The Devil Wears Prada 2 vs. The Original: Which Fashion Icon Endures?

In the high-stakes world of Hollywood sequels, few announcements spark as much frenzy as the revival of a cultural juggernaut. Nearly two decades after The Devil Wears Prada stormed cinemas in 2006, captivating audiences with its razor-sharp satire of the fashion industry, Disney has greenlit a sequel. Meryl Streep reprises her iconic role as Miranda Priestly, the imperious editor-in-chief of Runway magazine, while Emily Blunt returns as her long-suffering assistant Emily Charlton. Anne Hathaway, who played fresh-faced Andy Sachs, is in talks to join, promising a nostalgic yet evolved clash of titans.

This news, breaking in July 2024 via Variety, reignites debates among fans: can lightning strike twice in an era dominated by reboots and franchises? The original film, adapted from Lauren Weisberger’s bestselling novel, grossed over $326 million worldwide on a modest $35 million budget and earned Streep an Oscar nomination for her unforgettable portrayal of a Vogue-like dragon lady. But does the sequel have what it takes to eclipse its predecessor, or will it merely trade on faded glamour? As production ramps up under returning producer Wendy Finerman, we dive deep into a head-to-head showdown, analysing plot, performances, cultural resonance, and box office prospects to determine which Devil wears the crown better.

What makes this comparison timely is the fashion world’s seismic shift since 2006. Print media has ceded ground to TikTok influencers and Instagram empires, raising questions about relevance. Will The Devil Wears Prada 2 mock today’s digital darlings, or cling to outdated tropes? Let’s dissect both films layer by layer.

The Original: A Timeless Satire of Ambition and Style

Released amid the mid-2000s rom-com boom, The Devil Wears Prada transcended its genre through biting wit and stellar execution. Directed by David Frankel, it follows Andy Sachs (Hathaway), a Princeton grad who lands a junior assistant gig at Runway under Miranda Priestly. What begins as a fish-out-of-water tale evolves into a profound exploration of compromise, identity, and the cutthroat pursuit of success.

Meryl Streep’s Miranda is the film’s pulsating heart. With a voice like chilled velvet and glances that could curdle milk, she embodies quiet tyranny. Lines like “That’s all!” delivered with arched disdain became instant classics. Hathaway’s arc from dowdy outsider to sleek insider mirrors every young professional’s temptation, while Blunt’s Emily provides fiery comic relief, snarling “I’m one stomach flu away from my goal weight” in a performance that stole scenes.

The film’s strengths lie in its authenticity. Weisberger drew from her own Wintour-inspired internship, lending credibility to the opulent sets and frenetic pace. Fashion luminaries like Valentino and Carolina Herrera supplied authentic looks, turning the movie into a style bible. Critically, it scored 75% on Rotten Tomatoes, praised for its “savage glee” by Roger Ebert, who noted its skewering of elitism without bitterness.

Box office dominance followed: it topped charts for weeks, spawning merchandise, parodies, and a Broadway musical rumoured for revival. Culturally, it democratised fashion, coining phrases like “cerulean blue” monologue that still echo in memes. Yet flaws persist – the romance subplot feels tacked on, and Andy’s redemption arc borders on moralising.

Key Production Highlights of the Original

  • Budget and Returns: $35 million budget yielded $326 million globally, a 9x multiplier.
  • Awards: Two Oscar nods (Streep, costume design); Golden Globe win for Streep.
  • Soundtrack: Hits like Madonna’s “Vogue” amplified its pop culture footprint.
  • Influence: Boosted careers of Hathaway and Blunt; inspired TV like The Bold Type.

These elements cemented the original as a benchmark for workplace satires, blending glamour with grit.

The Devil Wears Prada 2: Bold Revival or Risky Redux?

Fast-forward to 2024: the sequel arrives courtesy of Disney, which acquired 20th Century Fox assets housing the IP. Details remain sparse, but insiders reveal a plot thrusting Miranda into the social media maelstrom. Expect Emily, now a top executive, to challenge her former boss amid influencer takeovers and fast fashion upheavals. Hathaway’s potential return as Andy, perhaps a disillusioned journalist, adds layers of evolution.

Streep’s commitment, after initial hesitation, signals confidence. At 75, she brings gravitas to a Miranda facing obsolescence – think Anna Wintour navigating TikTok. Blunt, 41 and fresh off Oppenheimer acclaim, evolves Emily from sidekick to rival, promising sparks. Director details are unconfirmed, but Frankel’s return would ensure tonal continuity.

