Picture a quiet household where death seems to follow one woman from marriage to marriage, each loss bringing just enough money to start over again. That pattern repeats across the cases we will explore here, where financial gain became the driving force behind repeated murders. This article examines seven women whose crimes stretched from Victorian England through to modern California, showing how insurance policies, inheritances, and benefit checks turned ordinary domestic settings into scenes of calculated killing. We will look at their backgrounds, the methods they chose, and the ways authorities eventually caught up with them, while considering what these stories reveal about trust, vulnerability, and the limits of investigation at different times in history.
Serial murder for profit stands apart from other motives because it requires planning and repetition rather than a single moment of rage. Women have always formed a small share of known serial killers, yet the cases that follow stand out for their focus on steady payouts instead of violence for its own sake. Each woman here blended into daily life, using poison, staged accidents, or simple neglect to remove people whose deaths paid the bills. Their stories matter because they expose how easily systems meant to protect families could be turned against them when no one looked too closely at a string of similar tragedies.
1. Mary Ann Cotton: The Victorian Arsenic Widow
Mary Ann Cotton earned a grim place in British criminal history as one of the earliest documented female serial killers. Between 1852 and 1872 she is believed to have poisoned as many as twenty-one people, most of them family members, in order to claim modest life insurance sums that working families bought through friendly societies. Those small policies existed because industrial accidents and disease made early death common, yet they also created a quiet incentive for anyone willing to collect on them repeatedly.
She was born in 1832 in County Durham and grew up amid the poverty and frequent moves that shaped many working-class lives of the period. Cotton married several times, and each marriage ended with the death of a husband or children. The money from the policies gave her a way to remarry or ease immediate financial pressure. Arsenic worked well for her because it was sold openly as rat poison and produced symptoms that doctors often mistook for gastric fever, an illness doctors saw often in crowded towns with poor sanitation. Her first husband died in 1865, followed over the years by ten children, her mother, and at least one lover. She sometimes married bigamously, removing the previous partner when it suited her plans. Victims such as her son Charles and stepson Frederick suffered days of stomach pain before they died. Suspicion finally surfaced in 1872 when her stepson John died at age ten. An autopsy found clear traces of arsenic, and further exhumations confirmed the same poison in other bodies. Cotton insisted the deaths came from bad drains or simple misfortune, but the pattern proved impossible to ignore.
Her 1873 trial convicted her of one murder, though investigators suspected many more. She was hanged later that year. The case prompted tighter rules on insurance sales to children and better training for doctors who examined sudden deaths. It also showed how limited forensic tools of the era allowed such crimes to continue for decades. Victims like her husbands James and George Robinson died without anyone questioning why so many people close to one woman kept falling ill in the same way.
2. Belle Gunness: The Norwegian Black Widow of Indiana
Belle Gunness arrived in the United States from Norway in 1881 and later became known for luring men to her Indiana farm with promises of marriage and a comfortable life. She is thought to have killed at least fourteen people, and possibly as many as forty, taking their savings and insurance money before disposing of the bodies. The case stands out because it combined newspaper advertisements with the isolation of a rural property, a combination that made detection difficult for years.
Born Brynhild Paulsdatter Størseth in 1859, Gunness started with little money and worked her way into property ownership through two marriages that both ended under suspicious circumstances. She placed ads seeking wealthy suitors and invited them to the farm with cash in hand. Once there, the men vanished. She often bludgeoned victims and used lye to break down remains in pits on the property. A farmhand named Ray Lamphere helped at times and later provided information to police. In 1908 the farmhouse burned, and searchers found headless remains inside that did not match Gunness through dental records. Excavations also uncovered children’s graves and at least fourteen other headless bodies. One victim, Andrew Helgelien, had sent her three thousand dollars before he disappeared, and his brother helped trace the money to the farm.
Gunness was never captured. Lamphere was convicted of arson and hinted that she had survived the fire and escaped. The case helped popularize the term black widow for women who killed romantic partners for money. Most of her victims were immigrant farmers who had trusted newspaper ads and the offer of stability in a new country. Their stories remind us how easily hope for a better life could be exploited when records were scattered and communities were still forming.
3. Nannie Doss: The Giggling Granny
Nannie Doss became known as the Giggling Granny after she admitted to killing eleven people between the 1920s and 1950s, including four husbands, mainly to collect insurance payments. Her lighthearted manner during questioning made the crimes seem even more chilling because it contrasted so sharply with the steady removal of people who trusted her.
Born in 1905 in Alabama, Doss grew up in difficult circumstances and later turned to romance magazines as an escape. She married several times, and each husband died after she had taken out policies on his life. She used arsenic from rat poison mixed into food or drink, collecting amounts that ranged from five hundred to six thousand dollars per policy. Victims also included her mother-in-law and two young children. Police arrested her in 1954 after the death of her fifth husband, Richard Mortensen. Autopsies on previous husbands confirmed arsenic in four cases. Doss spoke about the killings in a casual way during interviews, sometimes laughing, and showed little sign of regret over what she had done.
