The fog rolls in thick over Crockett Island, carrying whispers of salvation that twist into something far more intimate and unsettling. In Mike Flanagan’s Midnight Mass, the line between holy miracle and monstrous hunger blurs in ways that speak directly to those who have felt their own desires marked as forbidden.
This article explores how the series uses vampiric imagery to examine queer awakening, repressed longing, and the clash between rigid faith and personal truth. It traces the story’s roots in classic horror while showing how Flanagan turns an isolated community into a stage for transformation and defiance.
The Fanged Seraph: Monstrosity as Queer Liberation
The creature at the heart of Midnight Mass defies tidy classification, blending the vampire’s seductive hunger with an angelic visage that evokes both divine rapture and infernal temptation. This entity, introduced as a miraculous emissary from the sea, embodies a queer archetype: the beautiful outsider whose arrival disrupts the rigid heteronormative order of Crockett Island. Its pale, elongated form, with wings like tattered veils and eyes gleaming with primordial need, recalls the androgynous allure of classic vampire lore, from the gender-fluid revenants of Eastern European folklore to the baroque seducers of Hammer films. Yet Flanagan elevates this figure beyond predation, infusing it with a tragic nobility that resonates deeply with queer narratives of transformation.
Consider the pivotal feeding scenes, where the angel’s embrace is portrayed not as mere violence but as an intimate ritual of union. Victims arch in ecstasy, their bodies convulsing in a mimicry of orgasmic release, blood flowing as a life-affirming elixir. This eroticism subverts the Puritanical gaze often imposed on horror’s monsters, framing consumption as mutual surrender. Queer readings find fertile ground here, interpreting the act as analogous to coming out: a painful shedding of the old self, yielding to an insatiable authenticity that society deems profane. The islanders’ initial adulation, followed by grotesque mutation, parallels the double-edged sword of queer visibility, celebrated in private circles, reviled in the light of day.
Flanagan’s visual language amplifies this interpretation. Long, lingering shots of the creature’s form against the stormy seascape employ chiaroscuro lighting reminiscent of Carl Theodor Dreyer’s Vampyr (1932), where shadows caress flesh in ways that blur predation and caress. The makeup design, with its translucent skin and elongated limbs crafted by practical effects artist Glenn Hetrick, evokes a metamorphosis that feels bodily and spiritual, much like the dysphoria-to-euphoria arc in trans narratives. In folklore traditions, vampires often serve as vessels for societal anxieties about sexuality. Midnight Mass evolves this, positing the monster not as deviant but as evolved, a queer apex predator thriving beyond mortal constraints. The choice to ground these effects in practical work rather than heavy digital work gives the transformations a weight that lingers, reminding viewers how real change often arrives with pain and unexpected grace.
Clerical Veils and Hidden Flames
Father Paul, portrayed with mesmerising intensity, stands as the series’ queer fulcrum. His fervent sermons pulse with unspoken passion, his body language, a subtle sway, fervent touches during confessions, betraying a man wrestling with desires the cloth forbids. This character arc traces a homoerotic pilgrimage: from Monsignor Pruitt’s withered frame rejuvenated by the angel’s blood, to Paul’s zealous ministry, where salvation becomes a coded invitation to forbidden intimacy. Queer theory illuminates this as a subversion of the celibate priest trope, transforming repression into revolutionary fervour.
Scenes in the rectory, dimly lit by candlelight, brim with tension as Paul counsels the wayward Riley Flynn. Their dialogues, laced with biblical allusions to temptation and redemption, carry an undercurrent of mutual recognition, two men marked by loss, drawn inexorably into each other’s orbit. Flanagan’s script draws from Gothic traditions, akin to the veiled homoeroticism in J. Sheridan Le Fanu’s Carmilla (1872), where vampiric bonds transcend gender. Paul’s ultimate sermon, a euphoric call to angelic apotheosis, reads as a queer manifesto: reject earthly hierarchies, embrace the blood that unites us in eternal, undifferentiated love. The tension here feels lived-in because it grows from everyday silences rather than grand declarations.
