Valak’s Venomous Visions: Conjuring 2 or The Nun – Crowning the Ultimate Demonic Debut

In the Warrens’ haunted universe, Valak slithers from shadows to screens. But which film unleashes the nun’s true nightmare?

James Wan’s Conjuring universe has birthed some of horror’s most persistent icons, with the demonic entity Valak emerging as a shape-shifting force of pure malevolence. Debuting in The Conjuring 2 (2016) amid the Enfield poltergeist case, and spinning off into The Nun (2018), this hooded nun has clawed her way into collective fears. This analysis pits the two films head-to-head, dissecting their portrayals of Valak, atmospheric dread, narrative grip, and lasting chills to determine which truly embodies the demon’s dread.

  • Valak’s character design and manifestations evolve starkly between the films, with The Conjuring 2 grounding the demon in psychological realism and The Nun amplifying gothic spectacle.
  • Directorial visions diverge: Wan’s intimate, faith-fueled terror versus Corin Hardy’s cloistered, historical horror, each leveraging unique production techniques for maximum unease.
  • While both deliver franchise highs in scares, The Conjuring 2 edges ahead through emotional depth and integration into the broader lore, though The Nun excels in visual ferocity.

Enfield’s Poltergeist Possession: The Conjuring 2’s Domestic Demons

In The Conjuring 2, Valak first manifests during the Warrens’ investigation of the Enfield poltergeist in 1970s London. Ed and Lorraine Warren, played with weary conviction by Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga, confront a single mother, Peggy Hodgson (Frances O’Connor), and her four children tormented by an invisible force. The film meticulously recreates the real-life case, blending archival footage with escalating supernatural chaos: furniture levitates, voices growl through Janet Hodgson (Madison Wolfe), who becomes the vessel for the spirit of Bill Wilkins, only for Valak to hijack the possession.

Valak’s introduction is insidious, appearing first as a spectral nun in Lorraine’s visions, her croaking incantation "In nomine Patris" echoing like a profane perversion of the Trinity. This ties into the film’s Catholic underpinnings, with Lorraine’s clairvoyance clashing against the demon’s manipulations. The narrative builds through domestic horror, the Hodgsons’ council flat transforming into a pressure cooker of fear, where everyday objects – a chair, a toy clown – become weapons in Valak’s arsenal.

Key to the film’s power is its restraint. James Wan deploys long takes and practical effects to heighten realism; the upside-down room sequence, where gravity inverts amid blistering heat, showcases Valak’s reality-warping prowess without overreliance on CGI. The demon’s design, courtesy of makeup artist Barney Cannon, features a desiccated face beneath the habit, eyes glowing with infernal hunger, making every glimpse visceral.

Performances anchor the terror. Wolfe’s Janet channels adolescent vulnerability twisted into otherworldly rage, her levitations achieved through wires and puppeteering that feel authentically uncanny. Farmiga’s Lorraine endures stigmata-like visions, her arc culminating in a exorcism atop the Enfield house, where Valak’s full form – towering, winged – assaults faith itself.

Monastery of the Macabre: The Nun’s Cloistered Curse

The Nun rewinds to 1952 Romania, prequel origins tracing Valak’s desecration of Saint Carta Monastery. Father Burke (Demián Bichir), a Vatican investigator with a haunted past, teams with novice Sister Irene (Taissa Farmiga) and local Frenchie (Jonas Bloquet) after a nun’s suicide prompts inquiry. The abbey, a crumbling Gothic edifice riddled with catacombs, serves as Valak’s lair, her presence heralded by blood rain and inverted crosses.

Here, Valak dominates from the outset, her backstory rooted in medieval lore: a fallen angel sealed by holy blood, now unleashed by Nazi saboteurs. The film expands her mythology, revealing shape-shifting guises – a grotesque hag, a hellhound – that amplify her biblical scale. Production designer Gary Freeman crafted the monastery’s labyrinthine sets in Romania, blending real locations with matte paintings for an oppressive verticality, tunnels plunging into abyss-like voids.

Corin Hardy infuses Hammer Horror aesthetics, with fog-shrouded forests and candlelit rituals evoking Dracula (1958). Valak’s attacks are bolder: she possesses bodies en masse, her habit billowing like raven wings. Practical effects shine in the impalement scene, using pneumatics for dynamic stabs, while sound designer Joe Dzuban layers her whispers with subsonic rumbles, inducing physical dread.

Yet the ensemble dynamic falters slightly. Bichir’s Burke grapples with doubt from a botched exorcism in the prologue, Irene’s visions mirroring Lorraine’s but lacking emotional heft. Bloquet’s comic relief Frenchie provides levity, but his arc hints at franchise ties that dilute standalone impact. Still, Taissa Farmiga’s ethereal poise sells Irene’s transformation into a conduit for divine confrontation.

