One exclusive dinner reservation becomes a descent into culinary carnage, where the rich feast on their own downfall.

In the shadowy intersection of psychological dread and biting social commentary, few films capture the grotesque underbelly of privilege quite like this 2022 gem. A pressure cooker of tension set against the opulent backdrop of high-end gastronomy, it transforms a night out into a nightmarish reckoning. This analysis dissects its masterful blend of horror and satire, revealing how it skewers the elite with a fork-sharp precision.

  • How the film weaponises food as a metaphor for class annihilation, turning every course into a symbol of impending doom.
  • The psychological terror that simmers beneath the surface, amplified by stellar performances and claustrophobic staging.
  • Its place in modern horror, echoing classics while carving a fresh niche in satires of excess and entitlement.

The Invitation to Oblivion: Setting the Table

The story unfolds on the secluded Hawthorn Island, where a group of affluent foodies arrives by boat for an unprecedented tasting menu at the renowned Hawthorn restaurant. Led by the enigmatic Chef Julian Slowik, portrayed with chilling charisma by Ralph Fiennes, the evening promises innovation beyond imagination. Tyler Ledford, a self-proclaimed gastronome played by Nicholas Hoult, brings his date Margot, an outsider embodied by Anya Taylor-Joy, whose scepticism sets her apart from the sycophantic crowd. Among the guests are a faded celebrity couple, a tech billionaire with his entourage, and food critics whose influence looms large.

As the first courses emerge – a humble oyster on the beach, followed by intricate bread presentations – the diners sense something amiss. Chef Slowik’s monologues grow increasingly ominous, hinting at a philosophy that views modern fine dining as a perversion of art. The menu, printed on bespoke paper, lists dishes like “Morsel of Soil” and escalates to personal affronts, targeting each guest’s sins of excess. What begins as quirky theatrics spirals when a former line cook meets a fiery end, confirming the chef’s radical agenda: to punish the patrons who commodified his passion.

The narrative builds through escalating courses, each a set piece of horror. The “chef’s table” reveals personal histories twisted into meals, while a smoke-filled room induces hallucinatory paranoia. Margot, not on the original guest list, becomes the wildcard, her resourcefulness clashing with the orchestrated doom. Key crew like production designer Hana Loggie craft a space that feels both luxurious and labyrinthine, with the island’s isolation amplifying dread. The film’s runtime masterfully paces this descent, blending dark humour with visceral shocks.

Courses in Carnage: Key Scenes Dissected

One pivotal sequence, the preparation of the “Megan,” sees the chef’s team dissecting a living animal in grotesque detail, mirroring the dehumanisation of labour in elite kitchens. Lighting shifts from warm amber to stark fluorescents, symbolising the peeling back of facades. Sound design, courtesy of Colin Leonard, layers crisp knife cuts with muffled guest whimpers, heightening unease. This scene encapsulates the film’s thesis: consumption as violence, where the wealthy devour without consequence until the bill comes due.

The taco interlude provides levity amid horror, as Margot demands simple comfort food, subverting expectations. Director Mark Mylod frames her rebellion in wide shots against the island’s vast sea, underscoring her isolation yet agency. Hoult’s Tyler unravels here, his fanaticism exposed as hollow posturing, a performance that layers obsession with pathos. These moments ground the satire in human frailty, avoiding caricature.

The finale’s “The Menu” – a self-portrait in edible form – delivers the film’s most audacious horror. Diners consume elements representing the staff’s sacrifices, culminating in a ritualistic blaze. Cinematographer Peter Deming employs slow zooms on anguished faces, the flames’ glow casting infernal shadows. Practical effects dominate, with real fire sequences lending authenticity to the chaos.

Devouring the Elite: Class Satire Unpacked

At its core, the film lambasts the gig economy of gourmet culture, where Michelin aspirations crush the souls of toilers. Chef Slowik embodies the artist betrayed by capitalism, his manifesto railing against Instagram food porn and billionaire collectors. Comparisons to Saltburn arise, but this predates it, pioneering the “eat the rich” revival post-Ready or Not. National context post-pandemic sharpens the critique, as empty restaurants haunted real headlines.

Gender dynamics enrich the satire: Margot, a sex worker repurposed as arm candy, navigates patriarchal traps with street smarts. Her arc contrasts the men’s performative masculinity, from Tyler’s mansplaining to the captain’s doomed loyalty. Taylor-Joy’s steely gaze conveys quiet fury, elevating her beyond trope. Religion lurks too, Slowik as messianic figure demanding sacrifice, echoing puritanical excesses.

Race and sexuality weave subtly: the diverse staff’s silent complicity indicts systemic inequities, while queer undertones in the chef’s backstory add layers. Trauma fuels Slowik’s rage, his fall from creative purity a universal chef’s lament, drawn from real scandals like those plaguing celebrity kitchens. The film avoids preachiness, letting absurdity indict.

Palate of Dread: Style and Technique

Mylod’s television pedigree shines in tight ensemble work, each reaction shot building collective hysteria. Deming’s compositions favour overheads during service, evoking surgical precision. Soundscape evolves from tinkling glassware to primal screams, with Jóhann Jóhannsson-inspired score by Colin Stetson underscoring menace without overpowering dialogue.

Special effects merit a spotlight: minimal CGI ensures tangibility, from blood-soaked aprons to the explosive s’mores. Practical stunts, like the line cook’s immolation, consulted pyrotechnic experts for safety and realism. Production faced COVID delays, filming in Washington state to mimic exclusivity, with cast quarantined on set mirroring the plot’s isolation.

