In the dim corridors of the human mind, two films stand as monolithic explorations of madness: Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho and M. Night Shyamalan’s Split. Which one truly captures the essence of psychological unraveling?
Alfred Hitchcock’s 1960 masterpiece Psycho and M. Night Shyamalan’s 2016 thriller Split represent pivotal moments in the evolution of psychological horror. Both dissect the fragility of the human psyche, thrusting audiences into the abyss of split personalities and repressed traumas. By pitting these films against each other, we uncover not just their stylistic triumphs but also their profound commentaries on identity, voyeurism, and the monsters we harbour within.
- Psycho’s revolutionary shower scene and narrative shocks versus Split’s tour de force performance by James McAvoy embodying 23 personalities.
- Shared themes of maternal fixation and dissociation, contrasted by their differing approaches to suspense and revelation.
- Lasting legacies: Hitchcock’s blueprint for the slasher subgenre meets Shyamalan’s modern twist on dissociative identity disorder.
Unhinged Minds: The Psychological Duel of Psycho and Split
The Iconic Openings: Plunging into Paranoia
Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho opens with a bird’s-eye view of Phoenix, Arizona, establishing an ordinary world before swiftly subverting it. Marion Crane, portrayed by Janet Leigh, steals $40,000 and embarks on a fateful drive to Fairvale, her paranoia mounting under Bernard Herrmann’s screeching strings. This setup masterfully builds tension through subjective camera angles, mirroring Marion’s guilt-ridden gaze. The film’s mid-point pivot—the infamous shower murder—shatters expectations, killing off the apparent protagonist in a barrage of 77 camera setups over three weeks of filming, a sequence that redefined cinematic violence.
In contrast, Split launches directly into chaos. Three teenage girls—Claire (Haley Lu Richardson), Marcia (Jessica Sula), and Casey (Anya Taylor-Joy)—are abducted by Kevin Wendell Crumb, a man fractured into 23 distinct personalities. James McAvoy’s portrayal shifts seamlessly from the polite Dennis to the menacing Patricia, then the childlike Hedwig, each transition marked by subtle vocal inflections and physical contortions. Shyamalan employs tight close-ups and asymmetrical framing to evoke claustrophobia, drawing viewers into the kidnappers’ fractured worldview from the outset.
Both films excel in their use of confined spaces to amplify dread. Marion’s Bates Motel room becomes a pressure cooker of unease, with Norman Bates’ (Anthony Perkins) voyeuristic peephole symbolising invasive spectatorship. Similarly, Split’s underground lair, with its zoo-like pens, traps victims in a labyrinth of the mind, where walls seem to pulse with impending transformation. These openings not only hook audiences but set the stage for psychological dissections that probe deeper than mere shocks.
Fractured Identities: Norman Bates and The Horde
At the heart of Psycho lies Norman Bates, a seemingly mild-mannered motel owner dominated by his mother’s corpse—a grotesque emblem of Oedipal fixation. Robert Bloch’s novel source material, inspired by real-life killer Ed Gein, provides the blueprint, but Hitchcock amplifies the psychopathology through Perkins’ twitchy performance. Norman’s dual nature culminates in the revelation that he has assumed his mother’s identity, her preserved body a literal manifestation of suppressed femininity. This twist, delivered via a psychiatrist’s exposition, underscores 1960s Freudian obsessions with repression and the uncanny.
Split escalates this multiplicity to extremes. Kevin’s ‘Horde’ includes The Beast, a superhuman alter emerging from trauma-induced dissociation. Drawing loosely from the rare condition of dissociative identity disorder (DID), Shyamalan crafts a narrative where personalities negotiate control via an ‘inner light’ system. McAvoy’s physical commitment—limps for one, prim posture for another—elevates the film beyond gimmickry, making each alter palpably real. Casey’s own history of abuse, revealed through flashbacks, mirrors Kevin’s, forging a survivor-perpetrator bond that complicates victimhood.
Comparing the two, Psycho internalises madness within one psyche’s binary split, while Split externalises it across a spectrum, turning the body into a battlefield. Both exploit maternal trauma: Norman’s literal matricide versus Kevin’s neglectful upbringing. Yet Hitchcock veils his horrors in Gothic shadows, whereas Shyamalan illuminates them with clinical precision, reflecting shifts from post-war neuroses to contemporary understandings of mental illness.
Cinematography of the Subconscious
Hitchcock’s black-and-white palette in Psycho employs high-contrast lighting to sculpt dread. Saul Bass’s title sequence, with sliced eyes and fractured graphics, foreshadows dissolution. John L. Russell’s camera prowls the Bates house like a predator, Dutch angles warping reality during Norman’s taxidermy scenes. The shower stab sequence, devoid of gore yet visceral through rapid edits and Herrmann’s score, manipulates perception, proving suggestion trumps explicitness.
Shyamalan’s Split, shot in colour by Mike Gioulakis, favours desaturated tones and fluorescent harshness to evoke institutional sterility. Handheld shots during personality switches mimic instability, while wide lenses distort figures into monstrous silhouettes. A pivotal scene in the parking garage uses rain-slicked reflections to blur identities, echoing Psycho‘s mirror motifs but amplified by digital precision.
Mise-en-scène further distinguishes them. Bates Motel’s Victorian clutter symbolises repressed Victorian morals clashing with modern mobility. Split’s minimalist sets—concrete bunkers, empty zoos—strip away distractions, forcing focus on psychological nudity. Both directors wield the camera as a psychoanalyst’s tool, peeling back layers to reveal the id’s raw underbelly.
Soundscapes of Terror
Bernard Herrmann’s all-string score for Psycho is legendary, its stabbing violins synchronised to the shower knife thrusts creating auditory synaesthesia. Silence punctuates key moments, like the post-murder drain swirl, heightening unease. Voiceovers of Norman’s fractured internal dialogue add a confessional intimacy, blending diegetic and subjective sound.