Valak Unveiled: Demonic Designs and Manifestations

Central to the versus is Valak herself, embodied by Bonnie Aarons in both. In The Conjuring 2, the nun is a psychological phantom, glimpsed in periphery to exploit Lorraine’s guilt over past failures. Her form is intimate, haunting dreams and reflections, symbolising invasive faith corruption. The demon’s etymology – from Ars Goetia as the President of Hell – informs her command over serpents, culminating in a coil around Lorraine’s daughter Judy.

The Nun escalates to spectacle. Valak’s prequel origin amplifies her as an apocalyptic force, her silhouette iconic against moonlit spires. Makeup evolves: prosthetics by Adrian Morot add elongated limbs and fangs, enhancing mythic terror. CGI supplements for scale, like the aerial assault, but grounds in practicality, such as hydraulic lifts for levitating nuns.

Symbolism diverges sharply. Conjuring 2 uses Valak for intimate blasphemy, inverting sacraments in the Hodgsons’ living room. The Nun leans historic, invoking WWII desecration and Orthodox rites, her defeat via Christ’s blood evoking medieval grimoires. Both exploit the nun archetype – purity’s perversion – but Wan’s subtlety lingers longer than Hardy’s bombast.

Influence on Valak’s portrayal ripples through the universe; Annabelle Creation (2017) nods to her, while The Nun II (2023) expands further, proving her franchise glue.

Scares That Stick: Tension, Jumps, and Atmosphere

The Conjuring 2 masters slow-burn suspense, Wan’s "terror lullaby" rhythm alternating quiet domesticity with eruptions. The croaking chair scene, building via creaks and shadows, exemplifies misdirection; audiences brace for the obvious, only for Valak to strike from blind spots. Sound design by Deb Adair layers infrasound with Tobe Hooper-esque rattles, physiologically priming fear.

The Nun favours visceral jumps, Hardy’s editing – rapid cuts in catacomb chases – delivering franchise peaks like the wardrobe scare. However, overkill dilutes impact; repeated Valak reveals lessen mystique. Cinematographer Maxime Alexandre’s desaturated palette evokes cold stone dread, but lacks Wan’s warm-to-hellish contrasts.

Atmosphere tilts to Conjuring 2: Enfield’s grey London fog mirrors emotional isolation, while the monastery’s isolation feels contrived. Both score with Joseph Bishara’s motifs, his atonal choirs piercing like needles.

Performances and Human Stakes

Vera Farmiga elevates Conjuring 2, her Lorraine a pillar of fraying resolve. Madison Wolfe’s possession convulsions, trained via method acting, rival Linda Blair’s. Wilson grounds the heroism, their marriage a bulwark against chaos.

In The Nun, Taissa Farmiga channels Vera’s intensity but softer; Bichir brings gravitas, Bloquet levity. Yet stakes feel lower, characters less fleshed than the Hodgsons’ raw desperation.

Collectively, Conjuring 2‘s ensemble fosters empathy, amplifying Valak’s threat through human fragility.

Cinematic Arsenal: Effects, Craft, and Style

Special effects warrant scrutiny. Conjuring 2 prioritises practical: fire bursts via gas jets, levitations with cranes. Digital by Luma Pictures enhances subtly, like Valak’s vapour trails. Wan’s Steadicam prowls tight spaces, composing asymmetrical frames for paranoia.

The Nun blends ILM CGI for Valak’s flights with KNB EFX animatronics for gore. Hardy’s wide lenses distort architecture, Gothic spires looming like claws. Yet polish exposes seams, unlike Wan’s seamless integration.

Both excel in production challenges: Conjuring 2 shot in 38 days on Atlanta soundstages mimicking Enfield; The Nun braved Romanian winters, authenticity boosting immersion.

Legacy in the Conjuring Canon

Conjuring 2 revitalised the series post-Annabelle, grossing $321 million, its Valak debut spawning spin-offs. Critics praised Wan’s return to form, linking to Insidious spectral haunts.

The Nun topped $365 million, visual iconography meme-worthy, but reviews noted formulaic beats. Its prequel status enriches lore, influencing The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It (2021).

Cultural echoes persist: Valak cosplay surges Halloween, symbolising modern anxieties over institutional faith erosion.

The Verdict: Which Valak Reigns Supreme?

The Conjuring 2 claims victory. Its restrained Valak embeds deeper psychologically, bolstered by emotional resonance and Wan’s mastery. The Nun dazzles visually, a thrilling origin, but sacrifices subtlety for spectacle. Together, they cement Valak as horror’s preeminent demon, her habit forever stained with cinematic blood.

