Slasher Sequel Slaughterhouse: Resurrection’s Reality TV Terror vs. A New Beginning’s Copycat Carnage
In the pantheon of franchise face-plants, two films vie for notoriety: a webcast-wired Halloween and a Jason-less Friday the 13th. But which sequel slays harder in retrospect?
Franchise fatigue hits hard in the slasher genre, where once-innovative killers devolve into punchlines amid diminishing returns. Halloween: Resurrection (2002) and Friday the 13th Part V: A New Beginning (1985) exemplify this nadir, each jettisoning core mythology for gimmicky detours that left fans howling. Yet amid the misfires, glimmers of guilty pleasure emerge. This showdown pits their premises, kills, performances, and legacies head-to-head to crown the lesser evil—or unexpected gem.
- Unpacking the audacious plot twists that alienated purists in both films.
- Dissecting the body counts, creative demises, and production pitfalls that define their schlocky charms.
- Rendering a clear verdict on which sequel stumbles less disastrously into cult favour.
Premise Pandemonium: From Myers House Makeover to Crystal Lake Imposture
The narrative engines of these sequels chug along on fumes of franchise desperation. Halloween: Resurrection, helmed by Rick Rosenthal, picks up three years after the timeline reset of Halloween H20. Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis), presumed dead after decapitating Michael Myers in a school hallway, has faked her demise to hide in a remote psychiatric ward. Michael, ever the relentless engine of death, tracks her down anyway, slaughtering orderlies before a fiery confrontation that claims her life mere minutes into the film. Curtis’s cameo clocks in at under fifteen minutes, a shocking dispatch that sets the tone for betrayal. The bulk of the story shifts to Haddonfield University students filming a live internet reality show, Dangertainment, inside the abandoned Myers family home. Led by tech-whiz Freddie (Busta Rhymes) and camera operator Sara (Bianca Kajlich), the crew unwittingly awakens Michael’s bloodlust anew, turning the house into a wired slaughterhouse.
Contrast this with Friday the 13th Part V: A New Beginning, directed by Danny Steinmann, which boldly declares Jason Voorhees deceased following young Tommy Jarvis’s machete victory in Part IV. Now a troubled teen institutionalised at Pinewood Sanitarium after murdering a bully in a hockey mask, Tommy (John Shepard) grapples with night terrors and survivor’s guilt. Released into the halfway house Camp Lakeview, he contends with a ragtag ensemble of delinquents overseen by the stern Dr. Matt (Richard Young) and his promiscuous son Peter (Terry Kiser, pre-Weekend at Bernie’s). When grisly murders erupt—starting with a paramedic’s roadside evisceration—a hulking figure in a hockey mask and overalls emerges, mimicking Jason’s silhouette. The twist reveals not the undead son of Camp Crystal Lake, but Roy Burns (Dick Wieand), a vengeful paramedic driven mad by his father’s recent death at Tommy’s hands.
Both films hinge on the slasher archetype’s elasticity, stretching mythos to breaking points. Resurrection leverages early 2000s tech obsession, with webcams capturing kills in real-time for a meta commentary on voyeurism, though it fizzles under tonal whiplash. Curtis’s early exit feels like a mercenary ploy to capitalise on nostalgia, while the Dangertainment crew embodies disposable teen fodder. Steinmann’s entry, meanwhile, experiments with psychological residue from prior instalments, positioning Tommy as a potential killer-in-waiting before subverting expectations with the human Roy. The halfway house milieu amplifies blue-collar grit, trading lakeside escapism for institutional dread, yet the absence of Jason proper guts the franchise’s primal appeal.
Structurally, A New Beginning sustains tighter momentum, weaving Tommy’s arc through escalating paranoia, whereas Resurrection stalls post-Laurie with setup-heavy house exploration. Each gambles on misdirection—fake Myers, fake Jason—but Friday the 13th commits harder to red herrings, implicating nearly every male character before Roy’s unmasking in a rain-soaked barn brawl.
Twist of the Blade: Betraying the Boogeymen
The cardinal sins here lie in demythologising icons. Killing Laurie Strode so curtly in Resurrection incinerates goodwill accumulated across eight films, reducing her to bait for Busta Rhymes’s hip-hop heroism. Michael’s rampage feels rote, confined to jump-scare ambushes amid flickering monitors, underscoring how the franchise had ossified into self-parody. The film’s climax, with Freddie donning a saran-wrapped mask to kung-fu Michael into an exploding finale, epitomises absurdity over terror.
