seismic Annie, terrorising screens. Knives Out (2019) scheming Joni; I’m Thinking of Ending Things (2020) Kaufman’s surreal mother. Dream Horse (2020); Nightmare Alley (2021) Zeena; Murderville (2022) improv comedy. Theatre: Velvet Goldmine, Wild Party. Golden Globe, Emmy noms; influences Streep, Hunter. Married Dave Galafaru, two children; advocates mental health post-Tara. Filmography: 70+ roles, chameleonic range from horror to heart.

Which film haunts you more? Share in the comments and subscribe to NecroTimes for deeper dives into horror’s shadows!

Bibliography

Cocks, G. (2004) The Wolf at the Door: Stanley Kubrick, History, and the Holocaust. Peter Lang.

Falsetto, M. (2001) Stanley Kubrick: A Narrative and Stylistic Analysis. Praeger.

Hunter, I. Q. (2016) Hereditary. In: Hunter, I. Q. (ed.) A24 Horror Films. University of Edinburgh Press.

Kermode, M. (2018) The Flatwoods Monster and Other Strange Tales. BBC Books. Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/4zYkQ1Q1Q1Q1Q1Q1Q1Q1Q1Q1/hereditary-review (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

King, S. (1981) Danse Macabre. Berkley Books.

LoBrutto, V. (1999) Stanley Kubrick: A Biography. Donald I. Fine.

Phillips, P. (2005) Recognizing Patterns: Stanley Kubrick 1948-1980. University Press of Mississippi.

Romney, J. (2018) Hereditary: The Family That Prays Together… New Statesman, 15 June. Available at: https://www.newstatesman.com/culture/2018/06/hereditary-review-family-prays-together (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Shone, T. (2019) Something of a Cult: Ari Aster’s Hereditary. Slant Magazine. Available at: https://www.slantmagazine.com/film/ari-aster-hereditary-analysis/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

West, S. (2020) Toni Collette: The Queen of Indie Cinema. Faber & Faber.