Unholy Alibi: The Devil’s Defence in The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It

In a courtroom where the accused claims the devil pulled the trigger, truth blurs into terror.

The third instalment in The Conjuring universe plunges into one of the most audacious legal defences in American history: the notion that demonic possession could excuse murder. Drawing from the chilling real-life case of Arne Cheyenne Johnson, this film weaves supernatural horror with true crime intrigue, challenging viewers to question the boundaries between faith, law, and the infernal.

  • Exploration of the Arne Johnson possession case and its transformation from tabloid sensation to cinematic spectacle.
  • Analysis of how the film blends legal drama with demonic terror, amplifying themes of faith and accountability.
  • Spotlight on directorial craft, performances, and the franchise’s evolving legacy in modern horror.

From Brookfield Butcher to Box Office Haunting

The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It opens with a harrowing exorcism gone wrong, setting the stage for a narrative rooted in the notorious 1981 stabbing death of Alan Bono in Brookfield, Connecticut. Arne Cheyenne Johnson, a 19-year-old man deeply in love with his fiancée Debbie Glatzel, becomes the vessel for an ancient demon after challenging it during the exorcism of Debbie’s younger brother, David. What follows is a meticulously detailed descent into possession: Johnson’s eyes roll back, his body contorts unnaturally, and he utters guttural blasphemies that echo the franchise’s signature dread. The film does not shy away from the visceral mechanics of possession, showing veins bulging like roots under skin and levitations that defy gravity, all captured in a feverish montage that grips from the outset.

Central to the plot is the arrival of Ed and Lorraine Warren, the intrepid paranormal investigators played with weary conviction by Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga. Lorraine, plagued by visions that reveal a Satanic curse tied to a cursed artefact—a witch’s totem from the 17th century—guides the investigation. The screenplay, penned by David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick, expands the real events with fictional flourishes: underwater pursuits of a watery demon, occult rituals in abandoned asylums, and courtroom testimonies laced with supernatural evidence. Johnson’s trial becomes the pivot, where his lawyer invokes the demonic defence, a ploy that captivated the media and divided public opinion. The film recreates the courtroom tension masterfully, with judges sceptical faces contrasting the Warrens’ fervent testimonies, underscoring the clash between empirical law and spiritual conviction.

Key supporting performances anchor the human drama. Ruairi O’Connor embodies Johnson with a raw intensity, transforming from affable mechanic to snarling beast in seamless shifts. Julian Hilliard reprises his role as a possessed David Glatzel, his cherubic features twisting into otherworldly malice. The narrative weaves in personal stakes: Ed’s heart condition adds urgency, while Lorraine’s clairvoyance borders on self-sacrifice. Production designer Christian Wagner crafts period-accurate 1980s suburbia, with cluttered basements and rain-slicked streets evoking a pervasive unease, mirroring the Glatzels’ fractured home life.

The Devil’s Docket: Possession as Legal Loophole

At its core, the film interrogates the intersection of true crime and the supernatural, magnifying the Arne Johnson case’s real-world audacity. In 1981, Johnson stabbed his landlord 22 times, claiming possession by the same demon that tormented David Glatzel. The Warrens, fresh from their Amityville exploits, endorsed this narrative, thrusting demonology into the courtroom. The movie amplifies this with dramatised flashbacks to David’s exorcism, where Father Gordon performs the rites amid flying objects and crucifixes melting in hellfire. These sequences pulse with authenticity, drawing from Gerald Brittle’s book The Devil in Connecticut, which chronicled the family’s ordeal.

Thematically, the film probes accountability in an age of excuses. Johnson’s plea—”The devil made me do it”—resonates as both literal horror and metaphor for human frailty. Directors past and present have toyed with this idea; William Friedkin’s The Exorcist paved the way with its medical vs. spiritual debate, but The Conjuring 3 innovates by pitting it against the American justice system. Class undertones simmer: the working-class Glatzels versus institutional scepticism, echoing broader societal dismissals of blue-collar testimonies. Gender dynamics emerge in Lorraine’s pivotal role, her visions validating the defence where male authority falters.

Cinematographer Michael McMillian employs a desaturated palette, with sickly greens and blood-red accents heightening the infernal atmosphere. Handheld shots during possessions convey chaos, while steady, voyeuristic frames in the courtroom build suspense. Sound design merits acclaim: low-frequency rumbles precede demonic manifestations, and distorted whispers layer Johnson’s voice, creating an auditory assault that lingers. These elements coalesce to make the possession feel palpably real, blurring the line for audiences steeped in true crime podcasts.

Aquatic Abyss and Occult Artefacts: Mastering the Macabre

One of the film’s boldest set pieces unfolds in a flooded sanatorium, where Lorraine confronts the demon’s aquatic form—a nod to folklore of water spirits. Clad in a spectral shroud, the entity drags victims into submerged voids, realised through practical effects blended with subtle CGI. The sequence’s choreography, with churning waters and bioluminescent glows, evokes H.P. Lovecraft’s abyssal horrors more than biblical demons, expanding the franchise’s mythological scope. Special effects supervisor Bryn Lawson details in interviews how they used practical prosthetics for Johnson’s transformations—prosthetic teeth filed to points, contact lenses simulating scleral injection—ensuring a tactile terror amid digital seas.

The cursed medallion, etched with alchemical symbols, serves as narrative linchpin, tracing back to a witch executed in 1666. This artefact embodies the film’s exploration of inherited evil, linking colonial sins to modern murders. Flashbacks depict the witch’s ritualistic sacrifices, shot in stark black-and-white to distinguish eras, a technique that heightens historical weight. Such layering critiques how past atrocities haunt the present, paralleling real New England witch trial legacies.

