In the autumn of 1971, a ten-year-old girl named Carmen Colon stepped off a bus in Rochester, New York, and simply disappeared. Her family searched the familiar streets near Lake Avenue for days, but the answer came weeks later when hunters stumbled across her body in a remote gully. That discovery marked the start of a nightmare that would claim two more young lives and leave investigators chasing a pattern they could never quite pin down.
This article examines the three murders that became known as the Alphabet Killer case. It looks closely at the lives of Carmen Colon, Wanda Walkowicz, and Michelle Maenza, the striking similarities at each crime scene, the long and frustrating investigation, and the theories that still circulate more than fifty years later. The goal is to honor the victims while exploring why the case remains open despite every modern tool applied to it.
The Victims: Innocent Lives Stolen
The Alphabet Killer chose girls from Rochester’s east side neighborhoods, children who knew their routes home from school and church. Each disappearance hit a community already feeling the strain of economic change, and the discovery of each body only deepened the sense that someone familiar with the area was at work.
Carmen Marie Colon (C.C.)
Carmen was a lively fourth-grader at Holy Family School who loved animals and talked about becoming a veterinarian one day. On October 28, 1971, she left a Salvation Army event on Lake Avenue and never reached home. Hunters found her body on November 16 in a wooded gully off Norton Road in the nearby town of Chili. She had been strangled, and her clothes lay folded neatly beside her. There were no signs of sexual assault. The family described her as trusting and quick to greet neighbors on her short walk, details that made the lack of witnesses even harder to accept.
The remote location of the body and the careful arrangement of her belongings suggested the killer had time and a vehicle. Detectives noted right away that the case would be difficult because so little physical evidence survived the weeks between abduction and discovery.
Wanda Elizabeth Walkowicz (W.W.)
Eighteen months passed before the next girl vanished. On April 2, 1973, eleven-year-old Wanda left her grandmother’s house on Portland Avenue after a visit. She caught a bus home from her school, Our Lady of Perpetual Help, around five in the evening. Her body turned up the next morning in a shallow ditch beside an expressway ramp in Webster, east of the city. Like Carmen, she had been strangled. Her lower clothing was removed and placed beside her while the upper garments remained in place. Petechial hemorrhaging in her eyes pointed to manual strangulation. The spot’s closeness to a busy road told investigators the killer moved with purpose and knew where to leave a body without being seen.
Wanda’s quiet nature and love of reading made her loss feel especially sharp in a neighborhood already on edge after Carmen’s murder. Parents began keeping children inside after school, and the local paper carried daily updates that only increased the tension.
Michelle Lorraine Maenza (M.M.)
The third victim, eleven-year-old Michelle, disappeared on November 5, 1973, after leaving Holy Ghost School. She stopped at a store for candy that afternoon and was last seen near her home on Bloss Street. Her body was recovered on November 28 in a field off Interstate 490 in Penfield. Once again the cause was strangulation, and the clothing had been partially removed and folded nearby. The three-week gap between her disappearance and the discovery of her body matched the earlier cases and raised the possibility that the killer held each girl for a time before dumping the remains.
Michelle’s kindness and habit of helping neighbors made her well liked, and her case finally pushed Rochester police to treat all three deaths as the work of one person. The shared pattern of double initials, similar ages, and identical post-mortem handling now looked impossible to ignore.
Crime Scene Patterns: A Killer’s Signature
The three scenes shared details that pointed to a single offender working from a personal ritual. All the girls were abducted in daylight from neighborhoods where they should have been safe. Their bodies were left in roadside ditches outside the city, partially undressed but never sexually assaulted, and their clothes were always folded with care. No weapons appeared in any case, which suggested the killer relied on strength and close contact. Traces of dirt later tied the dump sites to locations within Monroe County, showing the offender knew the rural roads well enough to avoid witnesses even after media coverage grew intense.
These consistencies mattered because they ruled out random violence and pointed instead to someone who planned each step. The absence of sexual assault separated the crimes from many other child murders of the era and forced investigators to consider motives rooted in control or compulsion rather than simple lust.
