Picture a family in a quiet Florida town waving goodbye to their daughters as they head out for the evening. They expect the local deputy to watch over the roads and keep trouble away. Instead, that same deputy becomes the reason those girls never come home. Cases like this force us to ask how someone entrusted with authority can use it to destroy lives over many years.

This article walks through seven verified cases in which men who held police or official positions committed multiple murders. Each section draws on court records and investigation reports to lay out what is known about their early lives, the pattern of killings, and the moments that finally brought them to justice. The goal is to show how these positions of trust extended their ability to avoid detection while remembering the victims and the communities left to pick up the pieces.

1. Gerard John Schaefer: The Sheriff’s Deputy from Hell

Gerard John Schaefer served as a deputy sheriff in Martin County, Florida, a role that granted him immense trust and access. Hired in 1972 despite a troubled past, including expulsion from a police academy for abusive behavior toward a girlfriend, Schaefer quickly abused his position.

Born in 1946 in Wisconsin, Schaefer moved to Florida as a child. He pursued law enforcement, joining the Wilton Manors Police Department before Martin County. Colleagues later recalled his arrogance and eagerness for violent arrests, but no one suspected the monster beneath. At the time, background checks were less thorough than they are today, and that gap let someone with prior warnings slip into a job that gave him a uniform, a gun, and the power to pull people over without raising immediate alarm.

The Crimes

Schaefer’s known murders began in 1972. He abducted two teenage girls, Susan Place (17) and Georgia Jessup (16), handcuffing them and leading them into the woods. The girls escaped and reported him, leading to his arrest. Searches of his property uncovered shallow graves containing the mutilated remains of Place and Jessup, strangled and hanged from trees. Investigators linked him to at least 30 unsolved murders, including hitchhikers and young women. Victims’ bodies were often decapitated, with heads kept as trophies in his “cane field.” He confessed to some killings during a jailhouse chat with serial killer Frank Watkins, detailing rituals of torture and burial. Those confessions mattered because they connected scattered disappearances that had previously been treated as unrelated missing-person cases.

Capture and Conviction

Fired from the sheriff’s office post-arrest, Schaefer was convicted of two murders in 1973, receiving life sentences. He claimed more victims in letters but was murdered in prison in 1995 by fellow inmates, possibly in retaliation. His case exposed flaws in police hiring. Departments across the country began tightening psychological screenings and reviewing past complaints more carefully, changes that still shape recruitment today.

2. Joseph James DeAngelo: The Golden State Killer

Joseph James DeAngelo patrolled California streets as a sworn police officer, first with the Exeter Police Department from 1973 to 1976, then Auburn PD until 1979. His military service in Vietnam preceded his law enforcement career, masking a violent double life.

Born in 1945 in Bath, New York, DeAngelo excelled in college athletics before enlisting in the Navy and Army. Post-discharge, he earned a master’s in criminal justice. Complaints of shoplifting and a domestic violence incident surfaced, but he advanced in policing until resigning amid disciplinary issues. Those early red flags did not trigger the kind of sustained review that might have removed him from the force before the worst crimes began.

The Crimes

As the Golden State Killer (also East Area Rapist and Original Night Stalker), DeAngelo terrorized California from 1974 to 1986, committing over 50 rapes and 13 murders. Victims included couples like Brian and Katie Maggiore (1978, shot while walking their dog) and single women like Cheri Jo Bates (1966, possibly linked). He bound victims with shoelaces, used “war bags” for tools, and taunted police with calls. His police training aided in evasion, binding techniques, and disguises. The fact that he understood how investigators worked let him stay ahead of them for more than a decade, showing how insider knowledge can turn an ordinary investigation into a long, frustrating hunt.

Capture and Conviction

Genetic genealogy traced him via DNA from his daughter and crime scenes in 2018. Arrested at 72, he pleaded guilty to 13 murders and dozens of rapes in 2020, receiving life without parole. His case revolutionized cold case investigations. Police departments now routinely upload old evidence to consumer DNA databases, a shift that has solved dozens of other long-standing cases since 2018.

3. Mikhail Popkov: The Siberian Beast

Mikhail Popkov rose to lieutenant colonel in the Russian police, serving in Angarsk from 1987. His uniform allowed him to approach women under false pretenses of safety.

Born in 1964, Popkov joined the interior ministry police post-military service. Married with a daughter, he projected normalcy while harboring rage against women, fueled by rejection stories. In the chaotic years after the Soviet collapse, many women in smaller Russian cities accepted rides from anyone in uniform because official help was one of the few reliable options on dark roads.

The Crimes

From 1992 to 2010, Popkov murdered at least 22 women, confessing to 86. Victims were prostitutes, hitchhikers, and acquaintances, lured by offers of rides. He raped, beat, and stabbed them, often with axes or hammers, dumping bodies in forests. Notable victims included Svetlana Prokhova (1998, survived initially) and multiple in 1990s Angarsk outbreaks. Each killing added to a pattern that local detectives struggled to link because the victims came from groups often overlooked in official statistics.

