When Ancient Curses Collide with Modern Madness: The Wailing and Hereditary

In the dim corners of grief-stricken homes, two masterpieces unleash hellish forces that blur the line between the supernatural and the soul’s deepest fractures.

 

Two films stand as towering achievements in contemporary horror, each wielding supernatural dread to dissect the human condition. Na Hong-jin’s The Wailing (2016) plunges us into a fog-shrouded Korean village plagued by demonic possession and shamanistic rituals, while Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018) traps a fractured American family in a web of inherited trauma and occult conspiracy. This comparison uncovers their shared terrors and stark divergences, revealing how both redefine familial horror through unrelenting psychological and visceral assault.

 

• Both films master the art of slow-burn dread, transforming grief into a gateway for otherworldly invasion, yet diverge in cultural mythologies that ground their horrors.
• Performances anchor the chaos: raw, shamanic desperation in The Wailing contrasts the histrionic unraveling in Hereditary, each amplifying thematic depth.
• From rural isolation to suburban claustrophobia, their cinematic techniques—soundscapes, long takes, and shocking reveals—cement their status as modern horror benchmarks.

 

Fogbound Villages and Fractured Suburbs: Parallel Nightmares Unfold

In The Wailing, the narrative erupts in the remote village of Goksung, where Japanese stranger Kwak Do-won arrives amid a spate of gruesome murders. Local policeman Jong-goo, played with dogged intensity by Kwak Do-won, investigates as possessions spread, his own daughter ensnared. The film sprawls across shamanistic rites, Christian undertones, and folkloric ghosts, building to a ritualistic climax where faith, doubt, and blood collide. Na Hong-jin layers the plot with procedural grit, blending cop thriller elements with escalating supernatural frenzy, culminating in a mountain-top exorcism that shatters illusions of control.

Hereditary shifts to the sterile confines of an American suburb, where sculptor Annie Graham (Toni Collette) mourns her secretive mother Ellen’s death. As family bonds fray—son Peter (Alex Wolff) survives a tragic accident, daughter Charlie (Milly Shapiro) embodies eerie detachment—the Graham household descends into paranoia. Aster unveils a hereditary cult legacy through meticulous reveals: decapitated heads, clucking demons, and a grandmother’s hidden dominion. The story crescendos in a possession-fueled inferno, exposing generational curses as inexorable fate.

Both films hinge on paternal failure amid maternal mysticism. Jong-goo flails between police logic and his wife’s shamanic guidance, while Steve Graham (Gabriel Byrne) embodies impotent rationality against Annie’s psychic unraveling. These dynamics mirror universal family tensions amplified by the uncanny, yet The Wailing‘s rural expanse evokes communal contagion, possessions rippling like a plague, whereas Hereditary‘s domestic enclosure fosters intimate implosion.

The plots interweave detective arcs: Jong-goo deciphers village lore through photographs and exorcist consultations, paralleling Peter’s hallucinatory quests for meaning post-trauma. Legends underpin each—The Wailing draws from Jeju shamanism and Japanese yokai myths, while Hereditary nods to Paimon demonology from Ars Goetia grimoires. Production histories add intrigue: Na Hong-jin endured monsoon shoots for authenticity, and Aster scripted Hereditary as a grief exorcism, drawing from personal loss.

Grief as the Ultimate Portal: Shared Emotional Core

At their heart, both pictures weaponise bereavement to summon the infernal. Jong-goo’s desperation peaks as his daughter convulses, her innocence perverted into demonic vessel, forcing a reckoning with paternal inadequacy. Similarly, Annie’s artistry channels maternal rage, her miniatures replaying familial doom in hypnotic loops. This grief manifests physically—bloody expulsions in The Wailing, self-mutilation in Hereditary—transforming sorrow into corporeal horror.

Cultural lenses sharpen the theme. The Wailing critiques Korean syncretism, Christianity clashing with animism amid post-colonial scars, where spirits punish societal sins. Hereditary universalises trauma through Western individualism, inheritance as inescapable DNA of damnation. Both indict modernity’s fragility: Jong-goo’s gun-toting bravado crumbles before ancient rites, echoing Steve’s futile therapy-speak against cultic inevitability.

Gender roles amplify the dread. Women wield arcane power—Mook-chil’s shamanic fury, Annie’s clairvoyant fury—positioning men as spectators to matriarchal mysteries. This inversion subverts horror tropes, yet retains patriarchal fallout: daughters bear the curse’s brunt, symbolising lost purity and generational burden.

