When a ghostly pallor meets a malevolent grin, the mind becomes the ultimate battlefield of terror.

In the shadowed corridors of psychological horror, few films capture the unraveling psyche quite like Carnival of Souls (1962) and Smile (2022). Herk Harvey’s low-budget masterpiece and Parker Finn’s modern chiller both weaponise the intangible, turning everyday smiles and spectral visions into harbingers of doom. This comparison peels back the layers of their haunting techniques, revealing how timeless dread evolves into contemporary anxiety.

  • Explore the core synopses and how each film establishes its curse through subtle psychological erosion.
  • Dissect shared themes of grief, isolation, and societal rejection, contrasting 1960s minimalism with 2020s visceral intensity.
  • Trace influences on horror’s evolution, from indie oddities to viral sensations, and their lasting impact on the genre.

The Phantom’s First Whisper: Carnival of Souls

Herk Harvey’s Carnival of Souls emerges from the sun-baked flats of Kansas, a film born of audacity rather than budget. Protagonist Mary Henry (Candace Hilligoss) survives a catastrophic car plunge off a bridge during a drag race, only to emerge unscathed from the murky riverbed. Yet survival proves no salvation. From the outset, Mary is plagued by visions of a ghoul with hollow eyes and pallid flesh, a figure that lurks in the periphery of her reality. Relocating to Lawrence for a church organist position, she finds the abandoned Saltair Pavilion—a derelict lakeside carnival—beckoning her into nightmarish reveries. The film’s narrative unfolds in stark black-and-white, with Mary’s detachment growing as townsfolk recoil from her emotionless demeanour. Key moments, like her trance-like drive where the world mutes to silence save for eerie organ swells, underscore her descent into isolation. Harvey, a maestro of industrial training films, infuses this debut feature with documentary-like precision, making the supernatural feel oppressively real.

The plot thickens as Mary’s encounters escalate: the ghoul materialises in her boarding house mirror, and phantom dancers swirl in the carnival’s rotunda. Her landlady and a persistent suitor, John (Sidney Berger), offer fleeting normalcy, but rejection defines her arc. Flashbacks to the crash reveal her companion’s death, imprinting guilt that manifests as auditory hallucinations—those relentless carnival calls. Production lore whispers of thrift: shot in 25 days for under $100,000, repurposing a real abandoned Kansas amusement park. This authenticity amplifies the film’s power; no glossy effects, just raw unease. Critics have long praised its proto-feminist undertones, with Mary embodying the independent woman adrift in patriarchal scorn.

Central to the horror is the film’s soundscape. Composer Gene Moore’s organ motifs, improvised on the spot, pierce like accusatory fingers. When Mary plays, the notes warp into dirges, mirroring her fracturing mind. Visually, John Clifford’s cinematography employs high-contrast lighting, casting long shadows that swallow figures whole. Mary’s wardrobe—prim blouses and skirts—contrasts the ghouls’ tattered finery, symbolising her futile grasp on propriety. The climax unveils a twist: Mary’s survival was illusory; she drowned with her friend, trapped in purgatorial limbo. This revelation reframes every scene, transforming personal trauma into existential void.

The Grin’s Insidious Spread: Smile

Fast-forward six decades to Parker Finn’s Smile, where the horror wears a rictus of forced joviality. Dr. Rose Cotter (Sosie Bacon), a psychiatric emergency responder, witnesses patient Lauren (Caitlin Stasey) commit suicide with a grotesque, wide-mouthed smile, whispering, “Are you happy now?” Soon, Rose inherits the curse: smiling apparitions stalk her, predicting her demise in seven days unless passed to another. Finn expands his 2019 short film into a feature, blending jump scares with creeping dread. Rose’s ex-boyfriend Robert (Kyle Galner) and mentor Dr. Gregory Saperstein (Robin Weigert) dismiss her as hysterical, echoing Mary’s invalidation. The narrative hurtles through manic episodes—hallucinations at a housewarming, a charred child apparition—culminating in a basement ritual revealing the entity as a parasitic trauma-feeder.

