Catherine the Great rose from a minor German princess to one of the most formidable rulers Europe had ever seen, yet her story is still tangled in grotesque sexual myths that were deliberately spread to weaken her. This article examines how political enemies turned private rumors into public weapons, starting from the suspicious death of her husband Peter III and stretching through decades of fabricated tales about her personal life. It traces the real events of her rise, the origins of those smears, and why they continue to shape perceptions of powerful women long after her death in 1796.

Those rumors were never harmless gossip. They formed part of a calculated effort by foreign courts and domestic rivals to portray Catherine as morally unfit to rule, distracting attention from the hard political choices she made and the genuine crimes that accompanied her path to power. By looking closely at the historical record, the connections between her personal relationships and statecraft become clearer, revealing how sexual slander served as a tool to undermine legitimacy rather than reflect actual behavior.

From Princess to Tsarina: Catherine’s Rise Amid Turmoil

Catherine II, born Sophie Auguste Fredericka of Anhalt-Zerbst in 1729, arrived in Russia as a teenager with little more than a sharp mind and a willingness to adapt. She quickly learned the language, converted to Orthodoxy, and navigated the dangerous politics of Empress Elizabeth’s court. Her marriage at sixteen to the erratic Grand Duke Peter proved miserable from the start, marked by his open affairs and erratic behavior. When Peter took the throne in 1762, his pro-Prussian policies quickly alienated the Russian nobility and military, creating the opening Catherine needed.

On July 9, 1762, she declared herself empress with the support of the Orlov brothers, particularly her lover Grigory Orlov. Peter’s abdication came quickly, but his death just days later raised immediate questions. Official accounts claimed he died of hemorrhoidal colic while confined at Ropsha, yet whispers of strangulation and bruises circulated almost at once. Grigory Orlov was reportedly involved in the events, and Catherine’s public mourning did little to quiet suspicions of her involvement. This moment marked the true beginning of her reign and the point where sexual rumors began to be deployed against her with real force.

The Enigma of Peter III’s Death

Historians still debate whether Peter’s death was murder or the result of a drunken brawl that spiraled out of control. What remains clear is that Catherine benefited directly from his removal, and her enemies wasted no time linking the suspicious circumstances to her personal conduct. Prussian agents loyal to Frederick the Great, who had admired Peter, and British writers wary of Russian expansion both seized on the moment. They portrayed the new empress as a woman whose ambition knew no bounds, including the elimination of her own husband. The timing mattered because it allowed rivals to frame her rule as illegitimate from the outset.

The Anatomy of the Sexual Smears

The rumors spread with remarkable speed and creativity. English pamphlets described Catherine presiding over midnight orgies in the Winter Palace, while French writers claimed she had given birth to seventeen illegitimate children. The most enduring fabrication, the story of her death by stallion, appeared after her actual death from a stroke in 1796. Prussian physician Johann Georg Zimmermann helped circulate the tale, and French journalist Charles de la Villatte added further details in the Moniteur Universel. The account was physically impossible and contradicted every reliable report of her final hours, yet it proved impossible to erase once it took hold.

These stories served a clear purpose. By painting Catherine as a woman ruled by uncontrolled desires, her opponents hoped to justify their own opposition and to make her political achievements seem secondary to private scandal. Domestic critics, including some who had supported the coup, later joined the chorus when it suited their interests. Princess Dashkova, once a close ally, grew distant and contributed to the atmosphere of whispered disapproval. The smears were never random; they consistently targeted her status as a foreign-born woman who had seized power.

Enlightenment Empress or Imperial Seducer?

Catherine attempted to shape her own image through serious reforms and correspondence with leading Enlightenment thinkers. Her Nakaz of 1767 outlined legal principles influenced by Montesquieu and Beccaria, and she hosted Voltaire and Diderot in correspondence that projected an image of enlightened rule. Yet the sexual rumors persisted alongside these efforts, often amplified by cartoonists such as James Gillray who depicted her as a dominatrix astride the map of Europe. The contrast between her actual policies and the caricatures shows how difficult it was for any powerful woman to escape reduction to her personal life.

