The remote cabins of Keddie Resort in California’s Sierra Nevada once offered families a simple escape into the mountains. By the spring of 1981 that peace shattered when four people lost their lives inside Cabin 28, leaving behind a crime scene so violent that it still raises questions about what really happened that night and why the case has never been solved.

This article examines the events of April 11 and 12, 1981, the victims whose lives were cut short, the investigation that followed, and the theories that have persisted for more than four decades. It draws on official records, witness accounts, and later forensic developments to show how a single night in a small resort community continues to affect survivors and investigators alike.

The Isolated Setting of Keddie Resort

Keddie Resort sat in the Feather River Canyon near Quincy, a modest collection of cabins that had once drawn summer visitors but had fallen on harder times by the early 1980s. The area attracted low-income families and seasonal workers looking for affordable housing rather than vacationers. Cabin 28 itself was a plain three-bedroom unit that became home to Sue Sharp and her five children after they moved from Connecticut in search of a new beginning. The resort’s location, ringed by dense forest and reached only by a narrow road, created a close-knit but isolated atmosphere where everyone knew their neighbors.

That closeness mattered on the evening of April 10, 1981. John Sharp, Sue’s fifteen-year-old son, and his friend Dana Wingate made plans to attend a party but never made it there. Their decision to stay close to the cabin instead placed them at the center of what unfolded hours later. The surrounding woods and limited access would later complicate both the crime and the response that followed.

The Victims: Lives Cut Short

Sue Sharp, thirty-six, had recently separated from her husband and was working whatever jobs she could find to keep her family afloat. Friends remembered her as outgoing and fiercely protective of her children. Her son John was a popular athlete who often helped look after his younger siblings. Dana Wingate, seventeen, came from a difficult background and had become a regular presence in the Sharp home. Twelve-year-old Tina Sharp was the quiet youngest daughter whose distinctive flannel nightgown would become a detail investigators remembered.

The survivors included Sheila Sharp, fifteen, who returned home the next morning, and her younger brothers Rick and Greg, who had been sleeping in another room. Justin Smartt, fourteen, the son of neighbors in Cabin 27, had also spent time at the Sharp cabin that evening. Their safety while others were killed highlighted how selective and deliberate the violence appeared to be.

Discovery of the Crime Scene

Sheila Sharp arrived back at Cabin 28 around eight o’clock on the morning of April 12. What she found turned an ordinary Saturday into a scene of horror. Her mother lay face down in the living room, bound with electrical cord and medical tape, her throat cut and chest marked by multiple stab wounds. John and Dana were nearby, both bound and showing signs of severe blunt-force trauma and knife injuries. Tina was missing, her bed empty and a window screen removed. Sheila’s immediate screams brought neighbors, including Martin Smartt from next door, who tried to comfort her until authorities arrived.

The Plumas County Sheriff’s Office responded, though the remote location meant a full forensic response took time. Early confusion allowed several people to enter the cabin before it was properly secured, a step that would later draw criticism for its effect on evidence preservation.

The Brutality of the Attacks

Autopsies later showed that Sue suffered eleven stab wounds along with defensive injuries, indicating she fought back. John had deep cuts to his neck and blunt trauma to his face. Dana sustained repeated blows to the skull and a cut throat. Blood patterns suggested the three were alive through much of the assault. The absence of forced entry pointed to attackers the victims likely knew. A hammer found behind the sofa and bloody shoe prints became early points of interest, as did the fact that Tina had apparently been taken from the scene.

The timing of the attack, estimated between eleven at night and one in the morning, aligned with the point when John and Dana’s evening plans had already fallen through. These details mattered because they narrowed the window investigators had to work with and raised questions about who would have known the cabin’s layout and routines.

The Investigation: Twists and Dead Ends

Initial Response and Challenges

From the beginning the investigation faced practical obstacles. The remote setting limited immediate access to specialized forensic resources. The FBI offered limited assistance before stepping back. Witness statements were inconsistent, partly because several key people were teenagers still processing trauma. Rick and Greg, who had been in the cabin, reported hearing nothing, which raised the possibility they had been given something to keep them asleep.

Key Evidence and Forensic Clues

Investigators recovered a hammer from Cabin 27 that carried Martin Smartt’s fingerprints. Medical tape at the scene matched a brand used by his wife. John Sharp’s jacket later turned up in a Reno pawn shop. Dana Wingate’s blood appeared on a carpet taken from the neighboring cabin. Shoe prints matched a style sold at a local store and worn by Smartt. Each piece of evidence seemed to point toward people who lived nearby, yet chain-of-custody problems and the limits of 1980s technology prevented any charges from being filed at the time.

Suspects and the Justin Confession

Martin Smartt, an ex-Army medic with a criminal record, quickly became a focus because of personal tensions with the Sharp family. His wife and his roommate, John Boubede, also drew scrutiny. In 1984 Justin Smartt told a therapist that three men, including his stepfather, had carried out the killings. The details he provided matched information that had not been released to the public. He later recanted, claiming pressure, but the initial account kept investigators returning to the same small circle of neighbors.

Theories: Drug Debt, Personal Vendetta, or Cover-Up?

One leading theory centers on a personal dispute, possibly involving a small debt or jealousy over a teenage relationship. Another suggests the violence was meant to silence witnesses after an argument escalated. An anonymous letter sent to authorities in 1981 claimed three people were involved and hinted at efforts to protect them. Later claims linking the murders to drug activity or passing drifters were examined but never produced solid leads. A 2016 book compiled much of the existing evidence and renewed public interest, while DNA profiles recovered from the tape have yet to yield a public match.

These theories matter because each one points investigators in different directions, and the lack of a single clear path has kept the case open. Modern genetic genealogy offers new possibilities, though budget limits in a rural county continue to slow progress.

Tina Sharp’s Fate: The Final Cruelty

Tina’s disappearance added another layer of pain. Her skull was found in 1984 near Oroville, roughly one hundred miles away, showing animal damage but confirming her identity through dental records. The decision to move only her remains has never been fully explained, though it suggests an attempt to hide evidence or send a message. Her case remains classified as a homicide.

Legacy of Cabin 28

Cabin 28 was eventually torn down in 2022 after years of vandalism and unwanted attention. Survivors moved on with their lives, though Sheila Sharp has continued to speak publicly about the need for answers. Annual memorials keep the victims’ names in view. Advances in DNA technology give some hope that evidence collected decades ago may still produce results.

At Dyerbolical we have followed how cold-case units across the country are revisiting similar files with fresh tools, and this case stands as a clear example of both the damage caused by early investigative missteps and the persistence required to keep such files alive. Until new evidence surfaces, the questions left by that night in April 1981 remain open.

Bibliography

Stabbed in the Heart by Dmac, 2016.

Plumas County Sheriff’s Office case files and press releases, 1981-2022.

Autopsy reports for Sue Sharp, John Sharp, and Dana Wingate, Plumas County Coroner, 1981.

News articles from the Feather River Bulletin and Sacramento Bee covering the initial investigation and later developments.

Justin Smartt therapist statements and related court documents, 1984.

California Department of Justice cold case review summaries.

Interviews with Sheila Sharp in various documentaries and print features, 2000s-present.

Genetic genealogy discussions in forensic journals referencing the medical tape evidence.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289