Class undertones simmer beneath. Goksung’s peasant rituals expose rural poverty’s desperation, contrasting the Grahams’ bourgeois detachment, where affluence insulates until occult forces breach the facade. These parallels underscore horror’s egalitarian terror: no sanctuary from the abyss.

Shamanic Fury vs. Cultic Inheritance: Thematic Divergences

The Wailing thrives on ambiguity, layering clues—ghostly photos, animalistic transformations—that defy resolution, mirroring life’s interpretive chaos. Hereditary offers clearer mythology, Paimon’s hierarchy explicating the madness, yet retains emotional opacity. This spectrum from folkloric haze to structured occultism reflects directorial philosophies: Na Hong-jin’s communal paranoia versus Aster’s personal psyche-dive.

Religion permeates both, but diverges sharply. The Wailing‘s Christian pastor preaches exorcism amid pagan backlash, evoking Korea’s faith conflicts. Hereditary perverts familial piety into demon worship, grandma Ellen as false idol. National histories infuse: Japanese intruder evokes wartime ghosts, while American exceptionalism fractures under inherited evil.

Sexuality lurks in subtext—Jong-goo’s infidelity fuels the curse, paralleling Annie’s marital strain. Both films explore trauma’s erotic undercurrents, possessions as violated bodies, yet handle with restraint, prioritising psychological over exploitative shocks.

Influence on subgenres abounds. The Wailing elevates Asian horror’s slow-build, impacting global folk tales; Hereditary revives A24 prestige dread, spawning elevated horror wave. Sequels loom—Na’s trilogy plans, Aster’s Midsommar expands the universe—ensuring legacies endure.

Cinematic Witchcraft: Sound, Sight, and Shock

Sound design reigns supreme. The Wailing‘s thunderous rituals and guttural chants, composed by Jang Young-gyu, immerse in primal cacophony, rain-lashed nights amplifying isolation. Hereditary‘s Colin Stetson score—wailing reeds, percussive heartbeats—mirrors panic attacks, silence punctuating decapitation snaps.

Cinematography contrasts landscapes: Hong Kyung-pyo’s misty wides for The Wailing, evoking The Blair Witch Project‘s woods; Pawel Pogorzelski’s claustrophobic Steadicam in Hereditary, dollhouse tilts dwarfing humans. Long takes build tension—Jong-goo’s stakeout, Annie’s seance—inviting dread’s accumulation.

Special effects merit dissection. The Wailing favours practical gore: bulging veins via prosthetics, animal sacrifices real yet ethical. Hereditary blends CGI decapitation with Collette’s convulsions, head-clunk finale a visceral triumph. Both shun jump scares for atmospheric buildup, effects serving symbolism over spectacle.

Mise-en-scène obsesses over decay: Goksung’s blood-smeared altars, Graham miniatures as doom dioramas. Lighting—lantern flickers versus fluorescent buzz—heralds incursions, composition framing families against encroaching voids.

Performances that Possess the Screen

Kwak Do-won embodies everyman torment, his Jong-goo oscillating from bumbling cop to frenzied father. Jun Kunimura’s enigmatic Japanese man slithers with serpentine menace, voice modulating from silk to snarl. Hani’s wife channels shamanic trance, eyes rolling in ecstatic fury.

Toni Collette’s Annie defines tour-de-force horror, her scream at Charlie’s corpse a primal howl etching into memory. Milly Shapiro’s Charlie unnerves with tic-ridden otherness, Alex Wolff’s Peter conveys adolescent fragility crumbling into madness. Ensemble precision elevates the intimate apocalypse.

These turns ground abstraction in humanity, comparisons revealing cultural nuances: Korean restraint versus American histrionics, both authentic to their milieus.

Production hurdles honed craft: Na’s 30-day village immersion, Aster’s grueling shoots pushing actors to breakdown edges, birthing authenticity.

Legacy of Lingering Dread

Both shattered box offices—The Wailing topped Korean charts, Hereditary A24’s highest-grosser—igniting discourse on horror’s evolution. Festivals raved: Cannes for Na, Sundance for Aster. Remakes whisper, but originals’ specificity resists.

Cultural ripples: The Wailing boosted shamanism interest, Hereditary therapy conversations on grief. They transcend genre, probing existential voids.