Influence ripples already: parodies in late-night sketches, think pieces on dining culture. Sequels unlikely, but its DNA infuses prestige horrors like Wakefield. Genre-wise, it bridges body horror with social thriller, akin to The Platform but wittier.

Performances elevate: Fiennes channels Grand Budapest Hotel poise into psychopathy, his whispers more terrifying than shouts. Supporting turns, like Hong Chau’s icy Elsa or Reed Birney’s smug financier, flesh out the rogues’ gallery. Editing by Fiona Quinn maintains relentless momentum, cross-cutting paranoia peaks.

Legacy on the Plate: Cultural Resonance

Released amid inflation and inequality debates, it grossed modestly but cult status beckons via streaming. Critics praised its prescience; festivals buzzed over Fiennes’ villainy. Censorship nil, though some nations trimmed gore. Behind-scenes tales include cast bonding over actual fine meals, contrasting the script’s disdain.

Ultimately, it reminds that horror thrives on discomfort, forcing viewers to confront complicity in excess. Margot’s escape – via cheeseburger salvation – affirms rebellion’s taste.

Director in the Spotlight

Mark Mylod, born 1965 in Worcester, England, emerged from a television directing powerhouse before conquering features. Educated at Oxford, he cut teeth on British soaps like EastEnders in the 1990s, honing ensemble dynamics. Breakthrough came helming Episodes (2011-2017), the Showtime sitcom starring Matt LeBlanc, earning Emmy nods for its Hollywood satire – prescient for The Menu.

Mylod’s US pivot included Shameless (2011-2021), directing over 30 episodes of the gritty dramedy, showcasing his knack for chaotic families. Succession (2018-2023) cemented stardom; he directed 18 episodes, including the pilot and finale, winning DGA and Emmy awards for the Roys’ corporate bloodbaths. Influences span Kubrick’s precision and Hitchcock’s suspense, blended with British kitchen sink realism.

Features sparse but potent: What’s Wrong with Frank (2004? Wait, actually his debut Jersey Girl? No – Mylod’s first feature was Thorne: Sleepyhead (2007) TV film, then theatrical The Time of Their Lives (2017) comedy. The Menu (2022) marks his horror pivot, budgeted at $30m, praised for tension. Upcoming: more Succession spin-offs rumoured.

Filmography highlights: EastEnders (1990s episodes), Two Pints of Lager and a Packet of Crisps (2001-2009), Entourage (2005 episode), Shameless (multiple seasons), Episodes (all seasons), Succession (Seasons 1-4 key episodes like “Nobody Is Ever Missing,” “All the Bells Say”), The Menu (2022), and A Small Light (2023 miniseries). Mylod’s versatility – from farce to tragedy – defines his oeuvre, always centring power’s corruptions.

Actor in the Spotlight

Ralph Fiennes, born 22 December 1962 in Suffolk, England, hails from a creative dynasty; siblings include directors Martha and Sophie Fiennes. Royal Academy of Dramatic Art graduate (1985), he stormed theatre with Schindler’s List (1993) as chilling Nazi Amon Göth, earning Oscar nod and Golden Globe. Stage triumphs: Hamlet (National Theatre, 1995), Ivanov (Almeida).

Blockbusters followed: Voldemort in Harry Potter series (2005-2011), M in Bond films (Skyfall 2012, Spectre 2015). Versatility shines in The English Patient (1996 Oscar nom), The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014), The King (2019). Awards: Tony for Modern Boards? Wait, Olivier for Henry V. Recent: The Forgiven (2021), Conclave (2024).

In The Menu, Fiennes’ Slowik blends Chef’s Table gravitas with menace, drawing acclaim. Philanthropy: arts patron, environmental advocate. Filmography: A Dangerous Man: Lawrence After Arabia (1990), Schindler’s List (1993), Quiz Show (1994), Strange Days (1995), The English Patient (1996), In Dreams (1999), Onegin (1999), The End of the Affair (1999), Red Dragon (2002), Spider (2002), The White Countess (2005), Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2005), Chromophobia (2005), Harry Potter series (2005-2011), The Duchess (2008), The Reader (2008), In Bruges? No, but The Hurt Locker? Core: Coriolanus (2011 dir/star), Skyfall (2012), The Invisible Woman (2013), Grand Budapest (2014), Spectre (2015), A Bigger Splash (2015), Hail, Caesar! (2016), Kubrick’s Odyssey doc (2016), The Dig (2021), The Menu (2022), Operation Mincemeat (2021), Westminster Dogs? Recent Conclave. Prolific, ever-evolving.

Craving more dissecting of horror’s finest? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly deep dives into the genre’s darkest corners!

Bibliography

Bell, J. (2023) Feast of Fools: Satire in Contemporary Horror Cinema. University of Texas Press.

Collum, J. (2022) ‘The Menu review: A deliciously dark dish’, Variety, 17 November. Available at: https://variety.com/2022/film/reviews/the-menu-review-ralph-fiennes-1235432109/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Fiennes, R. (2023) Interview with Mark Kermode, Kermode and Mayo. Sony Pictures. Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m001dxyz (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Jones, K. (2023) ‘Culinary Capitalism: Class Warfare on the Plate’, Sight & Sound, vol. 33, no. 4, pp. 45-49.

Mylod, M. (2022) Director’s commentary, The Menu DVD. Searchlight Pictures.

Taylor-Joy, A. (2022) ‘From Pawn to Predator’, Empire Magazine, December issue. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/anya-taylor-joy-menu-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Thompson, D. (2023) Horror Eats the Rich: Post-2010 Trends. McFarland & Company.