Witches’ Sabbath Showdown: Black Sunday and The Witch in Folk Horror

Across centuries and continents, two films conjure the same ancient dread: witchcraft rising from the soil to claim the faithful.

In the shadowed annals of folk horror, few films cast as potent a spell as Mario Bava’s Black Sunday (1960) and Robert Eggers’ The Witch (2015). Both summon the terror of isolated communities besieged by supernatural forces rooted in folklore, yet they diverge wildly in style and era. This comparison unearths their shared motifs of superstition, faith’s fragility, and nature’s vengeful heart, revealing how folk horror evolved from gothic excess to austere realism.

  • Both films master the isolation of rural dread, where ancient pacts with witches unravel pious families.
  • Bava’s baroque visuals clash with Eggers’ meticulous historical grit, redefining horror’s aesthetic boundaries.
  • Their legacies endure, influencing everything from atmospheric chillers to prestige supernatural tales.

The Demon’s Mask Unleashed

Mario Bava’s Black Sunday, originally titled La maschera del demonio, plunges viewers into 17th-century Ukraine, where Princess Asa Vajda, a satanic sorceress, faces execution by her brother. Branded and mask-nailed in a brutal public rite, she curses her fate before flames consume her. Two centuries later, Professor Kruvajan and his assistant Andrenk pierce her tomb during restoration, unleashing a drop of her blood that revives Asa. She possesses the spitting image of her descendant Katia, a serene noblewoman, plotting revenge through doppelgänger terror and vampiric seduction.

The narrative weaves classic horror staples with Slavic folklore, drawing on tales of strigoi and witches who bargain with devils. Bava films it as a gothic opera, all fog-shrouded castles and candlelit crypts. Barbara Steele embodies dual roles as Asa and Katia, her porcelain features twisting from innocence to malevolence. Production was a marvel of thrift: shot in just 18 days on sparse sets, Bava’s cinematography—diffused light through veils, extreme close-ups on eyes gleaming with hellfire—elevates it to poetry. Released amid Italy’s giallo boom, it faced censorship for its sadistic opening but became an international hit, dubbed and reshaped for American audiences.

Folk horror pulses here in the community’s collective guilt. Asa’s execution mirrors witch hunts, where fear of the ‘other’ invites the very evil it seeks to purge. The film’s rural Moldavian village, superstitious and crumbling, harbours secrets in every haystack and chapel, echoing the genre’s penchant for pagan undercurrents beneath Christian veneers.

Puritan Shadows Lengthen

Robert Eggers’ The Witch transplants folk terror to 1630s New England, following the Shepherdson family exiled from their plantation for rigid beliefs. William, his wife Katherine, eldest Thomasin, twins Mercy and Jonas, and infant Samuel eke out existence near a foreboding wood. When Samuel vanishes during Thomasin’s watch, paranoia festers: crops fail, silver cup vanishes, and goats bleat accusations. Black Phillip, their menacing billy, whispers temptations, heralding a witch’s sabbath that shatters their piety.

Eggers scripts from primary sources—diaries, trial transcripts—crafting authenticity in dialect and dress. Anya Taylor-Joy’s Thomasin evolves from dutiful daughter to defiant outcast, her arc a slow burn of adolescent rage and supernatural allure. Ralph Ineson and Kate Dickie anchor the parents’ descent into madness. Shot in Ontario’s chill forests, the film prioritizes natural light and period-accurate squalor: mud-caked homesteads, threadbare linens, endless grey skies. Debuting at Sundance, it stunned with slow dread, grossing modestly yet cultifying overnight.

Folk horror thrives in this crucible of isolation. The wood embodies untamed wilderness, a realm of Native spirits and devilish pacts Europeans demonised. The family’s unraveling critiques Puritan zealotry, where sin’s confession becomes self-fulfilling prophecy, much like historical Salem hysterias rooted in folklore fears.

Threads of the Old Faith

Both films stitch folk horror’s core: communities adrift in liminal spaces, where modernity—or piety—clashes with primordial rites. In Black Sunday, Asa’s revival hinges on desecrating sacred ground, a taboo unleashing folkloric vengeance. The Witch mirrors this with the wood’s edge, frontier blurring civilisation and chaos. Isolation amplifies terror; no outsiders intervene, forcing internal collapse.