Real Affairs and the Gray Zone of Scandal

Catherine did maintain a series of relationships that were widely known at court. Grigory Orlov remained her favorite for a decade after the coup, receiving titles and estates in return. Later came Grigory Potemkin, whose influence extended far beyond the bedroom into military campaigns and governance. Other favorites such as Alexander Lanskoy died young, adding to the pattern of short-lived but intense attachments. These relationships were real, yet they were routinely exaggerated to suggest a level of promiscuity that exceeded even the standards of other eighteenth-century courts. Louis XV of France, for comparison, maintained far larger numbers of documented mistresses without similar lasting myths.

The overlap between personal intimacy and political power was genuine. Potemkin’s role in the annexation of Crimea and the construction of the Black Sea fleet cannot be separated from his closeness to Catherine. At the same time, the constant emphasis on her lovers obscured the administrative and cultural achievements of her long reign, including the expansion of Russian territory and the patronage of arts and education. The rumors worked because they reduced complex statecraft to bedroom gossip.

Propaganda Machinery: Foreign Powers and Print Warfare

Eighteenth-century print culture functioned much like today’s social media, allowing scandal to travel quickly across borders. London newspapers hostile to Russian growth after the Seven Years’ War published serialized attacks, while Frederick the Great subsidized pamphlets through intermediaries. Catherine tried to block imports, but copies reached Russian readers anyway. The psychological effect was cumulative: each new story chipped away at her reputation abroad and gave domestic opponents material to question her fitness. After the French Revolution, conservative writers began labeling her a Jacobin sympathizer, showing how the same sexual accusations could be repurposed for new political moments.

Victims of the Smear Campaign

Peter III was not a strong ruler, yet he deserved an honest accounting rather than murder followed by character assassination. Catherine’s lovers also paid prices: Orlov eventually lost favor and influence, while Potemkin died at fifty-two during a campaign. Her son Paul, who succeeded her, reversed many of her reforms and ordered the exhumation of his father’s remains in an attempt to restore Peter’s dignity. The rumors ultimately harmed Catherine most after her death, overshadowing the scale of her achievements with lurid fabrications that proved easier to remember.

Enduring Legacy: Myths in the Modern Age

Catherine ruled for thirty-four years and died on November 5, 1796. Her successors struggled with the legacy she left, and Paul’s own assassination in 1801 echoed the violence that had brought his mother to power. Modern depictions, including the 2019 HBO series, continue to reference the old myths even while attempting to present a fuller portrait. Historians such as Isabel de Madariaga and Robert Massie have documented that Catherine’s documented relationships numbered around twelve across her lifetime, a figure modest by the standards of many male monarchs. The persistence of the horse story and similar tales demonstrates how difficult it remains to correct deliberate disinformation once it enters popular culture.

The same pattern appears in later cases involving women in power, where personal conduct is scrutinized far more intensely than policy outcomes. Catherine’s experience illustrates why sexual rumors remain effective tools in political conflict: they shift focus from governance to morality and make rational discussion harder. At Dyerbolical we examine these historical mechanisms because they still shape how authority and scandal interact today.

Bibliography

Robert K. Massie, Catherine the Great: Portrait of a Woman (Random House, 2011).

Isabel de Madariaga, Catherine the Great: A Short History (Yale University Press, 1990).

Virginia Rounding, Catherine the Great: Love, Sex and Power (Hutchinson, 2006).

Simon Dixon, Catherine the Great (Profile Books, 2009).

John T. Alexander, Catherine the Great: Life and Legend (Oxford University Press, 1989).

Moniteur Universel, contemporary French reports on Catherine’s death, 1796–1797.

Correspondence of Voltaire and Catherine II, published collections.

James Gillray political cartoons, British Museum collection.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289