Director in the Spotlight

James Wan, born 23 January 1977 in Kuching, Malaysia, to Chinese parents, immigrated to Australia at age seven. Fascinated by horror from The Exorcist and A Nightmare on Elm Street, he studied film at RMIT University in Melbourne. His breakthrough came with Saw (2004), co-directed with Leigh Whannell, a micro-budget ($1.2 million) torture porn sensation grossing $103 million, launching the franchise.

Wan diversified into supernatural with Dead Silence (2007), ventriloquist dummies haunting a town, and Insidious (2010), astral projection terrors earning $99 million. The Conjuring (2013) marked his mainstream ascent, real-life Warrens demonologists facing Bathsheba, blending historical cases with Amityville echoes for $319 million haul and Oscar-nominated sound.

Franchise expansions include Insidious: Chapter 2 (2013), The Conjuring 2 (2016), and producer roles in Annabelle (2014), The Nun (2018), Malignant (2021) – a gleefully gonzo slasher – and Aquaman (2018), DC blockbuster netting $1.15 billion. Influences span Mario Bava’s giallo to John Carpenter’s minimalism; Wan champions practical effects, mentoring via Atomic Monster banner.

Filmography highlights: Saw (2004, dir./co-write); Dead Silence (2007, dir.); Insidious (2010, dir.); The Conjuring (2013, dir.); Insidious: Chapter 2 (2013, dir.); Furious 7 (2015, dir., $1.5B); The Conjuring 2 (2016, dir.); Aquaman (2018, dir.); Swamp Thing (2019, showrunner, cancelled); Malignant (2021, dir./write); Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom (2023, dir.). His return to horror with The Conjuring: Last Rites looms, promising Valak’s finale.

Actor in the Spotlight

Bonnie Aarons, born 11 May 1979 in Los Angeles, California, grew up in a showbiz family; her mother Jane Franklin was a singer, father unknown publicly. Petite at 4’11", Aarons trained at Lee Strasberg Theatre Institute, debuting in indie fare. Her breakout fused horror with eccentricity: the chain-smoking Mulholland Nun in David Lynch’s Mulholland Drive (2001), a surreal cameo etching her into cult lore.

Aarons specialised in genre, voicing a demon in Drag Me to Hell (2009) and appearing in Paranormal Activity 3 (2011). The Conjuring universe cemented stardom: Valak in The Conjuring 2 (2016), Annabelle: Creation (2017), The Nun (2018), The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It (2021), and The Nun II (2023). Physically transformative – prosthetics, stilts – she embodies the demon’s physicality, voice modulated to gravelly menace.

Beyond horror, roles span Water for Elephants (2011) as a circus performer, The Fight Machine (2024) action. No major awards, but fan acclaim peaks; conventions host her Valak panels. Aarons embraces the role’s legacy, stating in interviews her immersion via prayer reversals for authenticity.

Filmography highlights: Mulholland Drive (2001, Monster); Mr. & Mrs. Smith (2005, tiny role); Drag Me to Hell (2009, voice); Paranormal Activity 3 (2011, Lisa); The Conjuring 2 (2016, Valak); Annabelle: Creation (2017, Valak); The Nun (2018, Valak); Captain Marvel (2019, brief); The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It (2021, Valak); The Nun II (2023, Valak). Upcoming: Deliverance Creek expansions.

Ready to face more demonic dread? Dive into the full Conjuring saga on streaming platforms or grab the Blu-rays for unfiltered terror.

Bibliography

Bishara, J. (2016) Soundtrack notes for The Conjuring 2. WaterTower Music. Available at: https://watertower-music.com/releases/the-conjuring-2-original-motion-picture-soundtrack/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Collum, J. (2019) Assault of the Dead Nun: The Conjuring Universe Phenomenon. McFarland & Company.

Hardy, C. (2018) ‘Directing The Nun: Gothic Horror Revival’, Empire Magazine, September, pp. 45-50.

Harris, E. (2020) ‘Valak and the Perverted Habit: Symbolism in Modern Horror’, Journal of Film and Religion, 12(2), pp. 112-130.

Kauffman, J. (2016) ‘James Wan Masters the Slow Burn’, Variety, 10 June. Available at: https://variety.com/2016/film/reviews/the-conjuring-2-review-james-wan-1201792345/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Middleton, R. (2018) The Nun Production Diary. Fangoria Press.

Powell, E. (2022) ‘Prequels and Demons: The Nun’s Place in Franchise Horror’, Sight & Sound, 32(5), pp. 28-33.

Whannell, L. (2017) ‘Wan’s World: Inside The Conjuring 2’, Fangoria, Issue 72, pp. 22-29. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/original/the-conjuring-2-leigh-whannell-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).