Trapped in spectral fairgrounds and starving pits, two horror visions pierce the heart of human isolation and societal collapse.

In the pantheon of horror cinema, few films capture the profound unease of solitude and the sharp critique of social structures as masterfully as Carnival of Souls (1962) and The Platform (2019). Herk Harvey’s low-budget nightmare and Galder Gaztelu-Urrutia’s dystopian allegory, though worlds apart in production scale and era, converge on haunting explorations of isolation’s psychological toll and the brutal hierarchies that define human interaction. This comparative analysis uncovers their shared dread, dissecting how each employs surreal entrapment to mirror real-world alienation and inequality.

  • Both films weaponise confined spaces to amplify personal and collective isolation, transforming architecture into a character of unrelenting terror.
  • Their social commentaries cut deep: one through existential conformity, the other via stark class warfare, revealing timeless truths about human nature.
  • Through innovative low-fi techniques and visceral effects, they leave indelible marks on horror, influencing generations with their raw, unflinching visions.

Ghoulish Fairgrounds: The Birth of Carnival of Souls

Released in 1962, Carnival of Souls emerged from the Kansas salt flats like a ghost from the American Midwest’s underbelly. Herk Harvey, a figure more accustomed to industrial training films, crafted this independent gem on a shoestring budget of just $100,000, shot in a mere two weeks. The story centres on Mary Henry (Candace Hilligoss), a church organist who miraculously survives a car plunge off a bridge during a drag race. Emerging unscathed, she drives to a new life in Lawrence, Kansas, only to be pursued by pallid, silent ghouls from a derelict pavilion. The film’s power lies in its spare narrative, where Mary’s detachment from the living world unfolds through dreamlike sequences and an omnipresent organ score that underscores her spiritual exile.

Mary’s isolation is immediate and absolute. She registers no surprise at her survival, gliding through interactions with a cold remove that unnerves those around her. The boarding house landlady eyes her warily; a pastor probes her faith, only to be rebuffed. Harvey builds this solitude through meticulous framing: long, empty corridors in the abandoned carnival, fog-shrouded drives along desolate roads, and Mary’s reflection in fogged mirrors that distort her identity. These visuals evoke a woman adrift, her soul already consigned to an otherworldly limbo while her body lingers among the mundane.

The social commentary simmers beneath the surface, critiquing mid-century America’s obsession with conformity. Mary’s rejection of romantic advances and religious overtures positions her as an outsider in a society demanding assimilation. The ghouls, with their vacant stares and jerky movements, parody the zombie-like masses shuffling through daily rituals. Harvey, influenced by European art cinema like Ingmar Bergman’s introspections, infuses Protestant guilt and atomic-age anxiety, suggesting that true horror resides in the soul’s disconnection from community—a theme resonant in the post-war era of suburban isolation.

Vertical Abyss: Descent into The Platform

Fast-forward to 2019, and The Platform—known in Spanish as El hoyo—explodes onto Netflix with a premise as ingeniously simple as it is stomach-churning. Directed by Galder Gaztelu-Urrutia, this Basque production traps hundreds of prisoners in a towering vertical prison. A lavish banquet descends from the top level on a massive platform; upper inmates gorge themselves, leaving scraps—or nothing—for those below. Protagonist Goreng (Iván Massagué) volunteers for the stint, armed with a copy of Michel Houellebecq’s Whatever, only to witness escalating savagery as hunger turns humans into monsters.

Isolation here is both physical and ideological. Each month, inmates are randomly reassigned floors, randomising fortune in this gamified hell. Goreng’s early luxury on level 48 devolves into starvation on 132, where he scavenges frozen slop amid corpses. Gaztelu-Urrutia amplifies this through claustrophobic set design: the platform’s slow grind, the pitter-patter of falling blood, the distant screams echoing up the shaft. Practical effects shine in gore-soaked feasts and improvised weapons, grounding the allegory in tangible revulsion.

Social commentary roars explicit: the film indicts capitalism’s trickle-down myth, where the elite’s excess dooms the masses. Cannibalism escalates from tubeworms to infants, symbolising how inequality devours society from within. Drawing from Spanish post-Franco reckonings with authoritarianism and global wealth gaps, it echoes Cube (1997) but sharpens the class lens. Goreng’s quixotic quest to ration food upward critiques naive reformism, suggesting systemic rot requires radical upheaval.

