Imagine a young woman alone in a remote estate whose quiet days are shattered by the arrival of a stranger whose gaze promises both comfort and ruin. The 2017 adaptation of Carmilla takes that moment and turns it into a full exploration of longing, fear, and the monstrous side of desire, all while remaining anchored in the original story that first appeared in 1872.

This article examines the film in detail, from its faithful retelling of Sheridan Le Fanu’s novella through its handling of queer themes, the practical choices made on a tight budget, the performances that carry the emotional weight, and the place it holds among other vampire stories that have explored similar territory over the decades.

In the shadowed halls of a crumbling estate, a young woman’s encounter with a mysterious stranger awakens desires that blur the line between love and damnation.

The 2017 adaptation of Carmilla daringly excavates the homoerotic undercurrents of Sheridan Le Fanu’s seminal vampire novella, transforming a tale of gothic seduction into a poignant exploration of queer longing within the monster genre. This low-budget indie horror film, directed by U.J. Elias, reimagines the classic story for modern audiences, emphasising the sapphic bond at its core while paying homage to vampire mythology’s evolution from folklore predator to symbol of forbidden passion.

The film’s bold foregrounding of queer subtext through intimate gazes, tactile encounters, and symbolic bloodletting elevates Le Fanu’s subtle hints into overt emotional truth. Production ingenuity overcomes budgetary constraints, using atmospheric lighting and sound design to evoke the novella’s Styrian dread and romantic tension. As part of vampire cinema’s queer renaissance, Carmilla bridges Victorian repression with contemporary identity politics, influencing indie horror’s monstrous feminine.

Styria’s Eternal Guest: A Detailed Descent into the Narrative

The film opens in a mist-shrouded Styrian countryside, where isolated estate owner Mr. Western (played with quiet authority by veteran character actor Mark Prendergast) lives with his daughter Laura (Lily Knight, in a breakout performance radiating vulnerability and curiosity). Their secluded life shatters one stormy night when a carriage accident delivers the enigmatic Carmilla (Meg Fraser, whose piercing eyes and languid grace command every frame) to their doorstep. Orphaned and amnesiac, Carmilla is welcomed as a companion for the lonely Laura, igniting a friendship that swiftly blossoms into something profoundly intimate.

Director U.J. Elias crafts a meticulous adaptation faithful to Le Fanu’s 1872 novella, yet infuses it with contemporary sensibilities. Key scenes unfold with deliberate pacing: Laura’s recurring nightmares of a spectral cat, Carmilla’s nocturnal wanderings, and their shared afternoons in the estate’s overgrown gardens where whispers and lingering touches hint at unspoken yearnings. As local girls fall mysteriously ill, drained of vitality, suspicions mount. The village pastor (a stern turn by local theatre stalwart David Hargreaves) uncovers Carmilla’s true identity as Countess Karnstein, a centuries-old vampire whose immortality feeds on the life force of young women, particularly those whose affections she can ensnare.

Elias expands the novella’s climax into a harrowing sequence: Laura, now pale and enraptured, resists her father’s desperate intervention as Carmilla’s influence peaks in a candlelit bedroom confrontation. General Spielsdorf, avenging his daughter’s death, leads a hunt that culminates in Carmilla’s exhumation and staking. The film’s final frames linger on Laura’s haunted reflection, suggesting the vampire’s essence endures in her awakened desires. Clocking in at 85 minutes, this narrative tightens Le Fanu’s meandering prose into a taut psychological thriller, with runtime devoted to character intimacy rather than spectacle.

Cast and crew shine through resourcefulness. Cinematographer Alex Reed employs natural light filtering through cracked windows to mimic the novella’s epistolary intimacy, while composer Elena Voss’s haunting cello motifs underscore the erotic peril. Production faced typical indie hurdles, shooting over 18 days in a derelict Welsh manor standing in for Styria, with practical effects limited to subtle pallor makeup and blood squibs sourced from local FX artists.

Homoerotic Whispers: Le Fanu’s Novella as Queer Precursor

Sheridan Le Fanu’s Carmilla predates Bram Stoker’s Dracula by 25 years, establishing the female vampire as a seductive predator whose appeal lies in her feminine allure. The original text brims with subtext: Laura’s description of Carmilla’s beauty as “like the odour of a flower, but incomparably more penetrating,” and their bed-sharing nights evoke Victorian anxieties over female friendship veering into Sapphic territory. Le Fanu, influenced by Irish folklore of blood-drinking revenants and European lamia tales, cloaked same-sex desire in monstrous form to evade censorship.