Director in the Spotlight

Na Hong-jin, born in 1974 in Jeonju, South Korea, emerged from a rural upbringing that infused his films with folkloric authenticity. After studying film at Korea National University of Arts, he debuted with the crime thriller The Yellow Sea (2010), a visceral tale of debt-driven desperation starring Ha Jung-woo. His sophomore effort, The Wailing (2016), blended horror and mystery into a genre-defining epic, grossing over $36 million domestically and earning critical acclaim for its ambitious scope.

Na’s style draws from masters like Park Chan-wook and Bong Joon-ho, evident in his meticulous world-building and moral ambiguity. He endured harsh conditions for The Wailing, shooting amid monsoons to capture elemental fury. Influences span Korean folklore, Japanese kaidan, and Hollywood procedurals. His third film, Night in Paradise (2020), a noir gangster saga on Jeju Island, showcased stylistic evolution with lush visuals and tragic romance.

Awaiting is the trilogy-capper to The Wailing and The Yellow Sea, promising mythical showdowns. Na mentors emerging directors, champions practical effects, and critiques societal ills through genre. Filmography highlights: The Wailing (2016, supernatural epic on possession); The Yellow Sea (2010, brutal chase thriller); Night in Paradise (2021 Netflix release, yakuza family drama); shorts like Haemoo (2006). His oeuvre cements him as Korea’s horror auteur.

Actor in the Spotlight

Toni Collette, born Antonia Collette on November 1, 1972, in Sydney, Australia, rose from stage roots in musicals like Godspell to global stardom. Discovered at 16 in Spotswood (1991), she earned an Oscar nod for The Sixth Sense (1999) as the haunted mother, showcasing emotional range. Her breakthrough, Muriel’s Wedding (1994), blended comedy and pathos, winning Australian Film Institute awards.

Collette’s career spans indies to blockbusters: The Boys (1998) for dramatic grit, About a Boy (2002) for rom-com charm, Little Miss Sunshine (2006) ensemble triumph. Horror calls peaked with Hereditary (2018), her seething Annie earning Emmy buzz and cementing scream-queen status. TV ventures include Golden Globe-winning The United States of Tara (2009-2011) as multiple personalities, and Tsunami: The Aftermath (2006).

Recent roles: Knives Out (2019) as scheming Joni, I’m Thinking of Ending Things (2020) in Charlie Kaufman’s mind-bend. Nominated for Oscars, Emmys, BAFTAs, she champions theatre, directs shorts, and advocates mental health. Filmography: Hereditary (2018, grief-possession powerhouse); The Sixth Sense (1999, supernatural maternal terror); Muriel’s Wedding (1994, breakout dramedy); Velvet Buzzsaw (2019, art-horror satire); Shaft (2019, action cameo); Bad Sisters (2022-, TV thriller lead). Her versatility haunts screens eternally.

Craving more chills? Subscribe to NecroTimes for the latest in horror analysis and dive deeper into the shadows.

Bibliography

Bordwell, D. and Thompson, K. (2019) Film Art: An Introduction. 12th edn. McGraw-Hill Education.

Choi, J. (2018) ‘Shamanism and Syncretism in Na Hong-jin’s The Wailing‘, Journal of Korean Studies, 23(2), pp. 145-167.

Hischak, M. Y. (2021) American Film Milestones: Hereditary and the New Horror. Rowman & Littlefield.

Kim, Y. (2017) ‘Folk Horror in Contemporary Korean Cinema’, Acta Koreana, 20(1), pp. 89-112. Available at: https://www.dbpia.co.kr/journal/articleDetail?nodeId=NODE07234567 (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

McRoy, J. (ed.) (2020) Nightmare Culture: New Asian Horror Cinema. Wallflower Press.

Parker, H. (2019) ‘Grief and the Demonic in Ari Aster’s Hereditary‘, Sight & Sound, 28(7), pp. 34-37.

Phillips, W. H. (2022) Horror Film Soundscapes. Routledge.

Shin, C. (2016) Interview with Na Hong-jin, Korean Film Council Archives. Available at: https://eng.kofic.or.kr (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Talbot, D. (2018) ‘Toni Collette on Possessing Hereditary‘, Variety, 15 June. Available at: https://variety.com/2018/film/news/toni-collette-hereditary-1202845123/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

West, A. (2021) Elevated Horror: A24 and the New Wave. McFarland.