In the dead of winter, when the world seems to pull back and leave people alone with their thoughts, three films found a way to make that emptiness feel alive with something older and far more dangerous. This article looks closely at Robert Eggers’s The Witch, Lukas Feigelfeld’s Hagazussa, and Oz Perkins’s The Blackcoat’s Daughter, tracing how each one uses remote settings, religious pressure, and women caught in the middle to build a slow kind of terror that stays with viewers long after the final frame.
Amid the resurgence of folk horror in the 2010s, few films captured the primal dread of the supernatural entwined with human frailty as potently as Robert Eggers’s The Witch (2015), Lukas Feigelfeld’s Hagazussa (2017), and Oz Perkins’s The Blackcoat’s Daughter (2015). These works, bound by themes of isolation, religious repression, and the awakening of dark feminine forces, offer a chilling triad for comparison. Each unfolds in sparse, wintry landscapes where the boundaries between the natural world and infernal realms blur, inviting viewers into slow-burn nightmares that prioritise atmosphere over jump scares.
Isolation serves as the crucible for supernatural emergence in all three, transforming remote settings into characters of unrelenting menace. Central female figures embody repressed rage and otherworldly power, subverting patriarchal structures through possession and witchcraft. Debut directors Eggers, Feigelfeld, and Perkins master auditory and visual minimalism, crafting dread from silence, shadows, and stark cinematography.
Puritan Wilderness: Unpacking The Witch
Robert Eggers’s The Witch transports audiences to 1630s New England, where the Puritan family of William and Katherine Carver faces expulsion from their plantation for sowing discord. Relocating to a foreboding forest glade, they erect a fragile homestead overshadowed by a gnarled wood that whispers of pagan temptations. Their eldest daughter, Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy), teeters on womanhood’s edge, her budding sexuality clashing with the family’s rigid piety. Tragedy strikes when the infant Samuel vanishes during Thomasin’s watch, spirited away by a cackling hag who anoints herself with his blood in a scene of grotesque ritualism.
Suspicion festers among the family. William’s patriarchal authority crumbles as crops fail and livestock births monstrosities, a goat named Black Phillip that embodies satanic allure. Twin children Mercy and Jonas succumb to eerie songs, while son Caleb ventures into the woods, returning catatonic and feverish, tormented by visions of the witch in seductive guises. Katherine’s grief spirals into accusation, her maternal rage fixating on Thomasin as the familial scapegoat. Eggers meticulously recreates 17th-century dialogue from trial transcripts and diaries, immersing viewers in an authentic theocratic nightmare where sin and salvation entwine. That level of detail matters because it turns abstract historical fears into something you can almost smell and taste, making the family’s slow collapse feel inevitable rather than staged.
The film’s power lies in its refusal to rush revelations. Dread builds through long takes of mundane chores interrupted by uncanny omens: a silver cup vanishing, shadows lengthening unnaturally. Thomasin’s arc from dutiful daughter to accused witch culminates in Black Phillip’s temptation, her pact sealing the family’s doom in a frenzy of blood and blasphemy. Eggers draws from historical accounts like the 1692 Salem trials, yet roots the horror in domestic implosion, portraying the wilderness not as mere backdrop but as a sentient adversary reclaiming colonial hubris. The same care for period texture later showed up in his work on Nosferatu in 2024, where every creak and candle flicker carries the same weight.
Alpine Solitude: Hagazussa’s Cursed Outcast
Lukas Feigelfeld’s Hagazussa, set in 15th-century Bavarian Alps, echoes The Witch’s isolation but infuses it with pagan mysticism. Albrun (Aleksandra Cwen), branded a child-murdering witch after her mother’s ritualistic suicide, ekes out existence in a remote hut. Tormented by visions and boils symbolising inner torment, she milks a goat for sustenance while evading villagers’ pitchfork-wielding mobs. The narrative splits across timelines: Albrun’s solitary decline parallels her daughter Mele (also Cwen), orphaned and encountering the enigmatic swamp-dweller Ivord (Joachim Zukunft).
Feigelfeld’s camera lingers on the Alps’ majestic cruelty, towering peaks and misty valleys that dwarf human endeavour. Albrun’s rituals invoke pre-Christian deities, blending herbalism with hallucinatory trances where she births a demonic progeny amid flames. Ivord’s arrival introduces queer undertones and body horror; their coupling yields a changeling offspring, Marlis, whose eerie silence haunts the hut. The film’s soundscape, dominated by wind howls and goat bleats, amplifies psychological fracture, with Albrun’s descent mirroring ecological vengeance against Christian encroachment. Viewers feel the weight of that landscape because it never offers comfort, only scale that makes one woman’s suffering seem both tiny and endless.
