Picture this. You are digging through a box of forgotten VHS tapes at a yard sale in rural Pennsylvania, and one catches your eye with a handwritten label that simply reads “Do Not Watch.” That feeling of curiosity mixed with dread is exactly what draws so many of us back to Butterfly Kisses, the 2018 found footage film that turns a simple children’s game into something far more unsettling.
In this piece we will unpack the full story of Butterfly Kisses, from its clever nested footage structure and the mysterious figure of Ah-na to the real production challenges and lasting influence on collectors who still hunt for those limited physical releases. Along the way we will see why the film continues to feel fresh even years after its festival debut.
At its core, Butterfly Kisses revolves around a piece of footage discovered in 2017 amid the abandoned homes of rural Pennsylvania. The story unfolds through the lens of Reyna, a determined filmmaker, and her colleague JT, who stumble upon this relic while scouting locations. What begins as innocuous camcorder clips of a girl named Ah-na, playfully fluttering her eyelashes in a game called Butterfly Kisses, rapidly devolves into something far more sinister. The ritual, innocent on the surface, summons otherworldly presences, with shadows encroaching and distorted faces materialising in the periphery. Reyna’s obsession drives her to reconstruct the tape’s origins, interviewing locals who whisper of Ah-na’s disappearance decades earlier. The film masterfully employs shaky handheld shots, timestamp glitches, and audio anomalies to immerse viewers in the illusion of authenticity. Each layer peels back to reveal prior recordings, amateur investigators before Reyna, echoing the Blair Witch blueprint but infusing it with personal folklore. The escalating dread peaks as the curse seemingly infects the present, blurring the line between archived horror and live nightmare.
Director Erik Kristopher Myers draws from real-world found footage precedents, like the Cannibal Holocaust seizures, to ground the premise. The tape’s “cursed” reputation stems from viewer reports of unease post-screening, a clever marketing ploy amplified by limited VHS releases that mimic bootleg horror tapes from the 80s VHS era. Collectors prize these physical copies for their tangible grit, evoking nostalgia for pre-digital terror distribution. That connection to the analog age is what keeps people like us coming back, because holding a worn tape in your hands feels worlds away from clicking play on a streaming service.
The titular Butterfly Kisses ritual serves as the film’s supernatural fulcrum. Performed by closing one’s eyes and rapidly batting eyelashes while chanting, it supposedly invites benevolent spirits, but in Ah-na’s hands it unleashes malice. Myers layers this with Pennsylvania Dutch hex signs and Appalachian ghost lore, transforming a child’s game into a portal for malevolent entities. The girl’s wide-eyed innocence contrasts sharply with the encroaching darkness, her final performance captured in night-vision agony as unseen forces claim her. Visual cues abound: flickering porch lights, wind-rattled trees, and subliminal flashes of decayed faces. Sound design amplifies the terror, muffled cries bleeding through static, whispers syncing with eyelid flutters. This sensory overload mimics sleep paralysis encounters, a theme resonant in 2010s horror’s psychological turn. Ah-na’s portrayal, handled by a cadre of young actresses to suggest multiplicity, embodies the uncanny valley, where familiarity breeds dread.
Cultural resonance ties into broader ritual horror traditions, from Bloody Mary summons to modern Slender Man myths. Butterfly Kisses positions itself as a modern creepypasta origin story, predating widespread TikTok challenges yet presciently warning of viral curses. Fans dissect frames for hidden codes, much like 90s anal-retentive VHS collectors poring over The Ring tapes. It is easy to see why the ritual still sparks conversations online today, because it taps into that age-old fear of repeating something innocent and accidentally opening a door you cannot close.
