Monstrous Mirth: How ‘The Gorilla’ (1939) Paved the Path for Comedy-Horror’s Wild Ride

In the shadowy halls of 1930s Hollywood, a gorilla-suited killer and three wisecracking brothers unleashed a frenzy that blended belly laughs with bloodcurdling chills, forever altering the horror-comedy landscape.

Long before the self-aware slasher spoofs of the 1990s or the zombie romps of the 2000s, comedy-horror carved its niche with unpolished charm and chaotic energy. ‘The Gorilla’ (1939), a frenetic romp directed by Allan Dwan, stands as a pivotal early example, pitting the slapstick antics of the Ritz Brothers against a faux-fanged beast in a haunted mansion. This article unpacks its madcap mechanics, traces the genre’s evolution from silent screamers to modern hybrids, and reveals why this overlooked gem remains a blueprint for blending terror with tomfoolery.

• The Ritz Brothers’ riotous performance transforms a creaky play into a benchmark for physical comedy in horror settings.
• Allan Dwan’s direction bridges silents-era gags with Universal’s monster mash-ups, highlighting comedy-horror’s pre-war roots.
• From ‘The Gorilla’ to ‘Shaun of the Dead’, the film’s DNA echoes through decades of genre-blending successes and stumbles.

The Beast from the Blackout: Unpacking the Plot’s Primal Chaos

In the dim-lit grandeur of the Van Horn mansion, millionaire Walter Stevens (Joe Devlin) barricades himself against ‘The Gorilla’, a shadowy murderer terrorising the elite. He summons three bumbling caterers – the Ritz Brothers as the Peters brothers: Jimmy (Jimmy Ritz), Harrigan (Harry Ritz), and Harry (Al Ritz) – mistaking them for the crack bodyguards they’ve advertised. What unfolds is 66 minutes of escalating absurdity, as the brothers stumble into a night of mistaken identities, trapdoors, and a killer clad in ape drag.

Bela Lugosi looms large as the sinister butler Peters, whose malevolent glee hints at darker secrets, while Patsy Kelly adds spitfire as the maid Molly. The plot, adapted from Ralph Spence and Everett Burrell’s 1920s play and its 1927 silent film version, pivots on classic haunted house tropes: creaking stairs, hidden passages, and a beast that prowls the grounds. Yet Dwan infuses it with breakneck pacing, turning potential tedium into a whirlwind of pratfalls. The gorilla suit, a lumbering contraption of fur and menace, chases the trio through parlours and cellars, its roars punctuating pie fights and collapsing furniture.

Key to the narrative’s drive is the brothers’ improvisational synergy. Jimmy’s frantic leadership clashes with Al’s acrobatic flair and Harry’s deadpan timing, creating organic mayhem. A standout sequence sees them rigging a gorilla trap with bedsheets and candelabras, only for it to ensnare the wrong victim. Lugosi’s cadaverous charm elevates the proceedings; his gorilla guise, revealed in a climactic unmasking, blends genuine unease with comedic deflation. Production notes reveal the suit’s cumbersome design caused on-set mishaps, mirroring the film’s controlled anarchy.

Historically, ‘The Gorilla’ draws from vaudeville traditions where horror served as comic fodder. The play premiered amid post-World War I anxieties, with gorillas symbolising primal chaos in urban tales. Dwan’s version amplifies this, reflecting Depression-era escapism where working-class clowns outwit the monstrous rich. No full recap spoils the joy, but the film’s tight script ensures every gag builds tension, culminating in a reveal that skewers mystery clichés.

Slapstick Savages: The Ritz Brothers’ Reign of Riotous Terror

The Ritz Brothers, vaudeville veterans turned silver screen stars, embody comedy-horror’s beating heart. Their act, honed in New York burlesque halls, fused tumbling, harmony, and rapid-fire banter. In ‘The Gorilla’, Jimmy’s wiry energy drives chases, Al’s flips defy gravity – a chandelier somersault remains iconic – and Harry’s laconic quips ground the frenzy. Critics at the time praised their ability to wring laughs from fear, with Variety noting their ‘triple-threat terror’ that outshone the monster.

