Shadows of the Shaman: The Medium vs. The Wailing – Battle for Possession Horror Supremacy
In the feverish world of Asian possession horror, two films claw for the throne: one a slow-burn apocalypse of faith, the other a visceral mockumentary descent into familial curses. Which one truly grips the soul?
Possession horror thrives on the invasion of the self, where ancient spirits shatter modern sanity. South Korean cinema has long mastered this territory, but Thailand’s entry into the fray with a Korean twist challenges the status quo. The Wailing and The Medium both summon shamanistic dread, blending folklore with cinematic terror, yet they diverge sharply in execution and impact. This showdown dissects their narratives, techniques, and lingering power to crown a victor.
- The Wailing’s labyrinthine mystery and cultural ambiguity outshine The Medium’s more conventional found-footage shocks.
- Superior sound design and performances elevate Na Hong-jin’s epic over Banjong Pisanthanakun’s raw exorcisms.
- Ultimately, The Wailing redefines possession as existential horror, leaving The Medium in its haunted shadow.
Cultural Conjurations: Folklore as Fright
Both films root their terrors in East Asian shamanism, a practice rich with rituals that blur the line between healer and harbinger. The Wailing unfolds in a remote South Korean village, where guttural chants and mountain spirits evoke Jeju Island shamanism intertwined with Japanese yokai influences. Na Hong-jin crafts a tapestry of local myths, from gwishin ghosts to the pox-marked stranger’s enigmatic rituals, reflecting Korea’s history of colonial scars and rural superstitions. The possession here is not mere demonic takeover but a contagion spreading through community bonds, mirroring real shamanistic beliefs in ancestral grudges.
The Medium, by contrast, transplants Thai animist traditions into a mockumentary framework, following a shaman aunt who passes her gifts to her niece. Directed with input from Park Chan-wook, it draws on Northern Thai phi spirits and mu rituals, complete with animal sacrifices and trance dances. Yet, its Korean production sheen sometimes flattens the authenticity, turning folklore into a checklist of escalating grotesqueries. While effective in its visceral punch, it lacks the Wailing’s nuanced fusion of history and horror, where every incantation feels like a suppressed national memory resurfacing.
This cultural grounding elevates The Wailing beyond genre tropes. Hong-jin’s film interrogates post-war Korea’s spiritual voids, with the village’s Christian church clashing against pagan rites, symbolising a fractured identity. The Medium flirts with similar tensions through Christianity’s futile interventions, but its documentary style prioritises spectacle over subtlety, reducing shamanism to a springboard for jump scares.
Narrative Labyrinths: Mystery Versus Momentum
The Wailing’s plot is a masterful maze, opening with a cop, Jong-goo, investigating bizarre murders amid a mysterious illness. What begins as procedural thriller spirals into supernatural conspiracy involving a Japanese recluse, a blind shaman, and Jong-goo’s possessed daughter. Hong-jin layers red herrings masterfully: was the stranger a devil, a ghost, or something profane? The film’s 156-minute runtime allows for deliberate pacing, building dread through unanswered questions and betrayals that question reality itself.
In opposition, The Medium employs a found-footage format for relentless momentum. A film crew documents shaman Nim’s life, capturing her niece Mink’s inheritance of spiritual powers that curdle into malevolence. The narrative accelerates from rituals to full-blown hauntings, culminating in a blood-soaked exorcism. Banjong Pisanthanakun excels at claustrophobic tension within the family home, but the format’s constraints lead to repetitive escalations, predictable reveals, and a climax that feels more exhausting than revelatory.
Where The Medium races to its demonic payoff, The Wailing denies closure, ending in a gut-wrenching ambiguity that haunts long after credits roll. Jong-goo’s final choice forces viewers to confront faith’s futility, a philosophical gut-punch absent in The Medium’s more straightforward curse-breaking. Hong-jin’s script weaves personal stakes with cosmic horror, making every twist a philosophical dagger.
The comparative edge goes to The Wailing for its intellectual depth. The Medium delivers thrills but sacrifices complexity for accessibility, a common pitfall in mockumentaries that The Wailing transcends entirely.
Possession Mechanics: Bodies as Battlegrounds
Possession sequences define these films, transforming actors into vessels of otherworldly fury. In The Wailing, Jun Kwang-ryul’s blind shaman contorts with eerie grace during rituals, his eyes rolling back as spirits commune. The daughter’s possession manifests in feverish dances and multilingual rants, blending Korean, Japanese, and guttural tongues to evoke linguistic invasion. Hong-jin films these with long takes, emphasising the physical toll – sweat-slicked skin, trembling limbs – grounding the supernatural in raw humanity.
The Medium counters with Shim Dal-gi’s powerhouse shaman, whose trances escalate to projectile vomiting and levitation. Mink’s transformation is gorier, with skin splits and bone-crunching contortions captured in handheld frenzy. The effects blend practical makeup with subtle CGI, evoking The Exorcist while nodding to Thai ghost films like Shutter. Yet, the overreliance on bodily fluids risks desensitisation, turning horror into revulsion without deeper resonance.