Unlike The Witch’s familial unit, Hagazussa spotlights radical solitude, Albrun’s body as battleground for matriarchal legacies suppressed by inquisitorial zeal. Feigelfeld, inspired by Alpine folklore and Teutonic myths, crafts a sensory poem where witchcraft emerges as ecological rebellion. The film’s tripartite structure, mother, daughter, rebirth, cycles through trauma, culminating in hallucinatory flights over frozen tundras, a visual metaphor for transcending mortal chains. It sits alongside other European folk pieces that treat nature itself as an active participant rather than scenery.
Wintry Academy: The Blackcoat’s Daughter’s Dormant Evil
Oz Perkins’s The Blackcoat’s Daughter shifts to modern-day upstate New York, where boarding school girls Kat (Kiernan Shipka) and Rose (Lucy Boynton) remain over a February break. The Bramford Academy’s cavernous halls, lined with religious iconography, creak under perpetual snow. Kat experiences visions of a horned figure and hears demonic whispers, her behaviour alienating the oblivious Rose, who grapples with an unintended pregnancy. Intercut timelines reveal adult Joan (Emma Roberts) hitchhiking through blizzards, her fragmented memories hinting at survival from the school’s infernal outbreak.
Perkins employs non-linear storytelling to disorient, mirroring possession’s mental dissolution. Kat’s rituals in the boiler room, communing with a severed head, evoke Black Phillip’s whispers, while Rose’s futile calls home underscore institutional abandonment. Father Lambert (James Remar) and Mr. Gordon (Bill Skarsgård) arrive too late, their executions graphic yet understated. The film’s climax intertwines timelines, Joan’s beheading of a priestess figure affirming her demonic rebirth, a cycle of eternal recurrence. The fractured timeline works because it forces the audience to piece together the same broken memories the characters carry, turning confusion into shared unease.
Drawing from Catholic exorcism lore and Perkins’s own boarding school memories, the film weaponises silence: empty corridors echo with distant sobs, fluorescent lights buzz ominously. The Blackcoat’s Daughter distinguishes itself through intimate scale, the school’s chapel becoming a pressure cooker for adolescent angst fused with antiquity’s evils. Perkins returned to similar territory years later with Longlegs, showing how the same quiet dread can stretch across different decades without losing its grip.
Threads of Isolation: The Common Curse
All three films weaponise remoteness, transmuting physical distance into metaphysical chasms. The Witch’s forest glade, Hagazussa’s alpine hut, and The Blackcoat’s Daughter’s deserted academy function as liminal spaces where societal norms erode. This isolation amplifies internal conflicts, externalising Puritan guilt, pagan stigma, and Catholic repression as spectral visitations. Eggers, Feigelfeld, and Perkins reject Hollywood spectacle, favouring verisimilitude: practical locations enhance authenticity, forests and snowfields as co-conspirators in dread. The choice to stay grounded keeps the supernatural from feeling like a cheap trick and instead makes it the logical outcome of lives already stretched thin.
Religious frameworks unite them, portraying faith as double-edged. William’s Old Testament fervour invites the Devil, Albrun’s folk rites defy Church dogma, Kat’s nominal Catholicism awakens primordial forces. Patriarchy falters universally: absent or impotent fathers leave women vulnerable yet empowered through the supernatural, subverting victimhood into agency. That pattern keeps resurfacing in folk horror because it taps into real historical power imbalances that still resonate today.
Feminine Fury Unleashed
Central women, Thomasin, Albrun/Mele, Kat/Joan, embody repressed feminine archetypes. Thomasin’s sexual awakening defies modesty, Albrun’s maternal curse perpetuates bloodlines, Kat’s possession channels virginal rage. These figures reclaim power via taboo: nudity, blood rites, decapitation. Such portrayals critique historical witch hunts, where women’s autonomy threatened male order, echoing Silvia Federici’s theses on capitalism’s war on the commons and female bodies. The performances make those ideas land because they never treat the women as symbols first; they feel like people pushed past their limits.
Performances elevate these arcs. Taylor-Joy’s wide-eyed innocence fractures into defiant glee, Cwen’s raw physicality conveys torment’s toll, Shipka’s subtle mania builds to Roberts’s steely resolve. Directors cast non-professionals alongside veterans, grounding supernaturalism in human frailty. That mix of raw and polished acting stops the horror from drifting into pure abstraction.
Sonic and Visual Witchcraft
Auditory design reigns supreme. The Witch’s period-accurate chants and goat bleats pierce silence; Hagazussa’s throat-singing and wind symphonies induce trance; The Blackcoat’s Daughter’s diegetic hums and whispers burrow into psyches. Composers like Mark Korven, Peter Schilling, and Michael Yezerski prioritise subharmonics, vibrations felt corporeally. Sound becomes another character because it reaches places images alone cannot reach, settling under the skin before the eye even registers danger.
