The modest duplex at 119 Chase Road in West Pittston, Pennsylvania, stood quiet for decades until the Smurl family arrived in 1974. What followed was not a sudden eruption of strange events but a slow build of disturbances that stretched across thirteen years and left four children, their parents, and even visiting investigators describing encounters they could not explain away. This article traces the full timeline of reported activity from the first odd smells and sounds through the physical assaults and official investigations, weighs the evidence gathered by demonologists and police alike, and examines how the case still shapes discussions about the line between psychological strain and something more intrusive.
The Smurl family embodied the American dream in the 1970s: Jack, a hard-working truck driver, Janet, a devoted homemaker, and their children Dawn, Heather, Shannon, and Paul. In December 1974, they purchased half of a duplex built in 1923, splitting the property with Jack’s parents, Henry and Irene Smurl. The house, nestled in the Lackawanna River Valley, appeared ordinary, two storeys, wood-framed, with a shared basement. Financial pressures had forced the senior Smurls to sell their previous home, and the duplex offered a practical solution. Initial months passed uneventfully, but by mid-1975, subtle anomalies emerged. Family members noticed foul odours wafting from walls, akin to decaying flesh. Footsteps echoed in empty rooms at night, and doors slammed without cause. Janet, the most sensitive, reported feeling an oppressive presence, as if unseen eyes watched their every move. The senior Smurls experienced similar disturbances in their half, though they attributed them to settling foundations or overactive imaginations.
Background: A Family’s Move into Hell
The disturbances initially seemed benign pranks. Children’s toys moved inexplicably, and cold spots chilled rooms regardless of heating. Jack dismissed these as drafts, but Janet’s growing anxiety strained family relations. By 1976, the activity intensified: beds shook violently, waking the children in terror. One night, Paul, then a toddler, claimed a ‘pig man’ growled at him from the corner, a detail that would recur in later manifestations. These early episodes mattered because they set a pattern seen in other documented cases where minor annoyances gave way to sustained pressure on the household. The family’s Catholic faith prompted prayers, but relief proved fleeting. Neighbours reported no prior disturbances, yet the Smurls’ occupancy unleashed a barrage of phenomena that defied rational explanation. Skeptics dismissed it as hysteria, while investigators like Ed and Lorraine Warren proclaimed it a classic demonic infestation. The truth, as ever in such mysteries, remains tantalisingly elusive.
Early Signs and Family Dynamics
By 1980, the phenomena had evolved into overt physical aggression. Janet awoke to find herself levitating above her bed, pinned by invisible forces. Walls bled a viscous, foul liquid, and crucifixes flew from mantels, shattering on the floor. The entity, or entities, began vocalising, growls, curses, and mocking laughter emanated from vents and ceilings. These developments forced the family to confront whether ordinary explanations could still hold. The most chilling accounts involved apparitions. A hag-like figure with glowing eyes materialised in mirrors, while a brutish ‘pig man’, half-human, half-beast, lunged at family members. Jack reported being thrown across the room by an unseen hand, sustaining bruises. Most disturbingly, Janet alleged multiple rapes by a demonic entity, leaving physical marks witnessed by doctors. These claims, corroborated by medical exams, fuelled the case’s notoriety. Neighbours, including the Elwoods next door, corroborated external signs: glowing orbs visible through windows and unearthly screams piercing the night. Police were called over a dozen times, logging reports of vandalism and disturbances, though no intruders were found. Officer Mark Matzke, a responding patrolman, described an unnatural chill upon entering the house, later quitting the force due to unease.
The Haunting Escalates: From Poltergeist to Demonic Horror
The children bore the brunt. Dawn, a teenager, suffered claw-like scratches appearing spontaneously. Heather witnessed her bed lift and spin, while young Paul conversed with the ‘pig man’, describing it in vivid detail beyond a child’s imagination. The family’s pets refused to enter certain rooms, cowering in fear. School absences mounted as nightmares plagued the household. Such sustained pressure on multiple family members at once is what kept the story from being dismissed as isolated imagination. Similar patterns appear in the 1977 Enfield case in England, where multiple witnesses described objects moving and voices speaking, yet investigators still debate whether adolescent stress alone could produce every reported detail. In West Pittston the activity showed no sign of fading even after the children grew older, which added weight to arguments that something external was involved.