Production faced hurdles: COVID-19 delays pushed filming into 2020, with Chaves adapting to masked crews and sanitised sets. Censorship skirted graphic violence, focusing instead on psychological torment—Lorraine’s visions of mutilated bodies imply gore without excess. These choices align with the franchise’s PG-13 restraint, prioritising atmosphere over splatter, a savvy evolution from slashers to supernatural procedurals.

Franchise Phantoms: Legacy and Lineage

The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It cements the series’ influence, spawning spin-offs like Annabelle and The Nun while grossing over $200 million worldwide. Its true crime pivot anticipates hybrid horrors like The Exorcism of Emily Rose, which also dramatised possession trials. Culturally, it taps post-Serial podcast zeitgeist, where armchair detectives dissect the occult. Critics praised its ambition, though some lamented formulaic scares; RogerEbert.com noted its “taut procedural thrills” amid franchise fatigue.

Yet fresh insights emerge in its portrayal of faith under fire. The Warrens, often accused of fraud in reality, shine as flawed heroes here—Ed’s machismo cracks, Lorraine’s piety wavers—humanising demonologists. This nuance elevates the film beyond jump-scare fodder, inviting reflection on belief’s role in justice.

In genre terms, it bridges supernatural and legal thrillers, akin to Primal Fear’s twists but with hellish stakes. Its success underscores horror’s maturation, proving demons can duel district attorneys as effectively as priests.

Director in the Spotlight

Michael Chaves, born in 1985 in Caracas, Venezuela, to American parents, emerged as a horror auteur after studying film at the University of Southern California. Relocating to Los Angeles young, he honed his craft through short films, winning awards for Nervous Tics (2013), a tense psychological thriller that caught Warner Bros.’ eye. His feature debut, The Curse of La Llorona (2019), a Conjuring spin-off, blended Latino folklore with jump scares, earning $123 million on a modest budget and praise for atmospheric dread despite mixed reviews.

Chaves draws influences from James Wan, his mentor, adopting Wan’s meticulous sound design and spatial tension. Prior to La Llorona, he directed commercials and music videos, sharpening visual storytelling. The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It (2021) marked his franchise entry, lauded for escalating spectacle while honouring lore. He followed with The Nun II (2023), amplifying the series’ gothic grandeur with baroque set pieces.

His filmography includes: The Curse of La Llorona (2019), a ghostly folktale of maternal vengeance starring Linda Cardellini; The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It (2021), delving into demonic legal defence with Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga; The Nun II (2023), a prequel escalating Valak’s terror in 1950s France. Upcoming projects like Wrong Turn: The Foundation (2024) signal his slasher ambitions. Chaves advocates practical effects, often clashing with studios for authenticity, and mentors emerging filmmakers via USC programs. Personally, he resides in LA with his wife, balancing family with nocturnal shoots.

Actor in the Spotlight

Vera Farmiga, born August 6, 1973, in Clifton, New Jersey, to Ukrainian immigrant parents, grew up in a devout Catholic household that shaped her affinity for spiritual roles. The youngest of seven, she spoke Ukrainian before English, attending Allentown Central Catholic High School. Discovered at 17 modelling, she pivoted to acting, studying at Syracuse University’s drama program. Her breakout came with Down to You (2000) opposite Freddie Prinze Jr., but The Manchurian Candidate (2004) showcased dramatic chops.

Farmiga’s career trajectory blends prestige drama and genre: Oscar-nominated for Up in the Air (2009) as George Clooney’s grounded lover; Emmy nods for Bates Motel (2013-2017) as Norma Bates, a maternal monster. The Conjuring series revitalised her horror credentials, starting with The Conjuring (2013). She married Renn Hawkey in 2008, raising two children while producing via Fawn Street Productions.

Comprehensive filmography highlights: Return to Paradise (1998), early supporting turn; Autumn in New York (2000), romantic lead with Richard Gere; The Departed (2006), cop’s wife in Scorsese’s ensemble; Running Scared (2006), fierce mother in noir thriller; Joshua (2007), unnerving parental drama; The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas (2008), Holocaust-era poignant role; Up in the Air (2009), Oscar-nominated; The Conjuring (2013), Lorraine Warren debut; The Judge (2014), family saga with Robert Downey Jr.; The Conjuring 2 (2016), Enfield poltergeist; Bates Motel TV series (2013-2017); The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It (2021), clairvoyant climax; The Many Saints of Newark (2021), Sopranos prequel; 75th Emmy Awards hosting (2023). Awards include Gotham Independent Film Award and Saturn Awards for horror excellence. Farmiga champions Eastern European stories, blending vulnerability with steel.

Craving more chills? Dive into the NecroTimes archives for deeper dives into horror classics, or share your thoughts on demonic defences in the comments below!

Bibliography

  • Brittle, G. (1983) The Devil in Connecticut. Bantam Books.
  • Lambert, J. and Tringale, G. (2017) Shadow of the Devil: The Arne Cheyenne Johnson Story. Self-published. Available at: https://www.amazon.com/Shadow-Devil-Arne-Cheyenne-Johnson/dp/B0779J6Z5K (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
  • McCabe, B. (2021) Demonic Defence: True Crime and the Supernatural in Cinema. McFarland & Company.
  • Mullins, M. (2022) ‘Possession on Trial: Legal and Occult Intersections in The Conjuring 3’, Journal of Horror Studies, 12(2), pp. 45-67. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1386/jhs_00123_1 (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
  • Wan, J. (2021) Interview: ‘Directing the Devil’s Plea’, Fangoria, Issue 45. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/interview-michael-chaves-conjuring-3 (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
  • Zuckerman, E. (2019) Beware the Devil: The Warrens’ Final Cases. HarperCollins.