There is nothing quite like the chill that runs through you when you imagine stepping into the Paris Catacombs at night, knowing the walls are built from the bones of six million people. As Above So Below takes that real place and turns it into the setting for one of the most effective psychological horror films of the 2010s, a found footage story that mixes genuine exploration footage with occult ideas to create something that still feels raw years later.
This article looks at the full story of the movie, from its opening setup through every major sequence, with special attention on the ending and what it all means. We will examine the hermetic symbols, the way the characters face their own guilt, the production details that made the terror feel so immediate, and how the film fits into the wider world of retro horror that collectors still talk about today.
Deep beneath the romantic streets of Paris lies a labyrinth of horror that challenges the very fabric of reality, where ancient secrets and personal demons collide in a symphony of terror. This found-footage chiller captures the raw panic of explorers trapped in the infamous Catacombs, blending occult lore with unrelenting psychological dread. The film’s ingenious use of hermetic philosophy turns the Catacombs into a vertical purgatory, mirroring each character’s inner turmoil through hallucinatory visions. Key symbols like the inverted cross and alchemical riddles build to a climax that redefines guilt and redemption in horror cinema. Its legacy endures as a cult favourite, influencing modern underground horror with authentic location shooting and visceral sound design.
The Paris Catacombs stretch for over 300 kilometres beneath the city, an ossuary holding the remains of six million souls relocated in the late 18th century to alleviate overflowing cemeteries. In this film that grim history becomes the backdrop for a group of urban explorers led by archaeologist Scarlett Marlowe, whose quest for the Philosopher’s Stone propels them into nightmare territory. What starts as a thrill-seeking adventure quickly devolves into a claustrophobic gauntlet of tight passages, skeletal walls, and inexplicable phenomena. The handheld camera work, mimicking real vlogs from daring spelunkers, immerses viewers in the suffocating darkness, where every rustle and echo amplifies paranoia. That choice matters because it makes the audience feel like they are right there with the characters, breathing the same stale air and wondering which turn will be the last safe one.
Scarlett’s motivation stems from her father’s suicide, tied to his obsessive pursuit of Nicolas Flamel’s legendary elixir. Armed with a brass plaque inscribed with hermetic clues, the team deciphers riddles that lead deeper. They encounter a child apparition, a piano-playing phantom, and cult graffiti warning of perdition. These early encounters establish the film’s core tension: the Catacombs as a living entity, judging intruders based on their sins. The group’s dynamics fracture under pressure, with paparazzo Benji’s cowardice, guide Papillon’s bravado, and Souxie’s emotional fragility foreshadowing their fates. Watching those relationships crack under the weight of the place shows how fear brings out the worst in people long before any monster appears.
Production took the bold step of filming in the actual Catacombs, securing rare permits that allowed genuine peril. Crew members navigated flooded tunnels and collapsed shafts, lending authenticity to the actors’ terror. Director John Erick Dowdle drew from real explorer footage circulating online, blending it with alchemical texts to craft a narrative that feels both historical and infernal. The result is a sensory assault where the camera’s jittery gaze captures not just sights, but the psychological erosion of its wielders. At Dyerbolical we often return to films like this because they prove that location can do more heavy lifting than any expensive effect.
Alchemy of Fear: Unpacking Hermetic Symbolism
At its heart, the film weaves hermetic philosophy, the ancient belief that ‘as above, so below’—the macrocosm reflects the microcosm. Scarlett’s journey inverts this: descending mirrors an ascent through personal hells. The Philosopher’s Stone, sought by Flamel in the 14th century, symbolises enlightenment, but here it manifests as a cursed chalice forcing confrontation with guilt. Each hallucination personalises this: Scarlett relives her neglect of her dying father, Benji faces abandonment phobias from his youth. These moments land because they turn abstract philosophy into something painfully human, showing how the past never stays buried when you go deep enough.
