Rochester, New York, carried an ordinary rhythm in the mid-1960s until a ten-year-old girl named Carmen Colon stepped out on a simple errand and never came back. Her disappearance marked the start of a pattern that would leave three families shattered and an entire city questioning how a killer could strike so precisely in broad daylight. This article examines each of the three cases in full, the long investigation that followed, the suspects who surfaced over the years, and the renewed attention given to Joseph Naso as a possible connection, all while respecting the victims and their families.
The Victims: Three Innocent Lives Cut Short
The Alphabet Murders claimed the lives of three young girls from working-class families in Rochester. Each was described by loved ones as bright, trusting, and full of promise, their deaths leaving indelible scars on their communities.
Carmen Colon (C.C.): The First Victim
Carmen Colon, a 10-year-old fifth-grader at School No. 6, disappeared on December 28, 1965, while running a quick errand to a local deli on Child Street in Rochester’s northwest side. Last seen alive around 4 p.m., she was reported missing by her mother, who grew alarmed when Carmen failed to return home before dark. Just two days later, on December 30, her partially nude body was discovered by a highway crew in a ditch beneath a railroad overpass near Churchville, about 15 miles west of Rochester along the New York State Thruway.
An autopsy revealed Carmen had been sexually assaulted, strangled, and subjected to blunt force trauma. Her clothing was strewn nearby, and she had been placed in a posed position, arms crossed over her chest. The brutality shocked investigators, marking this as no random act but a calculated killing. That first case set the tone for everything that came later, because the details of how she was found suggested someone who planned rather than panicked.
Wanda Walkowicz (W.W.): A Seven-Year Gap
Nearly eight years passed before the next victim. Wanda Walkowicz, 11, vanished on April 2, 1973, after leaving Holy Family Church following Sunday Mass. The slight girl with long brown hair was sent to a grocery store on Lake Avenue but never arrived. Her body was found the next day, April 3, by a passerby in a weed-choked ditch on an access road off Route 104 in Webster, roughly 20 miles east of Rochester.
Like Carmen, Wanda had been raped, strangled, and dumped semi-nude. Her clothes were folded neatly beside her, and she clutched a rosary in her hand, a poignant detail underscoring her Catholic faith. The similarities to the Colon case prompted police to link them immediately, dubbing the killings the “Double Initial” murders. The eight-year gap mattered because it forced investigators to consider whether the same person had simply waited out the initial attention or whether life circumstances had kept him from striking again.
Michelle Maenza (M.M.): The Final Confirmed Victim
Michelle Maenza, also 11, disappeared on November 5, 1973, just seven months after Wanda. The shy seventh-grader left her home on Robert Circle to buy cigarettes for her mother at a nearby store on Culver Road. Witnesses placed her walking alone shortly after 6:30 p.m. Her skeletal remains were discovered three weeks later, on November 26, by hunters in a wooded area off Route 441 in Penfield, about 10 miles southeast of Rochester.
Decomposition obscured some details, but evidence confirmed sexual assault and manual strangulation. Michelle’s clothing was found folded nearby, mirroring the previous scenes. At this point, Rochester braced for more victims, but none followed, at least none publicly linked. The short interval between Wanda and Michelle suggested the offender had become more active, or perhaps more confident that he could continue without detection.
The Crimes: A Pattern of Precision and Cruelty
The Alphabet Murders stood out for their uniformity. All victims were white girls aged 10-11, slender builds, walking alone during errands in familiar neighborhoods. Abductions occurred in daylight or early evening, suggesting the killer blended into the community, perhaps driving a common vehicle like a panel truck reported by witnesses. The choice of victims who fit an alphabetical pattern added another layer, because it implied selection rather than pure opportunity.
Post-mortem, each girl was stripped, assaulted, strangled with bare hands, and redressed partially before being posed and dumped in ditches along major routes outside Monroe County. No murder weapons or personal items from the killer were left behind, indicating he cleaned up meticulously. Semen evidence existed but predated DNA profiling, rendering it useless at the time. The locations formed a rough triangle around Rochester, accessible via Interstate 490 and Route 104, which pointed to someone with solid local knowledge of the roads and quiet spots.
The Investigation: Decades of Dead Ends
Rochester Police Department formed a task force after Michelle’s discovery, interviewing over 1,000 suspects and polygraphing hundreds. Early leads focused on pedophiles, family members, and transients. A composite sketch of a swarthy man in his 30s circulated, based on sightings near crime scenes. The sheer volume of tips showed how seriously the department took the pattern, yet the absence of eyewitnesses who could place a specific person with any victim kept the case from breaking open.