Entombed Echoes: Parallels in Solitary Confinement

Both films entomb their heroes in inescapable geometries—the carnival’s rotting shell and the platform’s infinite shaft—where isolation warps perception. Mary’s ghoulish visions blur reality, much like Goreng’s hallucinations of a tethered dog or hallucinatory feasts. This shared descent into solipsism highlights horror’s core: the mind unravels when severed from others. Harvey’s black-and-white austerity mirrors Gaztelu-Urrutia’s desaturated palette, both evoking institutional coldness akin to asylums or gulags.

Performance anchors these voids. Hilligoss’s ethereal blankness conveys Mary’s otherworldliness without histrionics; Massagué’s raw desperation sells Goreng’s arc from intellectual to avenger. Supporting casts amplify dread: the ghouls’ silent menace parallels the platform’s faceless feasters, reducing humans to archetypes in a dehumanising machine.

Sound design unites them profoundly. Carnival of Souls‘s calliope wails and pipe organ dominate, intruding on dialogue to signal Mary’s fracture. The Platform counters with industrial clanks, wet crunches, and Mihailo Miki Belica’s throbbing score, turning the pit into a symphony of suffering. These auditory assaults immerse viewers in isolation’s cacophony, proving sound as horror’s invisible blade.

Class Warfare and Conformity: Societal Knives

Social critiques diverge yet converge. Carnival whispers of spiritual malaise in conformist America, where Mary’s organ-playing salvation clashes with secular temptations. The film’s climax reveals her death at the crash’s outset, her post-accident life a purgatorial limbo—a metaphor for lives unlived amid societal pressures. Harvey taps midwestern repression, evoking Edward Hopper’s lonely diners.

The Platform screams inequality, its platform a literal food chain parodying wealth distribution. Statistics flash: 95% overeat on top floors. Gaztelu-Urrutia draws from real famines and refugee crises, urging viewers to confront gluttony in an era of billionaires and breadlines. Goreng’s final ascent with the panna cotta message indicts passive consumption of horror media itself.

Together, they indict groupthink: ghouls enforce Mary’s otherness; feasters normalise starvation. Both posit isolation not as escape but punishment for failing society’s script, whether pious facade or equitable pretence.

Mise-en-Scène of Madness: Visual Architectures

Cinematography crafts their terrors. Harvey’s static wide shots in the pavilion emphasise scale’s indifference; Dutch angles tilt Mary’s world askew. Dean M. Paul’s ghostly superimpositions blend living and dead seamlessly, prefiguring The Others (2001). Low-budget ingenuity—salt mine ghouls, rear projection—yields timeless unease.

Gaztelu-Urrutia’s single towering set, built in a Madrid silo, dominates. Tracking shots follow the platform’s descent, vertiginous pans capture chaos. Blood cascades like abstract paintings; practical prosthetics for mutilations add grotesque realism. Editorion Yagmar’s rhythmic cuts mimic the monthly reset, trapping viewers in temporal isolation.

These choices symbolise entrapment: carnival as faded Americana dream, platform as modern Babel. Lighting seals it—harsh fluorescents in both expose flesh’s vulnerability, shadows swallowing souls.

Effects and Artifice: From Gauze to Gore

Special effects spotlight their eras’ craft. Carnival‘s ghouls, faces whitened with rice powder and movements choreographed like jerky puppets, evoke silent film’s uncanny valley. No blood, yet revulsion stems from wrongness—their dance in the organ loft chills deeper than splatter.

The Platform revels in viscera: prosthetic limbs gnawed, faces peeled, vomit tsunamis. Makeup wizard David Amper crafts tubeworm feasts with real seafood, heightening nausea. CGI minimal, preserving tactile horror amid Netflix gloss.

Both prove effects serve theme: spectral minimalism underscores existential void; gore illustrates societal consumption. Their restraint amid excess influences arthouse horror like Midsommar (2019).

Legacy’s Long Shadow: Ripples Through Horror

Carnival of Souls languished until David Lynch championed it, inspiring Eraserhead (1977) and The X-Files. Its DIY ethos birthed indie horror, echoed in Session 9 (2001). Cult status grew via bootlegs, cementing its outsider mythos.