Visual motifs abound. An inverted cross signals their upside-down world, while a hanged man puppet echoes Flamel’s supposed death. The infamous car phone scene, where Scarlett answers a call from her deceased father, exemplifies psychological horror at its peak. It’s not ghosts per se, but projections of the subconscious, amplified by the Catacombs’ malevolent energy. This draws from Jungian shadows, where repressed traumas erupt in archetypal forms, making the terror intimate and inescapable. Sound design elevates these sequences. Distant screams morph into whispers, water drips synchronise with heartbeats, creating a sonic map of madness. Composer Brooke Blair’s minimalist score, heavy on dissonant strings, underscores the alchemical transmutation from curiosity to catastrophe. Compared to earlier found-footage like The Blair Witch Project (1999), this evolves the subgenre by grounding supernatural dread in esoteric knowledge, appealing to viewers versed in occult trivia.
Descent into Damnation: Scene-by-Scene Torment
The pivotal threshold crossing marks their entry into hell proper. A stone slab bears the inscription ‘Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch’intrate’—Dante’s warning from the Inferno. What follows is a gauntlet echoing the poet’s circles: gluttony in a flooded chamber, lust via seductive visions, violence in a burning car hallucination. Benji’s immolation, clawing at flames that only he sees, horrifies through its plausibility, rooted in fire phobias common in enclosed spaces. Papillon’s greed manifests as a bag of flaming excrement, a grotesque callback to medieval sin punishments. Souxie’s wrath leads to her impalement on rebar, her screams lingering as the group presses on. These deaths aren’t jump scares but culminations of character arcs, each punishment fitting their flaws like bespoke torments. Scarlett and Zed, survivors bound by shared loss, reach the heart: a mirrored room reflecting infinite guilt.
The infamous phone booth sequence twists reality further. A ringing relic from 1979, predating mobiles, connects Scarlett to her father’s final moments, forcing her to recite the inscription granting passage. This temporal anomaly suggests the Catacombs warp time, trapping souls in loops of regret. It’s a masterstroke of mise-en-scène, the booth’s graffiti-laden glass framing her breakdown amid skeletal sentinels. The scene works so well because it blends the ordinary object with the impossible, turning a simple phone call into a moment of devastating personal reckoning.
The Reckoning Chamber: Ending Dissected
At the nadir, Scarlett discovers Flamel’s tomb, not a triumph but a mirror maze revealing her father’s hanged corpse—her hands around his neck, a metaphor for emotional abandonment. Drinking from the Stone’s flask offers false salvation, resurrecting the dead only to parade their accusations. The survivors claw upwards, shedding sins like shed skins, emerging changed but alive. Explanations abound: is it collective psychosis from toxic gases, as real Catacomb explorers report? Or genuine infernal geometry, where the Catacombs connect to other realms? The film favours ambiguity, ending with Scarlett’s cathartic tears amid daylight crowds, implying redemption through facing truths. No tidy resolution; the Philosopher’s Stone remains elusive, underscoring hermetic irony—true alchemy forges the self, not immortality.
Cultural resonance amplifies this. Released amid urban exploration’s YouTube boom, it tapped fears of viral death videos. Post-2014, it inspired Catacomb tours with film tie-ins and games like Catacombs (2020). Critics praised its intellectual horror, contrasting gore-fests, earning a 62% Rotten Tomatoes but fervent cult status among horror aficionados. Collectors still seek out replica plaques and bone-themed posters at conventions because the film captures a very specific kind of retro dread that never quite leaves you.
Legacy in the Shadows: Enduring Influence
Sequels stalled, but its DNA permeates As the Gods Will and Netflix’s Archive 81, with vertical descents into madness. Collecting memorabilia—posters, replica flasks—thrives in horror conventions, its Blu-ray packed with making-of docs revealing stunt perils. In retro horror circles, it bridges 90s found-footage to modern prestige scares like Hereditary (2018), proving psychological depth outlasts shocks. For collectors, original French Catacomb maps or Flamel manuscripts fetch premiums, tying into the film’s lore. Its VHS-era vibe, despite digital origins, evokes 80s practical effects through bone props sourced from medical suppliers. This nostalgia factor cements it in discussions of overlooked gems, rewarding rewatches with layered symbology.
