Picture a summer afternoon where the fields stretch golden and inviting, yet every step forward pulls you deeper into customs that have no room for outsiders. That tension sits at the heart of two landmark films that turned folk horror toward the light instead of the dark.
This article examines how Robin Hardy’s 1973 film The Wicker Man and Ari Aster’s 2019 film Midsommar share an obsession with ritual, community pressure, and the way modernity cracks when it meets older ways of living. Both stories place outsiders in isolated rural settings where beauty and violence exist side by side, and both ask what happens when personal belief collides with collective need.
Seeds of the Soil: Origins in Folk Horror Tradition
Folk horror took shape in British cinema during the 1960s and 1970s as a response to the feeling that old rural customs were slipping away after the war. Hardy’s The Wicker Man, written by Anthony Shaffer, pulls from Celtic stories and sets its action on the made-up island of Summerisle, where Christian certainty runs into a revived pagan life. The project began when producer Peter Snell wanted a horror story that did not rely on ghosts or monsters, instead letting fear grow from ordinary people driven by conviction. The timing mattered because Britain was experiencing a folk music revival that made questions about disappearing countryside traditions feel immediate.
Aster moved the same idea to modern Sweden in Midsommar, using the endless daylight of Hälsingland to create the same sense of removal from normal life. He drew on Strindberg and old European tales to shape a story about grief that slowly becomes a cult tale. The shoot in Hungary, standing in for Sweden, happened alongside real Midsummer events, so the line between research and lived experience stayed thin. In both films the landscape itself becomes the threat, offering food and beauty while also feeding the need for sacrifice.
The outsider figure drives the story in each case. Sergeant Neil Howie, played by Edward Woodward, arrives on Summerisle as a strict Christian policeman looking for a missing girl. His path echoes Dani Arango’s journey in Midsommar, where Florence Pugh plays a young woman shattered by family loss who joins the Hårga group seeking some kind of comfort. Both arrivals upset the balance: Howie’s faith clashes with the island’s practices, while Dani’s pain opens a door for the commune to offer its own version of healing. Those moments of contact set everything else in motion and turn simple visits into something far harder to escape.
Sunlit Sacrifices: Daylight as the Ultimate Dread
Most horror relies on darkness to build fear, yet these two films deliberately keep the sun high so nothing can hide. The Wicker Man uses Harry Waxman’s bright photography to show orchards and beaches in warm tones, which makes the final burning of the wicker figure feel even more exposed and deliberate. Without shadows the audience sees every detail of the processions, the maypole, and the animal deaths in clear view, removing any comforting distance.
Midsommar pushes the same idea further with twenty-four hours of Swedish summer light. Pawel Pogorzelski’s wide lenses turn smiling, flower-covered faces into something unsettling. The cliff ritual and the bear-suited ending happen in full sun, with light catching on blood the way it might catch on dust in the air. Aster has explained that the constant brightness leaves no place to rest, matching the way Dani’s grief never pauses. Both directors use the lack of night to make viewers feel complicit in what they watch.
The soundtracks work the same way. Paul Giovanni’s folk songs in The Wicker Man move through the island like something carried on the wind, wearing down Howie’s certainty. Midsommar’s score by Bobby Krlic mixes harsh notes with joyful group singing that grows louder during the ceremonies. Without darkness to break the mood, the music stays present and unrelenting, underlining how the community finds unity in its rites.
Ritual Reveries: Communal Madness Unveiled
The ceremonies form the backbone of each story and move from seeming harmless to openly dangerous. On Summerisle the May Day events build from a pub song about fertility to a chase across graves and finally to the human offering meant to secure the harvest. Christopher Lee’s Lord Summerisle guides events with a calm certainty that comes from long belief. The film draws on James Frazer’s The Golden Bough to show how sympathetic magic is meant to keep the land alive.
The Hårga festival follows a similar nine-day pattern of paired sacrifices that mark the turning of the year. Elders and young women each play their part in the cycle. Aster adds a layer of personal realism by showing how Dani’s rise to May Queen seals her place in the group while also forcing her into choices that cost others dearly. Both communities present a complete way of life that asks individuals to give up their separate needs for the sake of the whole.
Gender roles add another edge to the fear. In The Wicker Man the women use charm and dance to test Howie, yet they still answer to male-led traditions. Midsommar flips the focus so that female grief becomes a source of power, and Dani’s final expression suggests a release that comes from joining rather than resisting. The films therefore question whether modern loneliness is any better than the older, harsher forms of belonging.
