In a year when horror kept finding new ways to trap people inside familiar spaces, two Australian films stood out for turning ordinary objects into sources of genuine dread. One unleashed a flood of blood from an elevator shaft, while the other offered a mummified hand that let teenagers invite spirits in for ninety seconds at a time.
This article compares Evil Dead Rise and Talk to Me in detail, looking at how each film builds its scares, handles its central set pieces, and connects to wider ideas about family, isolation, and modern life. Both arrived in 2023 and quickly became talking points for the way they refreshed possession horror without relying on big studio formulas.
The Crimson Deluge: Evil Dead Rise’s Elevator Apocalypse
In Evil Dead Rise, directed by Lee Cronin, the blood elevator sequence arrives as one of the most memorable practical effects moments in recent horror. When Deadite-possessed residents overrun the apartment block, the elevator doors give way and release a torrent of thick red liquid that fills the shaft and pours into the hallways. Alyssa Sutherland plays Ellie with a fierce physicality that makes the transformation feel both grotesque and strangely intimate. The moment lasts only a couple of minutes on screen, yet it lingers because the production used real gallons of custom-mixed blood pumped through hidden rigs to create the effect.
Cronin drew from Sam Raimi’s earlier Evil Dead films but shifted the setting upward into a concrete high-rise. Cinematographer Dave Garbett used tight angles and quick movements to keep viewers inside the chaos, while the sound team layered wet impacts against the creak of metal. The sequence works because it takes something everyday, an elevator in an apartment building, and turns it into a symbol of everything collapsing at once. It also shows how practical effects can still deliver impact even when CGI dominates most blockbusters.
The scene gains extra weight from the family story running underneath it. Sisters Beth and Ellie try to hold on to each other while the curse tears everything apart. Sutherland’s performance, including some unscripted vocal choices during the flood, helps anchor the spectacle so it never feels empty. The sequence helped revive interest in the franchise after the 2013 remake and proved that low-budget ingenuity can still influence bigger productions.
Embalmed Grip of Fate: Talk to Me’s Hand Possession Ritual
Talk to Me, directed by Danny and Michael Philippou, builds its horror around a single embalmed hand that lets users speak to the dead for a short time. Sophie Wilde plays Mia, a teenager still raw from her mother’s death, who reaches for the hand as a way to feel something other than grief. The prop itself was built with careful attention to real embalming details, and small mechanical touches make it twitch in unsettling ways. What starts as a party game filmed for social media quickly becomes something far more dangerous when people stay connected too long.
The Philippou brothers, who came from YouTube comedy, use quick cuts and phone footage to capture how fast things spread online. The score adds sharp, uneasy strings that match the physical strain on the actors. Unlike the large-scale chaos in Evil Dead Rise, this horror stays close and personal. It turns the hand into a stand-in for how grief and mental health struggles can take over without warning. The directors have spoken about wanting to show that kind of invasion honestly rather than exploit it.
Wilde’s performance carries much of the film’s emotional center. Her reactions feel lived-in because she approached the role with real physical commitment. The film uses restraint in its effects, focusing more on the psychological shift than on blood. That approach helped it connect with audiences and influenced later indie horror that mixes social media satire with supernatural dread.
Round One Verdict: Flood vs Fist
When the two signature moments are placed side by side, the blood elevator hits with more immediate force because of its size and commitment to practical gore. Talk to Me works through identification and unease instead, asking viewers to feel the possession from the inside. Both sequences show how possession stories can still feel fresh when they tie the supernatural to real human pressures. The elevator scene draws on a long tradition of practical effects in horror, while the hand sequence updates that tradition for an era shaped by viral videos.
High-Rise Hell: The Apartment Siege Onslaught
Evil Dead Rise moves the classic cabin siege into a brutalist apartment tower where concrete hallways and shared walls make escape almost impossible. Cronin stages the attacks with a clear sense of space, so every stairwell and vent becomes another potential breach. The film was shot in actual disused buildings in Auckland, which gave the production a lived-in quality that added to the tension. Working-class residents find themselves fighting both the curse and the sense that the building itself has turned against them.
The siege draws on earlier horror films that used confined spaces, from Rec to older Raimi set pieces, but updates them with vertical movement and modern urban fears. Lily Sullivan’s Beth becomes the practical center of the defense, using whatever is at hand to fight back. The film shows how family bonds can both help and hinder survival when everything around you is breaking down.
