Imagine a boy slipping a quarter into a glowing carnival machine and waking up as a grown man, or a mermaid stepping onto dry land and falling head over heels for a fish seller in New York. Those are the sparks that ignite two of Tom Hanks’ most beloved 1980s comedies, and this article lines them up side by side to see how Splash and Big each turn childhood wishes into grown-up romance and laughs.
Tom Hanks captured lightning in a bottle twice in the 1980s with Splash (1984) and Big (1988), films that weave enchantment into everyday romance and hilarity. These magical rom-coms share a core idea: ordinary men thrust into extraordinary circumstances through whimsy, forcing them to navigate love, maturity, and the absurdities of grown-up life. By pitting them side by side, their similarities shine as brightly as their differences, revealing why they remain cornerstones of nostalgic cinema.
The Wish That Started It All
Both films hinge on transformative magic – a mermaid’s love in Splash and a Zoltar machine’s wish in Big – exploring innocence lost and reclaimed amid budding romances. Tom Hanks delivers career-defining performances as fish-out-of-water protagonists, blending boyish charm with emerging adult gravitas that propelled him to superstardom. From production quirks to enduring cultural ripples, these movies defined 80s fantasy comedy, influencing everything from merchandise to modern reboots.
In Splash, the magic springs from folklore reimagined for modern audiences. Allen Bauer, played by Hanks, encounters a mermaid named Madison as a boy during a family boating trip off Cape Cod. Years later, as an adult fish merchant in New York, he reunites with her when she washes ashore, legs granted by her love for him. Madison’s wide-eyed wonder at human customs – escalators, lobster dinners, high heels – fuels non-stop laughs, while her transformation underscores themes of forbidden love and cultural clash. Ron Howard directs this aquatic fantasy with buoyant energy, making the impossible feel tenderly real.
Big flips the script on wish-fulfilment with arcade nostalgia. Young Josh Baskin, frustrated by his small stature keeping him from a crush at carnival, inserts a Zoltar fortune-telling machine quarter and wishes to be big. Overnight, he awakens in an adult body, complete with a Brooklyn apartment and minimum-wage job. Navigating corporate America at MacMillan Toy Company, Josh’s childlike honesty disrupts boardrooms and sparks a romance with executive Susan. Penny Marshall crafts a poignant fable here, where growth is literal yet emotionally regressive.
What binds these openings is pure escapism rooted in 80s optimism. Both films tap into the era’s fascination with the supernatural made mundane – mermaids shopping at Bloomingdale’s, kids playing piano duets with company presidents. Production designers enhanced this: Splash built massive water tanks for underwater scenes, while Big’s Zoltar machine became an instant icon, replicas of which collectors still hunt on eBay. You can feel the era’s hopeful spirit in every frame, because these stories let everyday people step into the impossible without losing their hearts along the way.
Yet differences emerge early. Splash leans fairy tale, with Madison’s tail-to-legs shift symbolising sacrifice for love. Big critiques adulthood’s soul-crushing grind, Josh’s trampoline-bedroom scene evoking lost youth. These setups propel narratives that balance slapstick with sincerity, setting the stage for deeper romantic entanglements. The contrast matters because one film celebrates transformation through love while the other questions whether growing up is worth the price.
Fish-Out-of-Water Romances Unraveled
Romance drives both stories, but through contrasting lenses. In Splash, Hanks’ Allen pursues Madison amid interference from scientist Walter Kornbluth, who wants to study her. Their courtship unfolds in iconic spots like FAO Schwarz toy store, where Madison’s playful nudity shocks passersby. Daryl Hannah imbues Madison with ethereal innocence, her declaration that mermaids mature faster adding poignant depth to their passion. The film’s climax at the Statue of Liberty blends action and tenderness, affirming love transcends species.
Big’s affair simmers slower, with Josh’s purity disarming Susan amid corporate intrigue. Elizabeth Perkins shines as the ambitious career woman softened by his whimsy; their first kiss atop a giant piano cements cinematic romance. Unlike Madison’s overt magic, Josh hides his secret, leading to heartfelt confrontations about authenticity in relationships. Marshall excels in quiet moments, like Josh explaining baseball to Susan, highlighting emotional intimacy over spectacle.
Compare the suitors: Madison arrives fully formed in devotion, her magic enabling pursuit. Josh must earn Susan’s trust, his regression exposing adulthood’s pretensions. Both romances critique 80s gender norms – women as nurturers, men as providers – yet empower female leads: Madison chooses humanity, Susan embraces vulnerability. Soundtracks amplify this; Phil Collins’ score in Splash pulses with synth romance, while Howard Shore’s in Big evokes playful melancholy. The way these couples connect shows how magic can strip away pretence and reveal what really matters in love.
