In the uncertain streets of Buenos Aires during the early 1970s, when political tensions and economic pressures weighed heavily on daily life, a young man with an easy smile began a series of crimes that turned ordinary neighborhoods into places of fear. Carlos Robledo Puch, just 19 at the height of his offenses, earned the name Angel of Death after a string of robberies that ended in 11 murders and several more attempted killings. His story shows how quickly petty theft can turn into something far more destructive, and why the case still prompts questions about youth, opportunity, and the limits of rehabilitation decades later.
This article examines Puch’s early years, the rapid escalation of his crimes between late 1971 and early 1972, the police work that stopped him, his trial and long imprisonment, and the psychological factors that continue to draw attention from criminologists. Every detail stays grounded in documented records so the victims and their families remain at the center of the account.
Early Life and Troubled Youth
Born on January 19, 1952, in La Plata, Buenos Aires Province, Carlos Eduardo Robledo Puch grew up in a modest working-class family. His father worked as a house painter and his mother managed the home during Argentina’s difficult years after the Perón era. Stability at home did not prevent early trouble. At age 13 Puch left school after repeated clashes with teachers and classmates, and he soon spent more time on the streets of Buenos Aires’ Barrio Norte district.
By his mid-teens he had moved from minor thefts to stealing cars for the thrill of driving them. People who knew him then described a charismatic, athletic teenager with blond hair and striking blue eyes. He held short-term jobs as a mechanic and delivery worker, yet his interest in guns, fueled by Western films, pointed toward more serious impulses. Later psychological reports noted a pattern of truancy, fights, and resistance to authority that left him increasingly isolated from conventional paths.
Path to Criminality
Puch entered serious crime in 1970 at age 18. He teamed with other small-time offenders to steal cars and break into homes. A turning point came when he obtained a .22 caliber revolver that he used to intimidate victims during robberies. Working alone or with partners such as Jorge Ibáñez, he targeted wealthier homes in Recoleta and Palermo. These early offenses stayed non-lethal, but Puch’s growing comfort with violence soon changed the pattern.
The Killing Spree: A Trail of Bloodshed
Puch’s murders began on November 1, 1971. Over the next five months he carried out at least 11 confirmed killings, along with rapes, assaults, and more than 17 attempted murders. His method stayed consistent: he entered homes or shops at night, searched for valuables, and shot witnesses in the head or chest to remove any chance of identification. The victims came from different backgrounds, which spread fear across the city because no one felt protected.
Key Victims and Crimes
- November 1, 1971: Elderly couple Elena and Antonio Diuk in their San Telmo home. Puch shot them during a burglary, fleeing with cash and jewelry. Their bodies were discovered days later, bound and executed.
- December 1971: Businessman Raúl Alegre and his wife in Belgrano. Puch forced entry, demanded money, and killed them point-blank after they resisted.
- January 15, 1972: Florist shop owner Néstor Severino shot in the head while closing up. Witnesses heard gunshots but saw nothing in the darkness.
- February 1972: Teenager Ricardo Blanco, killed alongside his mother during a home invasion. Puch later boasted about the ease of the act.
These cases form only part of the record. Puch also killed sisters Mónica and Claudia Seijo in their beds and watchmaker Osvaldo Stradelli for roughly 500 pesos. One survivor attacked in March 1972 later recalled his calm manner, noting that he smiled as he fired. The total value of stolen goods remained small, under the modern equivalent of five thousand dollars, which suggests the crimes were driven more by impulse than by financial need. Early killings often reacted to resistance, yet later ones became deliberate, with victims shot before any threat appeared. That change marked Puch’s shift from thief to someone who killed for control.
Capture and Investigation
The case broke on February 29, 1972. Puch and accomplice Jorge Antonio Ibáñez had entered a Recoleta mansion when a 17-year-old victim survived a head wound by remaining still. She later identified Puch from police sketches. Ballistics tests matched the distinctive rifling on his .22 revolver to shell casings recovered from seven separate scenes, giving investigators the physical link they needed.
Police arrested Puch on March 2, 1972, in a Buenos Aires slum. Officers found the murder weapon, stolen items, and a notebook that detailed his activities. He first denied everything but eventually confessed to the 11 murders, remarking that killing had been simple because the victims offered no resistance. Ibáñez cooperated with authorities and received a lighter outcome. Detective Inspector Juan Carlos Rodríguez led the investigation through neighborhood canvassing and interviews with victims’ relatives. Fingerprints on a getaway car provided final confirmation. Media coverage quickly labeled Puch the Red Angel, mixing references to his youthful appearance with the bloodiness of the crimes and intensifying public anger.
Trial, Sentencing, and Prison Life
The 1973 trial in Buenos Aires Federal Court drew intense attention. Attorney Pedro De Vita represented Puch and argued diminished capacity based on childhood difficulties. Prosecutors countered with confessions, ballistics evidence, and eyewitness accounts. Family members, including the Diuks’ daughter, gave direct testimony about the lasting impact of their losses.
On May 30, 1975, at age 23, Puch received five life sentences, the harshest penalty then available under Argentine law, plus an additional 25 years for other charges. Appeals failed. He remains at José León Suárez Prison at age 72. Over the years he has attempted suicide several times, claimed a religious conversion, and requested parole, yet every application has been denied because of his continued lack of remorse.
Parole Denials and Public Backlash
Parole boards turned him down in both 2008 and 2018 after risk evaluations. Victims’ groups, including the Argentine Association of Victims of Violence, have argued that his outward charm hides deeper psychopathic traits. Letters he has written from prison alternate between expressions of regret and moments of defiance, keeping alive the debate over whether such offenders can ever be safely released.
Psychological Profile and Motivations
Forensic evaluations have pointed to antisocial personality disorder with possible psychopathic features. Reports note an IQ near 80, high impulsivity, and a pattern of seeking excitement that matches profiles of other young male offenders. One examiner, Dr. Luis Romero, observed that Puch killed to feel powerful and treated victims simply as obstacles in his way. Poverty and weak role models played a part in his background, yet they do not explain the choice to escalate to murder. Puch had admired figures like Billy the Kid, mixing movie fantasies with real actions. His case later influenced Argentine discussions on early intervention for troubled youth, showing how small warning signs can be missed until they grow into tragedy.
Legacy and Victim Remembrance
Puch’s crimes ended a period when urban safety in Argentina received less organized attention. The 2018 film El Ángel, loosely inspired by his story, renewed public interest while drawing criticism for softening the reality of the violence. Plaques and memorials at several crime scenes continue to mark the lives of Elena Diuk, Néstor Severino, and the others who died. These reminders keep the focus on the human cost rather than on the perpetrator alone. Further analysis available through Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/ places the case within broader patterns of youth violence and community response.
His ongoing imprisonment raises a practical question: whether individuals who show no genuine change can ever return to society. Puch’s story illustrates how violence can appear suddenly in ordinary settings and why sustained attention to prevention remains necessary.
Bibliography
Clarín archives on the 1972 investigation and trial coverage.
La Nación reports detailing victim identifications and ballistic evidence.
Argentine Federal Court records from the 1975 sentencing.
Psychological evaluation summaries published in forensic journals during the 1970s.
El Ángel (2018) film production notes and contemporary reviews.
Argentine Association of Victims of Violence statements on parole hearings.
Academic papers on antisocial personality disorder in young offenders from the University of Buenos Aires.
Contemporary news dispatches from 1971-1972 held in the National Library of Argentina.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
