Mind’s Fractured Mirrors: Repulsion and The Babadook’s Assault on Sanity

In the dim corridors of the mind, two women confront horrors born not from external monsters, but from the shattering of their own psyches.

Roman Polanski’s Repulsion (1965) and Jennifer Kent’s The Babadook (2014) stand as towering achievements in psychological horror, each peeling back the layers of female isolation and mental collapse with unflinching precision. These films, separated by nearly five decades, share a profound kinship in their exploration of grief, repression, and the monstrous potential lurking within the human subconscious. By juxtaposing their narratives, techniques, and cultural impacts, we uncover how psychological terror evolves while remaining eternally tethered to the fragility of the self.

• Both films masterfully depict the descent into madness through isolated female protagonists, using domestic spaces as prisons of the mind.
• They transform intangible traumas—sexual repression in Repulsion, maternal grief in The Babadook—into visceral, hallucinatory entities that blur reality and nightmare.
• Innovative sound design and claustrophobic cinematography in each amplify dread, proving the genre’s power lies not in gore, but in the erosion of sanity.

The Solitary Prisons of the Protagonist

Carol Ledoux in Repulsion, portrayed with haunting fragility by Catherine Deneuve, inhabits a Kensington flat that decays in tandem with her fracturing mind. Polanski’s camera lingers on her wide, unblinking eyes, capturing the slow creep of dissociation as everyday sounds—ticking clocks, dripping taps—morph into harbingers of doom. Her repulsion towards male touch stems from an implied incestuous trauma, rendering her apartment a fortress against the world, yet a tomb for her sanity. The film’s opening close-up of a scarred potato symbolises this rot, a mundane object transmogrified into an emblem of psychological putrefaction.

Similarly, Amelia in The Babadook barricades herself and her son Samuel within their creaking suburban home, a space haunted by the absence of her late husband. Essie Davis delivers a performance of raw, unraveling desperation, her face etched with exhaustion from sleepless nights and Samuel’s erratic behaviour. The Babadook itself emerges from a pop-up book, Mister Babadook, its top-hatted silhouette a manifestation of suppressed mourning. Kent frames Amelia’s kitchen and bedroom as battlegrounds where domesticity unravels, mirroring Carol’s space in how walls close in, shadows lengthen, and the boundary between protector and predator dissolves.

What unites these women is their profound isolation, not merely physical but emotional. Carol recoils from her sister Hélène’s lover and suitors alike, her catatonia a rebellion against patriarchal intrusion. Amelia, widowed on her husband’s birthday, resents Samuel as a reminder of loss, her grief festering into rage. Both narratives reject the male gaze as salvation; instead, men become catalysts for horror—brutally dispatched in hallucinatory violence that feels both inevitable and cathartic.

Trauma’s Monstrous Incarnations

In Repulsion, the horrors are internal projections: hands groping from walls, corridors stretching infinitely, a man raped by an invisible force in Carol’s hallucination. Polanski draws from surrealist traditions, evoking Buñuel’s Un Chien Andalou in its dream logic, where sexual dread manifests physically. The film’s black-and-white palette enhances this unreality, shadows pooling like ink blots from a Rorschach test, forcing viewers to confront their own repressed fears.

The Babadook externalises grief as a gothic entity, the Babadook’s gravelly voice and contorted form a pop-up book villain come alive. Kent subverts fairy-tale tropes, positioning the monster not as otherworldly but as an allegory for depression—an uninvited guest that must be acknowledged rather than exorcised. Amelia’s climactic confrontation, force-feeding the creature a bowl of worms in the basement, symbolises integration of trauma, a resolution Repulsion denies, leaving Carol in catatonic defeat.

Yet both films interrogate motherhood’s burdens differently. Carol’s childlike regression contrasts Amelia’s fraught maternal role; Samuel’s violent outbursts parallel Carol’s own, suggesting cycles of inherited madness. These incarnations critique societal expectations: the virginal beauty driven mad by desire, the grieving mother pathologised as hysterical. In each, the ‘monster’ is the psyche’s revenge against silence.

