Where crucifixes crack under curses and habits hide horrors, two gothic visions of religious dread collide across decades.

Two films separated by nearly six decades yet bound by the same shadowy shroud of gothic religious horror: Mario Bava’s Black Sunday (1960) and Corin Hardy’s The Nun (2018). Both summon the terror of corrupted faith, undead female fiends draped in monastic garb, and crumbling edifices where the divine frays into the demonic. This comparison unearths their shared roots in Italianate gloom and modern Conjuring spectacle, revealing how each captures the exquisite agony of belief besieged by the profane.

  • Black Sunday‘s black-and-white mastery establishes the gothic nun-witch archetype, blending operatic visuals with vampiric resurrection.
  • The Nun revitalises demonic possession within a Romanian abbey, amplifying jump scares and lore within a sprawling universe.
  • Juxtaposed, they illuminate evolutions in atmosphere, monstrosity, and faith’s fragility, from slow-burn dread to explosive frights.

Crimson Masks and Ancient Malice: Dissecting Black Sunday

Mario Bava’s Black Sunday, originally titled La maschera del demono, opens in 17th-century Moldavia with a spectacle of sadistic retribution. Princess Asa Vajda, a satanic sorceress accused of witchcraft alongside her lover Ivan (Arturo Dominici), faces impalement through iron masks studded with nails. As the executioner’s hammer falls, her curse echoes: vengeance upon her descendants and the Vajda lineage. Two centuries later, Professor Kruvajan (Andrea Checci) and his assistant Dr. Andrej Gorobov (John Richardson) stumble upon her desecrated tomb while investigating a plague of gruesome murders in the nearby castle. A bat carries Asa’s embalmed blood to the face of Princess Katia Vajda (both roles embodied by Barbara Steele), Asa’s spitting image and distant kin, igniting the witch’s spectral revival.

The narrative unfurls with deliberate, hypnotic pace, as Asa, her face a grotesque map of decayed beauty, manipulates thralls like the revived Ivan, now a shambling ghoul. Key murders punctuate the dread: Kruvajan’s blinding by acid, the professor’s throat torn by a possessed servant. Bava interweaves doppelgänger tension, with Katia battling her ancestor’s possession amid flickering candlelight and cobwebbed crypts. The climax erupts in the castle’s chapel, where crucifixes burn Asa and a purifying fire engulfs the undead horde. Steele’s dual performance anchors the film, her porcelain fragility masking volcanic malevolence.

Production lore enhances its mystique. Shot in just 18 days on sparse sets, Bava’s ingenuity as cinematographer turned limitations into virtues: fog machines conjured ethereal mists, diffused lighting sculpted Steele’s features into marble effigies. The score by Les Baxter weaves liturgical chants with dissonant strings, evoking ecclesiastical rites perverted. Black Sunday not only launched Bava’s directorial career but codified the Euro-horror aesthetic, influencing Hammer Films’ subsequent gothic cycles.

Habitual Hauntings: The Nun’s Abbey of Abominations

The Nun, a prequel-spinoff from James Wan’s Conjuring universe, transplants gothic motifs to 1952 Romania. Father Burke (Demián Bichir), a Vatican investigator plagued by a past exorcism failure, joins novice Sister Irene (Taissa Farmiga) and local Frenchie (Jonas Bloquet) to probe suicides at the fortified Cârța Monastery. What begins as routine inquiry unveils Valak, a towering demon manifesting as a profane nun, who drowned nuns in sanctified blood during World War II to breach hell’s gates. Flashbacks reveal the abbey’s wartime desecration, with Mother Superior (Charlotte Hope) invoking a blood seal to contain the entity.

The plot hurtles through escalating confrontations: animated corpses claw from graves, hallucinatory visions assail the protagonists, and Valak’s silhouette looms in vaulted halls. Irene, gifted with visions, confronts her own infernal mirror in the demon’s taunts. Frenchie’s impalement by a scythe-wielding corpse sets up sequels, while Burke’s doubt crumbles under demonic assault. The finale sees Irene reciting an incantation from a forbidden tome, banishing Valak with a massive crucifix conjured from light, though not before the demon claims a lingering foothold.

Hardy’s direction leans into visceral kinetics, shot on location in Romania’s Orthodox monasteries for authentic stone-and-shadow authenticity. Practical effects blend with CGI for Valak’s distortions—her habit billowing unnaturally, eyes like inverted crosses. The score by Charlie Clouser pulses with inverted choirs and subsonic rumbles, heightening the PG-13 assault of jump scares. Grossing over $365 million on a $22 million budget, it exemplifies franchise expansion, tethering standalone scares to Wan’s lore.

Edifices of the Eternal: Gothic Locales Entwined

Both films throne their terrors in ecclesiastical architecture, transforming sacred spaces into labyrinths of loss. Black Sunday‘s Moldavian castle sprawls like a living mausoleum, its vaulted ceilings and iron-barred windows trapping miasmic fog. Bava’s compositions frame doorways as proscenium arches, characters dwarfed by tapestries depicting Asa’s heresy trial. This verticality evokes spiritual vertigo, faith’s pillars buckling under pagan resurgence.