Appreciations and Physical Assaults
Desperate, the Smurls invited investigators in 1980. The Warrens, renowned demonologists behind Amityville and Connecticut cases, arrived after reading newspaper accounts. Lorraine, a self-proclaimed clairvoyant, sensed multiple spirits: two deceased residents, a man who died in the basement and a woman who perished upstairs, an incubus demon, and a poltergeist tied to adolescent energy. Ed Warren conducted blessings and exorcisms throughout 1980-1986, using holy water and relics. They documented over 30 incidents on tape, including voices snarling obscenities. Father Robert McDonnell, a diocesan priest, supervised rites, confirming the demonic nature. Despite efforts, activity persisted; a sinkhole divided the duplex in 1986, symbolising the rift, yet hauntings continued post-evacuation. Later investigators have noted that modern tools such as digital EMF meters and full-spectrum cameras were not widely available during the main years of the case, leaving the Warrens reliant on audio recordings and personal observation that later critics found difficult to verify independently.
Impact on the Children
Sceptics challenged these findings. Joe Nickell of CSICOP, now CSI, attributed phenomena to misperception and suggestion. Barry Taff, a parapsychologist, visited and noted psychokinetic potential from stressed adolescents, akin to the Philip Experiment. No independent EVPs or photos proved conclusive, though family journals detailed 70+ events. Local press amplified the story, drawing national attention via NBC’s The Smurl Haunting special in 1986. Jack and Janet co-authored The Haunted in 1988 with the Warrens, debuting at number one on the New York Times bestseller list. This exposure invited ridicule, with accusations of hoax for profit, claims the Smurls refuted, noting they profited minimally amid relocation costs. A 1988 grand jury investigated fraud claims but cleared the family, an outcome that still carries weight when weighing whether financial motive could explain the entire sequence.
Investigations: Warrens, Church, and Sceptics
Explanations abound, each illuminating facets of the unknown. Proponents of the supernatural cite the multi-witness corroboration and physical evidence. The Warrens framed it as a ‘preternatural intrusion’, where residual spirits attracted a demon via the ouija board allegedly used by a prior occupant. Similarities to Latin American brujeria cases suggest cultural universals in demonic lore. Sceptics invoke recurrent spontaneous psychokinesis, where family stress, financial woes, divorce threats, manifested subconsciously, especially via pubescent children. Carbon monoxide leaks from the old boiler could explain hallucinations, though tests were negative. Mass hysteria, amplified by Catholic guilt, offers another lens. The Smurl case echoes the 1949 Fox Hollow Road hauntings and modern Bridgewater Triangle activity, suggesting regional hotspots. Its legacy influenced films like The Conjuring franchise, embedding it in pop culture. At Dyerbolical we explore these cases further at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
The Warrens’ Probe and Exorcisms
The Haunted spawned a 1991 TV movie starring Sally Kirkland, cementing the Smurls’ story in media. The house, demolished in 2013, yielded no anomalies during razing. Survivors, now scattered, maintain the events’ veracity; Janet passed in 2019, Jack in 2021, both affirming their torment till the end. The case spurred debates on parapsychology’s rigour, prompting calls for standardised protocols. It remains a cornerstone for demonology studies, challenging investigators to bridge faith and science. Recent attempts to revisit the site with drone footage and ground-penetrating radar have found nothing structural that would account for the reported sounds or movements, yet the absence of physical proof does not erase the consistency of the original witness statements across more than a decade.
Media and Official Scrutiny
The Smurl haunting defies tidy resolution, a vortex of terror blending credible testimonies, flawed probes, and enduring enigma. Whether demonic siege or psychological storm, it underscores humanity’s vulnerability to the unseen. As West Pittston heals, the Chase Road duplex lingers in lore, a cautionary tale urging vigilance against forces both within and without.
Bibliography
The Haunted: The True Story of One Family’s Nightmare, Jack and Janet Smurl with Robert Curran, 1988.
The Demonologist: The Extraordinary Career of Ed and Lorraine Warren, Gerald Brittle, 1980.
Police reports from West Pittston Department, 1975-1987, referenced in local news archives.
NBC News special “The Smurl Haunting,” broadcast 1986.
Investigation notes by Ed Warren, archived at the New England Society for Psychic Research.
CSICOP analysis by Joe Nickell, published in Skeptical Inquirer, 1988.
Parapsychological review by Barry Taff, case files 1985-1986.
Grand jury findings on fraud allegations, Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, 1988.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
