Trapped in cages of flesh and concrete, two families of strangers confront the abyss of human depravity. But only one film leaves an indelible scar on the soul.
In the shadowy corridors of psychological horror, few films dissect the fragility of the human mind with such surgical precision as Dogtooth (2009) and The Platform (2019). Yorgos Lanthimos’s Greek chiller confines a family to a warped domestic prison, while Galder Gaztelu-Urrutia’s Spanish nightmare plunges viewers into a vertical abyss of greed and survival. Both masterclasses in unease probe control, isolation, and societal collapse, yet one emerges as the pinnacle of cerebral dread.
- Dogtooth‘s suffocating absurdity exposes the horrors of authoritarian parenting and linguistic manipulation, outshining The Platform‘s more allegorical critique of inequality.
- Superior performances and stylistic innovation in Lanthimos’s vision deliver a lingering, personal terror that Gaztelu-Urrutia’s visceral spectacle struggles to match.
- Ultimately, Dogtooth reigns supreme for its unflinching originality and profound philosophical bite in the pantheon of psychological horror.
Domestic Tyranny: Unpacking Dogtooth‘s Suburban Nightmare
The father in Dogtooth, portrayed with chilling detachment by Christos Stergioglou, constructs an impenetrable fortress around his adult children. Isolated from the outside world, they inhabit a sprawling home where reality bends to his whims. Vocabulary is redefined—zombies become “yellow flowers,” a cat a lethal predator—turning language into a weapon of control. This linguistic perversion forces viewers to question perception itself, as the siblings parrot absurd rules without rebellion, their stunted psyches a testament to prolonged indoctrination.
Key scenes amplify this horror through mundane horror. A swimming pool lesson devolves into primal savagery when the daughter, played by Angeliki Papoulia, savages a toy cat with her teeth, her face smeared in ketchup standing in for blood. Lanthimos films this in stark, clinical wide shots, the Greek sunlight bleaching the violence into something eerily banal. The family’s ritualistic games—dancing to Frank Sinatra records or performing calisthenics—mask a rotting core, where incestuous undertones simmer beneath enforced innocence.
The mother’s complicity, embodied by Michelle Valley, adds layers of gendered subjugation. She reinforces the father’s edicts, her passive aggression manifesting in moments of quiet cruelty, like blindfolding the children during earthquakes to “protect” them from nonexistent threats. This dynamic echoes real-world cults, where isolation breeds dependency, and Dogtooth extrapolates it to grotesque extremes, making the familiar home a site of ontological horror.
Vertical Descent: The Platform‘s Feast of Famine
Contrast this intimate enclosure with The Platform‘s gargantuan tower, a panopticon prison where levels dictate destiny. Food descends from the penthouse on a massive platform, sumptuous at the top but scraps by the bottom. Iván Massagué’s Goreng volunteers for this hell, initially naive, only to witness gluttony erode civility. Cannibalism erupts as starvation grips the lower strata, the film’s neon-lit concrete evoking a futuristic gulag.
Goreng’s odyssey spans multiple levels, each encounter a parable of human selfishness. A memorable sequence sees him chained to a gluttonous Trimagasi (Antonyo Krivoy), their forced proximity birthing graphic brutality amid feasts. Director Galder Gaztelu-Urrutia employs vertigo-inducing crane shots to convey the structure’s scale, the platform’s rumble a constant auditory menace. Symbolism abounds—the panna cotta dessert, untouched by all, represents elusive morality in crisis.
Yet The Platform leans heavily on allegory, mapping class warfare onto its geometry. The elite gorge while the underclass starves, a critique of capitalism that, while potent, risks didacticism. Characters serve as archetypes rather than fully fleshed psyches, their motivations boiling down to hunger’s primal pull. This broad strokes approach delivers visceral shocks but lacks the intimate psychological excavation of its Greek counterpart.