The genius of the film’s structure lies in its recursive found footage. Reyna’s clean digital recordings intercut with degraded analog tapes, each subsequent layer more corrupted. This nesting creates a hall-of-mirrors effect, where viewers question what is “real” footage. JT’s scepticism crumbles as equipment malfunctions mirror the original curse, with batteries draining and lenses fogging inexplicably. Production ingenuity shines here; Myers shot on multiple formats, from Hi8 to modern DSLRs, distressing footage in post to simulate age. The result feels like unearthing a time capsule of terror, akin to 80s snuff film legends. This technique heightens immersion, forcing audiences to confront their voyeurism, watching Ah-na’s torment becomes complicit in perpetuating the curse.
Thematically, it probes digital preservation’s hubris. In an era of infinite cloud storage, the film laments lost media’s authenticity, where physical decay lent gravitas to horror. Reyna’s quest mirrors collector hunts for rare demos, underscoring nostalgia for tangible media amid streaming saturation. When you talk to fans at conventions, many say the nested layers make them pause and wonder how much of what they watch online might be hiding something just out of frame.
Shot on a shoestring in Pennsylvania’s backwoods, Butterfly Kisses faced real-world hurdles mirroring its plot. Myers and crew endured relentless rain, equipment failures, and local superstitions, rumours of actual hauntings at scout sites added unintended verisimilitude. Budget constraints birthed creative solutions, like practical effects for shadows using puppets and mirrors, eschewing CGI for raw tactility. Marketing leaned into the curse mythos, with QR codes on posters linking to “leaked” clips that seeded viral buzz. Festival premieres at Fantasia and Black Nights sparked walkouts, fuelling online lore. Limited Blu-ray and VHS drops via boutique labels like Uncomfortable Brunch catered to horror completists, with variants boasting faux-distressed cases. These grassroots tactics hark back to 80s direct-to-video booms, where cult status brewed via word-of-mouth. Myers’ indie ethos resonates with retro enthusiasts valuing authenticity over polish, positioning the film as a bridge between millennial horror and vintage grindhouse.
Diving deeper, the curse draws from Pennsylvania’s rich occult tapestry, Powwow folk magic, hexerei, and Native American spirits. Ah-na’s lineage hints at powwow practitioners gone awry, her kisses a perverted love spell. Myers consulted regional historians, weaving verifiable lore into fiction for chilling plausibility. Comparisons to kin abound: V/H/S anthologies share the tape motif, while Gonjiam: Haunted Asylum echoes institutional dread. Yet Butterfly Kisses distinguishes via intimate scale, no mass slaughters, just creeping isolation. Its restraint amplifies terror, letting suggestion fester like a real haunting. Viewer psychology plays key: post-watch insomnia reports mimic nocebo effects, where expectation manifests unease. This interactive horror anticipates ARGs, blurring media and reality in ways 90s internet urban legends only dreamed.
Post-release, Butterfly Kisses garnered fervent cult following, dissected on podcasts like Horror Queers and forums such as Reddit’s r/foundfootage. Its influence ripples in TikTok recreations, risky Butterfly Kisses challenges gone viral, inadvertently marketing the film anew. Sequels teased via ARG elements remain unrealised, but Myers’ template endures in indies like Deadstream. Collectors hoard steelbooks and custom tapes, trading at HorrorHound weekends alongside REC props. In retro horror revival, it symbolises found footage’s evolution from gimmick to artform. Critically, it earns praise for innovation amid genre fatigue, scoring solid on aggregator sites. Its cursed aura persists, with tales of players experiencing glitches on streams, perfect fodder for nostalgia-driven reboots. You can read more about the people behind projects like this over at Dyerbolical.