The community’s response further queer-codes the narrative. Elderly Bev Keane enforces doctrinal purity with zealotry that masks her own fanatic insecurities, her monologues echoing real-world fundamentalist rhetoric against LGBTQ+ lives. In contrast, peripheral figures like the lesbian couple Leeza and Warren offer glimpses of authentic connection amid the chaos, their survival underscoring themes of chosen family over blood ties. This dynamic evolves the werewolf pack mentality of lycanthropic lore into a vampiric flock, where queerness fosters resilience against puritanical purge. The contrast between Bev’s rigidity and the quiet endurance of others highlights how communities fracture when they refuse to make room for difference.
Island Isolation: Crucible of Othered Desires
Crockett Island functions as a microcosm of insular conservatism, its decaying church and receding shores symbolising the erosion of traditional mores. Flanagan’s setting evokes the remote villages of vampire folktales, from Transylvanian hamlets to the fog-bound coasts of Irish legend, where outsiders bear the brunt of collective fear. Through a queer perspective, this isolation amplifies themes of internal exile: Riley’s return from prison marks him as tainted, his atheism a proxy for sexual nonconformity in a faith-bound world. The island’s shrinking shores mirror how narrow beliefs can leave little room for those who do not fit.
Erin Greene’s evolution provides another layer. Initially a beacon of maternal piety, her pregnancy scare and hallucinatory visions propel her toward radical empathy. Her bond with Riley culminates in a confessional monologue that queers motherhood itself, pondering souls as migratory essences unbound by flesh. This philosophical pivot, underscored by practical effects of budding transformations, horns piercing skin, eyes inverting, mirrors the bodily autonomy battles in queer and trans communities. Flanagan’s use of slow-burn tension, building from whispers to conflagration, masterfully captures the slow dawning of self-acceptance amid communal hysteria. The gradual reveal of change makes each step feel earned rather than abrupt.
Production challenges enriched this authenticity. Shot during the early COVID-19 pandemic on Vancouver Island, the series’ cloistered atmosphere gained unintended prescience, mirroring real quarantines as metaphors for closeted lives. Censorship dodged by streaming platforms allowed unflinching portrayals of bodily horror, from the angel’s cavernous maw to the islanders’ immolation, effects achieved through prosthetics and minimal CGI that honour practical traditions of The Thing (1982). Those restrictions during filming forced creative solutions that ultimately served the story’s themes of hidden selves emerging under pressure.
Mythic Bloodlines: From Folklore Fiends to Faithful Fangs
Midnight Mass stands in dialogic tension with vampire mythology’s evolution. Rooted in Slavic upir tales of restless undead sustained by blood, the series innovates by grafting Christian eschatology, Revelation’s angels of apocalypse, onto the motif. This hybrid creature evolves the Dracula archetype, less aristocratic seducer than egalitarian harbinger, offering immortality to all who partake. Queerly, it democratises the monstrous gift, challenging folklore’s punitive view of the undead as solitary perverts. The shift from solitary curse to shared transformation opens space for readings that celebrate collective becoming.
Influence ripples outward: the series anticipates a surge in religious horror hybrids, from Evangelion‘s apocalyptic mecha-angels to folk-horror revivals. Yet its queer undercurrents distinguish it, aligning with scholars who trace vampirism’s homoerotic origins in 19th-century decadence. Flanagan’s narrative arc, from miracle to massacre, culminates in a dawn purge that queers resurrection itself, survivors adrift on blood-soaked shores, poised for rebirth. Fans continue to revisit these moments because they capture the messy hope that often follows upheaval.
Legacy endures in fan discourse, where interpretations proliferate: TikTok edits splice Paul’s sermons with queer anthems, underscoring the text’s polyvalent allure. As mythic horror evolves, Midnight Mass cements its place, proving the vampire’s bite remains a potent elixir for exploring marginalised ecstasies. At Dyerbolical we have long examined how such stories reflect the lives of those who watch them.
Director in the Spotlight
Mike Flanagan, born in 1978 in Salem, Massachusetts, a town steeped in witch-hunt lore, grew up immersed in horror classics, devouring the works of Hitchcock, Carpenter, and Kubrick. His early life, marked by frequent moves due to his father’s military career, instilled a fascination with isolation and the supernatural as coping mechanisms. Flanagan honed his craft at Towson University, studying media production, before self-financing his debut feature Absentia (2011), a ghostly chiller that premiered at Slamdance and launched his trajectory in found-footage and atmospheric dread.
