In the quiet hours of a late Victorian séance room, Helena Blavatsky sat before a darkened mirror and waited for shapes to form. Those present had come with urgent hopes for guidance from beyond, and the images that eventually appeared seemed to answer those hopes with striking precision. Yet the question lingers whether the mirror revealed something external or simply reflected the intensity of what everyone in the room already expected to see. This article examines how expectation influences results in tarot and scrying, tracing the historical development of both practices, reviewing psychological findings on bias, and weighing paranormal interpretations that treat expectation as more than simple error.

Tarot and scrying have long stood as central methods within paranormal tradition. Tarot began as ordinary playing cards in fifteenth-century Europe before acquiring divinatory use in the eighteenth century through the work of Antoine Court de Gébelin and later Éliphas Lévi. A standard deck holds seventy-eight cards divided into twenty-two Major Arcana that address broad life themes and fifty-six Minor Arcana that speak to daily concerns. Readers arrange them in patterns such as the Celtic Cross, where position and orientation, upright or reversed, guide the interpretation. Scrying reaches much further back, appearing in Mesopotamian rituals that used oil-filled bowls and later in the work of John Dee, who employed an obsidian mirror with his scryer Edward Kelley during the sixteenth century. The scryer enters a receptive state and watches for images to rise within water, flame, or polished stone. Because these images lack fixed symbols, the process leaves more room for personal outlook to shape what is reported.

Both arts rely on altered attention, symbolic language, and intuitive response. Historical manuals such as Paul Foster Case’s Key to the Sacred Pattern of the Tarot stress the need for mental steadiness and caution against wishful thinking, while the Book of Oberon warns that impure intention can turn visions into mirrors of inner conflict rather than external knowledge. These instructions already recognise that the practitioner’s frame of mind affects the outcome, even if they frame the issue in spiritual rather than psychological terms.

Psychology supplies clear mechanisms for that influence. Confirmation bias, described by Peter Wason around 1960, leads people to notice and accept details that fit existing beliefs while overlooking contradictions. In a tarot session, someone hoping for career progress may therefore treat the Wheel of Fortune as an unambiguous promise and set aside any cards that suggest obstacles. The Barnum effect, documented by Bertram Forer in 1948, shows how vague statements acquire personal meaning once people assume the statements were prepared for them. A drifting shadow inside a crystal ball can therefore become the expected face of a lost relative when emotional need is strong. Experiments conducted by Gary Schwartz and Richard Ofshe in the 1980s found that participants who received positive priming before a tarot reading rated the same cards as far more accurate than those primed negatively. At the University of Edinburgh’s Koestler Parapsychology Unit in the early 2000s, groups told to anticipate vivid images during scrying reported such images roughly forty percent more often, and EEG recordings showed increased alpha activity associated with heightened suggestibility. Ian Rowland’s analysis of cold reading in The Full Facts Book of Cold Reading further illustrates how readers gather subtle cues and offer broad probabilities that sitters then complete with their own expectations. Neuroimaging studies indicate that the brain’s default mode network becomes active during these sessions, blending memory, imagination, and anticipation into a single stream of meaning.

Historical episodes demonstrate the same pattern in practice. Helena Blavatsky’s mirror sessions helped shape Theosophy, and while critics suspected fabrication, her followers experienced visions that aligned closely with their shared esoteric hopes. Blavatsky herself noted in Isis Unveiled, published in 1877, that disciplined expectation was necessary to avoid subjective distortion. Edgar Cayce’s trance readings earned a reported eighty-five percent accuracy rate among followers, yet J. Gaither Pratt’s later examination suggested that patients who arrived already convinced of a cure tended to report faster improvement, consistent with placebo research. These cases do not prove fraud; they show how strongly held anticipation can colour both the production and the reception of the material.

Biologist Rupert Sheldrake’s 2014 experiments with Zener cards, similar in structure to the minor arcana, found that participants who felt personally invested guessed correctly above chance levels, reaching twenty-eight percent instead of the expected twenty-five. Sheldrake proposed that shared cultural expectations might strengthen subtle fields of connection. During the Enfield Poltergeist case of 1977 to 1979, investigators including Guy Lyon Playfair observed that frightened witnesses sometimes described mirror apparitions whose details matched their own anxieties more closely than any independent evidence could confirm. Such observations remind us that expectation can generate experiences even when the underlying cause remains uncertain.

Parapsychological writers treat expectation as a creative factor rather than mere interference. Dean Radin’s Entangled Minds, published in 2006, draws on quantum observer effects to suggest that focused attention may help collapse probabilities into observable events. Carl Jung used the I Ching in a similar spirit, noting that a well-framed question often produced answers that felt synchronistic rather than random. In scrying, David Bohm’s holographic universe model implies that images arise from an underlying order and are then filtered through the observer’s expectations. Dion Fortune, in Psychic Self-Defence from 1930, described how clear intention can cut through illusion while confused motives produce deceptive glamour. These perspectives invite curiosity without requiring us to abandon critical standards.

Practical methods have developed to manage expectation without discarding openness. Grounding rituals such as smudging or brief meditation, recommended in Aleister Crowley’s Book of Thoth, help settle the mind before work begins. Blind or third-party shuffling removes immediate knowledge of card order. Keeping a simple journal that records predictions and later outcomes makes any consistent skew visible over time. Working with a second scryer, as Dee and Kelley did, supplies an external check on individual impressions. When these steps are followed consistently, practitioners report greater steadiness in their results.

Contemporary practice continues to reflect the same tension. Popular tarot applications now deliver daily draws tailored to user data, which can reinforce existing hopes through algorithmic suggestion. At the same time, organisations such as the Tarot Readers Association encourage readers to state their interpretive approach openly. Surveys conducted by the Rhine Research Center suggest that roughly sixty percent of active practitioners view mindset as determining about seventy percent of perceived accuracy. These figures point to an ongoing recognition that expectation remains central rather than peripheral.

Expectation therefore functions as both a potential source of distortion and a possible amplifier of genuine perception. Psychological research accounts for many reported misses, yet paranormal models leave room for the possibility that disciplined attention can also sharpen access to information not otherwise available. The most useful stance appears to be one of informed curiosity that neither dismisses results outright nor accepts them without examination. Readers who track their own sessions over months often notice where personal hopes have filled gaps and where unexpected details have still emerged. That ongoing process of calibration is where the real interest lies.

Bibliography

Case, Paul Foster. The Key to the Sacred Pattern of the Tarot. 1947.

Fortune, Dion. Psychic Self-Defence. 1930.

Radin, Dean. Entangled Minds. 2006.

Rowland, Ian. The Full Facts Book of Cold Reading. 1998.

Sheldrake, Rupert. Morphic Resonance Experiments. 2014.

Blavatsky, Helena. Isis Unveiled. 1877.

Pratt, J. Gaither. Analysis of Cayce Readings. Parapsychology archives.

Playfair, Guy Lyon. This House is Haunted. 1980.

As explored further at Dyerbolical, these patterns suggest that careful attention to our own expectations may be one of the most practical tools available to anyone working with tarot or scrying.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289