Soundscapes of Impending Collapse

Polanski’s use of sound in Repulsion is a symphony of dissonance. Composer Chico Hamilton’s jazz-inflected score underscores unease, while diegetic noises—Hélène’s lovemaking thuds, shattering glass—amplify Carol’s sensory overload. Silence punctuates violence, as in the rabbit rotting on the table, its stench implied through laboured breaths. This auditory isolation mirrors her emotional state, where external harmony invades her fragile equilibrium.

Kent employs sound with equal mastery in The Babadook, the Babadook’s signature scrape—”Ba-da-badoooook”—a chilling refrain that burrows into the viewer’s subconscious. Creaking floorboards, Samuel’s screams, and Amelia’s sobs build a cacophony of familial discord. The film’s sound design, blending low-frequency rumbles with domestic clatters, evokes real psychological distress, drawing from clinical descriptions of auditory hallucinations in trauma survivors.

Comparative analysis reveals evolution: Repulsion‘s analogue austerity yields to The Babadook‘s digital precision, yet both weaponise the everyday sonic palette. This technique cements their status as exemplars of psychological horror, where the ear becomes as besieged as the eye.

Cinematography’s Claustrophobic Grip

Gilbert Taylor’s cinematography in Repulsion employs deep focus and slow zooms to trap Carol within frames, her face often off-centre, emphasising alienation. Hallway distortions via fish-eye lenses evoke Lynchian unease avant la lettre, while harsh contrasts between lit rooms and encroaching dark symbolise encroaching insanity. Polanski’s handheld shots during kills inject urgency, the camera complicit in voyeurism.

Radek Ladczuk’s work in The Babadook favours static wide shots of empty spaces, heightening anticipation—the Babadook’s shadow looms before its form. Low angles empower Samuel’s paranoia, while close-ups on Amelia’s trembling hands convey tactile dread. Kent’s use of negative space, inspired by The Shining, transforms the home into a maze, much like Polanski’s flat.

Both eschew jump scares for sustained tension, proving psychological horror thrives on implication. Their visual languages—minimalist, expressionistic—invite psychoanalytic readings, where every frame dissects the female gaze turned inward.

Gender, Grief, and Societal Shadows

Repulsion grapples with 1960s sexual liberation’s underbelly, Carol’s breakdown a feminist critique of commodified femininity. Deneuve’s icy beauty belies vulnerability, Polanski—drawing from his own exile—infusing exile-within as universal dread. The film anticipates second-wave feminism, portraying hysteria not as weakness but resistance.

The Babadook extends this to modern motherhood, Amelia’s isolation reflecting work-life imbalances and mental health stigma. Kent, influenced by her own grief, crafts a post-9/11 parable of suppressed emotion, where the Babadook embodies collective anxiety. Samuel’s Oedipal aggression complicates dynamics, positioning the film as a queer-coded exploration of non-traditional family.

Juxtaposed, they trace psychological horror’s feminist arc: from repressed desire to acknowledged loss, both indicting societies that silence women’s pain.

Production Nightmares and Lasting Echoes

Repulsion, Polanski’s first English-language film, faced censorship battles; its rape scene pushed boundaries, earning an X rating. Shot in 21 days on a shoestring budget, it launched Polanski’s reputation for intimate terror, influencing Rosemary’s Baby and The Tenant.

The Babadook premiered at Sundance after Kent’s seven-year labour, its low budget yielding genre-defining impact. Viral marketing via the pop-up book amplified mystique, spawning merchandise and parodies.

Legacies intertwine: Repulsion birthed apartment horrors like Sisters; The Babadook popularised ‘trauma monsters’ in It Follows. Together, they affirm psychological horror’s endurance.

Special effects remain subtle: Repulsion‘s practical prosthetics for wall hands, The Babadook‘s puppetry and CGI for the creature. These ground abstractions in tactility, heightening authenticity.

Director in the Spotlight

Roman Polanski, born Rajmund Roman Liebling Polanski on 18 August 1933 in Paris to Polish-Jewish parents, endured unimaginable trauma that profoundly shaped his filmmaking. His family relocated to Kraków, Poland, where the Nazi occupation orphaned him young; his mother perished in Auschwitz, and he survived by scavenging on the Aryan side. Post-war, Polanski immersed in cinema, studying at the Łódź Film School, where he honed his craft amid Poland’s communist regime.