In The Nun, the abbey pulses with post-war decay: catacombs honeycombed with skeletal wards, bell towers tolling omens. Hardy’s wide-angle lenses distort cloisters into funhouse infinities, crucifixes inverted on blood-slick floors. Where Bava’s static shots meditate on decay, Hardy’s Steadicam prowls invasively, mirroring Valak’s omnipresence. Shared iconography abounds—desecrated chalices, swinging censers—yet Bava’s monochrome desaturates colour to ashen despair, while Hardy’s desaturated palette erupts in hellfire reds.

These settings embody gothic essence: the past invading the present via stone memory. Asa and Valak exploit monastic isolation, their influences seeping like crypt water. Such locales critique institutional faith, bastions meant to repel evil instead incubating it.

Profaned Piety: Religion’s Ruptured Core

Religious horror thrives on inversion, and both films feast on it. Black Sunday pits Orthodox rites against Asa’s satanism; her mask impalement parodies martyrdom, nails evoking Christ’s crown of thorns in reverse. Katia’s possession manifests stigmata-like burns, faith’s symbols weaponised. Bava draws from Black Mass folklore, blending Slavic vampirism with Catholic iconography for a pan-European heresy.

The Nun roots in Catholic demonology, Valak named from the Lesser Key of Solomon, a 72-demon arsenal. The abbey’s blood rite echoes real exorcismals, Irene’s visions paralleling saintly ecstasies turned nightmarish. Yet where Asa seeks dynastic revenge, Valak embodies cosmic rebellion, mocking sacraments with bilocation and pyrokinesis.

Juxtaposed, they probe faith’s dual blade: bulwark against chaos or gateway for it? Bava’s film philosophises slowly, Asa’s atheism devouring piety; Hardy’s accelerates to affirmation, Irene’s purity expelling the profane. Both indict clerical doubt—Kruvajan’s hubris, Burke’s trauma—rendering vulnerability.

Veiled Vixens: The Monstrous Feminine Unleashed

Central to each is a female harbinger of hell, cloaked in religious simulacra. Barbara Steele’s Asa/Katia mesmerises with split-screen superimpositions, her beauty rotting into skeletal horror via gelatinous prosthetics. Asa’s sensuality seduces intellectually, whispering genealogical doom; Katia’s innocence provides contrast, her possession convulsing in balletic agony.

Bonnie Aarons’ Valak towers at nine feet, habit concealing prosthetic limbs for unnatural gait. Her face—crooked teeth, leering eyes—distorts via practical makeup and VFX elongation. Unlike Asa’s calculated cunning, Valak assaults sensorily, voice a gravelly rasp defiling prayers. Both exploit gendered fears: Asa the Medusa-like witch, Valak the desecrated bride of Christ.

Culturally, they revive the witch-nun trope from folklore—think Bell Witch or Carmelite possessions—amplifying patriarchal anxieties. Steele’s campy grandeur versus Aarons’ brute physicality charts horror’s shift from psychological to corporeal.

Sensory Symphonies: Sound and Vision in Collision

Bava’s soundscape is a requiem: wind howls through casements, heartbeats thunder in silence, Baxter’s motifs swell operatically. Visually, his high-contrast lighting carves Steele’s visage like cameo glass, cobwebs veiling lenses for diffusion. Special effects remain artisanal—mattes for bats, slow dissolves for possessions—prioritising mood over gore.

Hardy’s arsenal modernises: Dolby Atmos funnels whispers from surrounds, impacts thunder subwoofers. Cinematographer Maxim Alexandre employs anamorphic flares on crosses, negative space swallowing figures. Valak’s effects hybridise—animatronics for close-ups, digital scaling for grandeur—delivering spectacle sans Bava’s restraint.

Yet harmony persists: both wield silence potently, breaths ragged before strikes. Bava influences Hardy’s silhouettes, Black Sunday‘s fog echoed in abbey mists.

Epochs Apart, Echoes Alike: Subgenre Metamorphosis

Black Sunday birthed the 1960s giallo-gothic wave, predating Hammer’s Dracula technicolour by restraint. Its low budget belied influence on Polanski’s Repulsion, Argento’s early works. Censorship gutted exports, yet cult status grew via bootlegs.

The Nun caps the demonic nun boom post-Conjuring 2, riding found-footage and franchise tides. It nods Bava via chiaroscuro, but prioritises accessibility—runtime trimmed for multiplexes, scares calibrated.

Evolution manifests in pacing: Bava’s 87 minutes simmer; Hardy’s 96 explode. Globalisation shifts locales—Moldavia to Romania—yet core persists: religion’s gothic fracture.

Enduring Curses: Legacies that Linger

Black Sunday endures as Euro-horror’s cornerstone, Steele its eternal icon. Remade loosely, it inspired Suspiria, modern gothics like The Witch. The Nun spawned sequels, embedding Valak in pop pantheon alongside Annabelle.

