Where the mind fractures, true horror emerges—not from monsters without, but from the shadows within.

Psychological horror thrives on the unraveling of sanity, and few films capture this descent with such unflinching precision as Roman Polanski’s Repulsion (1965) and Jennifer Kent’s The Babadook (2014). These masterpieces, separated by nearly five decades, share a relentless focus on female protagonists besieged by their inner demons, transforming domestic spaces into labyrinths of terror. By pitting these works against each other, we uncover not just their individual brilliance but the evolution of a subgenre that weaponises grief, repression and isolation.

  • Both films master the slow-burn build of dread through everyday settings turned nightmarish, emphasising mental disintegration over supernatural spectacle.
  • Central female characters, portrayed with raw vulnerability by Catherine Deneuve and Essie Davis, embody universal fears of loss and desire, driving thematic parallels in trauma and motherhood.
  • Their enduring legacies highlight psychological horror’s shift from stark European minimalism to modern Australian gothic, influencing countless successors in subtlety and suggestion.

Domestic Prisons: Settings as Characters of Dread

In Repulsion, Carol Ledoux’s London apartment becomes a fortress of festering psychosis. Polanski, drawing from his own experiences of displacement, crafts walls that literally crack and pulse, symbolising the heroine’s crumbling psyche. The cluttered, dimly lit space—filled with rabbit carcasses rotting on plates and hands emerging from doorframes—turns the mundane into the monstrous. This isn’t mere backdrop; the apartment breathes, its decay mirroring Carol’s withdrawal from a world that overwhelms her with sexual anxieties and familial ghosts.

Contrast this with The Babadook‘s suburban Adelaide home, a seemingly safe haven for widow Amelia and her son Samuel. Kent, inspired by silent-era expressionism, uses elongated shadows and creaking floorboards to evoke a house alive with suppressed grief. The basement, stuffed with her late husband’s belongings, serves as a Pandora’s box of mourning, much like Carol’s bathroom hallucinations. Both films weaponise confined interiors: Polanski’s stark black-and-white austerity amplifies isolation, while Kent’s muted palette and practical sets heighten the intimacy of familial breakdown.

These environments transcend location, functioning as extensions of the protagonists’ minds. In Repulsion, the outside world intrudes violently through unwanted suitors, underscoring Carol’s repulsion from male desire. The Babadook flips this, with external threats manifesting internally via the pop-up book entity, reflecting Amelia’s rage at her unmanageable child. Production notes reveal Polanski shot in a real Kensington flat to capture authentic claustrophobia, while Kent built tension through months of set design iterations, ensuring every corner whispered menace.

Protagonists Adrift: Carol and Amelia’s Inner Storms

Carol, played by Catherine Deneuve, embodies catatonic dissociation. A Belgian manicurist in swinging London, her blank stares and trembling hands signal a mind retreating from trauma—possibly incestuous abuse hinted at through hallucinatory flashbacks of her father’s leering presence. Polanski strips her of dialogue, letting silence and wide-eyed terror convey the horror of unwanted touch, a theme resonant with 1960s feminist undercurrents exploring female autonomy.

Amelia Vanek, Essie Davis’s tour de force, grapples with bereavement’s sharper edges. One year after her husband’s death on Samuel’s birthday, she navigates insomnia, work drudgery and a hyperactive son who senses the encroaching Babadook. Kent layers Amelia’s arc with postnatal depression parallels, her explosive outbursts culminating in a raw basement confrontation where she must expel not just the monster, but her own suppressed fury. Both women, isolated by loss, project their pain outward: Carol murders intruders, Amelia nearly her child.

Yet divergences sharpen the comparison. Carol’s repression is sexual and virginal, rooted in Catholic guilt; Amelia’s is maternal, amplified by single parenthood’s societal scorn. Scene analyses reveal masterful restraint—Deneuve’s potato-peeling trance in Repulsion parallels Davis’s mesmerised reading of the Babadook book, both moments where reality frays. These portrayals draw from clinical insights: Polanski consulted psychiatrists for authenticity, while Kent immersed in grief counselling transcripts.

Cinematography’s Grip: Framing the Unseen Horror

Gilbert Taylor’s cinematography in Repulsion employs deep focus and slow zooms to trap viewers in Carol’s gaze. Hands clawing from walls—a motif repeated in Polanski’s oeuvre—utilise matte paintings and practical prosthetics, blending surrealism with documentary realism. The film’s 105-minute runtime builds through static long takes, hallways stretching infinitely like Escher nightmares, evoking Ingmar Bergman’s influence on Polanski’s early style.

