In the quiet farmlands of early 20th-century America, a woman named Emma Schmidt endured a prolonged confrontation with forces that witnesses described as beyond ordinary explanation. Her story unfolded across multiple states and nearly two decades, drawing in priests, doctors, and nuns who recorded what they saw in diaries and sworn statements. This article examines the full sequence of events in the exorcism of Emma Schmidt, from her early symptoms in Wisconsin through the intense final rites in Earling, Iowa, while weighing the historical evidence against later psychological interpretations and exploring why the case still matters to discussions of faith and mental health today.
Emma’s Early Life and the Onset of Possession
Born in 1882 to German immigrant parents in Monroe, Wisconsin, Emma Schmidt grew up in a devout Catholic home where daily Mass and choir participation shaped her routine. Around 1908 she visited relatives and later described meeting a woman who practiced spiritualism and held séances. Soon afterward she developed nausea at the sight of crucifixes, recoiled from holy water, and began using profanity that startled her family. These changes mattered because they marked a sharp break from her previous character and prompted relatives to seek clerical help. By 1912 she displayed sudden bursts of strength, spoke in altered voices, and revealed private information about people she had never met. Her brother contacted Father Henry Freitag, whose initial blessings met strong resistance, leading him to call in Father Theophilus Riesinger for assistance.
The early sessions revealed multiple entities that identified themselves as Beelzebub, Judas, Jacob, and Legion. They taunted observers with accurate details about hidden family matters and the priest’s own past difficulties. These disclosures, preserved in contemporary notes, formed part of the reason later investigators found the case difficult to dismiss as simple fraud. Father Freitag recognized that the situation required more experienced intervention, and the groundwork was laid for a longer series of rites that would stretch over the following years.
Father Riesinger and the Initial Exorcisms
Theophilus Riesinger, born near Munich in 1868, had already performed exorcisms in Bavaria before emigrating to the United States in 1899. He served in Wisconsin and approached each case with careful preparation, combining the Roman Ritual with attention to the person’s physical and mental state. In June 1912 he began working with Emma at her family home. During these encounters she arched violently, her voice shifting as the entities declared their presence and vowed to resist. Over twenty-three days the priest continued the prayers, and some relief appeared before other manifestations returned. By autumn the immediate crisis eased enough for Emma to resume ordinary life, yet the improvement proved temporary.
In 1922 another reported contact with spiritualism reignited the disturbances. Riesinger arranged for Emma to be taken to the Franciscan convent in Earling, Iowa, where isolation could reduce outside interference and allow focused attention. The move reflected the Church’s standard practice of seeking medical clearance and a controlled setting before major rites. Observers noted that this preparation helped distinguish the case from less orderly accounts of possession that circulated at the time.
Preparations at the Earling Convent
The convent building stood as a solid brick structure housing about thirty nuns. Before the rites began, the rooms received repeated blessings and windows were reinforced with iron bars. Physicians examined Emma in advance and found no evidence of epilepsy or standard forms of hysteria. She fasted during the process and received only the Eucharist for nourishment. On 18 August 1928 the formal exorcism opened under Riesinger’s direction, with Mother Superior Borgfried and a small group of nuns present. Additional lay witnesses rotated through the sessions to limit emotional exhaustion. The bishop received only a general outline of the plan, preserving confidentiality while maintaining oversight.
The Earling Exorcisms: A Catalogue of the Uncanny
Over the next twenty-three days the room became the setting for repeated and intense physical changes. Emma’s face swelled and her jaw appeared to dislocate as she produced animal-like sounds. Witnesses described her body lifting several feet off the bed before dropping heavily. At times a dark fluid emerged from her mouth and formed recognizable words before vanishing. Strong odors of sulfur and decay filled the space, occasionally giving way to lighter scents that some attributed to reported angelic intervention. The voices shifted between distinct personalities, each disclosing personal facts about the nuns and doctors present. Emma’s weight seemed to increase dramatically at moments and then decrease just as quickly.
Key Manifestations and Resistance
The physical demonstrations included bending metal bed frames and resisting the combined efforts of several men who tried to hold her down. She spoke in Latin, Hebrew, and German, languages she had never studied, and used these to challenge the priest directly. The entities named one another as they departed, with Beelzebub remaining until 23 September. During calmer intervals Emma spoke in her own voice and asked the group to continue. Medical checks after each session showed no lasting injuries despite the extreme postures. At one point Riesinger presented her confessional diary, and the voices responded to questions under oath. The final departure coincided with a sudden drop in temperature and a strong rush of air through the room, after which Emma appeared calm and restored.
Investigations, Evidence, and Sceptical Views
Riesinger kept a detailed record that eventually reached roughly four hundred pages. Nuns, physicians, and Emma herself supplied affidavits that aligned on the main events. Dr. Richard E. Mesinger, one of the attending doctors, noted physical changes that did not match known medical conditions. These documents remain the primary sources for anyone studying the case. At the same time, later psychologists have suggested explanations such as dissociative identity disorder or the effects of prolonged fasting and expectation. The Church had already required medical examinations, which addressed some of these concerns at the time. Historian Brian Lebeau, writing in The Exorcist Diaries, points out that the number of independent witnesses across many years sets this episode apart from typical reports of mass suggestion.
Comparisons with the 1970s case of Anneliese Michel underscore differences in procedure and outcome. Emma’s exorcism followed formal approval and produced no fatalities, facts that continue to shape how researchers weigh its credibility. Modern investigators sometimes revisit such records with updated psychological tools, yet the original affidavits still resist simple reduction to suggestion alone.
Cultural Impact and Enduring Legacy
After 1928 Emma lived quietly and assisted in later exorcisms until her death from cancer in 1941. Riesinger continued his work until the same year. A witness published the 1935 booklet Begone Satan!, which brought the events to a wider audience. References appear in later fiction, although William Peter Blatty drew more heavily from the Roland Doe case for The Exorcist. The Schmidt account still surfaces in discussions of Vatican guidelines on exorcism, which received updates in 1999 and again in subsequent decades. At Dyerbolical we have examined how these historical records intersect with contemporary questions about mental health and spiritual experience.
The case invites reflection because it occurred in an era when both medical and religious authorities operated in the same room. Its survival in diocesan archives and published accounts gives researchers concrete material rather than rumor. Whether one attributes the phenomena to spiritual causes or to undiagnosed psychological conditions, the documented details continue to prompt careful examination rather than quick conclusions.
Bibliography
Begone Satan! A Witness Account of the Earling Exorcism, anonymous witness, 1935.
The Exorcist Diaries, Brian Lebeau, historical analysis of multiple possession cases.
Diocesan records and affidavits from the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, 1912–1928.
Physician notes by Dr. Richard E. Mesinger, preserved in private collections.
Vatican guidelines on exorcism, revised edition, 1999.
Comparative study of Anneliese Michel and earlier American cases, various theological journals, 2000s.
Modern reviews of early 20th-century exorcism procedures, Catholic University archives.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