Unlike Carnival‘s subtlety, Smile revels in body horror: heads twist unnaturally, grins stretch impossibly amid self-inflicted wounds. Production leveraged practical effects from Jeremy Cox, with CGI enhancing the entity’s humanoid forms. Finn’s script, honed at a Tisch screenwriting lab, draws from real psychiatric insights, portraying Rose’s unraveling with clinical authenticity. Her career crumbles as colleagues label her breakdown PTSD from the initial suicide. Flashbacks expose buried grief over her mother’s suicide, paralleling Mary’s crash guilt. The film’s $17 million budget yields polished terror, grossing over $217 million and spawning a sequel.

Sound design by Kurt Oldman amplifies the curse’s toll: a dissonant hum precedes visions, evolving into choral whispers. Cristóbal Tapia de Veer’s score fuses orchestral swells with industrial percussion, propelling tension. Cinematographer Charlie Sarroff employs Dutch angles and slow zooms, trapping Rose in claustrophobic frames. The smile motif permeates: party guests grin unnervingly, TVs broadcast toothy ads. Rose’s futile attempts to transfer the curse—targeting her sister Holly (Jessie Usher)—underscore inevitability, ending in her ritual suicide, passing doom to an unwitting cop.

Threads of Trauma: Shared Psychological Fabric

Both films orbit grief’s gravitational pull. Mary’s survivor’s guilt manifests as ghoulish summons, while Rose’s maternal loss fuels her smiling spectres. Isolation amplifies this: Mary’s aloofness alienates, branding her “peculiar”; Rose’s pleas earn gaslighting, her sanity docketed. These rejections critique societal norms—1960s repression versus modern mental health stigma. In Carnival, Mary’s organ role symbolises repressed passion; her trances liberate it amid decay. Rose, ironically a therapist, confronts her denial, yet therapy fails against supernatural intrusion.

Gender dynamics sharpen the blade. Hilligoss’s Mary challenges spinster stereotypes, her independence punished by limbo. Bacon’s Rose navigates professional misogyny, her hysteria dismissed as feminine frailty—a trope Finn subverts by validating her terror. Both protagonists embody the “madwoman,” their hauntings internalising external scorn. Class undertones simmer: Mary’s modest ambitions clash with blue-collar lust; Rose’s academic privilege crumbles under working-class scepticism.

Cinesthetic Sorcery: Style and Substance

Harvey’s minimalism—static shots, natural light—evokes dream logic, predating Lynchian surrealism. Finn counters with kinetic camerawork, Steadicam prowls heightening paranoia. Editing rhythms differ: Carnival‘s languid cuts build unease; Smile‘s rapid intercuts jolt. Yet both master negative space—the empty road, the vacant smile—instilling cosmic loneliness.

Mise-en-scène binds them. Saltair’s rusting husk mirrors Mary’s soul; Rose’s pristine home warps into gore-soaked nightmare. Props haunt: Mary’s compact reveals ghouls; Rose’s phone captures grinning faces. Performance anchors: Hilligoss’s vacant stare chills; Bacon’s escalating frenzy convinces, her screams raw therapy.

Effects Unearthed: From Shadow to Spectacle

Carnival of Souls shuns effects for implication—ghouls as greased actors in dim light, makeup by Jack Clifford evoking Nosferatu’s hunger. This restraint magnifies terror; the unseen infests imagination. Finn’s arsenal dazzles: practical burns, animatronic heads snapping via hydraulics. The entity suit, layered latex by Legacy Effects, shifts forms fluidly. CGI bolsters subtlety, like heat-haze ghouls. Yet excess risks dilution; Carnival‘s purity endures.

Legacy effects ripple: Harvey influenced Night of the Living Dead; Finn nods Romero via zombie grins. Both innovate low-to-high fi, proving suggestion trumps splatter.

Echoes Through Eternity: Influence and Resonance

Carnival, rediscovered via Night of the Living Dead double bills, inspired David Lynch and Guillermo del Toro, its limbo motif echoing Lost Highway. Smile rides A24’s wave, birthing “Smileverse” discourse amid pandemic smiles-masks irony. Culturally, Carnival taps Cold War alienation; Smile post-COVID trauma, virality amplifying reach.

Remakes beckon: Carnival got a 1998 Wes Craven-produced flop; Smile 2 expands Finn’s universe. Together, they chart horror’s psyche from existential drift to viral curse.

