When the Hodgson children in Enfield first heard knocks on their bedroom walls in 1977, no one could have predicted how quickly the situation would pull trained researchers into physical danger and lasting unease.
This article examines fifteen documented paranormal investigations spanning more than a century, each of which began with systematic attempts to record and understand reported phenomena yet ended with clear accounts of injury, illness or psychological strain for the people involved. Drawing on witness statements, official reports and published records, the following sections preserve every original detail while adding historical context, connections to related cases and reflections on what these events suggest about the limits of investigation.
1. The Enfield Poltergeist (1977–1979)
The Hodgson family in London’s Enfield district faced a prolonged series of disturbances that brought in researchers from the Society for Psychical Research, including Maurice Grosse and writer Guy Lyon Playfair, who recorded furniture moving on its own, objects flying across rooms and a distinctive gruff voice that identified itself as Bill. What began as careful note-taking and tape recordings soon turned physical when eleven-year-old Janet Hodgson was thrown from her bed, left with bruises and photographed in positions that appeared unnatural. Team members also noted scratches appearing on skin and small fires starting without explanation, while Grosse himself suffered chest pains he linked directly to the activity. The case later inspired a well-known film, yet Playfair continued to be unsettled by the preserved recordings of Janet’s altered voice long after the events subsided. In the broader picture of 1970s paranormal research, this investigation stands out because it combined multiple witnesses, photographic evidence and audio that still circulates today, reminding later investigators that even well-documented cases can cross from observation into direct impact on those present.
2. The Black Monk of Pontefract (1966–1974)
The Pritchard home in Pontefract, Yorkshire, became the setting for one of Britain’s most physically aggressive poltergeist cases, featuring cloaked figures, stones falling indoors and family members lifted then thrown against walls. Local investigators and clergy witnessed these events over several years, but the situation reached a new level during a 1974 séance organised by researcher Tom Cuniff when participant Joe Berkshire was suddenly drenched in boiling water from a cloth that had been dry moments earlier, resulting in severe burns. Reports also described a monk-like shape attempting to throttle those present, which ultimately prompted the family to move away. The house has since served as a cautionary example for anyone considering amateur attempts to engage with similar activity, illustrating how repeated exposure can escalate from unsettling noises to outright physical harm.
3. Borley Rectory (1929–1939)
Harry Price’s long-running study of Borley Rectory, often called England’s most haunted house, brought forward accounts of a nun’s apparition and bells that rang without anyone touching them. His team experienced fires that started spontaneously and walls that appeared to bleed, yet the investigation took a heavier toll when assistant Frederick Gregory died suddenly after describing attacks by unseen forces, followed by several other members suffering heart attacks and unexplained health problems. Price himself became entangled in legal disputes over the authenticity of some claims even as the rectory burned down in 1939. Later visits confirmed lingering residual activity, but the pattern of health issues among those who spent extended time there continues to raise questions about whether certain locations carry cumulative effects on the people who study them most closely.
4. The Amityville Horror (1975–1976)
Ed and Lorraine Warren examined the DeFeo and Lutz residence in Amityville, New York, the site of a notorious axe murder, where the new occupants reported swarms of flies, oozing substances and what they described as a demonic pig-like figure. The Warrens documented levitations and strange voices, but investigator Stephen Kaplan claimed he experienced possession after handling items from the house, leading to erratic behaviour that damaged his reputation. Lorraine Warren also described being physically assaulted by shadowy forms. The intense media coverage that followed encouraged similar reports in other locations, leaving many of the psychics and researchers involved feeling drained and uncertain about how far the influence had spread.
5. The Smurl Haunting (1985–1987)
The Smurl family in West Pittston, Pennsylvania, called on the Warrens after experiencing foul smells, beds that rose off the floor and apparitions they believed were attempting assault. During attempted exorcisms, investigators heard guttural voices and felt intense pressure on their bodies. The situation worsened when Jack Smurl was thrown down a flight of stairs and a priest assisting the Warrens suffered a stroke during a ritual. Neighbours later reported disturbances in their own homes, suggesting the activity may have extended beyond the original property. The bestselling book that chronicled the case has kept the story in public view, serving as a reminder that some reported entities appear to affect more than just the primary household under study.
6. The Perron Farmhouse (1971–1980)
The Old Arnold Estate in Rhode Island drew the Warrens to the Perron family after reports of apparitions and choking sensations. Séances pointed toward a supposed witch’s curse, yet the investigation became dangerous when Lorraine Warren was struck by an invisible force and Roger Perron endured nighttime attacks. Recordings captured what sounded like children screaming, which coincided with unexplained illnesses among family members. The events later inspired the film The Conjuring, but the Warrens themselves reported recurring nightmares and physical marks they attributed to the farmhouse spirits, showing how even experienced investigators can carry effects long after leaving the location.
7. Demon House, Gary, Indiana (2014)
Zak Bagans of Ghost Adventures investigated a Gary, Indiana home where children reportedly spoke in altered voices and moved backwards up stairs. His crew recorded self-inflicted injuries and apparent possessions, but the probe ended abruptly when Bagans blacked out and experienced seizures while other team members needed medical attention for paralysis and hallucinations. He eventually had the building demolished, though footage of shadowy shapes moving toward cameras remains available. The site is now avoided, providing a modern example of how quickly an investigation can shift from documentation to urgent medical concern.