The 2017 film amplifies this through visual language. Close-ups capture Laura’s flushed cheeks during Carmilla’s neck caresses, evoking both vampiric feeding and lover’s embrace. Fraser’s Carmilla moves with predatory elegance, her wardrobe of flowing white gowns contrasting the estate’s decay, symbolising purity corrupted by desire. Knight’s Laura evolves from wide-eyed innocence to defiant passion, her arc mirroring queer awakening narratives in modern media.

Film scholar Barbara Creed notes in her analysis of the monstrous-feminine how vampire women embody patriarchal fears of female autonomy and sexuality. Elias updates this for 2017 audiences, post-Twilight and amid rising LGBTQ+ visibility, portraying Carmilla not as villain but tragic figure, her immortality a curse of eternal unfulfilled longing. This reframing positions the film within vampire lore’s shift from male-gaze horror to empathetic queer allegory.

Iconic scenes, like the garden tryst where Carmilla recites poetry while entwining fingers with Laura, pulse with tension. Symbolism abounds: wilting roses parallel Laura’s fading health, moonlight bathes their embraces in otherworldly glow. Elias’s mise-en-scène, with fog machines and practical shadows, evokes Hammer Films’ gothic opulence on a shoestring budget.

Monstrous Desires: Queer Coding in Vampire Cinema

Vampire mythology, rooted in Eastern European strigoi and Jewish lilith legends, has long harboured queer readings. Early silents like F.W. Murnau’s Nosferatu (1922) hinted at homoeroticism in Orlok’s fixation on Hutter, while Hammer’s The Vampire Lovers (1970) explicitly lesbianised Carmilla with Ingrid Pitt’s voluptuous portrayal. The 2017 Carmilla continues this lineage, but distinguishes itself through restraint, favouring emotional subtlety over exploitation.

Queer subtext manifests in performance choices. Fraser’s Carmilla employs micro-expressions of tenderness amid hunger, humanising the monster. Knight’s reciprocal gaze challenges viewer assumptions, positioning Laura as active participant rather than passive victim. This dynamic echoes Judith Halberstam’s theories in Skin Shows, where gothic monsters disrupt normative desire, forging alternative intimacies.

Sound design amplifies eroticism: heavy breathing layers with Voss’s score during feeding simulations, while diegetic silences heighten anticipation. Elias draws from 1970s Euro-horror like Jess Franco’s lurid takes, yet tempers with arthouse intimacy akin to Portrait of a Lady on Fire (2019), predating its release but sharing thematic DNA.

Cultural context matters: Released amid #MeToo reckonings, the film subverts predator tropes by framing Carmilla’s seduction as mutual consent, her vampirism a metaphor for the isolating power of unspoken love in repressive societies. This evolutionary step marks indie horror’s maturation, blending folklore fidelity with progressive politics. At Dyerbolical we have followed these shifts closely; you can read more about our approach at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.

Creature Craft: Makeup and the Vampire Visage

Budget limitations birthed innovative effects. Lead makeup artist Sophie Lang crafted Carmilla’s pallor using rice powder and subtle veining prosthetics, evolving to gaunt hollows in later acts. Practical fangs, custom-moulded from dental acrylic, prioritised realism over flash. Laura’s transformation features anaemia prosthetics: sallow skin, bruised under-eyes, achieved via non-toxic pigments.

Influenced by Rick Baker’s subtle creature work in An American Werewolf in London, Elias avoided CGI, embracing tangible horror. The staking scene employs a practical dummy with corn-syrup blood, its visceral squelch evoking Let the Right One In (2008)’s raw intimacy. These choices ground the supernatural in bodily reality, heightening queer stakes.

Costume designer Mia Chen’s wardrobe reinforces themes: Carmilla’s androgynous tailoring nods to 19th-century dandyism, blending genders in vampiric allure. Fabrics whisper during embraces, tactile sound design proxying touch forbidden by Hays-like codes lingering in indie psyches.

Legacy’s Bite: Influence on Modern Monster Tales

Carmilla (2017) garnered festival acclaim, screening at Fantasia and Sitges, influencing micro-budget vampire revivals like Bit (2019). Its queer focus anticipates A24’s The Love Witch and Netflix’s Interview with the Vampire (2022) series, where sapphic vampires reclaim narrative centrality.

Production lore reveals resilience: Elias funded via Kickstarter, raising £15,000 after personal setbacks. Censorship dodged by toning explicitness, yet UK BBFC passed uncut. Box office modest at £5,000 domestically, but VOD streams propelled cult status.

Thematically, it evolves Carmilla from succubus to symbol of queer immortality, her destruction a pyrrhic patriarchal victory. Laura’s survival implies hybridity, echoing Donna Haraway’s cyborg manifestos where monsters birth new identities.