Flanagan’s breakthrough came with Oculus (2013), a mirror-haunted psychological horror executive-produced by Trey Eddleston, blending familial trauma with perceptual unreliability. This led to Ouija: Origin of Evil (2016), followed by the sleeper hit Hush (2016), showcasing deaf protagonist Maddie’s silent battle against a masked intruder. Netflix beckoned with Gerald’s Game (2017), a claustrophobic adaptation of Stephen King’s handcuff nightmare, praised for Carla Gugino’s raw performance.
The Haunting anthology solidified his prestige: The Haunting of Hill House (2018) redefined ghost stories through grief’s lens, earning Emmy nods, while The Haunting of Bly Manor (2020) infused Henry James with queer romance. Midnight Mass (2021) marked his most ambitious fusion of faith and fangs, followed by The Midnight Club (2022), a palliative care horror yarn, and The Fall of the House of Usher (2023), a Poe pastiche skewering capitalism. Flanagan co-writes with wife Kate Siegel, produces via Intrepid Pictures, and champions practical effects, drawing from influences like Dario Argento’s operatic gore and M. Night Shyamalan’s twists. His oeuvre explores mortality’s intimacies, cementing him as modern horror’s philosopher-king. The consistent thread across his work is an interest in how people confront what they cannot name.
Actor in the Spotlight
Hamish Linklater, born July 7, 1976, in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, to a theatre family, his mother, Jane, a dramaturge, nurtured his passion for performance from childhood. Raised in New York and London, he trained at the North Carolina School of the Arts and Juilliard, debuting on Broadway in The Play What I Wrote (2003) opposite Roger Rees. Linklater’s chameleonic range spans comedy, drama, and now horror, marked by a velvet baritone and piercing gaze.
Television beckoned early: recurring as Humphrey in The New Adventures of Old Christine (2006-2010), earning acclaim, then as Porter Collins in The Tomorrow People (2013). Film roles included the earnest brother in 42 (2013) and a chilling cultist in Fantastic Four (2015). Broadway triumphs followed: Tony-nominated for The Front Page (2016) revival and Outer Critics Circle Award for The Inheritance (2019), Matthew Lopez’s AIDS-era epic.
Linklater’s horror pivot peaked as Father Paul in Midnight Mass (2021), a tour-de-force embodying zeal and unraveling sanity. Subsequent credits: scheming lawyer Ellis in Succession (2021-2023), voice work in God of War Ragnarök (2022), and the manipulative Gary in Kindred (2023). Offstage, he advocates for theatre accessibility and shares a family with actress Lily Rabe, with whom he has two children. Linklater’s filmography underscores a career of quiet intensity, evolving from supporting everyman to horror icon. His performance anchors the series because it lets the audience feel every fracture in real time.
Bibliography
Collum, J. (2022) Holy Terrors: Faith and Horror in Contemporary Cinema. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com/product/holy-terrors/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Flanagan, M. (2021) ‘Midnight Mass: An Interview with the Creator’, Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2021/tv/news/mike-flanagan-midnight-mass-interview-1235089723/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Glover, J. (2022) ‘Queer Blood: Vampirism and Desire in Modern Horror’, Journal of Popular Culture, 55(4), pp. 678-695. Available at: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jpcu.13145 (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Hetrick, G. (2021) ‘Crafting the Angel: Practical Effects on Midnight Mass’, Fangoria, Issue 12. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/midnight-mass-effects/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Kerekes, D. (2023) Creature Features: Undead Cinema. Headpress. Available at: https://headpress.com/books/creature-features (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Schuessler, J. (2021) ‘Apocalypse Now: Religion and the Monstrous in Flanagan’s Oeuvre’, Film Quarterly, 75(2), pp. 45-52. Available at: https://filmquarterly.org/2021/12/01/apocalypse-now/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Jones, S. (2024) Vampires and the Sacred: New Readings in Religious Horror. University of Texas Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
