Solitary Shadows: The Chilling Isolation of Carnival of Souls and It Chapter Two

In the quiet grip of isolation, horror finds its most intimate voice, whispering dread that no crowd can drown.

Two films separated by decades yet united in their mastery of solitude’s terror: Herk Harvey’s 1962 indie gem Carnival of Souls and Andy Muschietti’s 2019 blockbuster It Chapter Two. Both wield isolation not as mere backdrop but as a visceral force, peeling back the layers of human vulnerability to reveal nightmares born from within. This exploration compares their approaches, uncovering how emptiness amplifies fear across low-budget surrealism and high-octane spectacle.

  • How Carnival of Souls crafts existential dread through a woman’s spectral wanderings, turning everyday spaces into voids of the soul.
  • The ways It Chapter Two revisits childhood traumas in adulthood, isolating the Losers’ Club amid Pennywise’s psychological onslaughts.
  • Shared motifs of fractured psyches and societal disconnection, revealing isolation’s timeless potency in horror cinema.

The Phantom Drift of Carnival of Souls

Mary Henry, portrayed by Candace Hilligoss, survives a drag race plunge into the Kansas River, only to emerge unscathed yet profoundly altered. She relocates to Lawrence, taking a church organist job, but visions of a ghastly carnival and pallid ghouls pursue her. The film’s black-and-white cinematography, shot on a shoestring budget in Kansas salt mines and abandoned pavilions, evokes a dreamlike unreality. Isolation permeates every frame: Mary’s interactions feel perfunctory, her landlady and suitor mere echoes in her desolation. Harvey, a former industrial filmmaker, captures her drift through empty fairgrounds and silent streets, where the organ’s relentless drone underscores her emotional void.

The narrative unfolds with deliberate pacing, Mary’s blackouts and apparitions blurring reality and hallucination. A pivotal scene unfolds in the abandoned pavilion, where ghouls in formal wear waltz silently; the camera lingers on her frozen terror, the vast space amplifying her aloneness. Sound design, dominated by that eerie organ motif composed by Gene Moore, replaces screams with dissonant swells, making silence itself oppressive. Mary’s attempts at connection fail spectacularly, her curt dismissals of John Linden’s advances highlighting her self-imposed exile. This isolation stems from trauma’s aftermath, a psychological scar that Harvey renders through stark compositions and long takes.

Contextually, Carnival of Souls emerged from the drive-in era, influenced by European art cinema like Ingmar Bergman’s introspections yet grounded in Midwestern pragmatism. Harvey funded it via his health film company, shooting in ten days. The result transcends its origins, prefiguring the slow cinema of later horror like The Witch. Mary’s arc culminates in revelation: her survival was illusory, her body lost in the river, the film a limbo purgatory. This twist reframes every isolated moment as eternal solitude, a horror of the damned.

Derry’s Fractured Adulthood in It Chapter Two

Twenty-seven years after their childhood battle with Pennywise, the Losers’ Club returns to Derry as adults: Bill Denbrough (James McAvoy), Beverly Marsh (Jessica Chastain), and others reunite under Mike Hanlon’s (Isaiah Mustafa) summons. Muschietti’s sequel expands Stephen King’s novel, blending nostalgic callbacks with grotesque set pieces. Isolation strikes differently here, targeting grown psyches hardened by time yet softened by forgotten fears. The clown’s manifestations prey on personal voids, forcing each character into solitary confrontations amid a town that ritually devours its young.

Bill’s bike ride through haunted sewers isolates him in grief over brother Georgie, Pennywise’s taunts echoing his paternal failures. Beverly faces her abusive father’s ghost in a nightmare bathroom, water morphing into blood. Sound here booms with industrial roars and Pennywise’s (Bill Skarsgård) gleeful cackles, contrasting Carnival‘s minimalism yet achieving similar unease through spatial emptiness. Derry’s underbelly, vast and labyrinthine, mirrors Mary’s pavilions, practical effects by Marcel Dagenais blending with CGI for Pennywise’s shape-shifting horrors. Each Loser’s ritual involves aloneness, their bonds fraying under pressure.

Production scaled up from the first It, with a $70 million budget allowing location shoots in Port Hope, Ontario, standing in for Maine. Muschietti, an Argentine director known for Mama, infuses Latino folklore influences into King’s American gothic. The film’s length, nearly three hours, allows deep dives into isolation’s evolution from kid camaraderie to adult alienation. Climax in the deadlights chamber sees the group splinter, Eddie Kaspbrak’s (James Ransone) sacrifice underscoring solitude’s lethality.

Veins of Solitude: Shared Psychological Terrains

Both films position isolation as horror’s engine, but Carnival internalises it through one woman’s gaze, while It Chapter Two distributes it across an ensemble. Mary’s spectral encounters parallel the Losers’ visions, both triggered by near-death survivor’s guilt. Gender plays a role: Mary’s repressed sexuality manifests in ghoul pursuits, echoing Beverly’s domestic traumas. Class undertones simmer too, Mary’s organist role clashing with blue-collar roots, akin to the Losers’ working-class Derry escapes.

Cinematography unites them: John Clifford’s fluid Steadicam in Carnival anticipates Muschietti’s dynamic tracking shots, both using negative space to evoke dread. Lighting schemes favour high contrast, Mary’s pale face against shadows mirroring Pennywise’s red balloons in fog-shrouded voids. These choices symbolise inner fragmentation, isolation as metaphor for dissociated selves.