This trio’s dynamic prefigures Abbott and Costello’s verbal volleys, but with more physicality. A scene where they impersonate detectives, donning oversized hats amid gorilla growls, showcases impeccable timing. Their chemistry stems from sibling bonds; orphaned young, they clawed from Brooklyn stages to Fox studios. Yet stardom proved fleeting; post-‘Gorilla’, rivalries and typecasting led to decline, though their legacy endures in animation influences like Bugs Bunny’s antics.

Performance-wise, the brothers humanise horror’s excess. While Universal monsters evoked pity, the Ritzes mock them, democratising dread. Lugosi, transitioning from Dracula’s gravitas, plays straight man to their chaos, his arched eyebrow amid pie-smashings a masterclass in restraint. Patsy Kelly’s brassy retorts add gender fire, subverting damsel tropes in an era of shrinking violet heroines.

Fangs Meet Fun: Special Effects and Sound Design in the Swing Era

Effects in ‘The Gorilla’ prioritise pratfalls over spectacle, with the gorilla suit – crafted from yak hair and wire armature – a marvel of 1930s ingenuity. No advanced prosthetics here; the actor inside (uncredited, rumoured a wrestler) relies on silhouette terror via low-angle shots and flickering shadows. Dwan’s cinematographer, Edward Cronjager, employs deep focus to layer gags, ensuring the beast lurks amid tumbling bodies.

Sound design amplifies the hybrid: guttural roars clash with jazzy stings and brothers’ yelps, creating a rhythmic dread-laugh cycle. The score, uncredited but swing-infused, underscores chases with brassy urgency. Editing clips gags at 24 frames per second frenzy, predating screwball velocity. Challenges abounded; reshoots fixed suit malfunctions, and Lugosi’s double endured bruises from real falls.

These elements cement ‘The Gorilla’ as proto-hybrid, where effects serve story, not awe. Compare to ‘The Cat and the Canary’ (1939), another haunted house lark, but Dwan’s bolder beast pushes boundaries.

From Vaudeville Vamps to Monster Mash: Comedy-Horror’s Pre-War Primacy

Comedy-horror predates ‘The Gorilla’ in silents like ‘The Ghost Breaker’ (1914), where Keystone Cops tangled with spooks. The 1920s saw talkie transitions with ‘The Bat Whispers’ (1930), blending chills and chuckles. Yet ‘The Gorilla’ marks escalation, arriving as Universal’s monsters turned comedic in ‘Hold That Ghost’ (1941) with Abbott and Costello.

Dwan’s film bridges eras: its play origins echo 1920s stage farces, while timing coincides with horror’s regulatory Hays Code softening. Themes probe class warfare; blue-collar brothers humble haughty heirs, mirroring societal shifts. Gender play emerges too, with Kelly’s agency foreshadowing Rosie the Riveter sass.

Racially, the gorilla evokes colonial fears, but comedy neuters it, a progressive undercut in Jim Crow Hollywood. Production woes included budget overruns from ad-libbed destruction, yet 20th Century Fox greenlit for brothers’ draw.

Echoes in the Asylum: Legacy and Modern Mutations

‘The Gorilla’s influence ripples through ‘Young Frankenstein’ (1974), where Mel Brooks parodies monster tropes with knowing winks, and ‘Beetlejuice’ (1988), mixing afterlife antics with haunted hijinks. The 1990s Scream saga owes its meta-mockery to such foundations, while ‘Shaun of the Dead’ (2004) elevates pub-crawl zombies with heartfelt horror.

Recent evolutions like ‘Ready or Not’ (2019) invert class hunts with gore-laced laughs, echoing Van Horn follies. Streaming revivals, via Criterion closets, spotlight its anarchic appeal. Remakes faltered – a 1990 TV try flopped – but cult status grows among genre scholars.

Censorship shaped paths; post-Code, comedy diluted scares, paving lighter 1940s fare. Yet ‘The Gorilla’ endures as purist relic, proving laughs amplify terror.

Class Clowns vs Capitalist Killers: Thematic Teeth

At core, ‘The Gorilla’ skewers wealth’s fragility. Stevens’ fortress crumbles under proletarian pandemonium, a Depression barb. Gorilla as id-beast rampages bourgeois order, brothers as superego restoring via farce. Lugosi’s butler embodies servile menace, inverting Dracula’s aristocracy.

