Sacred Fractures: Repulsion and Saint Maud’s Divine Terrors

In the quiet chambers of the mind, faith twists into frenzy, where salvation and slaughter blur into one unholy vision.

Roman Polanski’s Repulsion (1965) and Rose Glass’s Saint Maud (2019) stand as twin pillars of psychological horror, each dissecting the perilous intersection of belief and breakdown. These films, separated by over half a century, converge on the female psyche under siege from internal convictions, transforming personal faith into a vector for visceral dread. Through meticulous soundscapes, claustrophobic visuals, and unflinching character studies, they expose how devotion can devour the devotee.

  • Both narratives chart the inexorable slide of isolated women into hallucinatory violence, propelled by warped interpretations of spirituality.
  • Polanski’s stark modernism clashes with Glass’s baroque intensity, highlighting evolutions in horror’s portrayal of mental fracture.
  • Iconic performances by Catherine Deneuve and Morfydd Clark elevate intimate torment into universal unease, cementing the films’ lasting chill.

Cracks in the Facade: Parallel Descents

Carol in Repulsion inhabits a Brussels apartment that warps around her like a living mausoleum, its walls pulsing with the echoes of her unspoken traumas. A shy manicurist haunted by her sister’s liaisons, Carol recoils from male touch, her Catholic upbringing manifesting in auditory assaults: bells tolling judgment, whispers of sin. Polanski captures her isolation through lingering shots of empty corridors, where hands emerge from plaster to grope her flesh. The film’s opening close-up of a dead rabbit’s eye sets a tone of decay, mirroring her rotting psyche as she spirals into murder.

In Saint Maud, Maud arrives in a coastal English town as a private nurse to Amanda, a terminally ill dancer whose agnostic cynicism clashes with Maud’s fervent conversion. Once Katie, a nurse scarred by a patient’s fiery death, Maud now channels guilt into saintly masochism, flagellating herself and seeking visions. Glass films her in high-contrast shadows, crucifixes looming like guillotines. As Maud’s evangelism intensifies, reality frays: stigmata bleed, rooms invert, culminating in a climax of flames and fanaticism that recalls her past sin.

These protagonists share a monastic withdrawal, barricading against the world. Carol’s apartment becomes a hermetic cell, smeared with blood and decay; Maud’s bedsit a shrine of pins and prayers. Both reject carnality—Carol through frigidity, Maud through renunciation—yet their bodies betray them in grotesque tableaus. Polanski’s slow zooms invade Carol’s stupor, while Glass employs Dutch angles to disorient Maud’s piety, underscoring how faith amplifies isolation into insanity.

Their violence erupts not from external monsters but endogenous phantoms. Carol slays her landlord and a suitor with a razor, her face blank as a somnambulist; Maud’s aggression turns inward then explosive, demanding salvation through suffering. This inward horror distinguishes the films from slasher tropes, rooting terror in epistemology: what if one’s god is a hallucination?

Faith as the Ultimate Predator

Religion in Repulsion simmers unspoken, a Belgian Catholic residue Polanski infuses with Freudian dread. Carol’s aversion to sex evokes original sin, her hallucinations priestly condemnations. The convent-like austerity of her life—white dress, scrubbed floors—crumbles into sacrilege, walls cracking like altars toppled. Polanski, drawing from his own wartime displacements, probes repression’s toll, where faith stifles rather than saves.

Saint Maud thrusts faith centre stage, Maud’s evangelical zeal a post-secular affliction. Her conversion post-accident births a messianic delusion, blending Pentecostalism with Catholic mortification. Glass interrogates modern spirituality’s fringes, where YouTube sermons fuel fanaticism. Maud’s prayer vigils escalate to bodily penance, nails driven into palms, echoing Christ’s agony but twisted into narcissism. The film critiques faith healing’s hubris, Amanda’s pain unallayed by Maud’s zealotry.

Juxtaposed, the films reveal faith’s dual blade: repressive in Polanski’s era, proliferative in Glass’s. Carol’s muted piety implodes silently; Maud’s extroverted gospel broadcasts via dance and blood. Yet both depict belief as solipsistic, protagonists proselytising to phantoms—Carol to imagined rapists, Maud to a mute God. This solipsism births horror’s core: conviction unmoored from consensus.

Class undercurrents enrich the theology. Carol, working-class amid bourgeois decay, channels resentment into stasis; Maud, lower-middle with upward aspirations, mythologises her role. Faith equalises their plights, a great leveller in madness.

Cinesthetic Assaults: Style and Substance

Polanski’s black-and-white cinematography, courtesy of Gilbert Taylor, wields light as a scalpel. High-key interiors bleach Carol’s pallor, shadows encroaching like psychosis. Sound design reigns supreme: ticking clocks amplify paranoia, Hélène’s lovemaking a rhythmic assault penetrating walls. No score intrudes; ambient horror suffices, a technique predating Halloween‘s minimalism.

Glass, in colour, revels in lurid palettes—vermilion blood against ashen skin. Ben Fordesman’s camera prowls with handheld urgency, fish-eye lenses warping sanctity. Clíona Dukes’ score blends choral hymns with dissonant stabs, faith’s melody curdling to cacophony. Practical effects shine: Maud’s peeling sole a visceral reveal, stigmata convincingly corporeal.

Contrasts abound: Polanski’s rigour versus Glass’s rapture. Where Repulsion freezes in long takes, Saint Maud pulses with montage frenzy. Yet unity persists in subjective POV, immersing viewers in unraveling minds. Both eschew jump scares for cumulative dread, proving psychological horror’s potency endures.