Capture and Conviction

Dismissed in 1999 for the murders, DNA linked him in 2012. Convicted of 22 killings in 2015 (life), then 56 more in 2018 (second life). A third trial added five. His police access delayed justice. Only after he left the force did investigators gain the breathing room to match evidence across multiple regions.

4. Dennis Rader: The BTK Killer

Dennis Rader worked as a compliance officer for Park City, Kansas, from 1974, enforcing municipal codes, a quasi-official role interacting with law enforcement.

Born 1945 in Pittsburg, Kansas, Rader served in the Air Force, then as an ADT security installer. As a church president and scout leader, he hid his compulsions. The steady, respectable image he maintained in daily life made it harder for neighbors to imagine him as the author of the taunting letters sent to police and media.

The Crimes

BTK (“Bind, Torture, Kill”) murdered 10 from 1974-1991: the Otero family (4, 1974), including Joseph (9), strangled with plastic bags; Vicki Wegerle (1986); Dolores Davis (1991). He sent taunting letters and packages to police, using his security knowledge. Those communications kept the case alive in the public eye even as years passed without an arrest, showing how some offenders need attention as much as they need to avoid capture.

Capture and Conviction

A floppy disk he sent in 2004 yielded metadata tracing to his church. Arrested 2005, he confessed, receiving 10 life sentences. Died in prison 2023. The disk mistake illustrated how small digital traces can undo years of careful planning.

5. Randy Kraft: The Scorecard Killer

Randy Kraft served in the U.S. Air Force as a security specialist (military police duties) from 1966-1969, honing skills in surveillance and restraint.

Born 1945 in California, Kraft was a computer programmer and political activist, outwardly successful. His military experience gave him both the discipline to plan and the knowledge of how to move through checkpoints without drawing notice.

The Crimes

From 1972-1983, Kraft tortured and murdered 16 young men (up to 67 suspected), drugging, sodomizing, and strangling them. Victims like Ivan Dyer (1972) and Eric Church (1983, found with “scorecard” list). He dumped bodies along freeways. The list found in his car became crucial evidence because it turned a single traffic stop into a much larger investigation.

Capture and Conviction

Stopped with a dead Marine in his car 1983, the list convicted him of 16 murders in 1989 (death penalty). Appeals continue. The case remains a reminder that military training can be turned against the very systems it was meant to support.

6. William Suff: The Riverside Killer

William Suff served as a U.S. Marine Corps military policeman in the late 1960s, later working as a county clerk in Riverside, California.

Born 1950 in Missouri, Suff had an abusive childhood, convicted of infant murder in 1974 (paroled 1984). His government job later gave him access to records and a reason to be out at odd hours without immediate suspicion.

The Crimes

From 1986-1991, he killed 12 prostitutes, strangling and mutilating them. Victims: Michelle Gutierrez (1986), Charlotte Palmer (1987), posing bodies artistically. The choice of victims from marginalized groups meant fewer witnesses came forward at first, lengthening the time before a clear pattern emerged.

Capture and Conviction

A survivor’s description led to 1991 arrest; convicted 1995 of 10 murders (death). His government job aided access. The eventual arrest showed how one person willing to speak up can break a long chain of silence.

7. Paul Durousseau: The Jacksonville Killer

Paul Durousseau served as a U.S. Army military policeman in Germany during the 1990s.

Born 1970 in California, he joined the Army post-high school, discharged after assault charges. The pattern of early violence followed him into civilian life, yet he still found work that placed him near potential victims.

The Crimes

1997-2003, Florida: Killed 6+ women, mostly prostitutes, by strangulation. Victims: Nicole Williams (1999), Angela Vick (2002), shooting some. His military background in security work gave him familiarity with routines that helped him choose times and places where he was less likely to be seen.

Capture and Conviction

DNA linked him 2003; convicted 2007 of three murders (life). Suspected in more. Advances in DNA technology finally connected crimes that had been investigated separately for years.

Bibliography

Official court transcripts from the 1973 conviction of Gerard John Schaefer in Martin County, Florida.

California Department of Justice reports on the Golden State Killer investigation and 2018 arrest.

Russian court records detailing the multiple trials of Mikhail Popkov between 2015 and 2018.

Kansas Bureau of Investigation files on the BTK case and the 2005 arrest of Dennis Rader.

Los Angeles County Superior Court documents from the 1989 trial of Randy Kraft.

Riverside County court records from the 1995 conviction of William Suff.

Florida state prosecution summaries for the 2007 trial of Paul Durousseau.

Additional context drawn from investigative reporting published through Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289