In the 1970s, FBI profiling described the unsub as a white male, 25-35, local, possibly with a menial job and vehicle access. Tips poured in, including from prison inmates claiming knowledge. One notable suspect was a local man who failed a polygraph but had an alibi. By the 1980s, cases went cold. DNA from semen on the victims was retested in 2002 with partial profiles, entered into CODIS, yielding no matches. In 2011, RPD revisited files amid national cold case initiatives. Each new round of review reminded the public that technology alone could not solve what human memory and evidence gaps had already buried.
Key Suspects: From Locals to a West Coast Monster
Local Persons of Interest
Several Rochester residents drew scrutiny. A plumber named Edward “Crazy Eddie” Sereno matched witness descriptions and lived near abduction sites; he confessed vaguely before recanting. Another, a school janitor, had child pornography but no direct ties. These leads fizzled without evidence. The frustration for detectives lay in how many people could fit pieces of the description yet provide nothing that held up under closer examination.
Joseph Naso: The California Connection
The most compelling suspect emerged in 2010: Joseph Paul Naso, 77, arrested in Nevada for California murders. A former photographer from Rochester, Naso lived there in the 1960s, matching the timeline. His “List of 10” detailed “girls” in New York and California, with Rochester entries aligning chronologically. Naso, convicted in 2013 of four Golden State murders that also carried double initials, boasted of more kills. Rochester DA Michael Green called evidence “compelling,” including Naso’s residence near victims’ homes and a 1950s photo of him resembling early sketches. Partial DNA linked him loosely, but New York statute limitations prevented charges. Naso died in 2019, taking secrets to the grave. RPD still considers him responsible. The connection feels strong on paper, yet the lack of conclusive physical proof leaves room for reasonable doubt that another explanation might still exist.
Other Theories
Speculation linked the cases to BTK killer Dennis Rader, though geography never aligned, or the .22 Caliber Killer, whose method differed. Some posit multiple perpetrators, but the repeated details of folded clothing and body positioning argue against it. The pattern consistency remains the strongest argument for a single offender.
Psychological Profile and Motive
Criminologists view the killer as an organized offender: intelligent, socially adept, driven by power and sexual fantasy. The posing and folding of clothes suggest ritualism, possibly necrophilic tendencies. Alphabetical selection indicates narcissism, deriving satisfaction from media attention via the “Alphabet” moniker. Motive likely blended opportunity with obsession. Victims’ errands made them vulnerable; the killer may have stalked schools or churches. If Naso was responsible, his nomadic life from New York to California fit a transient predator who relocated to stay ahead of attention. The gaps between crimes also suggest periods when daily life or fear of detection kept him from acting.
Legacy: An Unsolved Enigma Enduring
Today, the Alphabet Murders remain open, files digitized for modern forensics. Families like the Colons and Maenzas advocate for justice, with Michelle’s mother passing in 2017 without closure. True crime podcasts and books, such as Harold Schechter’s works, keep awareness alive. The cases influenced policing by emphasizing pattern recognition in serial crimes and underscored both the power and the limitations of DNA from the pre-PCR era. For Rochester, annual memorials honor the girls, transforming tragedy into community resilience. As explored further at Dyerbolical once at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these files continue to draw fresh eyes whenever new forensic tools emerge.
Conclusion
The Alphabet Murders exemplify the terror of an unseen predator preying on innocence, their double-initial pattern a macabre signature etched in infamy. While Joseph Naso represents the closest path to answers, definitive proof eludes us, leaving Carmen, Wanda, and Michelle’s memories as solemn reminders of vulnerability and the quest for truth. These girls deserved safety; their stories demand we never forget, pushing law enforcement toward resolution in an era of advanced science. Until then, Rochester’s highways hold the quiet weight of unresolved questions.
Bibliography
Rochester Democrat and Chronicle archives covering the original investigations from 1965 through 1973.
New York State Police cold case summaries on the Alphabet Murders.
Associated Press coverage of Joseph Naso’s 2013 conviction and 2019 death.
Harold Schechter, “The Serial Killer Files,” references to the Rochester cases.
FBI Violent Criminal Apprehension Program (ViCAP) historical profiles on organized offenders.
Monroe County District Attorney statements regarding the Naso connection in 2011.
Contemporary reporting from the Democrat and Chronicle on the 2002 DNA retesting.
Victim family interviews archived through local Rochester media outlets.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
