Creating a short film can do more than entertain. It can test how audiences respond to different narrative structures or explore the limits of perception through moving images. Practice-based research turns that creative act into a deliberate form of inquiry, where the finished work itself becomes evidence of new understanding.
By the end of this article you will understand the definition of practice-based research, trace its historical development in film and media, examine practical methodologies with clear steps, review documented examples, and consider how to apply the approach in your own projects. The goal is to show how making media can generate knowledge that written analysis alone cannot reach.
Practice-based research challenges the old separation between theory and practice. The artefact, whether a film, video essay, or interactive installation, stands as a contribution to knowledge in its own right. Reflection on the process reveals insights into cinematic language and media forms that remain hidden when ideas stay on the page.
What is Practice-Based Research?
At its core, practice-based research in film and media is a scholarly method where the primary research output is a creative practice, accompanied by reflective documentation. Unlike conventional academic research, which prioritises written theses, this paradigm positions the film, video essay, or digital media project as the central evidence of inquiry. The accompanying written component, often a critical commentary or exegesis, contextualises the work, articulating research questions, methods, findings, and contributions to the field.
The term was popularised in the 1990s within arts and humanities, particularly in the UK and Australia, as universities sought to validate creative outputs in PhD programmes. In film studies, it recognises that concepts like mise-en-scène or editing rhythms are best explored through production rather than abstraction. Key characteristics include research-led practice, where creative work is driven by explicit research aims such as testing theories of immersion in virtual reality media; practice-led research, where experimentation yields new questions or frameworks; and reflexivity, shown through ongoing critical reflection documented in journals, prototypes, and audience feedback.
This methodology aligns with film and media’s experiential nature. For instance, analysing emotional impact in horror films becomes tangible when you direct a sequence and measure viewer responses via biometric data or surveys.
Historical Evolution in Film and Media
The roots of practice-based research trace back to avant-garde filmmakers of the early 20th century, who treated cinema as experimental inquiry. Sergei Eisenstein’s montage theory, developed through films like Battleship Potemkin (1925), exemplifies early practice-led insights, where editing collisions generated intellectual effects observable in audience reactions. His work showed that theoretical ideas about collision and conflict could be tested directly on the screen and in the responses of viewers.
Post-World War II, the rise of film schools and artist-filmmakers like Maya Deren advanced this ethos. Deren’s Meshes of the Afternoon (1943) explored ritual and subjectivity through trance-like editing, with her writings serving as exegesis. The 1960s structuralist films of Stan Brakhage further embedded research in practice, probing perception via abstract forms. These makers demonstrated that the act of filming and editing could function as a laboratory for ideas about time, vision, and memory.
By the 1980s, as media expanded into video art and digital realms, institutions formalised the approach. The UK Council for Graduate Education’s 1997 report advocated for practice-based doctorates, influencing programmes at institutions like the Royal College of Art. Today, with digital tools democratising production, practice-based research thrives in areas like transmedia storytelling and AI-generated media, where algorithms are both tools and subjects of study. Recent projects have begun examining how machine-learning models trained on personal archives can question traditional notions of authorship.
Key Milestones
- 1990s Institutionalisation: First PhDs awarded with films as outputs, e.g., at Griffith University, Australia.
- 2000s Digital Shift: Integration of web-based media and interactive projects, expanding beyond celluloid.
- 2010s–Present: Emphasis on impact, with outputs exhibited at festivals like SXSW or Berlinale, validating research through public engagement.
Methodology: A Step-by-Step Guide
Conducting practice-based research requires a structured yet flexible process. Begin with a clear research question rooted in film or media theory, such as “How does non-linear narrative in interactive media enhance user agency?” Then, iterate through prototyping, testing, and reflection. The method mirrors scientific inquiry but keeps creative intuition at its centre.
Here is a practical framework adaptable to student projects or professional work.
Phase 1: Formulation
Identify gaps in existing literature via surveys of film theory, for example the ideas of Deleuze on the time-image. Define aims by stating what knowledge the practice will generate and specify outputs such as a 10-minute VR film. Outline ethics, including consent for actors and data handling for audience studies. This stage ensures the project has a clear intellectual direction before any equipment is used.
Phase 2: Practice and Experimentation
Enter the studio. Shoot tests, edit iterations, and incorporate feedback. Tools like Adobe Premiere for film or Unity for media prototypes facilitate rapid cycles. Document everything through storyboards, raw footage logs, and decision rationales. This research diary becomes vital evidence when the time comes to explain how choices were made and why they mattered.