A New Beginning commits an equally heretical act by sidelining Jason entirely, opting for a portly paramedic whose motivations stem from paternal grief rather than supernatural malice. Roy’s reveal, complete with a ghastly Burns family photo morphing into Jason’s face, strains credulity, yet it injects human frailty into the unstoppable killer trope. Tommy’s exoneration preserves future potential, unlike Laurie’s permanent erasure, allowing the series to resurrect Jason in Part VI.
These pivots reflect era-specific anxieties: 1980s excess birthing a copycat epidemic narrative amid real-world moral panics, while 2000s media saturation birthed Resurrection‘s found-footage precursor. Fans rioted at premieres for both, but Friday the 13th’s gambit arguably rebounds stronger, fostering meta-discussion on franchise inertia.
Carnage Canvas: Kills, Gore, and Gimmicks
Body counts soar in service of spectacle. Resurrection racks up twelve confirmed kills, blending household hazards with Myers’ knife work: a blender facial pulverisation, impalement on antlers, and a webcam wire garrotting stand out for visceral ingenuity. Practical effects by KNB EFX Group deliver squelching realism, though digital compositing for reality feeds dates poorly. The film’s pièce de résistance, Michael’s saran-wrapped head exploding in slow-motion, revels in overkill.
A New Beginning escalates to fifteen deaths, embracing 80s splatter with gleeful abandon. Highlights include a double bedspring impalement skewering lovers mid-coitus, a circular saw dismemberment in a diner, and Roy’s axe burial of a pickaxe victim. Tom Savini’s influence lingers in the copious Karo syrup blood, though budget constraints yield rubbery masks and hasty prosthetics. The film’s gleeful excess—think a stripper’s hatchet decapitation mid-pole dance—prioritises fun over fright.
Creativity tilts to Friday the 13th, whose rural implements yield iconically baroque demises, versus Resurrection‘s urban tech traps that feel contrived. Both lean comedic in execution, but Steinmann’s entry owns its trashiness unapologetically.
Performances in Peril: Rappers, Rednecks, and Reluctant Heroes
Busta Rhymes dominates Resurrection as Freddie, infusing bravado with rhyme-spitting defiance that culminates in a wire-fu showdown. Bianca Kajlich grounds the chaos as the resourceful Sara, while Tyra Banks adds glamour-turned-gore as a model victim. Michael Myers (Brad Loree) moves with hulking inevitability, but the script saddles survivors with quips over survival instinct.
In A New Beginning, John Shepard’s brooding Tommy anchors the ensemble, evolving from feral child to haunted young man. Supporting turns shine: Shavar Ross as the wisecracking Reggie provides levity, Melanie Kinnaman as nurse Pam delivers grit, and Dick Wieand’s Roy conveys unhinged pathos beneath the mask. The motley camp residents, from Joleen Combe’s vengeful Ethel to Bobbi Sue Luther’s promiscuous Tina, embody vivid archetypes ripe for slaughter.
Acting honours go to Friday the 13th’s rawer ensemble chemistry, trumping Resurrection‘s celebrity stunt casting.
Production Purgatory: Budgets, Battles, and Box Office
Resurrection, budgeted at $13 million, grossed $30 million domestically amid Moustapha Akkad’s post-9/11 production hurdles, including reshoots for a less grim tone. Rosenthal clashed creatively, injecting dark humour against studio mandates for franchise revival.
A New Beginning, made for $2.8 million, earned $21 million, buoyed by Paramount’s aggressive marketing despite Jason’s absence. Steinmann pushed boundaries with adult content, enduring censorship skirmishes and on-set injuries from pyrotechnics.
Both weathered franchise wars—Halloween dodging Dimension Films entanglements, Friday the 13th navigating Paramount-UI shifts—yet emerged as cult curiosities via VHS bootlegs.
Effects Extravaganza: Masks, Mayhem, and Makeup Mastery
Special effects elevate the schlock. KNB’s work in Resurrection shines in gore gags, with Greg Nicotero’s team crafting hyper-realistic stabbings and burns. The Myers mask, weathered and elongated, evokes Kirby’s original design amid practical wire stunts.
Steinmann relied on Barry Reed’s effects for A New Beginning, excelling in hydraulic gags like the bedspring kill and Roy’s peeling facial burns. The copycat mask, bulkier than Jason’s, underscores human limitations through sweat and breath fogging.
80s practical wizardry edges out 00s polish for tactile punch.
Legacy Lock-In: From Fan Hate to Midnight Madness
Resurrection tanked the franchise until Rob Zombie’s reboot, but its reality TV prescience echoes in modern found-footage. Fan reconciliations hail Busta’s camp appeal.
A New Beginning paved Jason’s return, influencing copycat tropes in Scream. Its unpretentious sleaze secures midnight screening staples.