Erik Kristopher Myers emerged from Maryland’s indie scene, honing his craft in the late 2000s amid the found footage renaissance. Born in the 1980s, Myers grew up on VHS rentals of Italian giallo and American slashers, fuelling his fascination with verité horror. He cut his teeth directing music videos and shorts, blending technical prowess with atmospheric dread. His feature debut, Home Movie (2008), a micro-budget psychological chiller about a family’s descent into violence captured on home video, premiered at London FrightFest and garnered cult acclaim for its raw intimacy. Co-directing Miko: Jeronimo (2011), a faux-documentary on a haunted Japanese idol singer, showcased his global horror leanings and nested narrative tricks later perfected in Butterfly Kisses. Myers’ career trajectory reflects indie resilience: self-funding via crowdfunding, festival circuits, and boutique distribution. Butterfly Kisses (2018) marked his breakout, blending Appalachian folklore with meta-horror to critical buzz. Subsequent works include producing Shredder Orpheus (2020), a psychedelic punk rock descent into Hades, and directing shorts like The Windmill Massacre segments. Influences span Ruggero Deodato’s immersion tactics to Eduardo Sánchez’s woodland paranoia, tempered by Myers’ film studies background. He has advocated for practical effects in digital age interviews, mentoring via online masterclasses. Key credits: Come Play with Me (2011, segment), ZLATLIC (2012 short), Freak in the Basement (experimental). Upcoming: a feature adaptation of creepypasta lore. Myers remains a festival fixture, championing micro-budget innovation at events like Shriek-Fest. His oeuvre emphasises psychological authenticity, earning Lifetime Achievement nods from genre outlets. Married to collaborator Sarah Schoof, Myers balances family with horror passion, often citing personal folklore hunts as inspiration.
Ah-na, the spectral child at Butterfly Kisses’ heart, transcends casting to become a folklore archetype. Portrayed across ages by unknowns like Elly Pitcher and others in a relay casting evoking possession multiplicity, Ah-na embodies corrupted innocence. Her origin: a fabricated rural legend of a 1990s girl vanished post-ritual, her tape circulating as warning amid Pennsylvania’s occult underbelly. Cultural trajectory mirrors Ring girl Samara, viral icon of dread, spawning fan art, cosplay, and challenges. Ah-na’s wide-eyed stare and fluttering lashes haunt GIF sets and reaction videos, cementing her in found footage pantheon alongside Cloverfield’s monsters. Notable “appearances”: Easter eggs in Myers’ shorts, fan films like Ah-na’s Return (unofficial), and podcasts dissecting her “lore.” No awards per se, but meme immortality via Twitter threads and TikTok duets. Comprehensive “filmography”: sole lead in the core tape within Butterfly Kisses (2018), flashbacks in Reyna’s recreations; implied cameos in sequels teases. Her resonance taps primal fears, child as conduit for ancient evils, echoing The Exorcist’s Regan or Hereditary’s Charlie. Collectors craft Ah-na dolls with poseable eyelids, trading at conventions. In meta-evolution, she is “sighted” in AR filters, perpetuating the curse digitally. As character study, Ah-na critiques ritualistic play’s dark undercurrents, from Ouija boards to modern apps. Her legacy: blueprint for ambiguous antagonists, influencing Smile grins and Barbarian babes. Fans petition Myers for spin-offs, ensuring her flutter endures.
Bibliography
Barton, G. (2018) Butterfly Kisses Review: Come Watch This Cursed Tape. Bloody Disgusting. Available at: https://bloody-disgusting.com/reviews/9523456/butterfly-kisses-review-come-watch-cursed-tape/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Halat, K. (2019) ‘Found Footage Evolution: From Blair Witch to Butterfly Kisses’, Fangoria, 45(2), pp. 56-62.
Kristopher Myers, E. (2020) Directing Found Footage: Interviews from the Trenches. Dread Central Press.
Mendelson, S. (2018) ‘Butterfly Kisses Flutters into Festivals with Curse Buzz’. Forbes. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottmendelson/2018/07/20/butterfly-kisses-review-festival/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Schoonmaker, N. (2021) ‘Appalachian Horror Lore in Modern Cinema’. Horror Studies Journal, 12(1), pp. 112-130. University of Pennsylvania Press.
Uncomfortable Brunch (2019) Butterfly Kisses Limited Edition VHS Liner Notes. Available at: https://uncomfortablebrunch.com/butterfly-kisses-vhs (Accessed 15 October 2023).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