8. The Snedeker House Haunting (1986–1988)
The Snedeker family lived in a former Connecticut funeral parlour where they and the Warrens encountered basement apparitions and objects that appeared to levitate, including what looked like pieces of meat. Investigators heard gagging sounds coming from old morgue drains. The case turned especially disturbing when Carmen Snedeker described sexual assault by unseen figures and researcher John Zaffis developed severe respiratory problems that some linked to residual embalming materials. Multiple team members eventually withdrew from the investigation as the violence increased, and the book In a Dark Place later detailed how the events affected everyone involved.
9. Annabelle Doll Investigations (1970s–Present)
The Warrens kept the rag doll Annabelle in their museum after linking it to a series of deaths that followed its acquisition. People who tested its claimed powers reported car engine failures on the way home and heart attacks while handling it. In 2017 a séance conducted by medium Christopher Moon resulted in his hospitalisation after scratches spelling 666 appeared on his body. Lorraine Warren had previously warned about the doll’s supposed ability to transfer influence, and caretakers have continued to describe nightmares and family difficulties. Kept behind protective glass, the doll still attracts attention from those curious about its history, illustrating how certain objects maintain a reputation for affecting people across decades.
10. The Dybbuk Box (2001–2003)
Kevin Mannis purchased an antique wine cabinet that soon brought nightmares and sightings of hairy figures. After he sold it on eBay to Jason Haxton, further investigations noted sulphurous odours and electronic malfunctions. Haxton’s team experienced strokes, job losses and one temporary loss of vision attributed to shadow-like attacks. Haxton eventually sealed the box with Hebrew prayers, yet later owners reported ongoing problems, and the story was adapted into the film The Possession. The case shows how an item acquired out of simple curiosity can become associated with a chain of misfortunes that follow it through multiple hands.
11. Robert the Doll (1904–Present)
The Otto family in Key West owned the doll Robert, which was blamed for furniture moving and other disturbances in the early twentieth century. Today, visitors to the East Martello Museum report camera failures and sudden illnesses after taking unauthorised photographs. Tour guides note that people who mock the doll have suffered strokes or accidents, and letters from former visitors describe personal misfortunes they connect to their visit. A 2015 EVP session captured growling sounds followed by the lead researcher’s car crash. Robert remains on display, continuing to draw both sceptics and believers who test the long-standing warnings attached to it.
12. Villisca Axe Murder House (1912–Present)
The Iowa house where an entire family was murdered in 1912 now hosts overnight investigations that report child apparitions and tools moving on their own. During a 2014 Ghost Adventures visit, axes reportedly swung without anyone touching them, cutting Aaron Goodwin. Guests have described urges toward self-harm, and one person attempted suicide after staying there. Owner Martha Linn has logged more than one hundred cases of visitors feeling drained or becoming ill afterward. The property demonstrates how a location tied to historical violence can continue to affect modern investigators who spend extended time inside it.
13. The Exorcism of Roland Doe (1949)
A Jesuit team in Washington, DC, performed rituals for fourteen-year-old Roland Doe after reports of bed-shaking and Latin spoken in an altered voice. Scratches spelling HELL appeared on the priests, and one suffered a severe slash. Lead exorcist Father Bishop developed lifelong tremors following the rites. The case inspired the novel and film The Exorcist, yet leaked diaries suggest some team members believed the entity had affected them personally. It remains one of the most closely examined possession accounts in Church records, highlighting both the intensity of the reported phenomena and the lasting personal cost to those conducting the rituals.
14. Anneliese Michel Exorcism (1975–1976)
German student Anneliese Michel underwent sixty-seven exorcism rites while experiencing voices and self-inflicted injuries. Priests Father Arnold Renz and Pastor Ernst Alt heard objects fly and verbal attacks that named their personal failings. Anneliese died from malnutrition, leading to manslaughter convictions for her parents and the priests. Post-mortem examinations noted her body had not decomposed in the usual way, and some investigators reported shared visions. Playback of the recorded sessions later caused seizures in listeners, extending the documented effects beyond the original events and prompting ongoing discussion about the balance between medical and spiritual explanations.
15. The Devil Made Me Do It Case (1981)
Ed and Lorraine Warren assisted in the defence of Arne Johnson, who claimed possession after a graveyard incident involving a cursed hand. Courtroom recordings and levitations were presented, resulting in an acquittal on murder charges. The investigation darkened when David Glatzel suffered relapses and Lorraine Warren was choked during an evocation of tree demons. Residual activity reportedly followed the couple afterward, suggesting the influence may have transferred to those who became most involved. The case remains notable for its use of paranormal testimony in a legal setting and for the way it illustrated potential risks to the investigators themselves.
Bibliography
Guy Lyon Playfair, This House is Haunted: The True Story of the Enfield Poltergeist (1980).
Ed and Lorraine Warren, with Robert David Chase, Ghost Hunters: True Stories from the World’s Most Famous Demonologists (1989).
Jay Anson, The Amityville Horror (1977).
Jason Haxton, The Dybbuk Box (2011).
William Peter Blatty, The Exorcist (1971) and related case files.
Reports from the Society for Psychical Research archives on the Enfield and Borley investigations.
Contemporary coverage in Fate Magazine and local Connecticut and Pennsylvania newspapers from the 1980s.
Zak Bagans, Demon House documentary footage and production notes (2018).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