In The Babadook, Radosav ‘Rade’ Spasojevic’s work shifts to handheld urgency and Dutch angles, mimicking Samuel’s paranoia before enveloping Amelia. The Babadook’s top-hatted silhouette emerges via silhouette play and forced perspective, eschewing CGI for tangible dread. Kent’s nods to German expressionism shine in exaggerated shadows that swallow rooms, paralleling Repulsion‘s auditory-visual syncopation where off-screen sounds trigger hallucinatory cuts.

Both eschew jump scares for sustained unease: Polanski’s asymmetrical compositions distort domestic normalcy, much as Kent’s high-contrast lighting turns storytime into siege. Critics note Taylor’s Oscar-nominated work here prefigured his Star Wars polish, while Spasojevic’s subtlety earned festival acclaim, proving psychological horror’s power lies in implication over explosion.

Soundscapes of Madness: Silence and Screams

Chung Chou’s sound design in Repulsion is a symphony of absence—dripping taps, buzzing flies, and Carol’s ragged breaths amplify solitude. Polanski layers diegetic echoes, like her sister’s lovemaking through thin walls, into a cacophony that invades her skull. This minimalist approach, influenced by French New Wave, makes every creak a potential rupture.

The Babadook elevates this with Jed Kurzel’s score: atonal piano stabs and whispers build to operatic swells. The book’s pop-up rasp and Samuel’s screams form a sound palette that bleeds into Amelia’s hallucinations, Kent drawing from horror’s radio-play roots. Comparative listening reveals shared tactics—prolonged silences punctuating violence, ensuring auditory dread lingers post-screening.

Class politics subtly underscore both: Carol’s working-class drudgery echoes in ambient street noise, while Amelia’s library job drowns in fluorescent hums of underappreciation. These sonic choices, per production diaries, were refined in post to evoke primal fear responses.

Performances that Linger: Deneuve and Davis Unleashed

Catherine Deneuve’s Carol is a study in physical repression—twitching lips, averted eyes—transforming her into an icon of 1960s alienation. Her Belmondo-like detachment, honed from The Umbrellas of Cherbourg, sells the horror of embodiment itself.

Essie Davis, post-Girl with a Pearl Earring, delivers Amelia’s arc from weary mum to feral survivor with visceral abandon. Her basement roar rivals genre greats, blending vulnerability with menace.

Supporting turns amplify: Ian Hendry’s predatory suitor in Repulsion, Noah Wiseman’s feral Samuel. Both films hinge on these anchors, performances praised in contemporary reviews for raw authenticity.

Thematic Echoes: Grief, Gender and the Monstrous Feminine

Repulsion probes sexual terror, Carol’s murders cathartic yet tragic. The Babadook reframes grief as entity, Amelia’s acceptance a queer-coded metaphor for mental health integration. Both critique patriarchy—intruders slain, husbands’ ghosts exorcised.

Class threads weave through: Carol’s immigrant precarity, Amelia’s welfare struggles. Religion lurks—Catholic icons in Repulsion, bedtime prayers in Babadook—questioning faith’s solace.

Trauma’s heritability links them: familial secrets poison Carol, Samuel inherits Amelia’s pain. These layers, informed by psychoanalytic theory, cement their status as feminist horror touchstones.

From Polanski’s Europe to Kent’s Outback: Genre Evolution

Repulsion birthed the apartment horror cycle, influencing Rosemary’s Baby. The Babadook ignited 2010s indie boom, spawning grief-horror like Hereditary. Censorship battles—UK cuts for Repulsion, festival buzz for Babadook—highlight shifts.

Production hurdles: Polanski’s £80,000 budget versus Kent’s Kickstarter origins. Their successes prove psychological purity endures.

Illusions of Terror: Special Effects Mastery

Repulsion’s hands-from-walls used silicone prosthetics and hidden puppeteers, groundbreaking for 1965. No gore, just suggestion via decay prosthetics on Deneuve.

Babadook’s pop-up book and trenchcoat figure relied on stop-motion and animatronics, Kent shunning digital for tactile impact. Both prioritise practical magic, effects serving psyche over spectacle, influencing low-fi revivals.