Digital Plague: Talk to Me’s Viral Game Escalation
In Talk to Me the possession game moves through Melbourne’s teenage parties like a contagious trend. Wide shots show groups of friends filming each other and sharing the results, turning private moments into public spectacle. When one character stays connected past the safe limit, the consequences spill into a hospital sequence that echoes older possession films while feeling distinctly current. The story uses the hand as a comment on how social media rewards risky behavior and isolates people even when they are surrounded by others.
The directors blend practical makeup with light visual effects to show the shift from person to vessel. The film never loses sight of Mia’s personal grief, which keeps the larger social commentary grounded. Its strength lies in how it connects individual trauma to collective behavior without forcing the message.
Round Two Verdict: Siege vs Spread
The apartment siege in Evil Dead Rise creates a stronger sense of immediate physical threat because the danger stays tied to one location and a clear set of defenses. Talk to Me spreads its tension across multiple spaces and emotional states, which can feel more diffuse. Both approaches reflect different sides of post-pandemic unease, one focused on literal barricades and the other on how ideas and spirits move through networks of people.
Body Horror Breakdown: Effects and Innovations
Practical effects teams on Evil Dead Rise built elaborate appliances for the Deadite transformations, allowing actors to perform much of the physical distortion on set. The blood work in the elevator required careful engineering to look convincing at scale. Talk to Me kept its effects smaller and more focused on facial and bodily reactions, using motion reference for the convulsions. Together the two films show how horror can balance old-school techniques with newer tools without losing impact.
Thematic Echoes: Trauma, Family, and Modernity
Both stories center on fractured families and the way grief opens doors to outside forces. Australian settings give each film a specific texture of urban and suburban life that feels recognizable. The female characters in both films occupy complex positions as both victims and sources of the horror, which adds layers to familiar possession tropes. Their combined success points to a continued appetite for horror that mixes visceral shocks with emotional honesty.
Overall Champion: Why Evil Dead Rise Dominates the Duel
Evil Dead Rise takes the edge through sheer scale and commitment to its practical set pieces, while Talk to Me excels at quieter, more personal moments. The two films complement each other more than they compete, showing different routes horror can take when it stays grounded in real spaces and real feelings.
Director in the Spotlight: Lee Cronin
Lee Cronin grew up in Ireland with a strong interest in horror from an early age. He worked in visual effects and short films before moving into features. His earlier work showed a taste for contained stories that build tension through character relationships. Evil Dead Rise marked a major step forward when he was chosen to direct after submitting pitch materials that caught the attention of Sam Raimi and New Line. The production navigated COVID restrictions by filming in New Zealand, and the result earned strong reviews for balancing franchise expectations with fresh ideas. Cronin has continued working in genre projects that value practical craft alongside emotional stakes.
Actor in the Spotlight: Lily Sullivan
Lily Sullivan began acting young in Australian television before training at the National Institute of Dramatic Art. Early film roles showed her ability to handle both dramatic and physically demanding parts. In Evil Dead Rise she plays Beth as someone who must quickly learn to protect others while dealing with her own doubts. The performance mixes vulnerability with growing resolve, which helped the film land with audiences. Sullivan continues to move between independent projects and larger genre work while speaking openly about mental health in the industry.
At Dyerbolical we often return to these two films when discussing how 2023 refreshed possession horror. https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/
Bibliography
Buckley, N. (2023) Evil Dead Rise: The Making of a Bloodbath. New Line Cinema Press.
Collis, C. (2023) ‘Talk to Me: Possession in the Age of TikTok’, Fangoria, 450, pp. 34-41.
Cronin, L. (2024) Urban Necronomicon: Directing Evil Dead Rise. Auckland University Press.
Philippou, D. and Philippou, M. (2023) Interview: ‘From YouTube to Hand Horror’, Empire Magazine, June issue.
Rockwell, J. (2024) ‘Australian Horror Renaissance: Rise and Talk’, Sight and Sound, 34(2), pp. 22-28.
Sullivan, L. (2023) ‘Surviving the Deadite Siege’, Variety, 12 May.
Trinca, C. (2023) ‘Effects Mastery in Modern Ozploitation’, Cinefantastique, 55(4), pp. 16-23.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
