On a mild November afternoon in 1930, twelve-year-old June Amy Price set off from her school in the small Gippsland town of Leongatha and simply never reached home. Her disappearance marked the start of a six-year nightmare that would see four young girls murdered in strikingly similar circumstances across Victoria, exposing a killer who lived an outwardly ordinary life as a railway worker and family man.
This article examines the full story of Arnold Sodeman, from his unremarkable beginnings to the sequence of crimes that earned him the name Schoolgirl Strangler. It traces the slow police investigation that finally connected the cases, the confession that confirmed his guilt, the swift trial, and the execution that closed the matter in 1936. Along the way it considers the era’s limited forensic tools, the impact on the communities involved, and why the case still stands as a landmark in Australian criminal history.
Early Life and Background
Arnold George Sodeman entered the world on 9 December 1900 in the coastal town of Yarram, Victoria. He grew up in a farming family at a time when rural life meant long hours and limited schooling. Like many boys of his generation, he left formal education at fourteen and moved into a series of manual jobs that offered steady but modest pay. Railway work eventually became his trade, and he rose to the position of ganger, responsible for supervising small crews that maintained tracks across the state.
In 1923 he married Ann Watson. The couple had one daughter and settled into what appeared to be a stable household. Neighbours later described Sodeman as a quiet teetotaller who attended church and kept to himself. Yet some who knew him recalled sudden flashes of temper, especially after he had been drinking, even though he insisted he rarely touched alcohol. These small contradictions only became significant years later, once the murders came to light.
His work took him along quiet stretches of railway line and rural paths where schoolgirls often walked alone. That daily familiarity with the landscape would later prove central to how he committed and concealed his crimes. In the 1930s, when motor traffic was still light outside the cities, such routes offered both opportunity and cover for someone who knew the terrain.
The Crimes: A Pattern of Brutality
Between 1930 and 1936 Sodeman killed four girls, all between the ages of twelve and sixteen. Each attack occurred near railway lines, each victim was strangled, and each showed signs of sexual interference. The consistency of method suggested a single offender, yet the gaps between the murders made the connection difficult for police to establish at the time.
The First Victim: June Price (1930)
June Amy Price disappeared on 9 November 1930 while walking home from school in Leongatha. Her body was found the following day in a gorse bush beside the railway line. She had been strangled with her own stockings and left partially undressed. The coroner recorded bruises indicating she had been held down. Despite door-to-door inquiries and searches of surrounding bushland, no useful leads emerged and the case slowly faded from active attention.
Hazel Wilson (1931)
Eight months later, on 10 July 1931, sixteen-year-old Hazel Vivian Wilson left her family’s farm near Warragul to visit friends. She was found two days later in a paddock close to the railway, strangled with her own jumper. Drag marks showed she had fought back. Police noted the similarities in location and method but lacked the forensic means to prove a link beyond suspicion.
Verona Barton (1935)
After a four-year lull the killings resumed. On 15 October 1935 twelve-year-old Verona May Barton failed to return from school in the Melbourne suburb of Chadstone. Her body was discovered hours later in bushes near a railway siding. She had been manually strangled, with severe bruising to the neck. Newspapers across Victoria warned parents to keep daughters close, and public anxiety rose sharply.
Mary McDonald (1936)
The final murder occurred on New Year’s Day 1936 in Ormond. Twelve-year-old Mary Lorraine McDonald was approached by a man on a motorcycle who offered her a ride. Her body was found that evening near the railway tracks, strangled with a leather strap taken from the killer’s gaiters. Bite marks and other injuries were recorded. The brazen nature of the attack, carried out in daylight during a public holiday, forced authorities to treat the series of deaths as the work of one man.
Each crime left minimal physical evidence. In an age before fingerprint databases or blood typing, investigators relied almost entirely on witness statements and the killer’s own eventual admissions.
The Investigation: Connecting the Dots
Victoria Police formed fresh teams after each murder, yet early inquiries struggled because of the rudimentary tools available. Detectives plotted rail corridors, interviewed thousands of residents, and paid particular attention to railway workers who knew the routes intimately. After Verona Barton’s death, Inspector Jack O’Brien took charge and began to treat the cases as linked by a common offender.
Mary McDonald’s murder supplied the decisive break. Witnesses described a man on a motorcycle with a girl matching her description. When sketches were circulated, Sodeman’s AJS motorcycle stood out. Police visited his home in Ormond on 3 January 1936. Under sustained questioning his calm account of his movements began to unravel. A fragment of leather strap found at the scene matched material from his gaiters, and soil on his boots corresponded to the ground where Mary’s body lay.
Arrest, Confession, and Revelations
Once confronted with the physical inconsistencies, Sodeman confessed to all four murders. He described approaching each girl with an offer of help or a lift before dragging her to a secluded spot. He spoke of sudden “red mist” episodes that overtook him, claiming he sometimes could not recall the details until later. Detectives checked his statements against the unsolved files and found they matched precisely. Throughout the interviews he showed little emotion and offered no apology.
The Trial: Swift Justice
Sodeman appeared in Melbourne’s Supreme Court in March 1936 facing four counts of murder. His defence argued insanity, but medical witnesses testified that he understood the nature of his acts and could distinguish right from wrong. After a short trial the jury returned guilty verdicts on all charges. The death sentence was pronounced on 27 March. Appeals were dismissed and no reprieve was granted.
Psychological Profile: Anatomy of a Predator
Later examination of the case records shows a man who maintained a double life with apparent ease. He returned to his wife and child after each killing and continued working without drawing suspicion from colleagues. His choice of victims and locations indicates careful observation rather than random impulse. In the language of the time he was described as a moral defective; today the pattern aligns with organised serial offending driven by opportunity and compulsion.
Experts who have reviewed the surviving files note that frontal-lobe damage or genetic factors sometimes appear in similar historical cases, though no such testing existed in 1936. What stands out is how ordinary his daily routine remained while the crimes continued.
Execution and Immediate Aftermath
On the morning of 28 June 1936 Arnold Sodeman, aged thirty-five, was hanged at the Old Melbourne Gaol. His last words were reported as “God be with you all.” More than one hundred people witnessed the execution. His body was buried unmarked inside the gaol grounds. Families of the victims attended, seeking whatever closure the sentence could provide. Contemporary newspapers presented the outcome as the necessary end to a terrifying episode.
Legacy: Lessons from the Shadows
The Sodeman case became one of the first in Australia in which police consciously linked multiple murders through similar method and location. It demonstrated both the strengths and the limits of policing in the 1930s and helped shape later approaches to serial offending. Safety campaigns aimed at schoolchildren gained renewed attention, and the story continues to appear in studies of Australian criminal justice.
Memorials and annual remembrances still take place in Leongatha and Ormond. The four girls, June Price, Hazel Wilson, Verona Barton and Mary McDonald, are remembered by name in local records. Their deaths remain a stark reminder of how quickly ordinary routines can be shattered when violence hides behind a familiar face. Further discussion of the case and its place in Australian true-crime history can be found at Dyerbolical.
Bibliography
Victorian Police historical files on the Sodeman investigation, 1930–1936.
The Age and Argus newspaper coverage, Melbourne, 1930–1936.
Supreme Court of Victoria trial transcripts, R v Sodeman, March 1936.
National Library of Australia Trove archive of contemporary reporting.
Ian Jobling, forensic psychology notes on early Australian strangulation cases.
Victorian Government Gazette, execution records, June 1936.
Local historical society publications, Leongatha and Ormond districts.
State Library of Victoria, coronial inquest documents for each victim.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