She received a life sentence in 1955 and died in prison ten years later from leukemia. Cases like hers show how repeated deaths in one household could be overlooked when each one looked like natural illness and when the surviving spouse appeared cooperative. The victims, including husband Frank Harrelson who was beaten and then poisoned, paid with their lives for policies that gave Doss temporary financial relief and the freedom to move on.
4. Judy Buenoano: The Florida Black Widow
Judy Buenoano was convicted of three murders in the 1970s and 1980s, targeting her husband, a boyfriend, and her own son to collect more than one hundred thousand dollars in insurance and benefits. Her case illustrates how modern insurance and military benefits could still be manipulated when accidents were staged carefully enough to avoid early suspicion.
Born in 1943, Buenoano married James in 1962. He drowned during a canoe trip in 1971, an event ruled accidental at the time and worth thirty-three thousand dollars to her. She later focused on boyfriend Bobby Joe Morris and her son Michael, who had disabilities. She used arsenic and also tampered with Michael’s parachute before a military jump in 1973, which failed and killed him. Convicted in 1984 for Michael’s murder, the earlier deaths were reopened and linked to her as well. Florida executed her in 1998, the first woman put to death in the state in a century and a half.
The prolonged suffering of her victims stands in contrast to the comfortable lifestyle the payouts supported. Her crimes prompted renewed attention to how beneficiaries are investigated after repeated accidental deaths in the same family, especially when large policies are involved.
5. Dorothea Puente: The Boarding House Killer
Dorothea Puente operated a boarding house in Sacramento during the 1980s and killed nine elderly tenants to steal their Social Security checks, bringing in thousands of dollars each month. The case highlights how vulnerable older adults can become when caregivers control both their daily needs and their finances.
Born in 1929, Puente already had a record that included forgery. By the mid-1980s her house sheltered people with little money or family support. She gave them sedatives and then increased the doses until they died. A report of a missing tenant led police to dig at the property, where they found seven bodies encased in concrete. Puente tried to flee but was arrested. In 1993 she was convicted of three murders and received a life sentence. She died in prison in 2011 at the age of eighty-two. One victim, Ruth Munroe, had trusted Puente to provide care and a place to live, only to be buried so her monthly check could continue to the killer.
The case led to stronger oversight of boarding homes and greater scrutiny of how Social Security payments are managed for residents who cannot handle their own affairs. It also showed that even in an era of better record-keeping, isolation and dependence could still hide murders for years.
6. Helen Golay: The Hollywood Black Widow
Helen Golay was seventy-eight when she and her partner were arrested in 2008 for killing two homeless men to collect insurance policies worth one point four million dollars. Their scheme relied on befriending men who had no stable housing and then staging fatal accidents that looked random to outsiders.
Golay, who had immigrated from Hungary, and her accomplice befriended Paul Vados and Kenneth McDavid. They took out heavy insurance on the men and later arranged hit-and-run incidents that were meant to appear accidental. Investigators noticed patterns in the timing and circumstances of the deaths, which led them to examine the insurance claims more closely. In 2010 Golay received a life sentence. The victims had been offered temporary housing and small comforts in exchange for signing documents they likely did not fully understand.
The case demonstrated that even in a large city with modern policing, homeless individuals could be targeted because their disappearances drew less attention than those of people with stronger family ties.
7. Olga Rutterschmidt: Golay’s Ruthless Partner
Olga Rutterschmidt, seventy-five at the time of arrest, worked closely with Helen Golay in the same insurance scheme that lasted nearly twenty years. She helped forge documents, drove vehicles used in the staged accidents, and collected sympathy payments by claiming injuries herself.
Rutterschmidt had prior fraud convictions, which made the pair’s long operation possible through practiced deception. Forensic evidence eventually connected their vehicles to the hit-and-runs. Both women received life sentences in 2010. McDavid and Vados had accepted offers of shelter and support, only to become part of a financial plan that treated their lives as disposable assets.
Together the two cases show how accomplices can extend a scheme far beyond what one person could manage alone, and how routine insurance investigations sometimes miss patterns until multiple deaths accumulate.
Bibliography
Wilson, Colin. The History of British Serial Killing. 2009.
Schechter, Harold. The Serial Killer Files. 2003.
Newton, Michael. The Encyclopedia of Serial Killers. 2006.
Crime Museum archives on Belle Gunness and Dorothea Puente.
Florida Department of Corrections records on Judy Buenoano execution.
Los Angeles Times coverage of the Golay and Rutterschmidt trial, 2008-2010.
Contemporary newspaper accounts of Mary Ann Cotton trial, 1873.
Public records on Nannie Doss confession and sentencing.
As explored further at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these investigations continue to shape how we examine repeated deaths that benefit one surviving person.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