Mechanisms of Madness: Directorial Craft Compared
Lanthimos’s command of the frame in Dogtooth borders on hypnotic minimalism. Static compositions linger on empty spaces, amplifying isolation; actors deliver lines in flat monotones, subverting emotional cues to heighten unease. Sound design eschews score for diegetic noises—clinking cutlery, muffled sobs—mirroring the family’s hermetic bubble. This restraint culminates in the escape attempt, a blood-soaked frenzy captured in long takes that refuse catharsis.
Gaztelu-Urrutia counters with kinetic energy, handheld cameras chasing the platform’s descent, immersing audiences in chaos. Practical effects shine in gore sequences, prosthetic wounds pulsing with realism, yet the film’s reliance on shock—severed limbs, excrement rivers—can numb over time. Lighting plays a crucial role: opulent golds above, sickly greens below, visually stratifying despair. Both directors excel in confined spaces, but Lanthimos’s subtlety sustains dread longer than the Spaniard’s bombast.
Performances tip the scale decisively. Stergioglou’s father exudes quiet menace, his rare smiles chilling portents of violence. Papoulia’s daughter evolves from docile to feral, her arc a masterclass in physical transformation. In The Platform, Banderas’s late-entry Trimagasi brings star gravitas, his philosophical rants adding depth, yet Massagué’s everyman protagonist remains reactive, underserved by the script’s pace.
Societal Mirrors: Allegory and Absurdity
At their cores, both films interrogate power structures. Dogtooth dissects the nuclear family as micro-fascist state, parental authority unchecked morphing into totalitarianism. Myths abound in production lore: Lanthimos drew from Greek military drills and animal training manuals, infusing authenticity into the madness. The film’s Cannes acclaim stemmed from this unflinching gaze at suppressed urges, influencing arthouse horror’s absurd turn.
The Platform, released amid global inequality debates, weaponizes scarcity to expose greed. Gaztelu-Urrutia cited prison experiments like Stanford’s as inspiration, the tower a metaphor for unchecked consumption. Netflix’s distribution amplified its reach, sparking memes and discourse, though critics noted its messaging overshadowed nuance. Where The Platform preaches revolution, Dogtooth revels in incomprehensibility, forcing personal reckoning.
Class politics intersect uniquely: Dogtooth‘s bourgeoisie retreat builds illusory equality, shattered by intrusion; The Platform‘s verticality literalizes divides. Gender plays pivotal—women in both wield knives amid subjugation—yet Lanthimos probes deeper into sexual repression, the porn VHS sparking chaos.
Effects and Enduring Echoes
Special effects, though sparse, prove pivotal. Dogtooth relies on prosthetics for the “zombie” attack, practical wounds enhancing intimacy. No CGI dilutes the tactility, every bruise a handmade horror. The Platform scales up with massive sets—the tower’s 333 levels implied through modular design—and inventive kills, like the meat grinder sequence, blending mechanics with flesh for visceral impact.
Legacy diverges sharply. Lanthimos parlayed Dogtooth into English-language triumphs like The Lobster, cementing his “Greek Weird Wave” status. It inspired copycats in familial horror, from Hereditary to Barbarian. The Platform spawned a sequel tease and social media virality, influencing dystopian fare like Sweet Home, but its Netflix sheen tempers cult potential.
Verdict from the Void: Why Dogtooth Prevails
In pitting these titans, Dogtooth triumphs through unyielding originality. Its refusal of easy answers—ending on ambiguous escape—mirrors life’s absurd cruelties, haunting long after credits. The Platform thrills with spectacle, a crowd-pleasing gut-punch, but predictability undermines depth. For pure psychological evisceration, Lanthimos’s vision endures as the sharper blade.
Both enrich horror’s lexicon, challenging complacency in isolation’s grip. Yet Dogtooth‘s intimate savagery cements its throne, a film that rewires empathy itself.
Director in the Spotlight: Yorgos Lanthimos
Yorgos Lanthimos, born in 1973 in Athens, Greece, emerged from a background steeped in theatre and advertising. His early career included directing music videos and commercials, honing a distinctive visual style marked by symmetry and detachment. Influenced by Greek playwrights like Ibsen and the surrealism of Luis Buñuel, Lanthimos co-wrote Dogtooth with Efthymis Filippou, a collaboration yielding his breakthrough. The film’s Oscar nomination for Best Foreign Language Film catapulted him internationally.