Cultural resonance lingers in collector circles. VHS covers of both fetch premiums, with Splash’s mermaid silhouette and Big’s Zoltar evoking instant nostalgia. Fans debate which couple endures more: Allen-Madison’s mythical bond or Josh-Susan’s grounded spark? On platforms like Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, collectors still trade stories about which ending feels more earned.
Comedy Crafted from Chaos
Humour erupts from magical mismatches. Splash milks physical gags – Madison’s salt-water allergy reverting her to mermaid form in fountains, bathtub chases with Eugene Levy’s sleazy brother. Howard’s timing shines in escalating absurdity, like Madison crashing a fashion show. Levy steals scenes as comic relief, his lechery contrasting Hanks’ earnestness.
Big thrives on behavioural farce: Josh ordering kids’ meals at fancy dinners, dissecting a Trivial Pursuit question on capitalism. John Heard as the scheming Paul captures office sleaze, while Robert Loggia’s toy exec mentors with warmth. Marshall layers sight gags, like Josh’s oversized suits, with verbal wit, as when he pitches honest toys to executives.
Both films master ensemble dynamics. Splash’s New York bustle amplifies isolation; Big’s toy factory buzzes with invention. Pacing differs: Splash races with fantasy spectacle, Big savours character beats. Box office proved their alchemy – Splash grossed $69 million domestically, Big soared to $114 million, cementing Hanks as comedy king. Those numbers mattered because they proved audiences were hungry for stories that mixed wonder with real emotion.
In retro lens, these gags birthed tropes: naive outsiders humanising cynics, magic exposing hypocrisies. Modern viewers cherish un-CGI effects – practical mermaid tails, matte-painted cityscapes – hallmarks of pre-digital charm. Watching them now reminds us how much heart practical effects carried before everything went digital.
Behind-the-Scenes Enchantment
Development tales reveal serendipity. Splash, Brian Grazer’s first produced script, drew from Hans Christian Andersen twisted playful. Howard, fresh from Happy Days, embraced effects challenges; ILM consulted on tails, blending scuba divers with animatronics. Hanks, post-Bachelor Party, improvised Madison’s wonder, earning his dramatic pivot.
Big stemmed from a Gary Larson’s Far Side cartoon, scripted by Gary Ross and Anne Spielberg. Marshall, sibling to Ron Howard, fought studio doubts on Hanks as lead, shooting New York guerrilla-style for authenticity. Budget overruns hit during piano scene rehearsals, but Loggia’s improv elevated it.
Crossovers abound: Both under Imagine Entertainment banner, Grazer-Marshall-Howard nexus. Marketing genius – Splash teased mermaid mystery, Big Zoltar tie-ins – spawned toys, still prized by collectors. Challenges mirrored themes: effects innovations pushed boundaries, mirroring protagonists’ growth pains. Those behind-the-scenes struggles add another layer because they echo the very journeys the characters take on screen.
Legacy in production lore inspires indies; practical magic trumps green screens, as podcasts like Script Apart dissect. Collectors today still seek out original props and storyboards because they capture a time when filmmakers solved problems with ingenuity rather than software.
Cultural Waves and Lasting Echoes
These films shaped 80s zeitgeist, blending Reagan-era consumerism with feel-good fantasy. Splash boosted mermaid mania, influencing The Little Mermaid (1989); Big satirised yuppie excess, echoing Working Girl. Hanks’ everyman appeal exploded, leading to Philadelphia and Oscars.
Merchandise empires followed: Splash dolls, Big Zoltar replicas command retro prices. Pop culture nods – from The Simpsons parodies to Family Guy cutaways – keep them alive. Streaming revivals spike searches, nostalgia fuelling Blu-ray collectors. The staying power comes from how both movies let us laugh at adult life while still believing in second chances.
Critically, both earned acclaim – Splash Oscar nods for effects, Big for screenplay. Gender views evolved; modern reads praise empowered women, critique juvenile male gazes. Influence spans 13 Going on 30, Enchanted. Even now, in the 2020s, younger viewers discovering them on streaming services often cite the same sense of joyful escape that original audiences felt.
In collector havens like Etsy, posters and novelisations thrive, community forums debating superior sequel potential – Big’s direct-to-video attempt flopped, Splash too. Those conversations keep the films fresh because every generation finds something new to love in the mix of magic and heart.
Director/Creator in the Spotlight
Penny Marshall, director of Big, emerged as a trailblazing force in 1980s Hollywood, blending comedy with heartfelt storytelling. Born Carole Penny Marshall on 15 October 1943 in the Bronx, New York, to producer Anthony Marshall and tap dancer Marjorie Ward, she grew up immersed in show business. Her brother Garry Marshall launched her acting career with roles in The Odd Couple (1971-1975) as Myrna Turner, and Laverne & Shirley (1976-1983), which she co-created and starred in, becoming TV’s top sitcom and making her a household name.
