The Zodiac Killer case pulls people in because the murders and the messages feel intertwined in a way few other investigations do. A man who killed in Northern California between 1968 and 1969 also sent newspapers coded letters that promised to name him if anyone could read them. Those letters still sit in evidence files today. This article walks through the confirmed killings, the four main ciphers he mailed, the 2020 solution to the longest one, and the questions that remain for investigators and the victims families.
The first confirmed attack came on December 20, 1968, when David Faraday and Betty Lou Jensen were shot near Vallejo. Six months later Darlene Ferrin was killed and Michael Mageau wounded in another parking lot. In September 1969 the killer stabbed Cecelia Shepard and Bryan Hartnell at Lake Berryessa, then shot cab driver Paul Stine in San Francisco the following month. Those five deaths are the ones police treat as certain. The letters that followed claimed many more victims, but the confirmed count stays at five. Each new message carried symbols that mixed letters, numbers, and strange shapes, and the killer seemed to enjoy watching police and reporters struggle with them.
The Man Who Signed His Letters With a Crosshair
The Zodiac first used that name in letters mailed in August 1969. He sent three newspapers the same 408-symbol cipher and demanded they print it on the front page. When they did, a Vallejo schoolteacher couple named Donald and Bettye Harden solved it in a single weekend. Their solution showed the killer boasting that murder was fun and that he collected slaves for an afterlife. The Harden solution contained spelling mistakes and awkward phrasing, which suggested the writer had no formal training in codes. Still, it gave police their first real look inside the killers thinking, and it showed he wanted attention more than he wanted to stay hidden.
Those early letters arrived while the Bay Area was still shaking off the Summer of Love. The contrast between the peaceful image of Northern California and the sudden violence made the case stand out. Families of the victims had to watch the story grow into national headlines while they tried to grieve. The killer kept writing, and each new envelope carried the same circle-and-crosshairs symbol that became his signature.
Four Ciphers and the One That Took 51 Years
The 408-symbol cipher was only the first. In November 1969 the killer sent a 340-symbol message that used a different method. Instead of simple substitution, it mixed several symbols for the same letter and then rearranged the order of the lines. The FBI and Navy codebreakers tried and failed. Amateur attempts came and went. One 2017 claim that read maybe Labor Day fell apart under review. The message stayed silent until December 2020.
That month three men working together announced they had read it. David Oranchak, a web developer in Virginia, Jarl Van Eycke, a software engineer in Belgium, and Sam Blake, a mathematician in Australia, used an open-source program called AZdecrypt. They tested hundreds of thousands of possible arrangements until one produced readable English. The FBI reviewed their work and confirmed the solution on December 11, 2020. The message again talked about killing for pleasure and about slaves waiting in paradise. It contained the same kind of spelling errors seen in the 408 cipher. No name appeared.
Two shorter ciphers mailed in April 1970 have never been read in full. One of them, the Z13, is only thirteen symbols long and may contain a name. The other, the Z32, produced the word hero in one partial reading but otherwise stayed garbled. A 2021 claim that both revealed the name Lawrence Kaye was checked against DNA from the Stine crime scene and did not match. The remaining short ciphers keep the case open because they still might hold identifying information.
How the 2020 Solution Was Built and Why It Matters
Oranchak and his partners did not guess at random. They noticed that the 340-symbol grid could be read in diagonal strips if the rows were shifted in a repeating pattern. Once they rearranged the symbols that way, ordinary letter substitution produced the message. The process took months of testing on home computers. When the FBI accepted the solution, it marked the first time any of the longer Zodiac ciphers had been officially verified since 1969. That matters because it shows modern codebreaking tools can still reach back into old evidence and pull out information that once seemed lost.
Yet the solution did not end the investigation. The message contained no new names or addresses. It repeated the same themes of control and an afterlife that appeared in the first cipher. Some researchers point out that computer programs can sometimes produce multiple readable versions of the same grid, which raises the question of whether another key might exist. The FBI statement confirming the solve was brief and did not claim the case was closed. Those details keep skepticism alive even after the 2020 announcement.
DNA, Suspects, and the Limits of What We Know
Police have collected more than 2,500 names over the decades. One early suspect, Arthur Leigh Allen, was ruled out by DNA taken from the Stine cab. A later group called the Case Breakers pointed to a man named Gary Poste, but that claim also failed DNA comparison. A partial DNA profile recovered from the Stine stamp has been described in news reports as possibly belonging to someone named Glenn, though investigators have never released a full match. Each new suspect announcement brings renewed attention, yet none has produced an arrest. The ciphers remain important because they are the only physical items the killer himself created that might still contain his name.
At Dyerbolical we have followed how advances in genetic genealogy have solved other long-cold cases, and the Zodiac file is one of the few where that same approach has not yet produced a name. The gap between what the ciphers say and what the physical evidence can confirm is where the case still sits.
What the Ciphers Reveal About the Killer and the Victims
The messages show a writer who wanted to be feared and remembered. He demanded front-page coverage and complained when newspapers placed his letters inside the paper. He mixed boasts about body counts with complaints that people were afraid of death while he was not. Those statements tell us more about his need for attention than they do about any specific motive. The victims, meanwhile, left behind families who still answer questions from researchers and journalists more than fifty years later. Bryan Hartnell, who survived the Lake Berryessa attack, has spoken publicly about living with the scars and about wanting the case solved for the families who lost loved ones.
The ciphers also created a lasting subculture of amateur solvers. Online forums, books, and documentaries continue to appear. Some of that attention has produced useful tips that police still review. Much of it has simply repeated old theories. The difference matters because every hour spent on a dead-end theory is an hour not spent on fresh evidence or new DNA techniques.
Bibliography
David Oranchak, Jarl Van Eycke, and Sam Blake, solution announcement and methodology, December 2020, zodiackillerciphers.com.
FBI statement confirming the Z340 solution, December 11, 2020, fbi.gov.
Vallejo Police Department case summary and victim timeline, 1968-1969 records released to media.
Jarrett Kobek, How to Find Zodiac, 2021, published by We Heard You Like Books.
Robert Graysmith, Zodiac, 1986, St. Martins Press, with updated editions through 2020.
Tom Voigt, zodiackiller.com archive of original letters and police reports.
California Department of Justice, DNA profile updates on the Paul Stine evidence, public statements 2018-2023.
News coverage in the San Francisco Chronicle and Vallejo Times-Herald, August 1969 through December 2020.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