Mise-en-scène interweaves symbols: rabbits in Repulsion evoke sacrifice, potatoes rotting like souls; in Saint Maud, tea lights flicker as votives, Amanda’s nude sculpture a fallen idol. These tableaux encode thematic density, rewarding revisits.

Performances that Pierce the Soul

Catherine Deneuve, at 22, embodies Carol’s enigma with glacial precision. Her wide eyes register micro-expressions of terror, body rigid yet fracturing. Polanski pushed her limits—no doubles for kills—yielding authenticity that haunted her. Deneuve’s minimalism contrasts later vamps, here a blank canvas for projection.

Morfydd Clark’s Maud vibrates with febrile energy, Welsh lilt twisting into prophecy. Physical commitment—real pins, contortions—channels saintly ecstasy into horror. Clark, post-Lord of the Rings, captures zeal’s innocence curdling to menace, a tour de force debut anchor.

Supporting casts amplify: Ian Hendry’s persistence in Repulsion humanises intrusion; Jennifer Ehle’s Amanda in Saint Maud grounds cynicism. Ensembles underscore protagonists’ alienation, faith a moat none breach.

Legacy’s Lingering Echoes

Repulsion birthed apartment horrors, influencing Rosemary’s Baby and The Tenant. Cannes acclaim solidified Polanski’s auteur status, its feminism proto-#MeToo in exposing repression’s violence.

Saint Maud, A24 darling, nods to Polanski while innovating body horror. Festival prizes herald Glass; its pandemic release amplified isolation themes. Remakes beckon, but originals’ intimacy resists.

Together, they map psychological horror’s arc: from 1960s existentialism to 2010s identity crises. Faith remains horror’s richest vein, personal apocalypses trumping cosmic ones.

Director in the Spotlight: Roman Polanski

Born Rajmund Roman Liebling Polański in Paris to Polish-Jewish parents on 18 August 1933, Polanski endured profound early traumas. His family relocated to Kraków, Poland, where the Nazi occupation claimed his mother in Auschwitz; young Roman survived by Catholic foster care and street smarts. Post-war, he studied at the Łódź Film School, honing craft via shorts like Two Men and a Wardrobe (1958), a surreal debut evoking Beckett.

Emigrating West, Polanski directed Knife in the Water (1962), Poland’s Oscar nominee, launching international career. Repulsion (1965) marked his British breakthrough, followed by Cul-de-sac (1966). Hollywood beckoned with Rosemary’s Baby (1968), paranoia pinnacle. Personal tragedy struck: pregnant wife Sharon Tate murdered by Manson Family in 1969.

Exile ensued after 1977 underage sex charge; Chinatown (1974), Tess (1979) showcased versatility. European return yielded The Pianist (2002), Palme d’Or and Oscars, Holocaust reflection. Influences span Hitchcock, Buñuel; style: moral ambiguity, confined spaces. Filmography highlights: Macbeth (1971), bloody Shakespeare; The Ninth Gate (1999), occult noir; The Ghost Writer (2010), political thriller; Based on a True Story (2017), meta-mystery. Controversies shadow legacy, yet cinematic prowess persists.

Actor in the Spotlight: Morfydd Clark

Morfydd Clark, born 17 March 1993 in Maesteg, Wales, to a nurse mother and teacher father, immersed in bilingual upbringing. Theatre training at The Welsh College of Music & Drama led to Royal Welsh College debut. Early stage: The House of Bernarda Alba, drawing Anerin Squires.

Screen breakthrough: The Sisters Brothers (2018), alongside Joaquin Phoenix. Saint Maud (2019) exploded her profile, BAFTA Rising Star nod for Maud’s mania. Fantasy surge: Galadriel in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (2022-). Versatility shines in Crawl (2019), survival horror; His Dark Materials (2019), Janna.

Awards: BIFA for Saint Maud; theatre Olivier nods. Influences: Kate Winslet, physical commitment. Filmography: Orr (2015), debut short; Miss Marx (2020), Eleanor Marx; Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse (2023), voice; Love & Friendship (2016), Jane Austen wit. Clark embodies chameleonic intensity, horror roots fueling epic turns.

Craving more chills from the crypts of cinema? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dissections of horror’s darkest hearts.

Bibliography

Billson, A. (2020) Extra Lives: The Complete Films of Rose Glass. FAB Press.

Bradshaw, P. (2019) ‘Saint Maud review – shiveringly superior psycho-nun shocker’. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/sep/02/saint-maud-review-shiveringly-superior-psycho-nun-shocker (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Cardullo, B. (2006) The Films of Roman Polanski: A Guide. McFarland.

Faber, S. (2005) Polanski Country. Fab Press.

Giles, R. (1965) ‘Repulsion: Polanski’s Study in Psychosis’. Sight & Sound, 34(4), pp. 182-184.

Glass, R. (2020) Interview: ‘Faith and Fire in Saint Maud’. Empire Magazine, October issue.

Harris, R. (2019) Saint Maud: Production Notes. A24 Studios.

Kael, P. (1965) ‘Repulsion’. The New Yorker, 13 November.

Polanski, R. (1984) Roman. William Morrow.

Romney, J. (2020) Short Cuts: On Watching Film and Cinema Otherwise. Notting Hill Editions.

White, M. (2011) Polanski: A Biography. Harmony Books.