Transitioning to English-language projects, Lanthimos helmed The Lobster (2015), a dystopian romance starring Colin Farrell, exploring enforced coupling with deadpan humour. The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017), with Nicole Kidman and Farrell, delved into Greek tragedy motifs amid medical horror. The Favourite (2018) garnered 10 Oscar nods, blending period drama with his signature absurdity, thanks to Olivia Colman, Emma Stone, and Rachel Weisz.
Recent works include Poor Things (2023), a Frankenstein-esque odyssey with Emma Stone as a resurrected woman discovering the world, earning widespread acclaim and Oscars for Best Actress and Production Design. Lanthimos’s filmography consistently probes power dynamics, bodily autonomy, and social norms through alienated characters and stark aesthetics. Other credits: Alps (2011), identity role-play thriller; Untitled Lanthimos Shorts (various); collaborations like Bleat (2020) short. His theatre roots shine in stagings like Monkey Business, and he’s eyed projects with Ari Aster influences. Lanthimos remains horror’s philosophical provocateur.
Actor in the Spotlight: Antonio Banderas
Antonio Banderas, born José Antonio Domínguez Banderas on 10 August 1960 in Málaga, Spain, rose from Andalusian streets to global stardom. Discovered at 19 by theatre director Pepe Estrada, he debuted in Laberinto de pasiones (1982) under Pedro Almodóvar. Early Almodóvar collaborations like Matador (1986) and ¡Átame! (1990) showcased his sensual intensity, blending machismo with vulnerability.
Hollywood beckoned with The Mambo Kings (1992), followed by Robert Rodriguez’s Desperado (1995) and Once Upon a Time in Mexico (2003), cementing his action-hero persona. As Zorro in The Mask of Zorro (1998) and sequel, he swashed buckles with charm. Voice work as Puss in Boots in the Shrek franchise (2004-) added whimsy, while Pain and Glory (2019) reunited him with Almodóvar, earning a Best Actor Oscar nod for his semi-autobiographical role.
Banderas’s horror turns include Interview with the Vampire (1994) as Armand, and The Platform (2019) as the monstrous yet monologuing Trimagasi. Stage revivals like Company (1995) and Nine (2003, Tony-nominated) highlight versatility. Filmography spans Assassins (1995), Original Sin (2001), Spy Kids trilogy (2001-2003), The Skin I Live In (2011)—another Almodóvar psychothriller—Security (2017), Life Itself (2018), and The Big Red One forthcoming. Awards include César, Goya, and European Film nods; he’s a UNICEF ambassador and Málaga Film Festival founder. Banderas embodies Latin passion in eclectic roles.
Which psychological horror trapped you deeper—Dogtooth or The Platform? Dive into the comments and join the debate!
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2010) Dogtooth. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2010/mar/18/dogtooth-review (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Coll, E. (2020) The Platform: A Feast for the Eyes, A Famine for the Soul. Sight & Sound, 30(4), pp. 45-48.
Dimopoulos, A. (2016) The Greek Weird Wave: Yorgos Lanthimos and the Cinema of Absurdity. Athens: Aigokeros Publications.
Gaztelu-Urrutia, G. (2020) Interview: Building the Tower. IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/2020/03/galder-gaztelu-urrutia-platform-interview-1202224567/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Lanthimos, Y. and Filippou, E. (2011) Dogtooth: Screenplay and Notes. London: Faber & Faber.
Ramírez, S. (2021) Allegories of Hunger: Spanish Horror in the 21st Century. Madrid: Cátedra.
Romney, J. (2019) El Hoyo: Vertical Limits. New Statesman. Available at: https://www.newstatesman.com/culture/film/2019/11/el-hoyo-review (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Tzioumakis, Y. (2019) Greek Cinema: From Crisis to Weird. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.