In the summer of 1878 a modest cottage on Princess Street in Amherst, Nova Scotia, became the setting for a prolonged series of disturbances that left furniture in motion, fires starting without matches, and voices issuing threats no one could trace to a living person. The events centered on nineteen-year-old Esther Cox and continued for more than a year, drawing doctors, ministers, journalists, and curious neighbors who recorded what they saw. This article follows the documented timeline of those incidents, examines the witness statements that survive, and weighs the explanations that have been offered from the Victorian era to the present.

Historical Context and the Teed Household

Amherst served as a busy railway junction in Cumberland County, its population of roughly four thousand sustained by trade and the Intercolonial Railway. The Teed family rented a small cottage at what was then numbered 288 Princess Street. Daniel Teed worked as a car repairman for the railway and supported his wife Olive along with their children, including Esther Cox, who had returned to the household after a short and unhappy marriage. Esther had already faced the loss of her parents and the collapse of her own brief union, circumstances that left her emotionally strained before the first knocks were heard. Those personal pressures matter because later researchers would note similar patterns of stress in other reported poltergeist cases, where the central figure often carried recent upheaval.

The Initial Disturbances

The first clear outbreak occurred on the night of 12 August 1878. Esther complained of sharp abdominal pain after returning from a picnic, and a physician suggested a possible uterine issue. That same evening loud raps sounded through the walls and furniture. Within days the activity intensified: Esther’s bed rose several inches off the floor while she lay on it, drawers flew open, and clothing scattered as though caught in a sudden wind. Neighbors who came to observe confirmed the movements with their own eyes. These early episodes established a pattern in which the disturbances seemed tied to Esther’s presence yet operated beyond her direct control.

Apports and Strange Odours

Small objects soon appeared in places where they had not been placed. Coins, buttons, and tools materialized on shelves or inside clothing. At the same time, sharp smells resembling burning sulphur or spoiled meat filled rooms and then vanished without source. One local merchant reported finding a fresh egg beneath his porch after hearing accounts of similar arrivals, even though no chickens were kept nearby. Such details suggested an agency capable of moving or producing items, though witnesses could offer no mechanical explanation for how the objects arrived.

Escalation: Violence and Communications

By September the force had grown more aggressive. Heavy pieces of furniture slid across floors unaided, mirrors cracked, and a sewing machine started by itself. A voice identifying itself as “Bob” began to speak, and messages such as “Esther Cox, you are mine to kill” appeared on walls in coal dust or were carved with knives. On 21 September two fires broke out inside the house—one in a trunk and another in the pantry—without any visible ignition. Fire chief Alexander Moncton later stated that no matches or accelerants had been used. Esther herself suffered puncture wounds that appeared on her skin and swelling around her throat as though she were being choked by unseen hands. These physical effects turned the case from unsettling noises into something that threatened bodily harm.

The Shooting Incident

On 5 October Walter Edmonds, who had met Esther’s sister at the earlier picnic, drew a pistol and fired at Esther during one of the disturbances. The bullet struck her back yet caused only minor injury; she later claimed the entity had deflected it. Edmonds was convicted and served nine months in prison. After his release he reportedly returned to the house and provoked fresh activity, an episode that illustrated how deeply the events unsettled even those who tried to intervene.

Investigations and Notable Witnesses

Physician Dr. Carritte examined Esther on multiple occasions and found no evidence of epilepsy or deliberate trickery. Reverend Edwin Clay watched objects move and concluded the cause lay outside normal explanation. Neighbours including Mrs. Sarah Cox and John Blenkiron signed affidavits describing more than one hundred separate incidents, among them stones that fell from ceilings without anyone throwing them. American actor and writer Walter Hubbell lived in the cottage for six weeks in late 1878 and later published a detailed account titled The Great Amherst Mystery in 1888. His book preserves many of the original testimonies and records his own experiences, including a bed that shook beneath him and a chamber pot that shattered beside him. While some critics suggested Esther might have produced the voices through ventriloquism, Hubbell noted that the tone and pitch did not match her own speaking voice.

Esther stayed briefly with other families, and the phenomena followed her to the Snow household before quieting at Dr. Tupper’s during her menstrual periods, a detail that later researchers would compare with similar fluctuations reported in other cases. Local authorities once jailed her on a vagrancy charge after neighbors complained, yet renewed outbreaks upon her release persuaded officials that the activity was not simply her doing.

Theories and Explanations

Victorian observers divided between those who saw the work of spirits or demons and those who suspected fraud or hysteria. The Halifax Herald leaned toward the latter view, yet the number of independent witnesses made simple trickery difficult to sustain. The family gained neither money nor lasting advantage from the publicity, only discomfort and eventual relocation. In the twentieth century parapsychologist William Roll developed the concept of recurrent spontaneous psychokinesis, or RSPK, to describe cases in which an emotionally stressed individual appears to influence objects unconsciously. Esther’s recent personal losses fit the profile Roll and others identified. Some investigators have since applied modern tools such as portable audio recorders and environmental sensors to comparable outbreaks, seeking measurable changes in temperature or electromagnetic fields that might accompany reported activity. Even these methods leave room for debate, because no single instrument has yet captured conclusive proof that would satisfy every skeptic.

Comparisons with the Bell Witch haunting of 1817 and the Enfield case of 1977 highlight recurring elements: threats, moving objects, and a focal person under stress. Amherst stands out for the sheer quantity of signed statements collected at the time. Sceptics such as Joe Nickell have acknowledged that while exaggeration may have crept into some retellings, a core of unexplained reports remains that continues to invite study.

Cultural Impact and Legacy

Newspapers from Halifax to New York carried the story, and Hubbell later dramatized it on the vaudeville stage. Esther herself married twice after the events subsided around 1880 and lived until 1919. Amherst later placed a historical plaque at the site and offers occasional tours that recount the household’s ordeal. Contemporary podcasts and documentaries revisit the case, weighing Hubbell’s possible biases while recognizing the weight of the contemporary affidavits. At Dyerbolical further discussion of how such historical reports inform current field methods can be found at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.

Bibliography

Walter Hubbell, The Great Amherst Mystery (1888). Contemporary issues of the Halifax Herald and Amherst newspapers from 1878-1879. Affidavits collected by Reverend Edwin Clay and local residents. William G. Roll, The Poltergeist (1972). Joe Nickell, investigative notes on the Amherst case. Modern parapsychological reviews comparing RSPK patterns across documented outbreaks. Historical census and railway records for Amherst, Nova Scotia, 1878.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289