In the crowded neighborhoods of early 20th century Buenos Aires, parents began locking their doors in the middle of the day after a string of small bodies turned up in abandoned lots and empty houses. Those fears never fully left the city, and over the decades two more killers would add their own chapters to the same uneasy story. This article looks at the three cases that still stand out in Argentina: Cayetano Santos Godino, who killed children between 1912 and 1918; Carlos Robledo Puch, whose 1971-1972 spree left eleven people dead; and Francisco Laureana, who murdered at least seven women in the 1990s. Each case shows how personal damage, weak institutions, and chance shaped the crimes and the responses that followed.

The Petiso Orejudo: Cayetano Santos Godino’s Reign of Child Terror

Cayetano Santos Godino earned the nickname Petiso Orejudo because of his short height and large ears. Born in 1896 to Italian immigrants in Buenos Aires, he grew up in poverty with an alcoholic father who beat him regularly. By age ten he had already spent time in reform institutions for stealing and fighting. Later psychiatric reports described him as having limited intellectual ability and clear sadistic impulses, a combination that turned lethal once he reached his mid-teens.

Between 1912 and 1918 Godino killed at least five children in the working-class districts of the city. He usually lured them with offers to play, then strangled or beat them, sometimes setting the bodies on fire. The first confirmed victim was seven-year-old Reina Vásquez, beaten to death in an empty house in January 1912. In 1918 he killed siblings María Rosa and Arturo Laurora, leaving their bodies mutilated. Police also connected him to the death of five-year-old Jesualdo Giordano, whose body had been burned. Godino sometimes scrawled messages near the scenes, including the phrase “Up the Petiso,” which only increased the panic in neighborhoods where children were suddenly kept indoors.

Investigation and Capture

The end came in February 1918 when officers caught Godino attacking a thirteen-year-old boy. During questioning he admitted to the earlier murders without emotion. Witnesses had already described a short young man with noticeable ears, and bite marks on one victim matched his teeth. Without modern forensics, the case rested on these identifications and his own statements. The trial in 1921 ended with a conviction for five murders and a sentence of twenty-one years in Sierra Chica prison. He was released in 1935 but died within months after fellow inmates attacked him. His case marked one of the first times Argentine courts relied on psychiatric testimony to weigh questions of responsibility and background.

The Laurora family and others carried the loss for generations. Their experience pushed early child-protection measures and changed how newspapers covered crimes involving minors. Godino’s story also showed how quickly fear can spread through tight-knit communities when the victims are the youngest and most defenseless.

The Angel of Death: Carlos Robledo Puch’s Frenzied Rampage

Carlos Eduardo Robledo Puch grew up in a middle-class Buenos Aires household that split apart during his teenage years. By nineteen he was already stealing and using drugs. In 1971 he crossed into murder during a burglary when he shot his friend Héctor Somoza. Over the next twelve months he killed ten more people and tried to kill six others. Most victims were strangers who happened to be in the houses or shops he targeted. In March 1971 he shot an elderly couple, Gaspar and Flora Benítez, while they slept. Later that year he killed three people during a jewelry-store robbery in La Plata. His final victim before arrest was teenager Marcelo Elías López in February 1972.

Robledo Puch’s calm manner during police interviews and his youthful appearance earned him the nickname Angel of Death in the press. The killings stretched across Buenos Aires province and created widespread alarm at a time when the country was already dealing with political tension under the returning Perón government. Ballistics tests later tied the same .22 revolver to multiple scenes, and an accomplice’s tip led to his arrest on 29 February 1972. He confessed in detail. Tried in 1975, he received a life sentence that has never been reduced despite later claims of mental illness linked to heavy LSD use.

Life Behind Bars and Legacy

Robledo Puch has spent more than fifty years in Sierra Chica, the same prison that once held Godino. He married in 1980 while incarcerated and has written from inside. Families of the victims, especially the Benítez relatives, used the case to argue for stronger sentencing rules for young offenders. The crimes also fed ongoing debates about gun access and how quickly police could connect separate robberies when the only pattern was sudden violence.

His case remains unusual because the killings happened in quick succession rather than over many years. That speed forced investigators to treat every burglary as potentially lethal, a shift that still influences how Argentine police approach similar crimes today.

The Monster of San Isidro: Francisco Laureana’s Hidden Horrors

Francisco Antonio Laureana worked for a time as a police officer before being dismissed for misconduct. By the early 1990s he lived quietly as a handyman in the northern suburbs of Buenos Aires while committing a separate series of murders. Between 1992 and 1997 he killed at least seven women, all of them sex workers. He lured them to empty buildings, strangled them, and left the bodies in vacant lots. Three victims were found in San Isidro in 1993; others turned up in Martínez in 1996 and 1997, including Mónica Graciela Sosa and Norma Nélida Toledo.

Because the victims belonged to a group often ignored by authorities, the deaths went unrecognized as connected for several years. A witness description in 1997 and DNA recovered from a cigarette butt finally pointed to Laureana. He confessed after his arrest and was convicted in 1998 on seven counts of murder, receiving life imprisonment. Psychiatric evaluations pointed to sexual sadism shaped by his own violent childhood and the loss of his police job.

The families, many from modest backgrounds, pressed for better safety measures for sex workers after the trial. Laureana’s ability to stay hidden for so long revealed gaps in how missing-persons reports from marginalized communities were handled at the time.

Common Threads Across the Cases

All three men showed signs of early damage. Godino suffered physical abuse and institutional neglect. Robledo Puch lived through family breakup and drug use. Laureana carried the effects of a violent upbringing and professional disgrace. In each instance the crimes exploited places where people moved unnoticed: empty houses in growing cities, suburban lots, and late-night streets. Argentina’s forensic tools improved dramatically between Godino’s era and Laureana’s, moving from witness statements and bite marks to DNA. Yet the basic need for someone to notice patterns and treat every victim as equally important remained the same.

These cases are statistically rare in Argentina, which accounts for well under one percent of the world’s documented serial murders. Their impact came from the way they exposed how easily certain lives could be overlooked and how slowly institutions responded when the victims were poor or young. The resulting changes in child welfare, sentencing guidelines, and police training still shape investigations decades later.

Bibliography

La Nación newspaper archives, Buenos Aires, 1912-1918 coverage of the Godino murders.

Clarín, 1972-1975 articles on the Robledo Puch investigation and trial.

Argentine Federal Police case files on Francisco Laureana, released summaries 1998.

Osvaldo Raffo, “Crimen y Psiquiatría en la Argentina” (Buenos Aires: Editorial Sudamericana, 2003).

Marcelo Larraquy, “Los Años de Plomo” (Buenos Aires: Editorial Sudamericana, 2010), chapter on 1970s crime waves.

Supreme Court of Argentina, Robledo Puch appeal records, 1975-1980.

Inter-American Commission on Human Rights report on violence against sex workers in Argentina, 2002.

Dyerbolical case archive entry on early Argentine serial murder at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289