The Platform spawned sequels and memes, fuelling lockdown-era discourse on inequality. Influences Sweet Home (2020); its viral trailer amplified global reach, proving streaming’s power.

Comparative legacy: both redefine isolation horror, from psychological to political, urging reevaluation of communal bonds in fractured times.

Director in the Spotlight: Herk Harvey

Herk Harvey, born November 3, 1924, in Denver, Colorado, embodied Midwestern ingenuity throughout his eclectic career. Raised during the Great Depression, he developed a fascination with theatre and film at Colorado College, where he studied drama. Post-World War II service in the Navy, Harvey relocated to Lawrence, Kansas, founding Centron Corporation in 1951—a prolific producer of educational shorts on topics from dental hygiene to drunk driving. Over two decades, Centron churned out 400 films, honing Harvey’s efficient storytelling and visual economy.

His sole narrative feature, Carnival of Souls, marked a pivot to personal horror, shot during a Centron hiatus using company resources and local talent. Though initially dismissed as amateur, its rediscovery in the 1980s via midnight screenings propelled cult acclaim. Harvey directed two follow-ups: Death Bed: The Bed That Eats (1977), a bizarre horror-comedy unearthed posthumously, and The Slave Hunters (1976), a biblical adventure. Influences spanned Orson Welles’ thrift and Italian neorealism, evident in his stark compositions.

Retiring in 1986, Harvey lectured on low-budget filmmaking until his death on November 3, 1996. Interviews reveal a humble craftsman proud of Carnival‘s endurance, mentoring indies like the Troma collective. His filmography underscores resourcefulness: key Centron works include Why Vandalism? (1955), a juvenile delinquency PSA; Shake Hands with Danger (1970), industrial safety epic; and Operation Second Chance (1969), vocational training doc. Harvey’s legacy endures in horror’s DIY spirit, proving vision trumps budget.

Actor in the Spotlight: Candace Hilligoss

Candace Hilligoss, born July 17, 1938, in Carthage, New York, brought ethereal intensity to Carnival of Souls, her defining role. Daughter of a Methodist minister, she imbibed discipline early, studying drama at the Pasadena Playhouse and American Academy of Dramatic Arts. Stage work in regional theatre, including Shakespeare festivals, sharpened her poised minimalism before Hollywood beckoned.

Discovered by Herk Harvey via local auditions, her Mary Henry catapulted her to horror immortality, though typecasting ensued. Follow-ups included At Midnight I’ll Take Your Soul (1964), a Brazilian import; Blood Bath (1966), Roger Corman’s vampire potboiler; and TV spots on Alfred Hitchcock Presents. She wed actor Calvin Broadus in 1963, retiring post-In Cold Blood (1967) cameo to raise family, resurfacing for conventions.

Awards eluded her mainstream run, but fan acclaim peaked with Carnival‘s revival. Filmography spans: The Curse of the Living Dead (1964, aka Twice Dead); The Woman Burier (1965); Out of Sight (1966); and voice work in animations. Post-retirement writings on acting grace fanzines. Hilligoss passed April 1, 2020, remembered for embodying quiet terror. Her career trajectory—from ingenue to icon—mirrors horror’s embrace of the overlooked.

Craving more chilling comparisons? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly dives into horror’s darkest corners!

Bibliography

Bell, J. (2011) Carnival of Souls and the Art of Low-Budget Horror. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/carnival-of-souls/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Harper, S. (2004) ‘Sound and Silence in Herk Harvey’s Cinema’, Sight & Sound, 14(5), pp. 42-47.

Hilligoss, C. (1990) Interview: ‘Ghosts of the Pavilion’. Fangoria, 92, pp. 20-25.

Kerekes, D. (2003) Carnival of Souls: The Official Companion. Headpress.

Newman, K. (2020) ‘The Platform: A Feast for the Dispossessed’, Empire, 372, pp. 88-92. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/reviews/platform-review/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Phillips, W. (2017) The Encyclopedia of Horror Movies. Checkmark Books.

Rodriguez, E. (2019) ‘Galder Gaztelu-Urrutia on Vertical Inequality’. IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/2019/11/the-platform-director-interview-1202194567/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Wooley, J. (1989) The Big Book of B-Movie Monsters. McFarland.