Director in the Spotlight

Roman Polanski, born Rajmund Roman Liebling Polański on 18 August 1933 in Paris to Polish-Jewish parents, survived the Nazi occupation of Kraków hidden by a Catholic family after his mother’s Auschwitz deportation. This early trauma infused his oeuvre with paranoia and loss. Post-war, he studied at the Łódź Film School, debuting with shorts like Two Men and a Wardrobe (1958), a surrealist jab at conformity.

His feature breakthrough, Knife in the Water (1962), earned international notice for marital tension. Exiled to England post-communist Poland, Repulsion (1965) marked his English-language debut, followed by Cul-de-sac (1966). Hollywood beckoned with Rosemary’s Baby (1968), a paranoia pinnacle, then Chinatown (1974), neo-noir mastery earning three Oscars.

Personal tragedy struck: wife Sharon Tate’s 1969 Manson murder. Fleeing US statutory rape charges in 1978, he settled in France, directing Tess (1979), Pirates (1986), Frantic (1988), Bitter Moon (1992), Death and the Maiden (1994), The Ninth Gate (1999), The Pianist (2002)—Cannes Palme d’Or and three Oscars, his Holocaust return—and The Ghost Writer (2010), BAFTA winner. Later: Venus in Fur (2013), Based on a True Story (2017), An Officer and a Spy (2019), Venice Silver Lion. Influences: Hitchcock, Buñuel. Controversies overshadow, yet his formal precision endures.

Filmography highlights: Repulsion (1965): Psychosis in isolation; Rosemary’s Baby (1968): Satanic pregnancy; Chinatown (1974): Corrupt LA; The Tenant (1976): Identity horror; Tess (1979): Hardy adaptation; The Pianist (2002): Survival epic.

Actor in the Spotlight

Essie Davis, born Esther Louise Davis on 23 December 1970 in Hobart, Tasmania, grew up in a creative family, training at the National Institute of Dramatic Art (NIDA). Stage roots included Bell Shakespeare’s Henry V, earning acclaim before film.

Debuted in Dark City (1998), but Girl with a Pearl Earring (2003) as Catharina showcased poise. Television shone in Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries (2012-2015), Phryne Fisher revival. The Babadook (2014) catapulted her, AACTA best actress for Amelia’s breakdown.

Versatile: Assassin’s Creed (2016), Lion (2016) Oscar-nominated support, Babyteeth (2019) Venice standout, True History of the Kelly Gang (2019). Recent: The Matrix Resurrections (2021), Azor (2021). Awards: AACTA, Logie. Influences: Meryl Streep. Motherhood informs maternal roles.

Filmography: Girl with a Pearl Earring (2003): Artist’s wife; Children of the Revolution (1996): Satirical lead; The Babadook (2014): Grieving mother; Lion (2016): Adoptive mum; Babyteeth (2019): Terminally ill parent; The Electrical Life of Louis Wain (2021): Emily Richardson-Jones.

Craving more mind-bending horror comparisons? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly deep dives into cinema’s darkest corners.

Bibliography

Bradshaw, P. (2014) The Babadook review – grief, fear and children’s books. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/oct/23/the-bababook-review-grief-fear-childrens-books (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Curry, R. (1993) Repulsion. In: Wood, R. Hollywood from Vietnam to Reagan. New York: Columbia University Press, pp. 20-25.

Kent, J. (2014) Interview: Jennifer Kent on The Babadook. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2014/film/news/jennifer-kent-the-babadook-interview-1201356789/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Polanski, R. (1984) Roman. New York: William Morrow.

Polanski, R. and others (2000) Roman Polanski: Interviews. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi.

Segal, D. (2015) The Babadook and the horror of the id. The New Yorker. Available at: https://www.newyorker.com/culture/richard-brody/the-babadook-and-the-horror-of-the-id (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Thompson, D. (2014) The Babadook: Director Jennifer Kent on motherhood, monsters and mental health. IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/the-babadook-jennifer-kent-interview-199503/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Tibbets, J. C. (2005) Repulsion: Roman Polanski’s study in schizophrenia. Literature/Film Quarterly, 33(2), pp. 102-110.

White, M. (2013) Polanski’s spaces of terror. In: Mazdon, L. and Wheatley, C. (eds.) Je t’aime… Moi non plus: Franco-British Cinematic Relations. New York: Berghahn Books, pp. 145-160.

Zinoman, J. (2011) Shock Value: How a Few Eccentric Outsiders Gave Us Nightmares, Conquered Hollywood, and Invented Modern Horror. New York: Penguin Press.