His early shorts like Two Men and a Wardrobe (1958) showcased surrealism, leading to features such as Knife in the Water (1962), a tense thriller signalling his mastery of confined spaces. Exiled to the West after artistic clashes, Polanski arrived in London for Repulsion, cementing his psychological horror niche. Cul-de-sac (1966) followed with absurdist dread, then Hollywood beckoned with Rosemary’s Baby (1968), a paranoid masterpiece blending horror and satire.

Tragedy struck in 1969 with the murder of pregnant wife Sharon Tate by the Manson Family, imprinting grief on later works like Chinatown (1974), a neo-noir pinnacle. Fleeing US charges in 1978, Polanski continued in Europe: Tess (1979) earned Oscar nods; Pirates (1986) veered comedic; The Pianist (2002) won him Best Director at the Oscars, a Holocaust survivor’s elegy. Recent efforts include Venus in Fur (2013) and Based on a True Story (2017), exploring power and deception.

Influenced by Hitchcock and Buñuel, Polanski’s filmography—over 20 features—excels in moral ambiguity, often starring women in peril: The Tenant (1976) echoes Repulsion‘s identity crisis; Bitter Moon (1992) twists erotica into horror; An Officer and a Spy (2019) dissects injustice. A controversial figure due to legal woes, his cinema remains a testament to resilience and unflinching human portraits.

Actor in the Spotlight

Catherine Deneuve, born Catherine Dorléac on 22 October 1943 in Paris, France, into a theatrical dynasty—her parents actors, sister Françoise Dorléac a star—embarked on child modelling before cinema claimed her. Debuting at 13 in Les Collégiennes (1956), she gained notice in Les Demoiselles de Rochefort (1967) with her sibling, but Repulsion (1965) catapulted her to icon status at 22, embodying enigmatic beauty and madness.

Jacques Demy’s Les Parapluies de Cherbourg (1964) sung her to Cannes glory; Roman Polanski then cast her in his dread-soaked trio—Repulsion, The Tenant (1976), and producer on Macbeth (1971). Buñuel collaborations defined her: Belle de Jour (1967) as a bored housewife’s fantasies; Tristana (1970) as rebellious orphan; Le Fantôme de la liberté (1974) surreal vignettes.

Versatile across eras, Deneuve shone in Indochine (1992), earning César and Oscar nods as a plantation owner; The Umbrellas of Cherbourg redux in musicals; arthouse like 8 Women (2002), a whodunit ensemble. Recent roles: The Truth (2019) with daughter Chiara Mastroianni; De son vivant (2021) poignant drama. Over 120 films, she garnered César Awards (1981, 1996), Venice honours, and cultural ambassadorships, embodying French elegance amid complexity.

Mother to Christian Vadim and Chiara, Deneuve navigated scandals with poise, her icy poise masking depth—perfect for Repulsion‘s Carol. Influences from Bardot to Godard, she redefined the femme fatale as introspective force.

Craving deeper dives into horror’s darkest corners? Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive analyses and never miss a shiver.

Bibliography

Conrich, I. (2002) Coming of Age in the 1970s Scream Queen: The Stardom of Jamie Lee Curtis. Scope: An Online Journal of Film and Television Studies. Available at: https://www.scope.nottingham.ac.uk/article.php?issue=jan2005&id=308 (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Frey, D. (2019) The Rise of Renée Vivien. University of Illinois Press.

Kent, J. (2014) The Babadook: Director’s Commentary. Roadshow Entertainment.

Polanski, R. (1984) Roman. William Morrow.

Segal, D. (2014) ‘The Babadook and the Fright of Feeling Real’, The New York Times, 28 November. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/30/movies/the-babadook-and-the-fright-of-feeling-real.html (Accessed 15 October 2023).

White, M. (1995) Roman Polanski: Prophecy and Scepticism. Faber & Faber.

Williams, L. (2007) Screening Sex. Duke University Press.

Wilson, E. (1985) Adorned in Dreams: Fashion and Modernity. Virago Press.