Cinematography favours natural light: Jarin Blaschke’s golden-hour purges in The Witch, Klemens Neumann’s fog-shrouded vistas in Hagazussa, John Bailey’s chiaroscuro in The Blackcoat’s Daughter. Long takes and static frames mimic tableau vivant, freezing horror in amber. Practical effects, goat prosthetics, boils, blood flows, eschew CGI, preserving tactility. The decision to rely on what can actually be filmed in cold locations adds a layer of physical reality that digital effects often lose.
Production Perils and Enduring Echoes
Debuts marked by bootstrapped ambition: Eggers crowdfunded after script rejections, Feigelfeld self-financed post-drama school, Perkins leveraged family ties yet faced distribution woes. Censorship skirted, Hagazussa’s explicitness tested festivals, yet acclaim followed: The Witch grossed $40 million on $4 million budget, inspiring A24’s prestige horror wave. Those early struggles matter because they shaped the unpolished edge that later big-studio projects sometimes sand away.
Legacy permeates: The Witch birthed Eggers’s oeuvre, influencing Midsommar; Hagazussa championed Euro-folk revival; The Blackcoat’s Daughter presaged Perkins’s Longlegs. Collectively, they revitalised slow horror, proving dread’s potency in patience. At Dyerbolical we often return to these titles when tracing how small, patient films can shift an entire subgenre.
Director in the Spotlight
Robert Eggers, born July 7, 1983, in New Hampshire, immersed in maritime folklore from childhood summers in Rockland, Maine. A former production designer and actor in experimental theatre, Eggers honed his vision at New York University’s Tisch School, assisting on films like Bringing Out the Dead. His breakthrough script for The Witch, rejected over a dozen times, drew from family Bibles and Cotton Mather texts, securing A24 backing after The Babadook producers championed it.
Eggers’s oeuvre obsesses over historical authenticity, psychological descent, and mythic masculinity. Key works include The Witch (2015), a Sundance sensation exploring Puritan paranoia; The Lighthouse (2019), a black-and-white fever dream starring Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson as feuding keepers, lauded for sound design and monomania; The Northman (2022), a Viking revenge saga with Alexander Skarsgård, blending Shakespearean tragedy with Norse sagas, grossing $70 million; and Nosferatu (2024), a gothic remake featuring Bill Skarsgård as the count, Lily-Rose Depp, and Nicholas Hoult. Influences span Dreyer, Bergman, and Powell, with Eggers collaborating recurrently with cinematographer Jarin Blaschke and composer Mark Korven. Awards include Gotham and Independent Spirit nods; he resides in New York, perpetually researching period immersions.
Actor in the Spotlight
Anya Taylor-Joy, born April 16, 1996, in Miami to a British-Argentinian photographer father and Zambian psychologist mother, grew up multilingual in Buenos Aires and London. Scouted at 16 on Oxford Street, she trained at London’s Pinewood Studio drama school despite ballet aspirations thwarted by injury. Debuting in The Witch at 18, her Thomasin catapulted her to acclaim, earning Chainsaw and Fangoria awards for breakthrough performance.
Taylor-Joy’s career trajectory spans genre versatility: Split (2016) as captive Casey Cooke opposite James McAvoy’s Beast; Thoroughbreds (2017), icy sociopath alongside Olivia Cooke; The Queen’s Gambit (2020 miniseries), Emmy-nominated Beth Harmon, chess prodigy grappling addiction; The Northman (2022), Olga of Birch Woods; The Menu (2022), satirical horror with Ralph Fiennes; Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024), titular wasteland warrior. Early roles: Viking (2016), Crossmaglen (2016 short); voice in Playmobil: The Movie (2019). Awards: Golden Globe for The Queen’s Gambit, Critics’ Choice, SAG ensemble for Emma (2020). Known for porcelain features and expressive eyes, she advocates dyslexia awareness, resides between London and New York, and headlines Fellow Travelers (2023 miniseries).
Ready for More NecroTimes Dread?
Subscribe today for weekly plunges into horror’s abyss, never miss a nightmare.
Bibliography
Cooper, R. (2021) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Headpress.
Eggers, R. (2016) ‘The Witch: Historical Horrors’, Fangoria, 356, pp. 28-35.
Feigelfeld, L. (2019) Interview: Alpine Nightmares. Sight & Sound. British Film Institute.
Perkins, O. (2016) ‘Directing The Blackcoat’s Daughter’. Empire Magazine.
Scorsese, M. (2020) ‘Folk Horror Renaissance’. The New York Review of Books.
Thompson, D. (2018) A24: The Unholy Rise. Abrams Books.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