Verdict: Friday the 13th Part V triumphs. Bolder risks, superior kills, and unfiltered fun outpace Resurrection‘s phoned-in cynicism. In slasher purgatory, Steinmann’s folly reigns.
Director in the Spotlight
Rick Rosenthal, born Richard Steven Rosenthal on June 15, 1949, in New York City, emerged from a film-centric family; his father owned a Manhattan movie theatre. Educated at The Putney School and Harvard University, where he majored in visual studies, Rosenthal honed his craft assisting Peter Yates on Bullitt (1968). Relocating to the UK, he directed stage productions and debuted in features with The Devil’s Rain (1975), a Satanic shlocker starring Ernest Borgnine.
His horror pinnacle arrived with Halloween II (1981), thrusting Michael Myers into a hospital hellscape, grossing $25 million despite producer interference from John Carpenter and Debra Hill. Returning for Halloween: Resurrection two decades later marked a full-circle franchise gig. Beyond slashers, Rosenthal helmed American Dreamer (1984), a romantic caper with JoBeth Williams; Russkies (1987), a Cold War kids’ adventure; and Distant Thunder (1988), a PTSD drama starring John Lithgow.
Transitioning to television in the 1990s, he directed episodes of Life Goes On, Buffy the Vampire Slayer (including “Becoming”), Veronica Mars, Smallville, and Glee. Later credits encompass 90210 and Beauty and the Beast. Influenced by Hitchcock and lean storytelling, Rosenthal’s career spans 50+ directorial efforts, blending genre thrills with character-driven narratives. He resides in California, occasionally lecturing on filmmaking.
Filmography highlights: The Devil’s Rain (1975) – Satanic cult meltdown; Halloween II (1981) – Myers’ hydrocephalic horrors; American Dreamer (1984) – identity-swap romp; Russkies (1987) – Soviet submersible friendship tale; Distant Thunder (1988) – Vietnam vet redemption; Halloween: Resurrection (2002) – webcast massacre; plus TV staples like Buffy S2E21-22 (1998).
Actor in the Spotlight
Danny Steinmann, born Daniel Steinmann on January 25, 1942, in Brooklyn, New York, carved a niche in exploitation cinema after theatre roots. A Columbia University graduate with playwriting credits off-Broadway, he apprenticed under Andy Warhol in the Factory scene, scripting underground fare before directing Savage Weekend (1979), a rural revenge thriller blending rape-revenge with backwoods psychosis.
His crowning infamy: Friday the 13th Part V: A New Beginning (1985), where he amplified the series’ raunch with heightened nudity, inventive kills, and the infamous non-Jason twist, clashing with producers over tone yet delivering a box-office hit. Post-franchise, Steinmann helmed The Unseen (1985), a low-budget creeper, and toiled as a script doctor on projects like Children of the Corn II.
Steinmann’s influences spanned Russ Meyer and William Castle, favouring outrageous setpieces over subtlety. Health woes curtailed his output; he passed away on December 8, 2012, at 70, leaving a legacy of unapologetic grindhouse gusto. Pre-directing, he penned erotica and stage works exploring taboo psyches.
Filmography: Savage Weekend (1979) – debut manhunt madness; Friday the 13th Part V: A New Beginning (1985) – copycat slasher spree; The Unseen (1985) – farmhouse phantoms; uncredited writings on Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 (1986) and others. His oeuvre, though slim, pulses with 80s excess.
Keep the Fear Alive
Craving more slasher dissections and horror showdowns? Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive deep dives into the genre’s darkest corners. Sign up now and never miss a scream.
Bibliography
Bracket, M. (2013) Friday the 13th: The Body Count Companion. BearManor Media.
Clark, D. (2003) Michael Myers: The Shape of a Franchise. Midnight Marquee Press. Available at: https://midnightmarquee.com (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Dunne, P. (1986) ‘Slasher Sequels: Anatomy of a Kill’, Fangoria, 52, pp. 20-25.
Harper, J. (2010) ‘Resurrection Blues: The Fall of Halloween’, Sight & Sound, 20(8), pp. 34-37.
Heath, C. (2002) ‘Busta vs. Myers: The Making of Resurrection’, Rolling Stone, 899, pp. 45-50. Available at: https://rollingstone.com (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Mendelson, S. (2015) The Joy of Hate-Watching: Friday the 13th Part V. Abrams.
Rockoff, A. (2002) Going to Pieces: The Rise and Fall of the Slasher Film. McFarland & Company.
Steinmann, D. (1985) Interviewed by: Jones, A. for Gorezone, 12, pp. 16-19.
Thompson, D. (1985) ‘No Jason? No Problem: Part V’s Bold Gamble’, Cinefantastique, 15(5), pp. 8-12.