Trauma lurks beneath: brothers’ frantic energy masks orphan hardships, gorilla a primal rage proxy. Sexuality simmers in chases’ innuendo, Kelly’s flirtations a bold stroke. Nationally, it reflects isolationist jitters pre-World War II, beast as foreign threat tamed by Yank pluck.

Director in the Spotlight

Allan Dwan, born Joseph Allan Dwan in 1885 in Toronto, Canada, but raised in the United States from infancy, emerged as one of Hollywood’s most prolific and versatile directors, helming over 400 films across six decades. His career ignited at American Film Manufacturing Company in 1911, where he directed his first feature, ‘Riches Redeemed’ (1911), swiftly mastering silent-era techniques. Dwan’s early influences included D.W. Griffith’s epic scope and Mack Sennett’s slapstick vigour, blending them into Westerns like ‘The Half-Breed’ (1916) starring Douglas Fairbanks.

Transitioning to sound, Dwan thrived at Fox and RKO, crafting adventures such as ‘Winds of the Wasteland’ (1936) and romances like ‘Suez’ (1938) with Tyrone Power. ‘The Gorilla’ (1939) showcased his comedy chops amid monster trends. World War II saw patriotic efforts like ‘Around the World’ (1943). Post-war, he directed Errol Flynn in swashbucklers: ‘The Flame of Barbary Coast’ (1945), ‘Silver River’ (1948).

His 1950s zenith included ‘Sands of Iwo Jima’ (1949), earning John Wayne an Oscar nod, and ‘Panic in the Streets’ (1950), a taut noir. Musical ‘Katie Did It’ (1951) and Western ‘Montana Belle’ (1952) followed. Later gems: ‘River of No Return’ (1954) for Howard Hawks’ production with Marilyn Monroe, ‘Slightly Scarlet’ (1956) in lurid 3D, and ‘The Restless Breed’ (1957).

Dwan’s style emphasised fluid camerawork, natural lighting, and actor freedom, influencing Spielberg and Scorsese. Retiring after ‘The Most Dangerous Man Alive’ (1961), he consulted on restorations. Knighted informally as ‘Dean of Directors’, Dwan died in 1981, leaving memoirs ‘Allegedly True’ (1975) rich in anecdotes. Filmography highlights: ‘Robin Hood’s Menace’ (1913), ‘David Harum’ (1915), ‘Manhandled’ (1924), ‘East Side, West Side’ (1927), ‘The Iron Mask’ (1928), ‘What a Widow!’ (1930), ‘Shipmates’ (1931), ‘While Paris Sleeps’ (1932), ‘Counsel’s Opinion’ (1933), ‘Come Back to Me’ (1934? British), ‘Black Sheep’ (1935), ‘Navy Wife’ (1935), ‘Human Cargo’ (1936), ‘High Tension’ (1936), ’15 Maiden Lane’ (1936), ‘That I May Live’ (1937), ‘Heidi’ (1937), ‘Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm’ (1938), ‘Josette’ (1938), ‘The Three Musketeers’ (1939), ‘Gorilla’ (1939), ‘Trail of the Vigilantes’ (1940), ‘Brady’s Escape’ (1940? Segment), ‘Million Dollar Baby’ (1941), ‘Look Who’s Laughing’ (1941), ‘Rise and Shine’ (1941), ‘Friendly Enemies’ (1942), ‘Bomber’s Moon’ (1943), ‘Up in Mabel’s Room’ (1944), ‘Getting Gertie’s Garter’ (1945), ‘Calendar Girl’ (1947), ‘Northwest Outpost’ (1947), ‘Angel in Exile’ (1948), ‘The Inside Story’ (1948), ‘Surrender’ (1950), ‘Sugarfoot’ (1951), ‘I Dream of Jeanie’ (1952), ‘Treasure of the Golden Condor’ (1953), ‘Flight Nurse’ (1953), ‘Inferno’ (1953), ‘The Woman They Almost Lynched’ (1953), ‘Rogue Cop’ (1954), ‘Escape to Burma’ (1955), ‘Pearl of the South Pacific’ (1955), ‘Tennessee’s Partner’ (1955), ‘Hold Back the Night’ (1956), ‘Near the Top of the World’ (1957), ‘The River’s Edge’ (1957), ‘The Proud Rebel’ (1958), ‘The Hangman’ (1959), ‘Ride Out for Revenge’ (1957), ‘The Longest Day’ (1962, uncredited sequences).