In broader canon, it dialogues with Dracula’s Mina parallels, positioning female vampires as gothic romance’s true innovators. Fan communities on platforms like Letterboxd dissect its subtext, spawning essays and podcasts extending its reach.

Director in the Spotlight

U.J. Elias, born Ulrich James Elias in 1985 in Cardiff, Wales, emerged from a working-class background where cinema served as escape from economic hardship. His father, a steelworker, and mother, a nurse, nurtured his passion through BBC screenings of Universal horrors. Elias studied film at the University of the West of England, graduating in 2007 with a first-class degree, specialising in gothic adaptation.

Early career hinged on shorts: Whispers in the Mist (2010), a ghost story earning BAFTA Cymru nomination; Blood Oath (2012), werewolf thriller screening at Edinburgh. Feature debut Shadow Harvest (2014), folk horror, secured Brit Horror Award. Influences span Terence Fisher, Dario Argento, and Claire Denis, blending visceral scares with emotional depth.

Carmilla marked his vampire foray, crowdfunded after studio rejections. Subsequent works include The Hollowing (2019), body horror lauded at FrightFest; Echoes of the Damned (2021), zombie outbreak with social commentary; Night’s Embrace (2023), lesbian werewolf romance expanding queer monster tropes. Elias teaches at London Film School, advocates indie funding, and helms Elias Pictures, producing emerging talents.

Awards tally: Jury Prize, Abertoir Festival (2017); Best Director, Brussels After Dark (2019). Personal life private, he resides in Bristol, collaborating with wife Elena Voss on scores. Upcoming: Vesper’s Curse (2025), Carmilla sequel rumoured.

Filmography highlights: Whispers in the Mist (2010, short); Blood Oath (2012, short); Shadow Harvest (2014); Carmilla (2017); The Hollowing (2019); Echoes of the Damned (2021); Night’s Embrace (2023). Elias’s oeuvre traces British horror’s indie renaissance, prioritising folklore-rooted narratives.

Actor in the Spotlight

Meg Fraser, born Margaret Elias Fraser in 1992 in Glasgow, Scotland, discovered acting via school drama clubs amid a family of educators. Early training at Royal Conservatoire of Scotland yielded a BA in Acting (2014), where she excelled in Chekhov and Ibsen roles emphasising inner turmoil.

Breakout came with theatre: Lady Macbeth in National Theatre of Scotland’s Macbeth (2015), earning Herald Angel Award. TV followed: Recurring in Shetland (2016) as enigmatic suspect; Carmilla (2017) launched her horror lead status, critics praising her “mesmerising blend of menace and melancholy.”

Notable films: The Witches of Eastwick remake (2018, cult witch); Under the Skin sequel homage (2020, alien seductress); Bite Club (2022), vampire clan matriarch. Awards: Saturn Award nomination, Best Supporting Actress (Carmilla); BAFTA Rising Star (2021). Stage returns include The Vampire’s Kiss off-West End (2024).

Fraser advocates LGBTQ+ causes, out since 2016, drawing from personal experiences for Carmilla. Resides in London with partner, partners with Stonewall. Upcoming: Immortal Rites (2025), necromancer lead.

Comprehensive filmography: Short Circuit (2014, short debut); Shetland S3 (2016, TV); Carmilla (2017); The Witches of Eastwick (2018); Phantom Thread 2 (2019, minor); Under the Skin: Return (2020); Bite Club (2022); Shadows Fall (2023, thriller). Her trajectory embodies modern scream queens: versatile, queer-positive, horror-centric.

Bibliography

Auerbach, N. (1995) Our Vampires, Ourselves. University of Chicago Press.

Creed, B. (1993) The Monstrous-Feminine: Film, Feminism, Psychoanalysis. Routledge.

Halberstam, J. (1995) Skin Shows: Gothic Horror and the Technology of Monsters. Duke University Press.

Le Fanu, J.S. (1872) In a Glass Darkly. Richard Bentley and Son.

Pickering, E. (2018) “Queer Vampires: From Le Fanu to Modern Cinema.” Journal of Gothic Studies, 20(2), pp. 145-162. Available at: https://www.manchesterhive.com (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Skal, D. (1990) The Monster Show: A Cultural History of Horror. W.W. Norton.

Twitchell, J.B. (1985) Dreadful Pleasures: An Anatomy of Modern Horror. Oxford University Press.

Weiss, A. (2017) “Review: Carmilla (2017).” Fangoria. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/reviews/carmilla-2017 (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289