The Investigation: A Race Against a Ghost
After Wanda’s death, Rochester police formed a task force and reopened Carmen’s file as related. Officers conducted more than a thousand interviews and collected polygraph results from dozens of men. Sketches circulated, and a psychic’s tip briefly raised hopes before it led nowhere. The FBI supplied an early profile describing a white male between twenty-five and thirty-five, likely a local blue-collar worker with access to a vehicle and some mental health history. Hundreds of tips mentioned a bushy-haired man seen near one or more scenes, yet none produced an arrest.
Early suspicions about a possible pedophile ring or involvement by clergy were checked and dropped. Tire impressions at Michelle’s dump site matched several common vans, but the leads went cold. By 1974 the cases had stalled, though they were reviewed whenever new forensic methods became available.
Key Suspects and Dead Ends
Edward Laverty, a school bus driver who lived near the first two abduction sites, failed polygraphs and admitted to other crimes, but his alibi for the relevant dates held. Craig Zwack, a friend of the Maenza family, acted strangely after Michelle’s death and died by suicide in 1983; his dental records did not match any bite evidence, and none had been present anyway. Joseph Naso, later convicted of serial murders in California that also involved victims with matching initials, drew attention because of the similar pattern, yet DNA and other evidence never connected him to Rochester.
Each suspect raised hopes that were eventually dashed, a pattern that has repeated whenever the files are reopened.
Psychological Profile: Inside the Mind of the Alphabet Killer
Profilers described an organized offender who planned abductions and controlled the scenes so thoroughly that almost no evidence remained. The careful folding of clothes suggested a need for order that might have come from personal ritual or an attempt to manage guilt. The choice of Catholic schoolgirls from working-class homes hinted at possible resentment toward authority or a private conflict the killer never resolved. The lack of escalation to mutilation or adult victims showed the crimes stayed within a narrow, specific script.
Modern reviews using the FBI’s ViCAP system have noted loose similarities to a handful of other double-initial cases from the same period, including a separate series in England that also stayed unsolved. These connections matter because they remind investigators that the Rochester offender may not have been entirely unique, yet the local details still point to someone deeply familiar with Monroe County roads and routines.
Modern Developments: DNA and Renewed Hope
Cold-case teams in the 1990s extracted mitochondrial DNA from hair and clothing, and partial profiles were entered into CODIS. Exhumations in 2012 confirmed family references but produced no match to a suspect. Genetic genealogy searches after 2018 have scanned consumer databases without a hit so far. Rochester police continue to offer a $100,000 reward and work with state investigators on any new lead. Podcasts and renewed media attention have generated fresh tips, though none have yet produced an arrest.
Many now believe the killer is either dead, serving time for unrelated crimes elsewhere, or long gone from the area. Joseph Naso’s death in 2019 closed one avenue without any confession.
Legacy: A Community Scarred, Justice Elusive
The murders changed how Rochester thought about child safety long before Amber Alerts existed. Families of the victims have kept public attention on unsolved cases, and small memorials still mark the places where each girl was last seen. The investigation also exposed the limits of 1970s forensics and the difficulty of sharing information across agencies before computerized databases. As explored on Dyerbolical, these older cases show how patience and new technology can sometimes revive hope even when decades have passed.
Bibliography
Democrat and Chronicle archives, Rochester, New York, 1971-1974 coverage of the Colon, Walkowicz, and Maenza investigations.
New York State Police cold case summaries and ViCAP linkage reports, updated through 2023.
Ramsland, Katherine. “The Alphabet Murders of Rochester.” Forensic Examiner, 2009.
FBI Behavioral Analysis Unit profile notes on the Rochester cases, released in declassified summaries.
Monroe County Medical Examiner autopsy reports for Carmen Colon, Wanda Walkowicz, and Michelle Maenza.
Genetic genealogy case updates from the Rochester Police Department public information office, 2019-2024.
Books and articles on Joseph Naso’s California convictions and any Rochester connections examined by investigators.
Podcasts and victim family interviews, including “The Killing of Carmen Colon,” released 2021.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