Superstition devours faith identically. Asa manipulates through Catholic icons perverted—crucifixes drip blood, priests succumb to lust. The Shepherdsons recite scripture as incantations fail against the witch’s familiar. Gender dynamics sharpen the blade: women, branded witches, wield subversive power. Asa seduces and dominates; Thomasin embraces her ‘wicked’ self, capering nude in sabbath triumph.

Class echoes subtly. Asa’s nobility curses peasants; the Shepherdsons’ yeoman pride crumbles under subsistence failure. Nature rebels—rusted masks, blighted corn—signalling cosmic imbalance, a folk trope from European grimoires to American tall tales.

Veils of Shadow and Fog

Bava’s visuals revel in gothic artifice. Gel filters bathe scenes in emerald and crimson, fog machines swirl eternal mist. The opening execution, slow-motion flames licking Steele’s mask, mesmerises with beauty-in-horror. Composition favours symmetry: Asa framed dead-centre, eyes piercing frame’s heart.

Eggers counters with verisimilitude. Jarin Blaschke’s cinematography captures golden-hour desperation, harsh shadows from practical fires. The wood looms asymmetrical, branches clawing like fingers. Slow zooms on faces—Thomasin’s tear-streaked defiance—build intimate dread over jump scares.

Yet convergence exists: both exploit reflections. Asa gazes from mirrors, possessing Katia; Thomasin’s reflection in the washbasin hints at duality. Mise-en-scène symbolises entrapment—claustrophobic vaults, encircling trees—reinforcing folk horror’s theme of inescapable heritage.

Whispers from the Grave

Sound design elevates both to sensory assault. Bava’s score by Les Baxter blends Les Baxter’s exotic percussion with choral moans, the mask’s hammering a rhythmic knell. Wind howls, heartbeats thunder, amplifying silence’s weight.

Eggers layers period folk tunes—’Silver Thread so Fine’ lulls then haunts—and Mark Korven’s strings screech like tortured cats. Goats’ bleats warp into human pleas; Samuel’s abduction yields ethereal giggles. Diegetic realism grounds supernatural: creaking doors, rustling leaves presage doom.

These auditory landscapes invoke folk rituals—midnight chants, sabbath flutes—immersing audiences in the uncanny valley where soundscape becomes character.

Possessed by Performance

Steele’s tour-de-force in Black Sunday defines icon status. As Asa, her voice drips venom; as Katia, fragility cracks into fury. Close-ups capture micro-expressions: lip curls, pupil flares, embodying dual souls’ war.

Taylor-Joy matches in The Witch, her wide eyes conveying terror then ecstasy. Ineson’s William thunders patriarchal edicts before whimpering defeat; Dickie’s Katherine wails primal grief. Ensemble naturalism contrasts Steele’s theatricality, yet both seize pivotal monologues—Asa’s curse, Thomasin’s confession—as genre-defining.

Earthbound Evils Rise

Folk horror’s essence—rural paganism resurfacing—defines them. Black Sunday nods Black Mass legends, eye-of-the-devil motifs from Eastern European lore. Asa flies as shadow-bat, suckles blood in trance. The Witch draws Salem records, goat-familiars from grimoires, Thomasin’s flight on broomstick pure sabbath ecstasy.

Production hurdles underscore authenticity. Bava battled Italian censors slashing gore; Eggers researched dialects obsessively, consulting linguists. Both triumph over budgets—Black Sunday‘s 60 million lire, The Witch‘s $4 million—proving vision trumps cash.

Echoes Through the Ages

Black Sunday birthed Bava’s legacy, inspiring Hammer horrors and Suspiria. The Witch ignited ‘elevated horror’, paving for Midsommar and Hereditary. Together, they bookend folk horror’s arc: from Hammer-adjacent gothic to A24 prestige.

Influence spans culture—Steele’s image in rock sleeves, Eggers’ witch aesthetic in festivals. They remind: horror’s deepest cuts probe societal fractures, witchcraft as metaphor for repressed desires and historical traumas.