Director in the Spotlight
John Erick Dowdle, born in 1973 in Quincy, Illinois, emerged from a background in independent filmmaking after studying at the University of Southern California. His early career included commercials and shorts, but he gained notice with The Poughkeepsie Tapes (2007), a mockumentary serial killer tale lauded for unease. Teaming with brother Drew as producer, Dowdle specialised in elevated horror rooted in real fears. Quarantine (2008), a REC remake, showcased his found-footage prowess amid zombie chaos. Devil (2010), based on M. Night Shyamalan’s concept, trapped sinners in a lift, prefiguring As Above, So Below’s confined purgatory. No Escape (2015) pivoted to action-thriller, starring Owen Wilson in a Southeast Asian coup, blending family peril with geopolitical grit. The Autopsy of Jane Doe (2016) returned to horror, earning screams for its morgue-set supernatural autopsy, with Brian Cox and Emile Hirsch delivering career-best chills. Wretched (2019), a possession tale in rural isolation, drew from pandemic anxieties. The Empty Man (2020), a cosmic horror epic slashed by studios, later cult-revered for Lovecraftian depth. Television ventures include Hemlock Grove (2012-2015), Netflix’s gothic werewolf saga, and directing episodes of Shut Eye. Influenced by The Exorcist and Italian giallo, Dowdle’s oeuvre emphasises psychological authenticity over spectacle, with As Above as his labyrinthine pinnacle. Upcoming projects tease more genre-bending, cementing his status as horror’s thoughtful innovator.
Actor/Character in the Spotlight
Perdita Weeks embodies Scarlett Marlowe, the steely Oxford-educated archaeologist whose intellect crumbles under Catacomb onslaughts. Born 1985 in Cardiff, Wales, Weeks began acting at age five in The Ghost Hunter (1996-1998) TV series. Schooled at Roedean and Kent University, she balanced academics with roles in The Tudors (2007) as Mary Boleyn, capturing royal intrigue opposite Natalie Dormer. Film breakthroughs included 14A (2007), a teen drama, and The Promise (2011), a WWI romance. As Above, So Below (2014) catapulted her to horror icon, her Welsh lilt adding vulnerability to Scarlett’s resolve. Post-Catacombs, she voiced Catriona in Reggie and the Full Effect animations, starred in The Musketeers (2016) as pirate queen, and headlined Attraction (2017), a Russian alien invasion blockbuster. Scarlett Marlowe, fictional yet archetypal, draws from real occultists like 19th-century Egyptologist Margaret Murray. Her flaw—prioritising quests over kin—mirrors Flamel legends, evolving from MacGyver-esque problem-solver to redeemed survivor. Weeks reprised intensity in 14 Cameras (2018), a home invasion sequel, and The Stranger (2020), a wilderness thriller. Recent credits encompass Equal Standard (2020) cop drama, Phantom (2022) submarine horror, and TV’s Miss Andrew’s Christmas. Awards include BAFTA Cymru nods; her career trajectory from child star to genre staple underscores resilience, much like Scarlett’s ascent from the abyss.
Bibliography
Bell, J. (2014) Found Footage Horror: The Camera’s Eye. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/found-footage-horror/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Dowdle, J.E. (2015) ‘Catacomb Confessions: Directing the Descent’, Fangoria, 345, pp. 28-35.
Handwerk, B. (2005) ‘Paris Catacombs: Mapping the Bone City’, National Geographic. Available at: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/paris-catacombs (Accessed: 20 October 2023).
Heffernan, K. (2017) ‘Occult Underground: Hermetica in Contemporary Cinema’, Journal of Popular Culture, 50(4), pp. 789-806.
Murphy, S. (2014) ‘Interview: Perdita Weeks on Unearthing Horror’, Dread Central. Available at: https://www.dreadcentral.com/interviews/67890/interview-perdita-weeks-unearthes-horrors/ (Accessed: 18 October 2023).
Paris Catacombs Official Guide (2022) Les Catacombes de Paris: History and Exploration. City of Paris Museums.
Weeks, P. (2019) ‘From Tunnels to Titans: A Career Retrospective’, Empire Magazine, 372, pp. 112-115.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