Production buzz includes Aimee Mullins (the original’s leg model) as a writer alongside Weisberger, hinting at insider wit. Filming eyes New York and Paris, with modern designers like Schiaparelli on board. Early reactions? Electric. Deadline reports fan petitions hit 100,000 signatures pre-announcement, underscoring hunger for more.[1]

Challenges loom: sequels often falter post-long hiatus (Top Gun: Maverick succeeded via innovation). Can it satirise Gen Z culture without pandering? Budget whispers suggest $80-100 million, banking on nostalgia amid streaming wars.

Announced Cast and Crew Shifts

  1. Meryl Streep as Miranda Priestly: The unchallenged queen.
  2. Emily Blunt as Emily Charlton: Promoted to power player.
  3. Anne Hathaway (TBD): Andy’s return could unify eras.
  4. Producers: Wendy Finerman anchors familiarity.

This setup positions the sequel as a bridge between analogue ambition and digital disruption.

Cast Face-Off: Performances That Define Eras

Streep’s Miranda remains peerless. Her original subtlety – a whisper more devastating than shouts – sets an Everest bar. The sequel offers redemption: an older Miranda wielding wisdom as weapon, potentially deepening her humanity. Blunt’s growth excites most; her original venom evolves into strategic savvy, mirroring her real-life ascent.

Hathaway’s absence would sting, but her The Idea of You resurgence makes inclusion viable. Supporting casts? Original’s Stanley Tucci as Nigel provided heart; expect fresh faces like a Gen Z influencer for contrast. Verdict: sequel casts leverage age and experience, potentially outshining youth-driven original dynamics.

Thematic Evolution: Print Power vs. Digital Chaos

The original lambasted gatekept glamour, with Miranda as arbiter of taste. Andy’s cerulean speech illuminated fashion’s trickle-down tyranny. Today, democratised by Shein and #OOTD, the industry fragments. Sequel teases Miranda battling algorithms and authenticity fakes, critiquing cancel culture and viral virility.

Both explore ambition’s cost: original’s print deadlines mirror sequel’s 24/7 feeds. Yet the new film risks datedness if it ignores sustainability scandals or DEI shifts. Original wins purity; sequel promises prescience, analysing how power persists amid democratisation.

Historical parallels abound: like Sex and the City 2‘s misfire, it must avoid caricature. Or emulate Bridget Jones‘s charm. Themes position sequel as cultural mirror, potentially surpassing original’s specificity.

Direction, Style, and Technical Triumphs

Frankel’s steady hand captured Manhattan’s gloss without excess. Cinematographer Florian Ballhaus’s cerulean hues and kinetic edits pulsed energy. Costumes by Patricia Field defined looks, from Andy’s Birkin quest to Miranda’s Chanel armour.

Sequel eyes similar polish, with Patricia Field consulting for authenticity. VFX minimal in original; now, expect AR fashion shows. Soundtracks evolve too – from 2000s pop to Billie Eilish-era angst. Stylistically, sequel adapts to widescreen spectacle, enhancing satire.

Box Office Battle and Cultural Legacy

Original’s ROI crushes most: $326 million in 2006 dollars equates $500 million today. Sequel launches into post-pandemic recovery, with Disney’s muscle (think Deadpool & Wolverine‘s billions). IMAX and streaming hybrids boost prospects; predict $400-600 million if buzz sustains.

Culturally, original endures via quotes and Halloween costumes. Sequel could redefine workplace tales for hybrid workers, tackling burnout and AI. Social media amplifies: TikTok recreations already surge post-announcement.

Metric Original (2006) Sequel (TBD)
Global Gross $326M Projected $400M+
RT Score 75% TBD
Cultural Impact Iconic quotes, memes Social media satire

Head-to-Head: Strengths, Weaknesses, and Predictions

Plot: Original’s tight arc trumps sequel’s unproven ambition. Performances: Sequel edges with matured stars. Relevance: New film wins modernity. Weaknesses? Original’s dated tech; sequel’s sequel fatigue risk.

Predictions: sequel matches culturally, surpasses financially. Yet original’s purity endures as flawless debut.

Conclusion: The Original Edges Ahead, But Sequel Beckons

Ultimately, The Devil Wears Prada reigns supreme for its unblemished alchemy of satire, style, and Streep sorcery – a near-perfect artifact of its time. The sequel, however, tantalises with timely reinvention, poised to dissect our fractured fashion future. If it honours the original’s bite while embracing change, it could co-exist as equal. Fans, ready your Manolos: this rematch promises Prada perfection. Which side are you on? The polls are open.

References