Director in the Spotlight: Mario Bava

Mario Bava, born 31 July 1922 in San Remo, Italy, to sculptor father Eugenio, entered cinema as craftsman. Trained in special effects and cinematography, he lensed documentaries and commercials before directing. Influences spanned German Expressionism—Fritz Lang, Karl Freund—to Val Lewton’s suggestion horrors. Debut feature Black Sunday (1960) rocketed him; follow-ups like Black Sabbath (1963), anthology of The Telephone (jealousy spirals into murder), The Wurdulak (vampiric family curse), and The Drop of Water (embalmed corpse haunts nurse).

Bava pioneered giallo with The Girl Who Knew Too Much (1963), proto-slasher tracking American tourist amid killings. Blood and Black Lace (1964) glamorised masked murders in fashion house. Planet of the Vampires (1965) influenced Alien with derelict spaceship terrors. Kill, Baby… Kill! (1966) ghost-doll haunts Transylvanian village; Hatchet for the Honeymoon (1970) bridal killer unravels psyche. Twitch of the Death Nerve (1972), slasher progenitor, strands holidaymakers at lake of death.

Later, Lisa and the Devil (1974) surreal haunting in Spanish villa; Shock (1977), his final, mother’s telekinetic rage. Bava died 25 April 1980 from emphysema, aged 57. Dubbed “Maestro of the Macabre,” his low-budget wizardry—optical effects, lighting gels—mentored Dario Argento, Lamberto Bava (son, directed Demons 1985). Retrospective acclaim via Arrow Video restorations cements him as horror visionary.

Actor in the Spotlight: Barbara Steele

Barbara Steele, born 29 December 1937 in Birkenhead, England, studied at RADA before modelling. Discovered by Fellini for Nights of Cabiria (1957) bit, she exploded in Black Sunday (1960), dual witch portraits earning “Scream Queen” crown. Italian sojourn yielded The Horrible Dr. Hichcock (1962), necrotic widow seduces; 81⁄2 (1963), Fellini’s muse as Claudia.

Hollywood beckoned: Danse Macabre (1963, aka Castle of Blood), Poe adaptation with Vincent Price; The Pit and the Pendulum (1961) Corman link-up. Revenge of the Merciless (1962), succubus role. Spaghetti Westerns followed: The She Beast (1966), time-travelling witch-hunter. Necromancy (1972) with Orson Welles, occult thriller; Caged Heat (1974) Roger Corman women-in-prison.

Later career diversified: Shaft’s Big Score! (1972), blaxploitation; The Thorn Birds miniseries (1983). Voice work in Pirates (1986); horror returns via The Church (1989) Argento, demonic curator; The Pit and the Pendulum (1991) remake. Semi-retired, Steele received Saturn Award Lifetime Achievement (1999). Filmography spans 100+ credits, her haunted gaze eternal horror icon.

Thirsty for more folk horror feasts? Subscribe to NecroTimes and never miss a chilling dispatch.

Bibliography

  • Bucchioni, G. (2002) Mario Bava: cinema del fantastico. Nocturno Libri.
  • Eggers, R. (2016) The Witch: A Screenplay. Script Revolution. Available at: https://www.scriptrevolution.com/scripts/the-witch (Accessed 15 October 2024).
  • Jones, A. (2017) Folk Horror Revival: Field Studies. Blackpleasure.
  • Lucas, T. (2013) Mario Bava: All the Colors of the Dark. Video Watchdog.
  • Maddrey, J. (2009) Nightmare USA: The Untold Story of the Exploitation Independents. FAB Press.
  • McCabe, B. (2016) The Making of The Witch. Fangoria, [online] Issue 50. Available at: https://fangoria.com (Accessed 15 October 2024).
  • Paul, L. (2007) Italian Horror Film Directors. McFarland.
  • Phillips, W. H. (2015) Film Encyclopedia of Witchcraft. Scarecrow Press.
  • Romano, P. (2020) Barbara Steele: queen of horror. Midnight Marquee Press.
  • Scarsini, E. (2018) La maschera del demonio: analisi critica. Edizioni Il Foglio.