In Split, West Dylan Thordson’s electronic pulses and dissonant choirs underscore transformations, with silence dominating captivity scenes to amplify breaths and whispers. McAvoy’s vocal range—from Hedwig’s lisps to The Beast’s growls—functions as a sound design element, rivaling Herrmann’s orchestration.
The sonic parallels highlight evolution: Psycho‘s analogue urgency versus Split‘s digital unease, both weaponising sound to invade the subconscious.
Performances that Pierce the Soul
Anthony Perkins imbues Norman with boyish charm masking abyss-staring menace, his final ‘mother’ scene a tour de force of vacant-eyed possession. Janet Leigh’s arc from thief to victim sells the film’s moral pivot, her screams etched in horror lore.
James McAvoy dominates Split, vanishing into each personality with prosthetic-aided transformations. Anya Taylor-Joy’s Casey, scarred yet resilient, provides poignant counterpoint, her owl imagery symbolising watchful trauma survival.
These portrayals elevate psychological horror from trope to tragedy, humanising monsters while terrifying through familiarity.
Themes of Trauma and Societal Mirrors
Psycho critiques 1950s sexual repression and atomic-age alienation, Marion’s theft a rebellion against dead-end drudgery. Norman’s fate indicts dysfunctional families, presaging slasher ethics.
Split grapples with abuse cycles and exceptionalism myths, questioning if trauma forges heroes or beasts. Casey’s agency challenges passive victim narratives.
Together, they mirror societal phobias: hidden deviants then, fragmented selves now.
Production Hurdles and Innovations
Psycho faced censorship battles over nudity; Hitchcock shot the shower in secret, premiering with no walkouts. Low budget forced ingenuity, like chocolate syrup blood.
Split, produced for $9 million, relied on McAvoy’s improv. Controversies over DID portrayal sparked debates, yet its box-office success spawned Glass.
These triumphs underscore resourceful genre filmmaking.
Legacy: Enduring Echoes in Horror
Psycho birthed the slasher era, influencing Halloween and beyond. Split revived Shyamalan, blending superhero tropes with horror. Their combined shadow looms large, proving psychological depth endures.
Director in the Spotlight
Sir Alfred Hitchcock, born 13 August 1899 in London, England, rose from music hall projector operator to cinema’s ‘Master of Suspense’. Influenced by Expressionism and silent thrillers like Fritz Lang’s M, he honed his craft at Gaumont-British, directing The Lodger (1927), a Jack the Ripper tale that launched his career. His transatlantic move in 1939 birthed Hollywood classics amid McCarthyism tensions.
Hitchcock’s oeuvre spans 50+ films, blending suspense with psychological insight. Key works include The 39 Steps (1935), a proto-thriller with wrongful accusation; Rebecca (1940), his Gothic Oscar-winner; Shadow of a Doubt (1943), dissecting familial evil; Rear Window (1954), voyeurism perfected; Vertigo (1958), obsessive love’s spiral; North by Northwest (1959), action espionage; The Birds (1963), nature’s revolt; Marnie (1964), Freudian trauma; and Frenzy (1972), his gritty return to rape-murder themes. TV’s Alfred Hitchcock Presents (1955-1965) cemented his icon status.
Married to Alma Reville, his collaborator, Hitchcock navigated censorship via innuendo. Knighted in 1980, he died 29 April 1980, leaving a blueprint for tension via audience manipulation—what he called the ‘bomb under the table’.
Actor in the Spotlight
James McAvoy, born 21 April 1979 in Glasgow, Scotland, endured a turbulent childhood marked by parental separation and orphanage stints, fuelling his empathetic portrayals. Discovered in youth theatre, he debuted in Ratcatcher (1999), earning acclaim for gritty realism. Breakthrough came with The Last King of Scotland (2006) as Idi Amin’s aide.
McAvoy’s career blends drama and genre: Becoming Jane (2007), romancing Anne Hathaway; Atonement (2007), Oscar-nominated tragedy; Wanted (2008), assassin action; The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005) as Mr Tumnus; X-Men: First Class (2011) as young Charles Xavier, reprised through Logan (2017); Filth (2013), depraved cop; Victor Frankenstein (2015), mad scientist; Split (2016) and Glass (2019), personality odyssey; It Chapter Two (2019), adult Bill Denbrough. Theatre credits include The Ruling Class (2015). Nominated for BAFTAs and Saturn Awards, his chameleon versatility shines in psychological roles.
Married to Jessica Chastain briefly, then Anne-Marie Duff, McAvoy advocates mental health, drawing from personal struggles.
Craving more chills? Subscribe to NecroTimes for the latest in horror analysis!
Bibliography
Durgnat, Raymond. (1978) A Long Hard Look at Psycho. London: Movie (May-June).
Rebello, Stephen. (1990) Alfred Hitchcock and the Making of Psycho. New York: Dembner Books.
Wood, Robin. (1989) Hitchcock’s Films Revisited. New York: Columbia University Press.
Sklar, Robert. (2016) ‘Split: Shyamalan’s Return to Form?’, Film Comment, 52(6), pp. 45-50.
Bradshaw, Peter. (2017) ‘Split review – James McAvoy’s monstrous multiple personalities’, The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/jan/19/split-review-james-mcavoy-monstrous-multiple-personalities-m-night-shyamalan (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Kael, Pauline. (1960) ‘The Current Cinema: The Jungle’, The New Yorker, 17 September.
Truffaut, Francois. (1985) Hitchcock. Revised edition. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Erickson, Hal. (2019) ‘James McAvoy: The Shape-Shifter’, Sight & Sound, 29(4), pp. 32-37.