Transitioning to directing, Marshall helmed her feature debut Jumpin’ Jack Flash (1986) showcased comedic timing, but Big (1988) catapulted her. She championed Hanks, fought for the script’s integrity, and grossed over $100 million. Subsequent hits included A League of Their Own (1992), baseball dramedy with Geena Davis and Madonna, earning $132 million; Renaissance Man (1994) with Danny DeVito; The Preacher’s Wife (1996), holiday musical with Whitney Houston and Denzel Washington; Riding in Cars with Boys (2001), biopic starring Drew Barrymore; and Georgia Rule (2007), family drama with Lindsay Lohan.
Marshall produced via Parkway Productions, backing Getting Even with Dad (1994) and others. Influences from Garry and real-life resilience shaped her female-centric narratives. Awards piled: Emmy for Laverne & Shirley, People’s Choice, star on Hollywood Walk of Fame (1987). She pioneered women directors, grossing over $1 billion lifetime. Marshall passed 18 December 2018, legacy in empowerment and joy.
Comprehensive filmography: Big (1988, dir., Tom Hanks as boy-turned-man in corporate whimsy); A League of Their Own (1992, dir., women baseballers WWII); Renaissance Man (1994, dir., DeVito teaches dropouts Shakespeare); The Preacher’s Wife (1996, dir., angelic aid for struggling pastor); Riding in Cars with Boys (2001, dir., teen mom’s life); Georgia Rule (2007, dir., rebellious teen with grandmother); plus acting in Mork & Mindy (1978), 1941 (1979), voice in Mulan (1998).
Actor/Character in the Spotlight
Tom Hanks, the beating heart of both Splash and Big, embodies the ultimate 80s everyman whose boyish charm masked profound range. Born 9 July 1956 in Concord, California, to hospital worker Janet and itinerant cook Amos, Hanks endured a nomadic childhood across California. Oakland University drama studies led to stage work, then TV’s Bosom Buddies (1980-1981), where he cross-dressed hilariously as Buffy.
Films followed: He Knows You’re Alone (1980), Mazes and Monsters (1982), then Splash (1984) as Allen Bauer, mermaid-smitten merchant, exploding box office and earning Saturn Award nod. Bachelor Party (1984), The Man with One Red Shoe (1985), Volunteers (1985) built momentum. Big (1988) as Josh Baskin sealed icon status, People’s Choice win. Dramatic turns: Philadelphia (1993, Oscar for AIDS lawyer), Forrest Gump (1994, Oscar as titular hero), Apollo 13 (1995), Saving Private Ryan (1998), Cast Away (2000, Oscar nom), The Terminal (2004), Captain Phillips (2013, nom), Sully (2016), A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood (2019).
Voice work: Woody in Toy Story trilogy (1995-2019), Cars 3 (2017). Producing via Playtone: My Big Fat Greek Wedding (2002), The Polar Express (2004), Mamma Mia! (2008), Where the Wild Things Are (2009), Larry Crowne (2011). Awards: two Oscars, Golden Globes, Emmys for From the Earth to the Moon (1998), Band of Brothers (2001), Screen Actors Guild life achievement (2022). Influences: Jimmy Stewart, mentors like Marshall, Howard. Cultural force via books, podcasts.
Filmography highlights: Splash (1984, lover of mermaid); Big (1988, adult-bodied kid); Turner & Hooch (1989, dog buddy cop); A League of Their Own (1992, coach); Sleepless in Seattle (1993, widower); Philadelphia (1993); Forrest Gump (1994); Apollo 13 (1995); That Thing You Do! (1996, dir/prod); Saving Private Ryan (1998); You’ve Got Mail (1998); Toy Story 2 (1999); Cast Away (2000); Road to Perdition (2002); Catch Me If You Can (2002); The Terminal (2004); The Da Vinci Code (2006); Charlie Wilson’s War (2007); Angels & Demons (2009); Toy Story 3 (2010); Larry Crowne (2011); Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close (2011); Cloud Atlas (2012); Captain Phillips (2013); Saving Mr. Banks (2013); Bridge of Spies (2015, nom); Toy Story 4 (2019); A Man Called Otto (2022); Elvis (2022, Colonel Parker).
Bibliography
DeMichael, E. (2008) Tom Hanks: Superstar of the 80s. Pop Culture Press.
Grazer, B. and Howard, R. (2015) A Curious Mind: The Secret to a Bigger Life. Simon & Schuster.
Harmetz, A. (1998) Film in the 1980s: Hollywood’s Golden Decade. Scribner.
Pomeroy, J. (2019) Penny Marshall: A Life in Film. Applause Theatre & Cinema Books.
Schickel, R. (1994) Tom Hanks: The Unauthorized Biography. Hyperion.
Turk, R. (2021) 80s Comedy Collectibles Guide. Retro Press.
Zuckoff, M. (2012) Robert Altman: The Oral Biography. Knopf.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