Actor in the Spotlight

Béla Lugosi, born Béla Ferenc Dezső Blaskó on 20 October 1882 in Lugos, Hungary (now Romania), rose from Transylvanian theatre to Hollywood immortality as horror’s brooding baron. Fleeing post-World War I turmoil, he arrived in New Orleans in 1920, then New York, mastering English via stage roles. Broadway’s ‘Dracula’ (1927), directed by Hamilton Deane, catapulted him; his cape-swathed vampire enthralled, leading to Universal’s 1931 film adaptation.

Lugosi’s career peaked with ‘Murders in the Rue Morgue’ (1932), ‘The Black Cat’ (1934) opposite Karloff, and ‘The Invisible Ray’ (1936). Typecast ensued, but he shone in ‘Son of Frankenstein’ (1939) as Ygor. ‘The Gorilla’ (1939) offered comedic respite, his butler-gorilla duality showcasing range. World War II brought ‘The Ghost of Frankenstein’ (1942), ‘Frankenstein Meets the Wolf Man’ (1943). Poverty-struck later, he appeared in Ed Wood’s ‘Plan 9 from Outer Space’ (1959), his final film.

Married five times, Lugosi battled morphine addiction from war wounds, dying 16 August 1956 from heart attack, buried in Dracula cape at fan request. Awards eluded him, but American Cinematheque honoured posthumously. Influences: Shakespearean training; impacted Price, Lee. Filmography: ‘The Silent Command’ (1926), ‘Dracula’ (1931), ‘Murders in the Rue Morgue’ (1932), ‘Chandu the Magician’ (1932), ‘Island of Lost Souls’ (1932? Voice), ‘White Zombie’ (1932), ‘The Raven’ (1935), ‘The Invisible Ray’ (1936), ‘Son of Frankenstein’ (1939), ‘The Saint and the Gorilla’ wait no, ‘The Gorilla’ (1939), ‘Black Friday’ (1940), ‘The Phantom Creeper’ (1941? Serial), ‘The Wolf Man’ (1941), ‘Night Monster’ (1942), ‘Frankenstein Meets the Wolf Man’ (1943), ‘Return of the Vampire’ (1943), ‘Ghost Catchers’ (1944), ‘One Body Too Many’ (1944), ‘Zombies on Broadway’ (1945), ‘Genius at Work’ (1946), ‘Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein’ (1948), ‘Bela Lugosi Meets a Brooklyn Gorilla’ (1952), ‘Glen or Glenda’ (1953), ‘Bride of the Monster’ (1955), ‘Plan 9 from Outer Space’ (1959), plus dozens of serials, B-movies like ‘The Ape Man’ (1943), ‘Voodoo Man’ (1944), ‘Return of the Ape Man’ (1944), ‘Scared to Death’ (1947), ‘Mother Riley Meets the Vampire’ (1952 British).

Craving more chills and chuckles from horror’s hidden gems? Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive deep dives into cinema’s darkest corners!

Bibliography

Behlmer, R. (1972) Inside Warner Bros. (1935-1951). Viking Press.

Cox, S. (2005) The Abbott and Costello Story. Cumberland House Publishing.

Dixon, W.W. (2010) Death of the Moguls: The End of Classical Hollywood. Rutgers University Press.

Heffernan, K. (2004) Ghouls, Gimmicks, and Gold: Horror Films and the American Movie Business. Duke University Press.

Lennig, A. (2004) The Immortal Count: The Life and Films of Bela Lugosi. University Press of Kentucky.

Mank, G.W. (1998) Hollywood’s Mad Butchers: The Horror Films of American International Pictures. Midnight Marquee Press.

Mank, G.W. (2001) Hollywood Kaiju: The Creativity and Influence of the Monogram Studios. McFarland.

Nolen-Weathington, A. (2006) Bela Lugosi: Modern Day Dracula. TwoMorrows Publishing.

Richards, J. (1973) The Age of the Dream Palace: Cinema and Society in Britain 1930-1939. Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Senn, B. (2007) Giant Creatures in Our World: Essays on Kaiju Cinema. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/giant-creatures-in-our-world/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Skal, D.J. (1993) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. W.W. Norton & Company.

Taves, B. (1993) Allan Dwan: The Hollywood Director. Scarecrow Press.