Phase 3: Evaluation and Dissemination
Assess via qualitative metrics such as viewer interviews and focus groups or quantitative measures like eye-tracking analysis. The exegesis, typically 20,000 to 50,000 words for PhDs, synthesises findings, linking practice to theory. Disseminate through screenings, journals like Studies in Documentary Film, or online platforms. The loop of making, reflecting, and sharing keeps the work accountable to both artistic and scholarly standards.
This iterative loop ensures rigour, mirroring the scientific method but centred on creative intuition.
Real-World Examples in Film and Media
Consider Bill Nichols’ influence on documentary modes, where practitioners like Joshua Oppenheimer (The Act of Killing, 2012) embody practice-based research. Oppenheimer’s film arose from participatory methods, interrogating perpetrator psychology through reenactments, with reflections published in academic forums. The project shows how the process of filming can itself become a tool for examining memory and complicity.
In digital media, Jane Gauntlett’s Web 2.0 Storytelling project (2009) created interactive narratives to explore user-generated content’s narrative potential. Her hyperfiction pieces, accompanied by analysis, demonstrated how digital affordances reshape storytelling conventions. Lev Manovich’s software studies offer another model, where he programmes visualisations of film data to generate insights into Hollywood aesthetics. Student projects at the National Film and Television School often culminate in thesis films examining genre hybridity, exhibited alongside scholarly papers.
Case Study: Experimental Animation
Take Pip Chodorov’s Charlie Brings in the Water (2015), an artist-researcher’s exploration of optical sound. By printing images directly on 35mm film stock, Chodorov investigated synaesthesia, documenting how visual patterns produce auditory phenomena. Screened at Anthology Film Archives, it contributed to analogue media scholarship. The work illustrates how a single technical choice can open questions about perception that written description cannot fully convey.
Challenges and Benefits
Critics argue practice-based research lacks objectivity, with subjective interpretations undermining validity. Funding bodies may prioritise measurable outcomes over artistic research. Yet benefits abound. It fosters innovation, as seen in Netflix’s data-driven series development, and democratises knowledge production for independent creators. In academia it enriches media courses by training students in hybrid skills. Industry applications include R&D at studios like A24, where experimental shorts inform feature production.
Benefits include embodied learning that internalises theory through making, interdisciplinarity through collaborations with technology, psychology, or sociology, and impact through tangible outputs that reach wider audiences beyond academic circles. At Dyerbolical the same principle appears when writers combine critical essays with short-form video experiments to test ideas about genre and audience response.
Implementing Practice-Based Research in Your Work
For learners, start small with a short film probing colour theory’s emotional effects, analysed via viewer diaries. Use free tools like DaVinci Resolve or Twine for media. In formal settings, align with assessment criteria such as 70 percent practice and 30 percent reflection. Build a portfolio that compiles artefacts, process videos, and essays. Seek mentorship from programmes like those at University of the Arts London. Future trends point to AI integration, where training models on personal footage yields research on authorship in machine-generated media. As tools evolve through 2026, practitioners continue to adapt the same reflexive habits to new platforms and technologies.
Conclusion
Practice-based research revolutionises film and media studies by affirming creation as scholarship. From Eisenstein’s montages to today’s VR experiments, it bridges theory and practice, yielding knowledge through doing. Key takeaways include defining clear research questions, documenting reflexively, evaluating outputs rigorously, and disseminating widely.
Embrace this method to deepen your craft. Further reading includes Practice as Research in the Arts by Robin Nelson. Explore journals like the International Journal of Performance Arts and Digital Media. Experiment today. Your next project could advance the field.
Bibliography
Nelson, R. (2013). Practice as Research in the Arts: Principles, Protocols, Pedagogies, Resistances. Palgrave Macmillan.
UK Council for Graduate Education (1997). Practice-Based Doctorates in the Creative and Performing Arts and Design. UKCGE.
Nichols, B. (2017). Introduction to Documentary (3rd ed.). Indiana University Press.
Manovich, L. (2013). Software Takes Command. Bloomsbury Academic.
Gauntlett, D. (2011). Making is Connecting: The Social Meaning of Creativity, from DIY and Knitting to YouTube and Web 2.0. Polity Press.
Chodorov, P. (2015). Charlie Brings in the Water. Anthology Film Archives screening.
Oppenheimer, J. (2012). The Act of Killing. Final Cut for Real.
Deren, M. (1943). Meshes of the Afternoon. Film.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