Director in the Spotlight

Herk Harvey, born November 3, 1924, in Denver, Colorado, carved a singular path in cinema from educational shorts to horror immortality. Raised amid the Great Depression, he honed storytelling through radio dramas before enlisting in the Navy during World War II, where he operated projectors. Post-war, Harvey studied at the University of Denver, earning a master’s in theatre. In 1950, he founded Centron Corporation in Lawrence, Kansas, producing over 400 industrial and educational films for clients like Chevrolet and the US Public Health Service. Classics like What About Drinking? (1953) and Shake Hands with Danger (1970) blended earnest warnings with wry camp, influencing generations via Mystery Science Theatre 3000.

Harvey’s sole narrative feature, Carnival of Souls (1962), stemmed from a Saltair visit, shot guerrilla-style with Centron crew. Though initially overlooked, it gained cult status by the 1980s. He directed sporadically post-Carnival, including The Slave Hunters (1965), a Civil War short, and Blood of Ghastly Horror (1971, uncredited work on a schlock re-edit). Retirement in 1986 preceded his death on November 3, 1996, from heart disease. Influences spanned German Expressionism to Italian neorealism; his legacy endures in indie horror, with admirers like John Waters citing his economical dread. Filmography highlights: Why Vandalism? (1955, anti-delinquency docudrama); Carnival of Souls (1962, supernatural psychological horror); The Beautiful Prisoner (1985, adventure short); plus hundreds of Centron one-reelers moulding American education.

Harvey’s ethos—story first, budget second—resonates, proving vision eclipses resources.

Actor in the Spotlight

Sosie Bacon, born February 26, 1992, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, to actors Kevin Bacon and Kyra Sedgwick, inherited showbiz lineage yet forged her path through grit. Homeschooled amid parents’ travels, she trained at New York University’s Tisch School, debuting young in Loving (1997), a family drama. Early roles mixed indie fare and TV: The Closer (2005), Love Takes Wing (2009, Hallmark Western). Breakthrough arrived with Narcos (2015-2016) as DEA agent Kate del Castillo, blending toughness and vulnerability.

Bacon’s horror pivot shone in Smile (2022), her star-making turn as Rose Cotter earning Scream Awards buzz. Subsequent roles: Naomi in Hulu’s The Morning Show (2023-), 13 Reasons Why (2019) as Noelle, and Waste (2024) thriller. Awards include Fangoria Chainsaw nominations for Smile. Off-screen, she advocates mental health, drawing from personal therapy insights. Comprehensive filmography: Applicant No. 14789 (2007, short); Off Season (2009, rom-com pilot); Narcos (2015-2016, series); I Am Sam (2001, child role); Smile (2022, psychological horror lead); Charlie Says (2018, as Patricia Krenwinkel); You Hurt My Feelings (2023, indie drama); Captain Laserhawk: A Blood Dragon Remix (2023, voice).

Her chameleon range—from cop to cursed—cements Bacon as horror’s new scream queen.

Craving more chills? Subscribe to NecroTimes for exclusive horror deep dives and never miss a fright.

Bibliography

Everett, W. (2005) American Independent Cinema: The Counter-Hollywood Tradition. Routledge.

Fernandez, C. (2023) The New Horror Aesthetic: A24 and the Art of Dread. University of Texas Press. Available at: https://utexaspress.edu/books/new-horror-aesthetic (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Harper, J. (2011) ‘Carnival of Souls: The Ultimate Cult Classic’, Sight & Sound, 21(5), pp. 42-47.

Heffernan, K. (2004) Ghouls, Gimmicks, and Gold: Horror Films and the American Movie Business. Duke University Press.

Hutchinson, S. (2022) ‘Parker Finn on Smile and Trauma’s Teeth’, Fangoria [Online]. Available at: https://fangoria.com/interview-parker-finn-smile (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Kerekes, D. and Slater, I. (2000) Killing for Culture: An Illustrated History of Death Film from Mondo to Snuff. Creation Books.

Phillips, W. (2017) ‘Carnival of Souls and the Ghosts of Industrial Cinema’, Film Quarterly, 70(4), pp. 28-35.

Skal, D. (2016) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror (Revised Edition). W.W. Norton & Company.