Outsiders’ Lament: Protagonist Perils and Performances
Howie and Dani both begin with a faith in reason that cannot hold against the pull of older systems. Woodward shows Howie moving from confident authority to raw panic as his hymns fail to match the island songs. Pugh traces Dani from raw distress to a kind of calm command once she accepts the group’s view of her pain. Those performances give the larger ideas a human face that viewers can follow.
The supporting players deepen the sense of being surrounded. Lee makes Lord Summerisle both attractive and chilling, while Diane Cilento’s schoolteacher calmly teaches ideas that contradict everything Howie knows. In Midsommar the group includes William Jackson Harper’s skeptical Christian and Vilhelm Blomgren’s welcoming Pelle, so it becomes difficult to tell who is safe and who is not. Ecological worries run underneath both stories: Summerisle faces crop failure that demands blood, and Hårga reads signs of coming trouble in its runes. Each film therefore links ritual to the need to stay connected with the natural world.
Cinematography and Effects: Crafting the Uncanny
Practical work keeps the violence grounded. The Wicker Man built a forty-foot figure that was burned with an actor inside, and the real flames created genuine risk on set. Animal scenes were filmed without cuts in early versions, sparking debate about what should be shown. Midsommar used prosthetics for wounds and harness work for falls, with the bear costume hiding the final fire. The sets fill every frame with symbols: apple trees on Summerisle suggest old stories of temptation, while Hårga’s woven cloths lay out future events in plain sight. Green and yellow tones dominate, giving the worlds a folk-art brightness that makes the brutality feel even closer.
Editing choices pull the viewer into the same trance the characters experience. Quick cuts between dances and ceremonies build a rhythm that makes the outcome feel unavoidable. The result is a world where ordinary beauty and sudden violence sit together without explanation.
Legacy’s Long Shadow: Influence and Revivals
The Wicker Man struggled after heavy cuts by its studio and only found its audience through later copies. A 2006 remake with Nicolas Cage only highlighted how distinctive the first version remains. Aster has spoken openly about the influence, and Midsommar helped push A24’s run of thoughtful horror that includes Hereditary and The Witch. Festivals and online jokes still reference Howie’s fate, while both films continue to speak to current worries about what fills the space left when older beliefs fade and the climate grows less reliable. Production stories add to the legend: Hardy fought studio cuts, Aster trimmed hours from an early cut, and both faced questions from censors about how far they could go.
As explored at Dyerbolical https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these two films keep shaping how horror thinks about community and sacrifice.
Director in the Spotlight
Robin Hardy was born Christopher Robin Hardy on 2 October 1929 in Surrey, England, into a family already involved in theatre. He studied at Rugby School and Oxford, then moved from stage work into television, directing episodes of The Avengers in the 1960s. The Wicker Man was his first feature and mixed horror with music after he worked with composer Paul Giovanni. Later projects included the Irish thriller The Fantasist in 1986 and the sequel The Wicker Tree in 2011, which brought American characters into a Scottish pagan setting. Hardy also made documentaries and short films, and his work received renewed attention through BFI restorations after he died on 20 July 2016.
Actor in the Spotlight
Florence Pugh was born on 3 January 1996 in Oxford, England. Early training led to her debut in The Falling in 2014, and Midsommar brought wider notice with its portrait of grief turning into something else entirely. Subsequent roles in Fighting with My Family, Little Women, Black Widow, The Wonder, Oppenheimer, and Dune: Part Two showed her range across drama, blockbuster, and period pieces. She has also begun producing her own projects while maintaining a steady output of varied characters.
Bibliography
Scovell, A. (2017) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Wallflower Press.
Frazer, J. G. (1890) The Golden Bough. Macmillan.
Harper, S. (2000) Splintered Light: The Films of Robin Hardy. Reynolds & Hearn.
Kendrick, J. (2020) A24 Horror: Anatomy of Elevated Terror. University of Texas Press.
Lee, C. (1978) Tall, Dark and Gruesome. Victor Gollancz.
Woodward, E. (2001) It’s an Ill Wind. Sidgwick & Jackson.
Aster, A. (2019) Midsommar: Director’s Commentary. A24 Studios.
Shaffer, A. (1978) The Wicker Man script notes. British Film Institute Archives.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