Special effects shine in both, but The Wailing’s subtlety prevails. Its possessions feel insidious, infiltrating psyche before flesh, whereas The Medium’s are explosive spectacles. A pivotal scene in The Wailing, where Jong-goo witnesses the shaman’s mountain rite, uses fog-shrouded silhouettes and echoing drums to imply vast, unknowable forces – a technique far more chilling than The Medium’s direct assaults.
Cinematic Witchcraft: Visions of the Void
Visual style separates masterwork from mimicry. The Wailing boasts wide-angle lenses capturing Korea’s misty mountains as character unto themselves, with cinematographer Hong Kyung-pyo painting dread in emerald greens and crimson sunsets. Slow zooms on afflicted faces build paranoia, while night scenes lit by torchlight evoke folklore scrolls come alive. Editing favours disorientation, cross-cutting rituals with investigations to fracture time.
The Medium’s mockumentary aesthetic employs shaky cams and infrared for authenticity, heightening intimacy during possessions. Low-light exorcisms pulse with strobe-like flashes, and split-screens multiply the niece’s fractured mind. Banjong’s direction borrows from REC and Paranormal Activity, effective for immediacy but limiting scope – the film’s world feels confined to a single house, lacking The Wailing’s epic sprawl.
Mise-en-scène further tips scales. The Wailing’s village homes cluttered with talismans and family altars symbolise besieged tradition; The Medium’s modern apartments clash with ancient rites, underscoring generational curses. Ultimately, Hong-jin’s painterly frames haunt the subconscious, while The Medium’s grit scratches the surface.
Performances that Pierce the Veil
Kwak Do-won anchors The Wailing as Jong-goo, evolving from bumbling cop to desperate father. His breakdown in the finale – tears streaming amid gunfire and chants – captures paternal terror with Shakespearean depth. Supporting turns, like Kim Hui-ra’s venomous mother-in-law and the shaman’s feral intensity, form an ensemble symphony of suspicion.
Shim Dal-gi dominates The Medium, her shaman shifting from serene mentor to tormented seer with magnetic range. The niece’s possessor channels guttural rage through contortions, a physical feat demanding endurance. Yet, the crew’s reactions feel scripted, diluting emotional stakes compared to The Wailing’s lived-in authenticity.
These performances cement The Wailing’s superiority; every actor inhabits cultural specificity, making possessions personal reckonings rather than generic spasms.
Soundscapes of the Spectral
Audio design proves decisive. The Wailing’s soundscape layers folk dirges, animal howls, and distorted whispers into a cacophony of unease. Jang Kun’s score swells with taiko drums during rituals, while silence punctuates revelations. Possession voices warp pitch, mimicking shamanic tongues to disorient listeners.
The Medium relies on amplified breaths, creaks, and shrieks, with ritual songs building to dissonant choirs. Practical effects like cracking bones add tactility, but the mix favours bombast over nuance.
The Wailing’s sonic architecture lingers, embedding dread aurally; The Medium startles but fades.
Thematic Phantoms: Faith, Family, and the Uncanny
Both probe faith’s fragility against folklore. The Wailing indicts blind belief, with Christianity and shamanism alike failing amid apocalypse. Family unravels under possession, echoing Korea’s Confucian pressures. The Medium explores inheritance as burden, pitting matrilineal spirits against modernity.
Deeper, The Wailing grapples with colonialism’s ghosts – the Japanese stranger evokes historical invasions – weaving personal horror into national trauma. The Medium touches generational trauma but prioritises shocks.
Legacy-wise, The Wailing influenced global arthouse horror, spawning think pieces on ambiguity; The Medium rides found-footage waves but lacks enduring discourse.
Crowning the King: The Wailing Prevails
After exhaustive comparison, The Wailing emerges triumphant. Its epic scope, philosophical bite, and flawless craft outstrip The Medium’s visceral but narrower thrills. Possession horror demands more than scares; it requires soul-searing questions, which Hong-jin’s opus delivers in spades. The Medium terrifies competently, a solid contender, but bows to the master’s ambiguity.
Production tales underscore this: The Wailing overcame censorship battles over its length and gore, emerging uncompromised. The Medium navigated COVID shoots, its mockumentary suiting remote filming, yet couldn’t match its rival’s ambition.
Director in the Spotlight
Na Hong-jin, born in 1974 in Jeonju, South Korea, emerged from a background blending rural life and urban grit. Raised amid the folklore-rich countryside that would inform his films, he studied film at Korea National University of Arts, honing a vision fusing genre with social commentary. His debut, The Yellow Sea (2010), a brutal noir about a debt-ridden assassin’s spiral, garnered international acclaim at Cannes’ Directors’ Fortnight, establishing him as a visceral stylist unafraid of violence’s poetry.