Their kinship affirms gothic religious horror’s vitality, bridging analogue artistry to digital deluge. In comparing them, we witness cinema’s undying fascination with faith’s forbidden flip-side.

Ultimately, Bava’s elegy and Hardy’s onslaught prove the subgenre’s elasticity: terror eternal, as long as altars stand.

Director in the Spotlight

Mario Bava, born 31 July 1922 in San Remo, Italy, emerged from a cinematic dynasty—his father Eugenio a sculptor-turned-projectionist. Initially a cinematographer, Bava honed mastery on Riccardo Freda’s peplum epics like Maciste all’inferno (1962), innovating optical effects with custom labs. Directing Black Sunday (1960) marked his solo debut after ghost-directing Freda’s I vampiri (1957). The film’s acclaim propelled his auteur status amid Italy’s genre boom.

Bava’s oeuvre spans gothic to giallo: Black Sabbath (1963), an anthology with Karloff, blending Poe adaptations; Blood and Black Lace (1964), pioneering slasher aesthetics with modish murders; Planet of the Vampires (1965), proto-space horror influencing Alien; Kill, Baby… Kill! (1966), spectral village nightmare. Later, Twitch of the Death Nerve (1971) body-count innovator; Bay of Blood (1971), giallo peak. He dabbled in sword-and-sandal (Hercules in the Haunted World, 1961) and sci-fi (Terror in the Crypt, 1964). Health woes and industry woes curtailed output; his final, Shock (1977), a psychological descent. Bava died 25 April 1980, leaving unfinished Killer Nun. Revered as ‘Maestro of the Macabre’, his influence permeates Argento, Romero, Carpenter—low-budget wizardry defining horror visuals.

Actor in the Spotlight

Barbara Steele, born 29 December 1937 in Birkenhead, England, embodied horror’s dark muse after drama studies at RADA. Spotted in Bachelors’ Weekend (1952), she rocketed via Black Sunday (1960), her dual role cementing ‘scream queen’ moniker. AIP distributed it stateside, launching her Italian exile where she starred in 40+ genre gems.

Key roles: The Pit and the Pendulum (1961), Poe’s tortured wife; The Horrible Dr. Hichcock (1962), necrophile’s bride; 81⁄2 (1963), Fellini’s Claudia; Danielle (1963, aka Revenge of the Merciless); The She Beast (1966), transylvanian witch. Spaghetti westerns followed (The Long Hair of the Dakotas, 1967), then horror resurgence: The Crimson Cult (1970) with Boris Karloff; The Devil Rides Out (1968). 1970s pivoted to They Came from Within (1975, Cronenberg), I Never Promised You a Rose Garden (1977). Later, Caged Heat (1974) exploitation; TV arcs in The Winds of War (1983). Awards scarce, but BAFTA nod for Fellini; 2010 Lifetime Achievement from Sitges Festival. Semi-retired, Steele’s velvet voice and piercing gaze immortalised feminine dread, influencing Neill, Bigelow.

Filmography highlights: Black Sunday (1960) – Asa/Katia; Pit and Pendulum (1961) – Elizabeth; <em;The Hours of Love (1963); Castle of Blood (1964); The Ghost (1963); Terror Creatures from the Grave (1965); Nightmare Castle (1965); The She Beast (1966); Cursor maledetto (1967, cursed dagger); An Angel for Satan (1966); The Maniacs (1964, comedy); Revenge of the Vampire (1965); post-70s: Dark Purpose (1964); Student of Prague (196X); voice in Carmilla (1980s adaptations). Her archive spans 50+ credits, a gothic pantheon pillar.

Thirsty for more shadows? Dive deeper into NecroTimes’ crypt of horror analysis.

Bibliography

Brown, R. (2012) Mario Bava: All the Colors of the Dark. Image Entertainment.

Jones, A. (2010) Gothic: The Dark Heart of Cinema. Wallflower Press.

Knee, M. (2003) ‘The Nun in the Gothic’, Journal of Film and Religion, 7(2), pp. 45-62.

Maddox, M. (2019) ‘Valak and the Demonic Nun Phenomenon’, Fangoria, 45(1), pp. 78-85. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/articles/valak-nun (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Paul, W. (1994) Laughing, Screaming: Modern Hollywood Horror and Comedy. Columbia University Press.

Romero, G. and Cooper, A. (2021) Conjuring Universe: Demons Deconstructed. Titan Books.

Siegel, J. (1972) Barbara Steele: Portrait of a Scream Queen. Midnight Marquee Press.

Soderman, B. (2017) ‘Italian Gothic Soundscapes’, Audio-Visions: Journal of Sound Studies, 3(1), pp. 112-130.

Tamborini, R. (2005) La maschera del demonio: Analisi critica. Edizioni Il Foglio.

Wooley, J. (1987) The Bava Brothers and the Italian Gothic Cinema. Midnight Marquee.