One of the earliest detailed records of state sanctioned cruelty comes from the Assyrian king Ashurnasirpal II, who proudly described flaying rebels and draping their skins over city walls. That ancient boast still echoes through later centuries whenever governments have claimed that extreme pain served a higher purpose. This article traces how authorities from antiquity to the present day have built legal, religious, and political arguments to defend the use of torture, examining the patterns that connect those rationales across time and place.

The story matters because the same basic claims keep resurfacing. Rulers insist that pain extracts truth, protects order, or saves souls. Victims are recast as threats whose suffering is therefore acceptable. By looking closely at these arguments we see how institutions protect themselves while ordinary people pay the price. The record also shows why those defenses rarely hold up under later scrutiny.

Ancient Civilizations: Divine Right and State Security

In the earliest empires, torture was treated as an open instrument of rule rather than a secret practice. Kings presented it as part of the natural order, endorsed by gods and necessary for stability. The Assyrian Empire between roughly 900 and 612 BCE offers one of the clearest examples. Rulers such as Ashurnasirpal II recorded their methods on palace walls and in royal annals, describing flayings, impalements, and blindings as punishment for rebellion. They framed these acts as both warnings to others and demonstrations of piety. Captured enemies were presented as dangers to divine balance, so their public agony served to keep society intact. Legal codes of the period, known as the Assyrian Laws, even required torture for slaves and commoners when officials sought confessions, establishing an early precedent that pain could reliably uncover facts.

The Roman Empire later turned the same idea into a formal legal procedure. The Twelve Tables of 450 BCE allowed slaves to be tortured when they testified against their owners, on the theory that people of lower status were naturally dishonest. Over time emperors extended the practice to free citizens during treason investigations. Writers such as Cicero warned that information gained this way was often false, yet officials like Trajan continued to authorize it for cases involving threats to the state. Methods including the rack and public scourging became standard tools. The underlying claim was simple: only suffering could force hidden loyalties into the open. That legal framework survived long after Rome itself fell and influenced later European systems of justice.

Medieval Europe: The Inquisition and Religious Purity

During the Middle Ages the Catholic Church and secular rulers joined forces to treat heresy as a crime that justified physical coercion. Pope Gregory IX created the Papal Inquisition in 1231, and the 1252 bull Ad Extirpanda gave inquisitors explicit permission to use torture. The stated goal was to save souls through confession rather than to punish bodies. Figures such as Bernard Gui argued that brief sessions on the rack or with water were far preferable to eternal damnation. Victims, frequently Cathars or Jews, faced devices like the strappado, which dislocated shoulders, yet officials insisted the methods did not cause death. Records compiled by historian Henry Charles Lea indicate more than 100,000 trials by 1500. Once a confession was obtained, relapse into heresy could lead to execution without further proceedings.

The later European witch trials followed a similar logic. The Malleus Maleficarum of 1486 instructed interrogators to overcome supposed supernatural resistance with thumbscrews and other instruments. In England during the 1640s, Matthew Hopkins oversaw the torture of hundreds of women on the grounds that their suffering would protect communities from Satan. Many confessions were later withdrawn once the pain stopped, yet thousands of executions occurred across the continent. A few voices, including Reginald Scot in his 1584 book Discoverie of Witchcraft, questioned whether the evidence was real, but widespread fear kept the machinery running. Torture was presented as necessary religious work rather than simple cruelty.

Colonial and Imperial Eras: Civilizing Missions and Control

European expansion carried these practices into new territories under the banner of conversion and order. Spanish forces in the Americas used floggings and burnings to locate hidden treasure and to compel submission. The Requerimiento document required native peoples to accept Spanish authority or face war, and resistance was treated as justification for further violence. Bartolomé de las Casas documented the resulting deaths of millions, yet colonial law continued to permit harsh measures against those labeled infidels. The same pattern appeared in the transatlantic slave trade. Ship captains and plantation owners applied whippings and other punishments to extract information about planned rebellions. Virginia’s 1705 slave codes, for example, set limits on lashes while still requiring testimony under duress. Native American captives during conflicts such as King Philip’s War in 1675 also faced interrogation justified by biblical references. In each setting the victims were described as lesser beings whose pain served a larger civilizing purpose.

20th Century Totalitarianism: Ideological Enforcement

Modern dictatorships scaled these methods to industrial levels and wrapped them in new ideological language. In Nazi Germany the Gestapo employed sleep deprivation and beatings under the label of enhanced interrogation, claiming the techniques were needed to identify racial enemies. Heinrich Himmler and others presented the work as scientific necessity. The Soviet NKVD under Stalin used continuous questioning known as the conveyor to produce confessions of counter revolutionary activity. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn later recorded how millions endured these sessions, all framed as essential to preserving socialism. In 1970s Chile and Argentina, military regimes applied waterboarding and other methods to tens of thousands of people labeled subversives. Official manuals cited national security as the overriding concern. The victims were cast as existential threats whose suffering protected society at large.

Contemporary Justifications: The War on Terror

After the September 2001 attacks, United States officials revived similar arguments under the heading of enhanced interrogation. The 2004 Bybee Memo defined torture narrowly so that techniques such as waterboarding would fall outside the legal prohibition. Officials including Dick Cheney described the methods as effective against imminent threats. The 2014 Senate Intelligence Committee report later examined the cases of 119 detainees and found that the claimed intelligence gains were minimal or nonexistent. Photographs from Abu Ghraib in 2004 revealed systematic humiliation, again defended at the time as necessary for information gathering. Facilities such as Guantánamo Bay have continued to use practices including rectal feeding, with medical personnel sometimes involved in oversight. These episodes repeat the older pattern: security is said to outweigh ordinary restraints on state power.

Psychological and Legal Underpinnings

Across all these periods the justifications tend to rest on three recurring ideas. One is the claim that suffering produces reliable information. Another is the portrayal of certain groups as less than fully human. The third is the assertion that extraordinary danger requires extraordinary measures. Experiments conducted by Philip Zimbardo and Stanley Milgram in the twentieth century illustrated how ordinary people can set aside moral objections when placed in positions of authority or obedience. Legal developments such as the Geneva Conventions of 1949 and the United Nations Convention Against Torture of 1984 attempted to close the loopholes, yet governments have continued to find new wording that permits similar conduct. Research, including a 2017 Australian study, has repeatedly shown that information obtained through torture is frequently unreliable and leads to false confessions. The long term effects on survivors and their communities include lasting trauma that passes across generations.

These patterns demonstrate that the practice damages the institutions that employ it. It creates cycles of resentment and undercuts claims of moral authority. The historical record therefore offers a cautionary lesson rather than a simple chronicle of past events.

Conclusion

From the Assyrian reliefs to the memos of the early twenty first century, officials have consistently described torture as a regrettable but essential tool. The arguments change with each era, yet the underlying logic remains the same. Victims are redefined as dangers, and their pain is presented as serving a greater good. International agreements now exist to prevent these practices, but enforcement depends on continued public attention and institutional accountability. Understanding how earlier societies convinced themselves that brutality was justified helps us recognize the same reasoning when it appears again. Only by examining those claims directly can we avoid repeating the same mistakes.

Further discussion of these historical questions appears on Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.

Bibliography

Henry Charles Lea, A History of the Inquisition of the Middle Ages.

Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago.

United States Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, Committee Study of the Central Intelligence Agency’s Detention and Interrogation Program, 2014.

Bartolomé de las Casas, A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies.

Philip Zimbardo, The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil.

Reginald Scot, The Discoverie of Witchcraft, 1584.

United Nations Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, 1984.

Geneva Conventions, 1949.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289