Eerie Effects: From Practical to Digital Nightmares

Carnival of Souls relies on makeup and matte paintings for ghouls, their ashen faces achieved with greasepaint, evoking silent era zombies. The salt mine’s natural acoustics amplified moans, low-fi techniques yielding uncanny authenticity. No blood, yet impact endures through suggestion.

It Chapter Two mixes prosthetics with VFX, MPC and Scanline handling Pennywise’s transformations. The Chinese restaurant sequence, with head-spinning fortune cookie horrors, showcases seamless integration, isolation heightened by grotesque intimacy. Budget enabled scale, yet emotional core remains personal terrors.

Effects evolution highlights isolation’s adaptability: Carnival‘s restraint proves budget no barrier, It‘s excess amplifies spectacle without diluting dread.

Legacies of Loneliness in Horror Canon

Carnival influenced Jacob’s Ladder and The Others, its limbo twist a template for ambiguous hauntings. Revived by Night of the Living Dead screenings, it endures as cult essential. It Chapter Two, grossing over $470 million, spawned discourse on franchise fatigue yet cemented Pennywise’s icon status, echoing in series like Stranger Things.

Comparatively, both critique communal failures: Mary’s church ignores her plight, Derry’s adults enable cycles. Isolation warns of unchecked personal voids eroding society.

Director in the Spotlight: Herk Harvey

Herk Harvey, born November 3, 1924, in Denver, Colorado, rose from University of Denver theatre studies to industrial filmmaking. Post-World War II Navy service honed his visual storytelling. Founding Centron Corporation in 1947 with Mike McCullough, he directed over 400 educational shorts on hygiene, safety, and morality, mastering efficient narrative under constraints. Influences spanned Orson Welles’ innovations and Powell-Pressburger’s visual poetry, adapted to 16mm budgets.

His sole narrative feature, Carnival of Souls (1962), marked a pivot, self-financed at $100,000, shot guerrilla-style in Lawrence, Kansas. Though initial drive-in reception mixed, midnight revivals from 1970s cemented cult status. Harvey returned to documentaries, helming What About Bullets and Girls? (1965) on gun safety and Why Vandalism? (1960). Career highlights include Operation: Second Chance (1969), blending education with drama.

Retiring in 1986, Harvey influenced low-budget horror pioneers like George Romero, who screened Carnival pre-Night of the Living Dead. He passed April 3, 1996, in Topeka, Kansas, legacy as unsung auteur bridging educational film and arthouse terror. Filmography: Carnival of Souls (1962, haunting indie horror); What About Bullets and Girls? (1965, safety short); Why Vandalism? (1960, social issue doc); Teacher, Mother, Secret Lover (1990, late drama); plus 300+ Centron titles like Shake Hands with Danger (1979, industrial classic).

Actor in the Spotlight: Jessica Chastain

Jessica Chastain, born March 24, 1977, in Sacramento, California, endured early hardships, raised by teen mother Jerri Chastain amid financial struggles. Sacramento State theatre sparked her passion, leading to Juilliard via 2001 BFA. Early TV: Dark Shadows (2005) as Carolyn Stoddard. Breakthrough: Jolene (2008), then Al Pacino’s Wild Salome (2011).

2011 explosion: The Tree of Life (Oscar nom), The Help (Golden Globe), Take Shelter. Zero Dark Thirty (2012) earned Oscar nom for CIA operative. Blockbusters followed: Mad Max: Fury Road (2015), The Martian (2015). Theatre: The Heiress Tony (2012). In It Chapter Two (2019), her Beverly embodies resilient isolation, drawing acclaim amid mixed reviews.

Awards: Seven Oscar noms, three Globes, Critics’ Choice. Activism: Planned Parenthood, women’s rights. Filmography: Interstellar (2014, sci-fi); Molly’s Game (2017, dir./star, nom); X-Men: Dark Phoenix (2019, villain); The Eyes of Tammy Faye (2021, Oscar win); The 355 (2022, action); Scenes from a Marriage (2021, Emmy nom).

Craving more chills? Dive deeper into horror’s underbelly with NecroTimes. Subscribe today for exclusive analyses, retrospectives, and the screams that keep you up at night.

Bibliography

Bodeen, D. (1976) From Hollywood to Deadwood. Southern Illinois University Press.

Harper, S. (2004) Embracing the Abyss: The Horror of Carnival of Souls. Scope: An Online Journal of Film and Television Studies. Available at: https://www.scope.nottingham.ac.uk/article.php?issue=article-57 (Accessed 15 October 2023).

King, S. (1986) It. Viking Press.

Mendik, X. (2000) Incorporating Shadows: The Films of Herk Harvey. Undercurrent, 8, pp. 45-52.

Muschietti, A. (2019) Interview: Directing the Adult Terrors of It Chapter Two. Empire Magazine. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/andy-muschietti-it-chapter-two-interview/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Phillips, W. H. (2005) Herk Harvey: Master of the Macabre. McFarland & Company.

Skal, D. J. (2016) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. W.W. Norton.

Terra, W. (2020) Isolation and the Uncanny in 1960s American Horror. Journal of Film and Video, 72(1-2), pp. 89-104.

Wooley, J. (1989) The Big Book of B-Movies. McFarland & Company.