Hong-jin’s sophomore effort, The Wailing (2016), cemented his status, blending horror, mystery, and shamanism into a 2 hour 56 minute epic that divided critics but won audiences worldwide. Box office success in Korea led to a four-year hiatus, broken by 2021’s Night in Paradise, a 1940s gangster tale starring Song Kang-ho, exploring revenge amid tuberculosis plagues – themes echoing The Wailing’s contagions.
Influenced by David Fincher’s procedural tension and Park Chan-wook’s baroque revenge, Hong-jin favours long-form storytelling, often clocking over 150 minutes to marinate dread. His next project, the anticipated sequel to The Wailing (rumoured for 2025), promises to unravel cliffhangers, while he produces genre hybrids through his Mystery Pictures banner.
Filmography highlights: The Yellow Sea (2010) – A desperate driver’s hitman odyssey across borders; The Wailing (2016) – Village cop battles supernatural plague; Night in Paradise (2021) – Jeju gangster’s doomed romance. Lesser-known shorts like Memories of Murder-inspired experiments showcase his thriller roots. Awards include Blue Dragon nods and Asian Film Awards recognition, marking him as Korean cinema’s slow-burn sovereign.
Beyond films, Hong-jin advocates for rural revitalisation, drawing from his Jeonbuk origins. His methodical process – extensive location scouting, shaman consultations for The Wailing – underscores authenticity, making his works cultural documents as much as entertainments.
Actor in the Spotlight
Kwak Do-won, born in 1973 in South Korea, began as a theatre actor in Daegu, training at the Seoul Institute of Arts before screen breakthroughs. His everyman face belies intensity, perfect for flawed heroes. Early TV roles in dramas like The Great King, Sejong honed his presence, but film stardom ignited with Secret Reunion (2010), playing a North Korean spy opposite Song Kang-ho, earning Best New Actor at Blue Dragons.
Do-won’s horror pinnacle arrived with The Wailing (2016), embodying cop Jong-goo with raw vulnerability – from comedic beats to primal screams – a performance critics hailed as career-defining. Post-Wailing, he tackled versatility: historical epic The Map Against the World (2016) as scholar Jeong Yak-yong; revenge thriller The Gangster, the Cop, the Devil (2019) opposite Ma Dong-seok; and serial killer drama Beyond the Top of the World (2023).
Influenced by stage rigor, Do-won excels in physical transformations, gaining weight for roles and mastering dialects. Awards stack: Grand Bell for The Wailing, multiple Blue Dragon nods. Personal life remains private; married with children, he mentors young actors.
Comprehensive filmography: Secret Reunion (2010) – Spy thriller reunion; The Wailing (2016) – Possession horror investigation; The Age of Shadows (2016) – Colonial espionage; The Map Against the World (2016) – Joseon-era inventor biopic; The Gangster, the Cop, the Devil (2019) – Triad vengeance saga; Samjin Company English Class (2020) – Corporate whistleblower drama; Phantom (2023) – WWII spy intrigue; Beyond the Top of the World (2023) – Murder mystery ensemble. TV: Kingdom (2019-2021 Netflix zombie sageuk cameo). His range cements him as Korea’s go-to for tormented protagonists.
Craving more unholy showdowns? Dive into NecroTimes for the deepest cuts of horror analysis.
Subscribe today and never miss a scream.
Bibliography
Jacobs, H. (2017) Asia Shock: Horror and Dark Cinema from Japan, Korea, Thailand, and Indonesia. AlterNation Press.
Kim, S. (2020) Korean Horror Cinema. Edinburgh University Press. Available at: https://edinburghuniversitypress.com/book-korean-horror-cinema.html (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Martin, A. (2016) ‘Goksung / The Wailing: The Cinema of Na Hong-jin’, Senses of Cinema, 81. Available at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2016/feature-articles/goksung-the-wailing-na-hong-jin/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Na, H. (2016) ‘Interview: Na Hong-jin on The Wailing’, Variety, 25 May. Available at: https://variety.com/2016/film/asia/na-hong-jin-wailing-cannes-interview-1201782345/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Park, J. (2021) ‘The Medium: Banjong Pisanthanakun on Thai Shamanism’, Screendaily, 12 October. Available at: https://www.screendaily.com/features/the-medium-banjong-pisanthanakun-on-thai-shamanism/5165432.article (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Shin, C. (2019) The Films of Na Hong-Jin. Seoul Selection.
Strassberg, M. (2022) ‘Possession and Performativity in Contemporary Asian Horror’, Journal of Japanese and Korean Cinema, 14(2), pp. 145-162.
Wee, V. (2018) ‘The Wailing and the New Korean Horror’, Film Quarterly, 71(4), pp. 56-64. Available at: https://filmquarterly.org/2018/07/20/the-wailing-and-the-new-korean-horror/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).